Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Customer service situation at work - investigation

256 replies

Londdi · 08/01/2024 17:51

I work in a swimming pool. Week ago customer walked in 2 mins before closing time. It was long and exhausting day -we had competitions in a pool / I did job for two people and didn’t even have a break. She starts off by “I recently got a membership…” which is usually query that needs some work on computer - our computers do get turn off 30 mins prior so I interrupted “I don’t think I’ll be much help out computers are already off” I don’t think I used any negative tone, but I was extremely tired about to grab a coat and go home. The customer got extremely upset that I didn’t let her finish . In normal circumstances I would apologise and let her continue and just stayed extra, but she was on a phone and started saying to the person on a line how disgusting my customer service is etc. wanted to speak to manager . So I left home as my manager said knowing how tough that day was. Am I in a wrong here ? This customer wants me fired . I know I probably should have not interrupt and it was a mistake, but is it really that huge to get fired over ? Am I being unreasonable and my behaviour was that bad? (Been in company for 8 years).

OP posts:
WonderLife · 08/01/2024 21:02

You were rude but it's not gross misconduct and you aren't going to lose a job of 8 years because of it.

You might get a warning or be made to apologise though.

Jom222 · 08/01/2024 21:02

I hate to say it but this woman's generation is accustomed to a totally different level of customer service. It's like they think it's 1975 and a clerk is waiting just to assist them with any minor thing, happily and never ever overworked LOL.

My experience in retail was that the customers who go straight from an unrewarding experience straight to I'LL HAVE HER HEAD ON A PLATTER are obv unreasonable and nothing will please her.

If you run across her in future you can expect her to smirk triumphantly at you if she doesn't take the opportunity to yell at you for your mistreatment of her, A Very Important Customer.

Try not to let it get you down!

I worked for a veterinarian in the 80's whose assistant offended a wealthy woman who demanded she be fired so the Dr 'fired' her in front of said client. For a long time when this client came in the assistant would make herself scarce. Finally client saw the assistant and was indignant that she was still there. The Dr told her she was a single mother and he had to take pity on her and rehired her. My god the audacity of some people and they ways we coddle them!

Beautiful3 · 08/01/2024 21:05

I don't think you'd be sacked for that. But next time just listen, and say its closing time so you'll email her the next day.

SkulkHollow · 08/01/2024 21:05

Honestly, don't worry about it. There is no way you will lose your job over this.

I don't even think you were particually rude from what you say. People need to chill the fuck out and accept that people working customer facing jobs occasionally don't behave according to some ridiculous, made up standard.

Princesspollyyy · 08/01/2024 21:06

You were really very rude. Al you needed to do was explain really nicely and politely that unfortunately you can't help her as the computers get turned off 30 mins become closing time, and the centre closes in 2 minutes time.

You could have offered to help her if she comes back tomorrow?

Put yourself in her shoes. Would you like to be spoken to like that? Maybe she didn't realise you were about to close. How would you like your mum or family member being spoken to like that?

DeeLusional · 08/01/2024 21:12

You saved her the time and hassle of explaining something you weren't able to do anything about anyway. I really hate it when customer services lets me explain at length and then say "Not my job/computer's down/the person who deals with that is off etc.". You did her a favour. Deny deny deny, you weren't rude at all. And to all the folk saying"How would you like to be spoken to like that/your mother to be spoken to like that" - very over-sensitive bunch. If you just said what you say you did, not rude at all.

Towerofsong · 08/01/2024 21:14

Sounds like she could have come in 25 minutes before closing and your response would be the same 'computers are off'

Why are the computers turned off half an hour before closing? They should only take 3 minutes to lower down!

SpicyMoth · 08/01/2024 21:15

“I don’t think I’ll be much help out computers are already off”

Am I seriously the only one who doesn't understand how this is seen as rude 2 mins before closing time?
Sure you could've thrown a "I'm sorry but..." in there - but I really don't see how this is rude?
Comparatively, there are MUCH ruder people out there - Such as my GP receptionist who got the arse with me today because I didn't know the really complicated name of an anti-sickness medication my midwife had told me to phone for...

