Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Customer service situation at work - investigation

256 replies

Londdi · 08/01/2024 17:51

I work in a swimming pool. Week ago customer walked in 2 mins before closing time. It was long and exhausting day -we had competitions in a pool / I did job for two people and didn’t even have a break. She starts off by “I recently got a membership…” which is usually query that needs some work on computer - our computers do get turn off 30 mins prior so I interrupted “I don’t think I’ll be much help out computers are already off” I don’t think I used any negative tone, but I was extremely tired about to grab a coat and go home. The customer got extremely upset that I didn’t let her finish . In normal circumstances I would apologise and let her continue and just stayed extra, but she was on a phone and started saying to the person on a line how disgusting my customer service is etc. wanted to speak to manager . So I left home as my manager said knowing how tough that day was. Am I in a wrong here ? This customer wants me fired . I know I probably should have not interrupt and it was a mistake, but is it really that huge to get fired over ? Am I being unreasonable and my behaviour was that bad? (Been in company for 8 years).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
catherinewales · 14/01/2024 22:36

How did you get on

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 10/01/2024 18:39

MaisyAndTallulah · 10/01/2024 01:00

I did thanks. Your posts are a great example of rudeness.

If you think my posts are rude then you have lead a very sheltered life!

The whole point is that OP has been reassured by numerous posters, myself included, that she is most certainly not in danger of losing her job. And yet, she continues to post ridiculous nonsense in defence of her actions, including that as the women was a "pensioner" she couldn't possibly understand technical issues.

OP did not behave well and instead of trying to excuse herself she should instead be looking at ways to do better in future, but we haven't seen any desire from her to do so.

Then there are people like you, who seem to want to rush to the defence of a rude person, while at the same time accusing others of it. Bore off. (yes, I've been rude to you- sue me!!!):

enchantedsquirrelwood · 10/01/2024 15:16

To be fair, that woman's generation, of which I am one, is definitely accustomed to a different level of customer service. It incudes actual customer service, not having someone cut you off mid-sentence, and not having it assumed that you age suggests that you are either stupid or technologically inept

I'm not that generation but I expect that level of customer service too. But not when the doors are going to close in a matter of minutes.

ellyeth · 10/01/2024 14:55

I think you handled it badly and should not have interrupted. However, I think it would be sufficient for you to be reprimanded, not sacked.

Years ago I was putting food through the conveyer belt at a supermarket. I had forgotten one item so went back to get it and my husband continued packing. The girl on the till complained when I added the single item to the other items on the belt because she said "We are closing now". I thought it was ridiculous and told her so. It still annoys me when I think about it. I appreciate customers can be unreasonable but a little heed for customer service should be the norm.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 10/01/2024 11:19

Platypuslover · 09/01/2024 18:17

what an entitled twat that is. Rude to start with that’s she’s on the phone while speaking to you in the first place but then Hs complains about you?!

unless there is a recording of what was said, I’d demand to know what she says and insists you were polite she is lying and demand she gets banned in return.

If I was that manager I would not want people like that there. She’ll offend and upset just about every staff member and other customer.

Woah - good thing you're not working in customer services 🤭

Morgysmum · 10/01/2024 10:24

I have been there. Not in the same situation, but I work in retail and it's super frustrating when they roll in just before you close.
I don't think you did anything wrong, you explained that the computer was off.
If she was really wanting help, she wouldn't have been on the phone.
You may have been a little short, but when you are tired I get it.
I doubt they can fire you over this, you might get a ticking off. Which if you ask me, would be a over reaction. You got a Karen before you closed, I think you handled it well. Sadly "customers," have got really rude and bad mannered since covid. That isn't just my opinion, it's from my colleagues, my partner (also works retail) and a few other people, I have spoken to at the bus stop, retail workers and sadly a nurse, who said even patients are being awful to staff and make going into work stressful.

Trainingfairy · 10/01/2024 09:54

This is pretty striaghtforward. Clearly you were a bit rude and didn't give her the chance to explain her query. In mitigation you were tired and the company (for some reason!) closes the system down 30 mins before closing. Both of those points are not the customer's problem so yes, you could have dealt with it better and maybe your employer will suggest some customer service training. It would be helpful for you to know why the systems are closed down early as that doesn't help you to deal with customer queries after close down.
The fact that the customer was rude talking on her phone whilst dealing with you is not within your control. Additionally, although the customer can make a formal complaint about you which no doubt your employer will investigate, the customer does not have the power to put your head on the block and demand your dismissal. There is no way this fairly low level transgression will result in you losing your job; there'll be an investigation of the facts, you might be called to a disciplinary hearing with your employer, assuming you don't have any other warnings on your record you'll probably get a warning which will sit on your file for 12 months and additional training recommended. The customer will be appeased with an explanation about why you couldn't deal with her problem and an admission of bad customer service and an apology. And that should be it. Anything over and above this is entirely inappropriate so push back if that is the case. Take some time to reflect, think about how you could have better managed this situation and learn from it - and move on. I'm sure everything will be fine OP.

