Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Customer service situation at work - investigation

256 replies

Londdi · 08/01/2024 17:51

I work in a swimming pool. Week ago customer walked in 2 mins before closing time. It was long and exhausting day -we had competitions in a pool / I did job for two people and didn’t even have a break. She starts off by “I recently got a membership…” which is usually query that needs some work on computer - our computers do get turn off 30 mins prior so I interrupted “I don’t think I’ll be much help out computers are already off” I don’t think I used any negative tone, but I was extremely tired about to grab a coat and go home. The customer got extremely upset that I didn’t let her finish . In normal circumstances I would apologise and let her continue and just stayed extra, but she was on a phone and started saying to the person on a line how disgusting my customer service is etc. wanted to speak to manager . So I left home as my manager said knowing how tough that day was. Am I in a wrong here ? This customer wants me fired . I know I probably should have not interrupt and it was a mistake, but is it really that huge to get fired over ? Am I being unreasonable and my behaviour was that bad? (Been in company for 8 years).

OP posts:
JenniferJupiterVenusandMars · 09/01/2024 07:20

Coconutter24 · 08/01/2024 20:57

If you have any meetings with work regarding this please do not say what you just wrote! You’re basically saying you couldn’t be bothered to explain to her because she’s old and probably wouldn’t get it.

You were rude to her you shut her down before she’d even got the question out and you could have handled it much better. Regardless of how crap of a day you were having it wasn’t the customers fault. I do get how frustrating it is though when it’s time to nearly clock off and a customer comes in but they are still a customer and you were still at work

WTF OP!?
You definitely have a very poor attitude that’s offensive and ageist.

IBE45 · 09/01/2024 08:09

margotrose · 09/01/2024 06:27

specifically going in two minutes before closing is, especially doing whilst on your phone. It's rude!

But the customer is not paid to be polite and considerate about timing - OP is. That's her job. It's not the customers fault if she doesn't get paid after closing - they're doing nothing wrong with coming in at 5.58 and asking a question.

Of course they're not, but it's about being a decent human being. I don't purposely go into places at closing time and delay people getting out on time, because I realise that their time is just as important as my own. I agreed that OP could have been politer, no doubt about it. People working in customer facing roles are often poorly paid, understaffed and have to put up with a lot of crap from people, why make their jobs harder or more unpleasant just because you can? I know this is true of many roles, but again why actively do it.

This thread has made me realised how differently I think from so many mumsnetters. It's a bit depressing actually.

forcedfun · 09/01/2024 08:10

margotrose · 09/01/2024 06:27

specifically going in two minutes before closing is, especially doing whilst on your phone. It's rude!

But the customer is not paid to be polite and considerate about timing - OP is. That's her job. It's not the customers fault if she doesn't get paid after closing - they're doing nothing wrong with coming in at 5.58 and asking a question.

So you are only polite and considerate when you are being paid to be?

Good grief. No wonder some people are monstrously rude to those working in customer service. It's almost like some (vile) people get a kick out of being rude and treating those in customer service like dirt.

DeeLusional · 09/01/2024 08:20

Towerofsong · 08/01/2024 21:14

Sounds like she could have come in 25 minutes before closing and your response would be the same 'computers are off'

Why are the computers turned off half an hour before closing? They should only take 3 minutes to lower down!

OP isn't management, the time the computers are turned off isn't down to her.

Neriah · 09/01/2024 08:23

Londdi · 08/01/2024 19:40

Our membership enquires are usually quite technical in nature (app/smartphone) and the lady was pensioner …. Yes it was an assumption based on reality . Didn’t mean to shame someone based on age . Like I wouldn’t shame my own mum but I understand that it’s much harder to understand for older generation or explain what the issue is.

When in a hole, stop digging. As one of the older generation and over pension age, I will lay bets that I and many of my similarly aged mates coulod run rings around you with any technology you care to select.

You really need to address your bias and prejudices around older people.

MindHowYouGoes · 09/01/2024 08:27

You were very rude and I’d have complained about you too. Since you started out thinking you were in the right and full of excuses maybe this isn’t the first time a customer has found you curt or unhelpful. Also ageist - just because the woman was older it doesn’t mean she doesn’t know how to work an app.

id have a think about how you could adjust the attitude a bit so you can be prepared to have a useful conversation with your manager. Definitely don’t mention the fact you just wanted to go home.

