Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not understand the use of dummies!

106 replies

FestiveMulledWine · 28/11/2023 10:58

New mum here!

I don’t understand dummies! They seem to cause more issues in the long run:

  • Baby won’t sleep through the night as they wake for their dummy.
  • Baby is teething so is fussy with dummy.
  • Baby gets emotionally attached to dummy so it’s hard to remove.
  • Once teeth arrive the dummy, if used a lot pushes the teeth forward.
  • The dummy hinders the muscles in the tongue from developing causing speech issues.

I genuinely don’t get why you’d give a dummy?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MeinKraft · 29/11/2023 00:42

Bearbookagainandagain · 28/11/2023 13:28

Baby screams screams screams, give them dummy: stops screaming.

Not rocket science

lol yes. Some babies just love dummies. Some love clinging to comforters, some love the sling, they're all different just like human adults are.

Sceptre86 · 29/11/2023 00:23

Eldest wouldn't take one. Ds did, loved his, he gave it up at 2 much more easily than expected. Dd2 has had one since she was 4 months old. It seemed to give her comfort and help with reflux.

WillowCraft · 28/11/2023 23:00

They are just a tool like anything else. Some babies are more sucky than others. Anything that settles a tiny upset baby is worth a try. One of mine did great with a dummy, the other not so much.
It's no different to why do some parents cosleep, use a sling, use a bouncer, use white noise, swaddle, give a comforter, give a bath before bed etc etc

Topofthemountain · 28/11/2023 22:49

I was never, ever going to use a dummy.

Day 4, 1am I was stood over a pan sterilising a dummy.

She wasn't particularly impressed, and soon spat it out in favour of her thumb.

SwingTheMonkey · 28/11/2023 22:28

charlotte361 · 28/11/2023 20:37

I never used dummies for the reason t I didnt want my darling babies to look like chavs

You're way too late to this thread to be trolling… 0/10 for you, my friend 👎🏻

DemelzaandRoss · 28/11/2023 21:09

It’s your choice. Personally, our youngest son loved his dummy & it (they) prevented many, many sleepless nights.
We always ensured there were a selection in his cot, so he could reach one when he needed them.
Our other children didn’t like them & preferred blankies.

Pickingmyselfup · 28/11/2023 20:59

1.Baby won’t sleep through the night as they wake for their dummy.

Sometimes they wake up for it, especially when tiny. On the whole the dummy solved more problems than it caused.

  1. Baby is teething so is fussy with dummy.

I don't remember this being an issue

  1. Baby gets emotionally attached to dummy so it’s hard to remove.

I seem to remember one or two difficult nights but they were old enough to grasp the concept that the dummies had gone.

  1. Once teeth arrive the dummy, if used a lot pushes the teeth forward.

The dentist has never said anything about my kids teeth.

  1. The dummy hinders the muscles in the tongue from developing causing speech issues.

Both of mine were late to talk and they were very attached to their dummy. I think they were mainly just late talkers because they were late doing everything but granted a dummy probably didn't help either.

I didn't breastfeed and because babies like to comfort suck I couldn't offer them anything other than milk which wasn't what they needed. A dummy helped soothe them when they were tired and needing to suck.

Research also suggests it helps protect against SIDS too. I remember reading the information and seeing how things like breastfeeding, a dummy, back sleeping and room sharing all helped.

It's a personal decision at the end of the day and on the whole it doesn't cause issues. I'm sure there will be some babies who have some or all of the issues above but it's all about weighing up the pros and cons.

I chose not to pursue breastfeeding after giving it a go both times and failing. I was comfortable with my decision to formula feed because for me the pros outweighed the cons.

angelikacpickles · 28/11/2023 20:43

FestiveMulledWine · 28/11/2023 13:42

I don’t think I’m being clear, here. I’m not judging. Family keep telling me to give LO a dummy but I just can’t see the benefits of one. I feel like they’ll cause more issues in the future so I don’t really want to but DH is listening to family and the pressure is mounting. It’s a genuine concern question not a judge. Sorry to anyone who thought I was judging. Maybe I’m just sleep deprived 😂

Why do they think you should give one? I gave both of mine dummies because they wanted to suck a lot (and were good feeders so there were no issues with weight gain etc.) but there's no need to give one if you don't want to. There definitely are benefits though - for some babies, it can settle them when nothing else will.

