Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not understand the use of dummies!

106 replies

FestiveMulledWine · 28/11/2023 10:58

New mum here!

I don’t understand dummies! They seem to cause more issues in the long run:

  • Baby won’t sleep through the night as they wake for their dummy.
  • Baby is teething so is fussy with dummy.
  • Baby gets emotionally attached to dummy so it’s hard to remove.
  • Once teeth arrive the dummy, if used a lot pushes the teeth forward.
  • The dummy hinders the muscles in the tongue from developing causing speech issues.

I genuinely don’t get why you’d give a dummy?

OP posts:
MadameCamembert · 28/11/2023 11:10

Maybe because some people might be a stressed line parent and need a little help with comforting? Or might have multiple kids? Or might have a difficult to settle baby?

Come on. Don’t be so facetious.

You might thing you’ve mastered the mum thing but, believe me, you’ll soon realise that we’re all just doing our best. It sounds like as a new mum you’ve just not had chance to learn that yet.

HeliumChestedTrollop · 28/11/2023 11:10

As soon as all my 3 were born, I gave them a dummy. The reason is that I was never allowed one and therefore sucked my thumb and all my life I have had crooked teeth because of it. My children have lovely straight teeth. Dummies do NOT cause crooked teeth, they are soft and help prevent it.

I never breastfed but my babies were all big and constantly hungry and wanting to be sucking on something all the time so dummies were a lifesaver for me

Fridaysgirl17 · 28/11/2023 11:11

My first had one as he was 6 weeks premature & under 5 lbs & his suck reflex wasn't fully developed so NICU staff recommended it to help him as he wasn't able to feed properly & required tube feeding & it really helped him. My second was also premature but almost doubled his brother's weight so he fed easier & I had soothers for him but he was never very interested might have used it once or twice.

35965a · 28/11/2023 11:11

‘I don’t get it’ usually means ‘I do get it but I’m judging’

Stringagal · 28/11/2023 11:12

Neither of mine had a dummy, but I wished I’d given one to my youngest. She sucked her fingers for years, causing problems with her teeth and a big ugly lumps on her fingers.

We tried everything to get her to stop, in the end I emailed her dentist ahead of an appointment and he quite bluntly showed her photos of children with wonky teeth caused by thumb sucking. He told her when the next tooth fell out she had to stop, and miraculously she did. She was 6 - a dummy would’ve been taken away years before that!

violetcuriosity · 28/11/2023 11:12

I'm guessing you haven't met colic 😂 or cluster feeding when you need a wee!

PrimalLass · 28/11/2023 11:12

How new? Why are you judging decades if not centuries of mothers who've been there done that?

RafaistheKingofClay · 28/11/2023 11:14

It won’t deal with the cause of the pain, but babies get comfort from sucking so will help them deal with it much better.

Also the SIDS thing and it’s easier to wean off than a thumb.

MaryShelley1818 · 28/11/2023 11:15

As pretty much everyone has educated you, they reduce the risk of SIDs...some babies won't use one but why would you not at least try to protect your child as much as possible.
Both of mine only used them for sleeping, both had very advanced speech, both were removed at approximately 18mths with no issues whatsoever.
Plus they never cried for them overnight when they spat them out.

I can't tell whether you're genuinely asking for information but if you were hth.

Almondmum · 28/11/2023 11:15

I can't work out if you're being deliberately obtuse...but I'll reply as if you're genuine and try and keep it simple.

Your baby is crying a lot..you've tried everything, they don't calm down. At this point your frazzled and knackered and just about ready to try anything that won't cause actual harm. You give a dummy. It stops them crying.

Or. You breastfeed and they want to be on the boob permanently and you can tell they're really feeding. you're frazzled and exhausted so you try a dummy instead. It works.

Of course if your baby is happy and settled without one you wouldn't introduce it. But can you really not see why people would if they're not?!

LegoLegoParrot · 28/11/2023 11:15

A dummy can reduce the risk of SIDS and it helps to soothe them? For what it's worth, DS rejected his at 6 months so no issues at all with speech or teeth.
I'd have no issue using one again.

dcsp · 28/11/2023 11:16

We had not intended to use a dummy.

DS was born at 34weeks + 2 days and was initially tube-fed; the staff in the Special Care Baby Unit gave him a green feeding-trainer dummy to help him transition from that to expressed milk in a bottle.

Having used this (with the desired outcome) he was then used to having a dummy - so he had a dummy for quite a while.

I'm not saying that the OP is saying they don't "understand the use of dummies" in a judgy way, but it's not a big jump from saying that to judging other people, often without the knowledge/understanding of their specific circumstances.