MindHowYouGoes · 09/01/2024 08:29

Also that’s an early closing time - what if the woman works full time and had to make a special effort to get there before it closed?

or are we all assuming customers are as inconvenient as possible just to piss workers off? If you’re open you’re open.

Noshowlomo · 09/01/2024 08:34

You can tell the people who have worked in retail/customer facing roles on this thread. The ones who support the OP.
Everyone bleating on about customer service is king, clearly have never seen the absolute worst of humanity which you do in customer facing roles.
The “maybe you shouldn’t work in customer service” means nothing, because absolutely everyone who does or has had been on the receiving end of shit from the public. So if everyone quit, the next lot would also be on the receiving end of shit from the public. Working in customer service seems to make you an emotional punch bag and we’re all human. The OP doesn’t clock on and turn into a robot. 8 years and no issues, so I’d say she’s a great candidate to work in CS. A lot give up much sooner due to their treatment and how they are talked to by customers.
Be better customers !

IBE45 · 09/01/2024 08:44

Noshowlomo · 09/01/2024 08:34

You can tell the people who have worked in retail/customer facing roles on this thread. The ones who support the OP.
Everyone bleating on about customer service is king, clearly have never seen the absolute worst of humanity which you do in customer facing roles.
The “maybe you shouldn’t work in customer service” means nothing, because absolutely everyone who does or has had been on the receiving end of shit from the public. So if everyone quit, the next lot would also be on the receiving end of shit from the public. Working in customer service seems to make you an emotional punch bag and we’re all human. The OP doesn’t clock on and turn into a robot. 8 years and no issues, so I’d say she’s a great candidate to work in CS. A lot give up much sooner due to their treatment and how they are talked to by customers.
Be better customers !

This! Having worked in customer service when I was younger, I feel a lot of compassion for those who do. And I can picture, some right horrors behind the comments on this thread. The entitlement and expectation. It's as though they've never had a bad day at work or not delivered 100%. I think they see people in customer service as robots, yet I doubt they perform their roles with robotic precision everyday. People in customer service generally want to provide good service, not all but the vast majority do. If you're a person who always feels they receive poor service then you're probably the problem.

Cosywintertime · 09/01/2024 08:52

Noshowlomo · 09/01/2024 08:34

You can tell the people who have worked in retail/customer facing roles on this thread. The ones who support the OP.
Everyone bleating on about customer service is king, clearly have never seen the absolute worst of humanity which you do in customer facing roles.
The “maybe you shouldn’t work in customer service” means nothing, because absolutely everyone who does or has had been on the receiving end of shit from the public. So if everyone quit, the next lot would also be on the receiving end of shit from the public. Working in customer service seems to make you an emotional punch bag and we’re all human. The OP doesn’t clock on and turn into a robot. 8 years and no issues, so I’d say she’s a great candidate to work in CS. A lot give up much sooner due to their treatment and how they are talked to by customers.
Be better customers !

To be fair though in this instance the customer was not at fault in the interaction, she asked the op a question, the op cut her off immediately and said she couldn’t help. It was rude.

i don’t think it’s dismissible, but I’d habe a word with her if I was her manager.

Wintersgirl · 09/01/2024 09:00

This customer wants me fired

She can want you fired all she likes, this is not the Apprentice, laws and processes are in place before someone gets the sack, it's actually quite hard to fire someone these days, unless it's REALLY bad.

NonPlayerCharacter · 09/01/2024 09:00

Cosywintertime · 09/01/2024 08:52

To be fair though in this instance the customer was not at fault in the interaction, she asked the op a question, the op cut her off immediately and said she couldn’t help. It was rude.

i don’t think it’s dismissible, but I’d habe a word with her if I was her manager.

The customer wasn't at fault in the interaction, and it's one thing to communicate with the business about it, but the level of escalation and demand for sacking is absolutely ridiculous. It's not her decision to sack people so if the place is halfway decent then it won't even be a consideration, but it's understandably scared OP.

If it actually did come to an actual sacking, which I'm sure it won't, then OP is better off out of such a loony place.

Ferraria · 09/01/2024 09:09

I've worked in customer service for many years so I initially had some sympathy, although you were rude.