AuntyMabelandPippin · 28/11/2023 20:42

I hate dummies. However, I wasn't going to have a child permanently attached to my boob, which was what was happening before I gave them one in desperation.

As it happened, two of mine had them, two sucked their thumbs (within days of birth). The difference was, the two with dummies had them in their cot only till the dummy fairy took them at three, the two who used their thumbs were still sucking them when they were eight.

charlotte361 · 28/11/2023 20:37

I never used dummies for the reason t I didnt want my darling babies to look like chavs

TheGlitterFairy · 28/11/2023 20:37

DS was preemie and the NICU staff asked if we wanted to use a dummy to a) help soothe him when he was in his incubator and then b) to teach him to suck / feed so that we could remove the tube that we had to feed him through to transition to a bottle (with pumped milk then formula).

At the time I would have done anything to get him feeding, healthy and out of hospital so we decided to run with it.

He’s recently given it up himself at nearly 2.5yrs which is amazing. For the last year he’s only had it for sleep anyway so I’m happy with what we did and how he/ we’ve weaned him off it.

honeylulu · 28/11/2023 20:27

If your baby is good at self soothing then I'd agree, no need for a dummy, even less need to be "obsessed" with dummies.

But you mention being sleep deprived which may or may not mean your baby ... isn't self soothing? If so a dummy might help.

I didn't want mine to have dummies. I thought they looked "common". I'm really ashamed of myself now. My eldest really struggled to self soothe even though he was tired and was trying to go to sleep. (He didn't like being held or rocked or fed to sleep.) The dummy gave him that little bit of extra comfort. I was very judicious with it and I'd remove it when he was asleep. He only had it from 6 weeks to 12 weeks.

I was more knackered and defeated with youngest and she was a VERY sucky baby. I would have been her 24 hour human dummy if she had her way. She had a dummy earlier and for much longer. But she has nice straight teeth and was an early non-stop talker so it really wasn't a problem. The only slight regret I have is that in most of her baby photos she's got a dummy in her gob.

Benibidibici · 28/11/2023 20:27

Agreed, id have preferred either of mine to suck their thumb. They can't lose it in the cot at night and they tend to be easier to wean off a thumb during the day imho as they want to use both hands to play which stops them sucking, whereas a dummy they can suck constantly while having hands free.

Greybluewhite · 28/11/2023 20:24

Mine had dummies to reduce the risk of SIDS. I would try anything to reduce it even a little bit.

My first two used it for naptimes and bedtime mainly, no problems giving it up. It was also a lifesaver for DC3 who suffered with horrible reflux.

I find people who don’t use dummies tend to be judgey, no idea why.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 28/11/2023 20:01

My dd1 was still sucking her thumb after she learned to drive.
Just saying.

Jimmyspiano · 28/11/2023 19:26

Babies who are tube fed sometimes have a dummy to prevent oral aversion. It also helps babies who use CPAP to create a good seal to allow it to work more effectively.

SarahAndQuack · 28/11/2023 19:25

FestiveMulledWine · 28/11/2023 13:42

I don’t think I’m being clear, here. I’m not judging. Family keep telling me to give LO a dummy but I just can’t see the benefits of one. I feel like they’ll cause more issues in the future so I don’t really want to but DH is listening to family and the pressure is mounting. It’s a genuine concern question not a judge. Sorry to anyone who thought I was judging. Maybe I’m just sleep deprived 😂

I get it.

DD was not an easy baby - she had sepsis when she was newborn and kept losing weight for ages; she didn't sleep for years. But, the one thing she didn't seem fussed about was sucking to soothe. Some babies just aren't. She didn't want a dummy; she didn't suck her thumb; she didn't particularly want to feed all the time (in fact getting her to feed was usually the challenge).