I feel like people are reading a tone into OP's reply that very much doesn't seem to be there?

yhk · 08/01/2024 21:16

Keep in mind that the customer has probably over sauced the complaint.

Tell the management the truth; that you had begun to advise the customer (who was on the phone while asking you a question) that the computers were closed for the day, then the customer started slagging you off on their telephone and refused to engage with you further.

It's your word against theirs.

NoNotMyHair · 08/01/2024 21:16

Jom222 · 08/01/2024 21:02

I hate to say it but this woman's generation is accustomed to a totally different level of customer service. It's like they think it's 1975 and a clerk is waiting just to assist them with any minor thing, happily and never ever overworked LOL.

My experience in retail was that the customers who go straight from an unrewarding experience straight to I'LL HAVE HER HEAD ON A PLATTER are obv unreasonable and nothing will please her.

If you run across her in future you can expect her to smirk triumphantly at you if she doesn't take the opportunity to yell at you for your mistreatment of her, A Very Important Customer.

Try not to let it get you down!

I worked for a veterinarian in the 80's whose assistant offended a wealthy woman who demanded she be fired so the Dr 'fired' her in front of said client. For a long time when this client came in the assistant would make herself scarce. Finally client saw the assistant and was indignant that she was still there. The Dr told her she was a single mother and he had to take pity on her and rehired her. My god the audacity of some people and they ways we coddle them!

It doesn't sound like you are cut out for a public facing role either.

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 08/01/2024 21:19

Londdi · 08/01/2024 19:42

Investigation process. Well it happened week ago. My manager basically said not to worry at all, but after she complained formal way in multiple emails I am going in for meeting (not sure if I’ll get a warning or what will happen), but never had a meeting before..,

Be incredibly apologetic, tell them it was a one off and you are truly sorry. Tell them how you should have handled the situation but do not mention the age of the person. That will not make you look good as you can see from the replies on this thread.

Muchof · 08/01/2024 21:19

You should have let her finish her question before you decide you are not going to be able to help her. So yes you were rude, I would definitely have complained about you, but wanting somebody to be sacked is completely over the top.

blackpanth · 08/01/2024 21:19

You won't get sacked. She was rude

WickDittington · 08/01/2024 21:21

You were trying to help her by warning her that her query couldn’t be dealt with at closing time. You probably shouldn’t have interrupted her or maybe you should have said you were trying to save her time.

Goodfood1 · 08/01/2024 21:23

I don't think you were rude. I think she was. Very disrespectful coming in 2 mins before closing time with any query. Then putting you down in front of you on the phone. Really didn't deserve better treatment imo. I realise most have said different but that's how I see it.

SoOutingWhoCares · 08/01/2024 21:25

@SpicyMoth It's not about tone, it's about the fact OP cut the woman off before she could even ask her question. They just assumed it was computer related, it could have been anything. It's wrong to interrupt like that and have no time to listen to the question, closing time or not.

weirdoboelady · 08/01/2024 21:27

This is what I think happened, and if I am correct, this is what I think you should say.

'The customer came in and it became clear to me that she was going to need help from the computers, which had already been switched off. She was on the phone, so I tried to convey to her in a quick and efficient manner that we were unlikely to be able to help her (so her phone call wouldn't be interrupted for too long for nothing). I now quite understand that although I was trying to be helpful, my manner in trying to say things quickly came across to the customer as rude, and I would like to apologise for this. It was not my intention to be rude to the customer, only to be helpful, and I am sorry that I did not convey this in a more skilled way.'

Inyourwildestdreams · 08/01/2024 21:31

I’m an assistant manager in retail and if one of my team spoke to a customer like that I’d be pretty pissed to be honest. Yes, it’s 2 minutes until closing and you’ve had a crap day but all customers should be greeted politely and listened to. You actually didn’t even find out what she was going to ask! If your systems are shut down and you can no longer help customers then there should be a sign up advising that the desk is closed. All you had to do was advise her that the systems were shut down so you were unable to help with her enquiry but if she popped in or called tomorrow then you’d be happy to help. Better yet, offer to take her number and you will call her tomorrow to deal with her enquiry.

