Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not understand the use of dummies!

106 replies

FestiveMulledWine · 28/11/2023 10:58

New mum here!

I don’t understand dummies! They seem to cause more issues in the long run:

  • Baby won’t sleep through the night as they wake for their dummy.
  • Baby is teething so is fussy with dummy.
  • Baby gets emotionally attached to dummy so it’s hard to remove.
  • Once teeth arrive the dummy, if used a lot pushes the teeth forward.
  • The dummy hinders the muscles in the tongue from developing causing speech issues.

I genuinely don’t get why you’d give a dummy?

OP posts:
Hollyhead · 28/11/2023 10:59

They can help babies learn to self soothe/settle which is a valuable (yet currently unfashionable) skill for them to learn as often as possible once they’re out the tiny newborn phase. I agree sometimes they can be more of a hinderance, and they need to be removed early intoddlerhood if possible.

Santaiswashinghissleigh · 28/11/2023 11:00

Maybe look at SIDS information..

YorkshirePuddingBelongs · 28/11/2023 11:00

Don’t give your kid a dummy then.

What do you want, a medal for being a better parent?

PomBearsandaFruitShoot · 28/11/2023 11:00

It’s comforting for them and can help prevent SIDS!! My little boy stopped using his day and night all by himself around 21 months old 🤷‍♀️

SandwichSnarfer · 28/11/2023 11:01

They reduce the risk of SIDS if used consistently

They don’t cause speech issues if their use is stopped timeously

They’re enormously soothing to babies and can be an invaluable source of comfort

They’re easier to remove than a thumb, which is what a lot of children will rely on instead

My son would never take one, but for the SIDS risk mitigation alone I would have loved it if he had.

FestiveMulledWine · 28/11/2023 11:02

@YorkshirePuddingBelongs yes please, one with a golden ribbon. 🙄

It was a genuine question because so, so many people have told me to give LO a dummy and I don’t get the obsession with them!

OP posts:
HeddaGarbled · 28/11/2023 11:02

When they’ve used your nipple as a soother for the last several hours and you’re red raw ……. then you’ll understand.

Pandamumium · 28/11/2023 11:02

I didn’t want to give my children a dummy. My DS, my eldest, never had one, but sucked his thumb.
DD1 had reflux. After one night when she was awake and crying for 6 hours we tried a dummy. It worked. Waking during the night to replace the dummy was better than being awake for hours on end.

User1775 · 28/11/2023 11:02

Yeah, you're a new mum and probably, from the tone of your post have some support and an easy baby. Wind your neck in and let others do what is best for them. Almost ALL parents love and want the best for their children and there is no one right way. Dummies and handmade pacifiers have been used since for well over 5000 years, it is a new thing.

Thehop · 28/11/2023 11:03

2 of mine had one, 2 didn't

they reduce risk of SIDS

some children like them, some don't

you genuinely cannot understand that every parent is different?

YorkshirePuddingBelongs · 28/11/2023 11:03

FestiveMulledWine · 28/11/2023 11:02

@YorkshirePuddingBelongs yes please, one with a golden ribbon. 🙄

It was a genuine question because so, so many people have told me to give LO a dummy and I don’t get the obsession with them!

Do you feel you need to understand? It’s really not hard to figure out why someone might give a child a dummy.

SandwichSnarfer · 28/11/2023 11:03

HeddaGarbled · 28/11/2023 11:02

When they’ve used your nipple as a soother for the last several hours and you’re red raw ……. then you’ll understand.

Yes, the number of times I tried giving my son one when I was bleeding from the nipples and crying because I so badly needed even 30 minutes of him not being latched! If he had taken a dummy it would have given me just a little respite.

ElevenSeven · 28/11/2023 11:04

Yes, yabu.

FestiveMulledWine · 28/11/2023 11:05

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Sirzy · 28/11/2023 11:05

Ds didn’t have a dummy until he was in hospital at 8 weeks old. The staff then asked if they could give him one to help soothe and regulate his breathing.

its like a lot of things. There are pros and cons and you can make a decision based on what’s best for your baby.

pickledandpuzzled · 28/11/2023 11:05

Some children really need to soothing, and other don’t.