I do remember getting a little bit ticked off by people constantly saying 'aww, she needs a dummy!' We did try a few times just in case it was magic, but she spat them out and cried. After those few tries it became quite annoying that people would keep saying 'aw she needs one' because clearly, it wasn't helpful for her.

I absolutely would have got dummies for her if she'd been a sucky baby or could use it to self-sooth. Frankly, by the time she was 18 months, if someone had told me laudanum was back in vogue, I'd have gone for it. So it is annoying when people assume you're not giving a baby a dummy just because your baby is easy.

Hankunamatata · 28/11/2023 19:23

I wouldn't have continued bf if it wasn't for a dummy. I also wanted to stop thumb sucking and sids was also a huge concern

Mumtobabyhavoc · 28/11/2023 19:19

All babies are different. I was extremely lucky with mine: didn't really want it and a very short period of thumb-sucking. I never really offered one.
Now, weaning off the bottle... different story altogether. 🤷‍♀️

cakewench · 28/11/2023 18:57

Sorry OP but your post really does come off as judgmental. We get a lot of posters feigning ignorance on a topic when it's really just a stealth brag ("ooh I've no idea why someone would feed their child non-organic homemade everything when it's so obvious that anything less is basically poison. Or do you think I should feel my baby pureed McDonalds like my friends do?" Like no middle ground ever.

Anyway. DS had a dummy, and I agree with others, it's a lot easier to ween them off a dummy than their thumb. Also it meant he could fall asleep alone a lot easier (not 'alone' but, I and my boobs weren't required to be there for every single bedtime).

Probably loads of other reasons as well. I did limit it to bedtimes so it wasn't an out and about thing, though other people do that and there's nothing wrong with that. I don't see loads of adults with them so I'm assuming they all managed to wean eventually.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 28/11/2023 17:42

I never had one for dd1, who found her thumb from birth (and v likely even before) but in desperation (I had been very anti dummies*) gave one to dd2 at a few weeks old because she had 3 months’ colic and it was the only thing that seemed to give her any relief.

It was a godsend even after the colic. If she had her dummy and bit of blanket, she’d happily go to sleep anywhere, and we were travelling quite a bit.

She didn’t give it up altogether until she was coming up to 6.

Her speech was never at all affected and her teeth (she’s long grown up) were always perfect.

*I’m old enough to remember when dummies were thought of as a very common, lower class thing, and I’m sure a lot of the ‘anti’ still stems from this. Personally I’d advise anyone to try one with a new baby if they have trouble getting it to sleep.

RedStripeypillow · 28/11/2023 17:30

Both of mine had a dummy. They were a brilliant tool to settle my babies. We used them until about 2 and it was easy to give up. I can honestly say, we had problems with absolutely none of the points you made. They have lovely teeth and speak beautifully and are both teenagers with no Ill effects from the dummies.

On the other hand I have friends whose children didn't have dummies, who then sucked their thumb and this is more of an issue with teeth and finding it hard to stop it.

CornTheCob · 28/11/2023 17:01

Dummies were a permanent fixture with mine.
When I was pregnant with my first I said there was no way I was giving a dummy.
Within a few days after the birth, I was almost kicking the door of boots off its hinges in my desperation to buy a dummy.
Peace was restored in Ches CornTheCob.

x2boys · 28/11/2023 16:58

Well as oh say your a new mum ,we are all perfect parents x before we actually have children
Fwiw I sucked my thumb until u was 9/10
My boys both had a dummy ,you can throw dummies away you can't throw a thumb away.

pickledandpuzzled · 28/11/2023 16:48

@Maxus I posted in favour of dummies earlier. This post wasn’t a dismissal of dummies but a response to OP wondering why they were pushing the dummy on a baby who didn’t need it. I can see it was unclear.

I agree, babies need various comforters and shouldn’t be denied them!

Some people also seem to like ‘stage marker’ items like dummies, rusks, first trainers, denim jackets and haircuts.
I am not a fan. But some do, and a dummy can be used in that way/fall into that category. Maybe because there’s only so much you can give a baby that the baby cares about?

Swipe left for the next trending thread