Rottweilermummy · 10/01/2024 09:27

Yes could have dealt with it differently in hindsight , but coming into somewhere 2 mins before closing is not best time, if you need assistance in any way either. Tough for you that you had had bad day short staffed for way you answered , you don't deserve to be sacked, though

MaisyAndTallulah · 10/01/2024 01:00

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 09/01/2024 23:51

@MaisyAndTallulah - maybe read the whole thread and how the OP spoke about people of pensioner (why do you still use that old fashioned word so much in the UK btw??) age not being able to cope with technical issues. She has not presented her case well at all.

I did thanks. Your posts are a great example of rudeness.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 09/01/2024 23:52

Well said @mandlerparr.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 09/01/2024 23:51

@MaisyAndTallulah - maybe read the whole thread and how the OP spoke about people of pensioner (why do you still use that old fashioned word so much in the UK btw??) age not being able to cope with technical issues. She has not presented her case well at all.

poetryandwine · 09/01/2024 22:24

PS. When there us a trend, as the OP speaks of. Of course there is probably the odd person who will have a difficult time with any app and who may be more likely to be older

poetryandwine · 09/01/2024 22:20

MaisyAndTallulah · 09/01/2024 20:24

Good lord,what a mean post. The OP asked whether she was rude, not for a critique on her technology skills.

Her posts have been honest, civil and easy to read.

I think she's got the message loud and clear that yes, she was rude. It's not really what she was asking though; she was asking for support at a time when she was fearful of losing her job.

How easy it is for you to post a withering message, anonymously, to someone who's feeling vulnerable. What a mean thing to do. Does it make you feel powerful?

Surely everyone knows that working reception in a leisure centre is unlikely to be highly paid or carrying great benefits.

People like you with your lofty attitudes and inability to empathise cause so much unnecessary upset.

Perhaps it is you who needs to reflect on their rudeness and take time to "retrain" in basic manners.

Edited

I was responding to OP’s assumption that

a. This customer was likely to have a tech query

b. As she is a pensioner, answering it would likely be difficult

c. This is an intrinsic characteristic of her age

I stand by my belief that these notions reflect bias, and that an inability to explain an app to customers cannot be blamed (primarily) on the customers

mandlerparr · 09/01/2024 21:34

and longevity has nothing to do with it. There are plenty of people who have been in jobs for decades who aren't doing those jobs very well.

mandlerparr · 09/01/2024 21:32

Noshowlomo · 09/01/2024 08:34

You can tell the people who have worked in retail/customer facing roles on this thread. The ones who support the OP.
Everyone bleating on about customer service is king, clearly have never seen the absolute worst of humanity which you do in customer facing roles.
The “maybe you shouldn’t work in customer service” means nothing, because absolutely everyone who does or has had been on the receiving end of shit from the public. So if everyone quit, the next lot would also be on the receiving end of shit from the public. Working in customer service seems to make you an emotional punch bag and we’re all human. The OP doesn’t clock on and turn into a robot. 8 years and no issues, so I’d say she’s a great candidate to work in CS. A lot give up much sooner due to their treatment and how they are talked to by customers.
Be better customers !

I have worked retail and customer service which means I know exactly how an employee is supposed to act and what the OP did is not it. She treated this customer shabbily based on her tiredness and previous customers. This customer did nothing to her. Frankly, my experience makes me judge workers by how I would handle things in their situation. I don't threaten to get anyone fired or demand it. In this situation I would have just told the OP to not interrupt customers, especially within the first few seconds of them speaking. Sure, if they start in on a rant, take control of the conversation. But even by the OP's own words, the customer didn't even get to ask anything. It is obvious that the OP either had poor customer service training or was not trained at all. This is what I always assume first when an employee behaves badly, especially for no reason or for being expected to do their job. That they have had no training or need to be trained on how to do their job. Having said that, OP's further responses and excuses have made it pretty clear that they need more than a bit of training and that a customer facing position may not be the best type of work for them. Some people just don't have the right personality for it and that is okay, but they should realize it before they have a miserable life doing jobs they aren't suited for. Or at least until they learn to not take out a hard workday on the customers.

Islandgirl68 · 09/01/2024 21:14

Don't see how that is rude. It was two minutes to closing. You just interrupted her to let her know you would not be able to help as the pcs were off. It was rude of her to expect some help when the doors were about to be locked up. Yiu had every right to let her know it was shutting time and she would have to come back. Having good customer service does not mean being a door mat.

CoffeeMama1 · 09/01/2024 20:48

They sound like an asshole..it's rude to expect to be served anywhere if you're on your phone, that's rude full stop.

Noshowlomo · 09/01/2024 20:47

My post was in response to @ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming

Noshowlomo · 09/01/2024 20:46

I know of soooo many people who leave as they don’t like customer service because of the customers. That’s why customer service jobs such as retail/call centre work have shelf lives. There are Facebook and Reddit pages dedicated to horrible/crazy customer stories and lots of “I left retail then and vowed never to return”. I would never work in a customer facing role again.
You can be as dedicated to customer service as you like but you’ll still get people taking their bad days out on you. I was once complained about for being too friendly. I’ve had money thrown at me, dirty looks, been told my boobs were nice, moaned at because tea bags had gone up in price, listened to my colleague get shouted at on Tesco deli counter because they wouldn’t reduce food that didn’t need reducing, and much much more. It can be a HORRIBLE job.
Now, what happened between the OP and customer could have been handled better but I know of the pain of finishing a certain time and customers strolling around, smug and 5 mins before a shop closes and without a care that workers also have family and kids to go home to, kids to pick up etc. Again, human beings not robots.