However you lost me with your comments about older people. Appalling and you admit you treated her the way you did because you made assumptions about her based on age. You need urgent retraining.

Ariela · 09/01/2024 09:16

@Londdi It seems to me you could also say she didn't let you finish - because she turned away and spoke to her phone, and then wouldn't talk to you.

Next time, I'd have bluffed it and say you were just about to ask for her details and details of what she wanted to know so you could get someone to ring her tomorrow, but when you told her the computers were off she rudely carried on her phone conversation, turned away and refused to speak to you, which left you unable to help her any further.

melj1213 · 09/01/2024 09:37

I would say that you were unreasonable to cut the customer off and shut them down but you're not going to be sacked for it - anyone (repeatedly) demanding a worker is fired over something this minor will be showing management how unreasonable they are and management have all dealt with customers like this before so yes there will be a consequence (IE you're spoken to about your customer service) but you're not getting sacked.

I worked in customer services for a supermarket and now work in our pharmacy and the worst thing you can do when someone is asking a question is cut them off to shut them down. Even if you think you know what they're going to ask, if you cut them off then people assume you're not listening/are being rude because you don't want to deal with them and it often takes longer in the end as they will then just plow on with whatever they were going to say initially anyway, and you just repeat yourself at the end that you can't help right now, which makes them madder than if you'd let them finish before saying "Sorry but there's nothing I can do right now".

In your initial conversation in your situation I would have tried to get in first - so as soon as she walked through the door I would have called out something like "Just to let you know we close in two minutes, is there something I can help you with now?" and then when she started talking about her membership, as soon as you knew she wanted to do something you were unable to do there and then (as opposed to a quick "I have a membership, was at the members only swim session earlier and think I left my green bobble hat, do you have a lost property box?") that's when you could interrupt with "Apologies but as I said when you arrived we are closing now so I can't access the membership system right now, you can either come back tomorrow or leave your number and I can call you, which would you prefer?".

However, in the situation you were in where you didn't get in early, when you interrupted I would have explained why I was interrupting, explain what I can do and what I can't do there and then and ask what they need, eg:

"I just got a membership recently ..."
"Apologies for interrupting you but I can see you're on a call and just to save you time if it's something I can't address this evening as we are closing in two minutes: if your question is a general one about the centre/facilities I can answer it now but if it's about your membership details then unfortunately the system is shut down so I won't be able to check any details now, you'll have to come back tomorrow. Is there something I can help you with now? ... No? Then we reopen at 9 tomorrow if you want to pop in or should I write our phone number down so you can call us instead?"

FUPAgirl · 09/01/2024 09:56

I really cannot stand poor customer service. However I can completely see where you are coming from here, there was no point in her continuing when you knew you couldn't help. It actually really pisses me off when I'm allowed to fully explain my problem only to be told I need someone else, and then have to explain it all again. I would prefer to be interrupted.

She sounds awful. I get the impression that English isn't your first language, might that be a factor in her reaction?? Fingers crossed that she takes her business elsewhere.

Tagyoureit · 09/01/2024 09:59

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 09/01/2024 02:17

There's an easy answer to that - if you aren't suited to a customer service role then you shouldn't be doing it. There are plenty of othes who actually do care about providing good service, who would be far better in the role.

🤣🤣🤣

I no longer work but if every customer facing worker decided to do that you'd be well and truly fucked! There would be no one around to work!

forcedfun · 09/01/2024 10:13

Noshowlomo · 09/01/2024 08:34

You can tell the people who have worked in retail/customer facing roles on this thread. The ones who support the OP.
Everyone bleating on about customer service is king, clearly have never seen the absolute worst of humanity which you do in customer facing roles.
The “maybe you shouldn’t work in customer service” means nothing, because absolutely everyone who does or has had been on the receiving end of shit from the public. So if everyone quit, the next lot would also be on the receiving end of shit from the public. Working in customer service seems to make you an emotional punch bag and we’re all human. The OP doesn’t clock on and turn into a robot. 8 years and no issues, so I’d say she’s a great candidate to work in CS. A lot give up much sooner due to their treatment and how they are talked to by customers.
Be better customers !

Agreed.