I really do get it - in my store the number of customers we get in the door literally 2 minutes before closing time wanting refunds or exchanges (we’re in a store that requires trying on items etc) is infuriating. Unfortunately it’s all part of the job. And customers are NOT all polite. She was rude being on her phone etc. But she’s not the paid member of staff in the situation. If customers are still able to get into the building then you’re still in full customer service mode!

catherinewales · 08/01/2024 21:33

I wouldn't stress over this. She's put an official complaint in and your boss has to investigate. I think if what you've written here is what happened, you won't have anything to worry about.

Lesina · 08/01/2024 21:35

You were exceptionally rude and offered poor customer service. You shouldn’t lose your job, but I would expect some pointed feedback from management.

Mourningmorningsleep · 08/01/2024 21:37

Everyone has a bad day sometimes. You were a bit rude, she was a bit rude, everyone goes home feels a bit grumpy and moves on should be the end of it. The fact that she's following this up and mention of being sacked is very over the top. You'll be fine don't feel bad, you're just human and this was a minor incident.

Londonrach1 · 08/01/2024 21:38

Reading your updates sounds like the customer is a bully and tbh she needs banning from the centre due to her treatment of the staff. Your manager needs to support you here.

ChateauMargaux · 08/01/2024 21:45

Take someone with you to the meeting - do not go alone.

Answer questions but do not offer any mitigating circumstances or apologies.

Maybe write down what happened and refer to it, if questioned or asked for clarification. Insist that you were not rude, did not use an aggressive tone, did not raise your voice and were simply stating that you would not be able to help. When you tried to explain further, she would not allow you to speak.

A woman came in to the building, after I had closed the computer and was preparing to leave at the end of my shift. This is almost one hour after the usual last admission time to the centre.

It is our practice to turn off our computers 30 minutes before the end of the shift to allow us sufficient time to complete the rest of our end of day tasks. I had completed all other tasks and was preparing to leave.

The customer entered and while on the phone to a third party, started to talk about her membership. Without access to the computer, I cannot provide any information so I said that to her. My exact words were: “I don’t think I’ll be much help out computers are already off”.

At that point, she turned away from me and spoke to the person on the phone, saying how disgusting the service was. I tried to engage her in discussion to explain the situation but she refused to speak to me and demanded to speak to the manager.

The manager was present, she told me she would take over the discussion and allowed me to leave.

If whoever is hosting the meeting insists that you admit to something .. you can admit that you can see why, in hindsight, that prefacing the comment by the words, I am really sorry but we have already closed reception and I am about to shut the building. I am sorry I cannot deal with your query right now, would you mind coming back during our opening hours.

Be firm, stick to your guns and remind whoever it is that you have 8 years of experience in the job and have never had a member of the public complain about you or in fact be so rude in your presence. You were not making an issue of her rudeness, nor are you making an issue of it now, but you do feel that in this case, you were not the person who is in the wrong. However, if they insist then say, fine - I will apologise, I will promise to make every effort to be polite to everyone, including those people who arrive after the reception has closed and you very much hope that such a situation will not arise in the future and that if it is, you will do your best to ensure it is resolved in your presence to avoid this very situation.

I hope you manager sticks up for you. It seems totally unreasonable. Perhaps you could take the tack of..... I think there was a misunderstanding - the woman was on the phone while talking to me and it was not clear whether she was talking to me or to the person on the phone - slightly risky though..

Dancerprancer19 · 08/01/2024 21:47

Reallynotoverreacting · 08/01/2024 17:55

What did your manager say? If I was your manager, I'd probably placate the customer and say it will be fed back, then have a word with you and ask you to be more careful in future. Can't see you losing your job over this

This

Christmascarrots · 08/01/2024 21:51

She’s rude. I’d fully expect to be given short shrift if I walked in anywhere 2 mins before closing with a query. She’s doubly rude for being on her phone and bitching about you. You should not be losing your job over this and I’d expect your manager to fully support you.