Doublebiscuit77 · 09/01/2024 20:35

You were rude but it's not a fireable offence. For next time, I'd say one of two options- let her finish, treat her as if she was the first customer of the day regardless of anything else, kindly explain about your systems, offer to make an appointment to go through her issue at another time, go overboard etc.
Or explain in a much less blunt, clear and apologetic way about the systems, make an appointment etc (even if you don't do appointments, just make out you do, make her feel special).
She was rude too on her phone.
Also, why hadn't you had a break? Pretty poor on your company's part.

MaisyAndTallulah · 09/01/2024 20:24

poetryandwine · 09/01/2024 10:37

I have worked customer facing roles when young and I have had sympathy for the OP from the beginning of her first post, although I agree with many that cutting the customer off was wrong. My sympathy elevated when we learnt that the customer is escalating her complaint over this relatively minor matter. It isn’t worthy of sacking and I doubt management will think otherwise.

But OP, like@Neriah I know people of pensionable age who could undoubtedly put your technical skills to shame. That’s not a criticism; they could do the same to most people. It is a suggestion that you harbour bias.

Your command of written English on this thread is adequate at best. That’s not a criticism either but it does suggest that if you find it difficult to explain things you may be part of the problem.

Good lord,what a mean post. The OP asked whether she was rude, not for a critique on her technology skills.

Her posts have been honest, civil and easy to read.

I think she's got the message loud and clear that yes, she was rude. It's not really what she was asking though; she was asking for support at a time when she was fearful of losing her job.

How easy it is for you to post a withering message, anonymously, to someone who's feeling vulnerable. What a mean thing to do. Does it make you feel powerful?

Surely everyone knows that working reception in a leisure centre is unlikely to be highly paid or carrying great benefits.

People like you with your lofty attitudes and inability to empathise cause so much unnecessary upset.

Perhaps it is you who needs to reflect on their rudeness and take time to "retrain" in basic manners.

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 09/01/2024 20:06

Platypuslover · 09/01/2024 18:17

what an entitled twat that is. Rude to start with that’s she’s on the phone while speaking to you in the first place but then Hs complains about you?!

unless there is a recording of what was said, I’d demand to know what she says and insists you were polite she is lying and demand she gets banned in return.

If I was that manager I would not want people like that there. She’ll offend and upset just about every staff member and other customer.

There are no words ...........

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 09/01/2024 20:02

PriOn1 · 09/01/2024 15:20

The main trouble is not the customers but those colleagues that always manage to get everyone's backs up and escalate every bad situation.

I call bollocks on this.

You’re one of those customers.

And you don't know what you are talking about. As I said in a previous posts, the majority of people I know who left a customer service role did so because of difficult staff rather than difficult customers.

@QueenCamilla is right.

NoNotMyHair · 09/01/2024 19:46

@Londdi no one cares what kind of day you have had - a customer isn't there to care. They are there to get a service which she has paid for. I worked with the public in many roles over my years from student to now. All it really takes is a little bit of people handling - there is no need to be bending over backwards or anything else. They just want to know you heard them and can inform them of what to do next. Very easy! Perhaps you would be better suited elsewhere.

martinisforeveryone · 09/01/2024 19:36

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 09/01/2024 19:03

Nope - I worked in customer service of one kind or another for almost 50 years. The place I worked for the longest, 26 years, were passionate about customer service, it was the cornerstone of the business. I think OP was extremely rude.

Surely you realise that we have all struck difficult customers - way more difficult than the woman OP is talking about - and yet none of us quit because we couldn't deal with it. It was our job to deal with it. If someone goes into customer service thinking it's all going to be fluffy and sweet then they really, really, shouldn't be in the job. I don't know of a single person who left because they couldn't deal with the customers so you are talking rubbish.

I think the arrogance of stating that you can tell who's never worked in customer services sums up why there are so many complaints about poor customer service, and not only from people from (I paraphrase) a 'bygone age' My DCs complain of the same, but to be fair, we also all compliment and give thanks where due.

Let it be said that the role is most often poorly rewarded both in pay and in praise and that customers or clients can be an absolute PITA to deal with. Some.
No one appears to be disputing that. If you take that role though, you can still conduct yourself in a skilled and professional manner.

I've been customer facing and have worked Christmas Eve and New Year Eve many times, under the most demanding situations, so I do absolutely know both sides of the coin. This swimming pool member was rude being on the phone while approaching the desk last minute, but it doesn't excuse the OP's response. The customer was also reacting totally out of proportion if they sent in multiple email complaints, but still there is a case for more training because this situation was badly handled.