I worked in a professional job and then took a break and worked in customer service alongside studying. I was shocked how rudely I was spoken to. People staying on their phones. People talking to me like I was stupid or less than them. People peeling change out of grotty snotty tissues and handing it to me. And the rudest ones were generally very middle class (as am I). It was eye opening.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 09/01/2024 10:20

And the rudest ones were generally very middle class (as am I). It was eye opening

Yes, I worked in a library for a bit and had to work alternate Saturday mornings. Oh my goodness the working mums who came in with their snotty attitudes. They didn't realise I had a "professional" job alongside, I worked two jobs for about six months. But they thought library staff were beneath them.

Completely different demographic on weekdays.

Edited: working in a library is a professional job. You might not be a qualified librarian but you need to know about a lot of stuff and it is hugely underpaid.

GinAndJuice99 · 09/01/2024 10:26

The customer was rude to come in and start asking questions two minutes before closing time.

forcedfun · 09/01/2024 10:27

enchantedsquirrelwood · 09/01/2024 10:20

And the rudest ones were generally very middle class (as am I). It was eye opening

Yes, I worked in a library for a bit and had to work alternate Saturday mornings. Oh my goodness the working mums who came in with their snotty attitudes. They didn't realise I had a "professional" job alongside, I worked two jobs for about six months. But they thought library staff were beneath them.

Completely different demographic on weekdays.

Edited: working in a library is a professional job. You might not be a qualified librarian but you need to know about a lot of stuff and it is hugely underpaid.

Edited

Yes my job was in a library too. Everyone I worked with was gloriously well read and very interesting. But some of the professional middle class people who came in were phenomenally rude. The very same type of people who would have been very respectful towards me if they had met me in my other job. Very revealing.

poetryandwine · 09/01/2024 10:37

I have worked customer facing roles when young and I have had sympathy for the OP from the beginning of her first post, although I agree with many that cutting the customer off was wrong. My sympathy elevated when we learnt that the customer is escalating her complaint over this relatively minor matter. It isn’t worthy of sacking and I doubt management will think otherwise.

But OP, like@Neriah I know people of pensionable age who could undoubtedly put your technical skills to shame. That’s not a criticism; they could do the same to most people. It is a suggestion that you harbour bias.

Your command of written English on this thread is adequate at best. That’s not a criticism either but it does suggest that if you find it difficult to explain things you may be part of the problem.

phoenixrosehere · 09/01/2024 11:09

Noshowlomo · 09/01/2024 08:34

You can tell the people who have worked in retail/customer facing roles on this thread. The ones who support the OP.
Everyone bleating on about customer service is king, clearly have never seen the absolute worst of humanity which you do in customer facing roles.
The “maybe you shouldn’t work in customer service” means nothing, because absolutely everyone who does or has had been on the receiving end of shit from the public. So if everyone quit, the next lot would also be on the receiving end of shit from the public. Working in customer service seems to make you an emotional punch bag and we’re all human. The OP doesn’t clock on and turn into a robot. 8 years and no issues, so I’d say she’s a great candidate to work in CS. A lot give up much sooner due to their treatment and how they are talked to by customers.
Be better customers !

I worked years in customer service and retail and definitely don’t think the customer is always right, BUT OP was rude and could have handled it better.

She interrupted a customer assuming she knew what they were going to say based on her own biases which is rude. OP was still on the clock, place was still open regardless if it was two minutes to close.

Do I think OP should be fired? Absolutely not, but she was in the wrong and a verbal warning or a few minutes training on better ways to handle such situations is enough imo unless there have been past complaints.

I’ve had bad days, some due to my own managers treating me like crap, but I still remained polite to customers regardless and was met with the same. I don’t know what their day was like and they don’t know mine and I don’t want to pass on my bad day to them. I rather be the one thing that helped than the x number that added to it. I get rudeness, I kill it with kindness and it means they can’t say I was rude if they’re those types looking to complain.

margotrose · 09/01/2024 11:23

I worked in retail and customer service for years @Noshowlomo and I don't support the OP at all.

I do sympathise with her but you can't be rude to the customer no matter how pissed off you are and how much they inconvenience you.

Lou7171 · 09/01/2024 11:33

Fully agree with you. You can tell who has worked with the public and who hasn't. It can be emotionally taxing. Being low paid is not only shit because of the finiancial worries but it also often comes along with a sort of low status within society. This can definitely be felt when working with the general public by the way they treat you.