ElaineMBenes · 28/11/2023 11:16

I genuinely don’t get why you’d give a dummy?

Then don't use one.

However, lots of parents choose to give their child a dummy and that's okay. They have their benefits.

OfMark87 · 28/11/2023 11:17

My two both have/had a dummy.

My oldest is 6, has the most beautiful teeth and her speech is amazing and she had a dummy at night until she was 3.

My youngest is 17 months and he still has one for sleep and when he's upset. His speech is coming on a treat.

I gave them a dummy on the advice of the midwives when my oldest once in scbu x

Necessitynamechange · 28/11/2023 11:17

FestiveMulledWine · 28/11/2023 10:58

New mum here!

I don’t understand dummies! They seem to cause more issues in the long run:

  • Baby won’t sleep through the night as they wake for their dummy.
  • Baby is teething so is fussy with dummy.
  • Baby gets emotionally attached to dummy so it’s hard to remove.
  • Once teeth arrive the dummy, if used a lot pushes the teeth forward.
  • The dummy hinders the muscles in the tongue from developing causing speech issues.

I genuinely don’t get why you’d give a dummy?

Do you mean to sound so smug?

My ds had one at the suggestion of a doctor because it soothed the pain of cannulation when he was tiny and ill.

My daughter had one because she liked it.

Both got rid at 6 months and it never caused an issue.

Puffintop · 28/11/2023 11:18

So people have suggested using one, you don’t want too… I’m not sure what the issue is?
its been a while since I’ve had a baby but I don’t remember roving hoards of soother dealers forcing them on my infants 🤷🏻‍♀️
use one, don’t use one, I can guarantee you that no one else really cares.

KeepSmiling89 · 28/11/2023 11:18

I'm a speech and language therapist and research has actually shown that dummies don't cause speech issues (when used properly):
https://speechandlanguage.org.uk/talking-point/parents/do-dummies-affect-speech/#:~:text=Advice%20for%20Parents%20%26%20Carers&text=It%20may%20also%20be%20advisable,speech%20skills%20in%20young%20children.

They have their place in terms of soothing babies (hence why they're also called 'soothers' or 'pacifiers'). As long as they're not used when a baby/toddler is trying to speak, they won't cause any issues speech-wise.
My advice - keep them to nap/bedtimes to soothe baby and keep it away during the day when they should be babbling and experimenting with speech sounds etc.

Do dummies affect speech?

https://speechandlanguage.org.uk/talking-point/parents/do-dummies-affect-speech#:~:text=Advice%20for%20Parents%20%26%20Carers&text=It%20may%20also%20be%20advisable,speech%20skills%20in%20young%20children.

Oganesson118 · 28/11/2023 11:18

I think there's something about them helping with SIDS, and if they don't have a dummy they will find their thumb or something which is harder to remove.

My daughter never took to a dummy so it became a non issue for us but I don't think they're a terrible thing (though not keen on seeing pre schoolers/school age kids with them, barring SEN etc)

FuckingHellAdele · 28/11/2023 11:18

FestiveMulledWine · Today 10:58

New mum here!

Yes sunshine, we know. We know.

Maxus · 28/11/2023 11:18

Oh look, another new mum who thinks they know it all 😏 my youngest had a dummy, he needed the comfort that a dummy brough. He needed it untill he was 4 for comfort and to help him sleep. It didn't affect his teeth before you go there, at 15 he has had zero problems and they are perfectly straight. It didn't affect his speech, he was talking in sentences at 16 months and never stopped since. It helped with SIDS. I am perfectly happy that he had a dummy, it soothed him alongside all the cuddles and a interactions in the world. It stopped him becoming distressed, he is now a confident intellegent teenager. Do I regret the dummy? Absolutely 100% not.

DGPP · 28/11/2023 11:18

Because it helps with colic and crying? Do some reading

IglesiasPiggl · 28/11/2023 11:18

Dummies only cause issues if usage continues beyond early toddlerhood. There is loads of time before that, when a dummy helps settle a baby. That's why people use them. My DS1 had one between 6 and 16 weeks then decided he didn't like it. DS2 was never interested. They're all different.

HeliumChestedTrollop · 28/11/2023 11:19

and one of mine even had his dummy still overnight when he started school at 4 and half, he used it for comfort I think, so shoot me now, #badmother😂

he is now a well adjusted 32 year old and no he does not still have the dummy😃

PTSDBarbiegirl · 28/11/2023 11:19

As you say, you're a NEW parent, congratulations.

Bigroundpear · 28/11/2023 11:20

My kids wouldn’t use one - despite me trying so ended up using me as a human dummy around 20 hours of the day… I felt I was going to die of exhaustion. Managing dummy problems would have been blessed relief.