DS1 wouldn’t take a dummy and needed to be constantly held and jostled and flipping day. Then he found his thumb. Do you know how hard it is to remove a thumb when the teeth are being impacted?

DS2 took a dummy and easily transitioned away from it when he needed to. Then he got a cold and … found his thumb. Repeat of problem with DS1.

FS1 was the absolute pits. Developmentally delayed so couldn’t manage to keep his dummy in at night, so I slept with my arm in his crib helping him keep it in.

Point of all the above being- just you wait. Sometimes you do whatever it takes to get by.

Caffeineneedednow · 28/11/2023 11:06

As others have said SIDS is a hige concern. They also help them soothe. My eldest would throw them all down the side of the cot from about 8-9 months so we stopped them he is now 5 and sucks his thumb which is the same except we can't stop that.

My youngest is 13 months, he uses it to soothe to go to sleep and sleeps through alot better then his brother did without his dummy. Can you provide the scje tofic evidence of all of these negative scenarios specficiay the teeth and speech as I think they are rather debatable and like you said mabey only am issue if the child constantly has a dummy in their mouth which I would say is rare anyway.

PeppermintPorpoise · 28/11/2023 11:07

If you don't get it don't do it. You're going to have to learn in the coming years that all children and parents are different and that you too will be doing things other parents don't understand and might even judge you for and how to deal with these differences.

YorkshirePuddingBelongs · 28/11/2023 11:07

My DD needed a dummy because she would use my nipples to soothe and it got sore and tiring after a while. She now aged 10 sucks her thumb which sends me potty!

DS had a dummy for a few months then one day took it out and threw it out his cot never to be seen again 😂

AndrewGarfieldsLaptop · 28/11/2023 11:08

How's the weather up on that high horse

cadburyegg · 28/11/2023 11:08

Some babies find sucking very soothing. Both of mine did but I didn't want their babies sucking my nipples constantly because it made them sore. With ds2 I also had a 3 year old to look after so couldn't spend all my time holding a baby.

I took ds1's dummy away at 6 months, ds2's at 20 months ish. No issues. Their teeth are fine.

Other parents make different decisions to you, something you will witness many times over the next 10 years. Shockingly, you may also make decisions some other parents don't agree with!

Wonderlot · 28/11/2023 11:09
  1. it reduces the risk of SID’s which was very important to me
  2. First were twins and so couldn’t always feed both of them immediately, dummy soothed the one that had to wait
  3. next child used my boob as a dummy, and as she was prem it wasn’t safe to co sleep. I would therefore have to sit awake for hours each night, get around 1 hours sleep when my husband got up, then get up with 2 year old twins. The dummy saved us as it meant that once she was finished feeding but sucking for comfort, I could give her the dummy and put her in her cot. It’s been a godsend for her, never had any issues settling as I can just give her the dummy and she self settles (older two stopped using the dummy around 5 months so we then had to rock them to sleep). It’s such a source of comfort for her too, so if she cries in the car on a long journey she can have her dummy, whereas the older two would just scream continuously for 2 hours. Hasn’t affected her speech at all, she’s an early talker.

In short there are many reasons why someone might use a dummy, and it has lots of advantages. Google could probably tell you that fyi

cadburyegg · 28/11/2023 11:09
  • I didn't want them, not "their babies"
Dorriethelittlewitch · 28/11/2023 11:09

The Nicu staff insisted on giving my eldest one. I was told it was that or formula so they could stop him crying for me when I wasn't there. As he comfort fed, being able to swop my nipple for a dummy helped a lot...six hours at a time is long time to be chewed on.

With dc2 I had mixed feelings but basically it ended up being the only way to get her to go down without me attached in some way.

Over all, it worked for us. They both grew out of them naturally and with minimal issues.

Caffeineneedednow · 28/11/2023 11:09

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Both of mine also have allergies and my eldest who didn't take the dummy found his thumb and the youngest used his dummy. Sometimes when there poorly they need some kind of comfort even more.

I would have done anything to stop mine crying and if a dummy worked then that's what I did