Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not understand the use of dummies!

106 replies

FestiveMulledWine · 28/11/2023 10:58

New mum here!

I don’t understand dummies! They seem to cause more issues in the long run:

  • Baby won’t sleep through the night as they wake for their dummy.
  • Baby is teething so is fussy with dummy.
  • Baby gets emotionally attached to dummy so it’s hard to remove.
  • Once teeth arrive the dummy, if used a lot pushes the teeth forward.
  • The dummy hinders the muscles in the tongue from developing causing speech issues.

I genuinely don’t get why you’d give a dummy?

OP posts:
Radiatorlife · 28/11/2023 11:20

I gave DD a dummy as she was a ‘sucky’ baby and would have otherwise wanted to be sucking my nipple for 23 hours of the day. She had a dummy for around 2 years. No teeth issues, no speech issues and no problems taking it away. She never lost it in the night.

I would rather her have a dummy over sucking her thumb anytime.

ghostyslovesheets · 28/11/2023 11:20

Babies suck to sooth - I had two thumb suckers and a dummy user

teeth wise the thumb suckers needed much more invasive braces and treatment - dummy had a brace for 12 months (2+ years for the thumbs)

dummy was given to the pigs at the children’s farm at 2 - thumbs very hard to remove!

Lovingitallnow · 28/11/2023 11:20

Why do people eat chocolate? Why do they drive instead of walk? Why do they stay up late? Why do they leave the kitchen in a mess in the morning? Why do some people iron? Why do some people not iron? Why don't people moisturise every day? Why don't people wear sunscreen? Why do people pray? Why don't people pray? I mean, you could ask anything I guess. Every one has their preferences and babies are no different.

SwingTheMonkey · 28/11/2023 11:21

Oh to be a first time mum who thinks they’ve won parenting 😂

Do you really need to understand why people use them, op? Don’t want to use one? Then don’t.

And by the way, over the coming years, (you’ll no doubt not believe this, as you’re a perfect mum!) you’ll lose count of the number of times you are judged for something you are doing or not doing with your kids…

ChristmasSugarplumFairy · 28/11/2023 11:21

Reduces SIDs risk, soothes baby, gave my nipples a rest, easier to remove than a thumb, very handy to smear some bonjela on when teething... So many reasons.
DS1s speech was way ahead of the rest of his cohort of so it never did him any harm that way and his teeth are perfect.

AlltheFs · 28/11/2023 11:22

I didn’t use one as I found it easier just to have her latched on - she fed so much that it didn’t seem worth using a dummy.
I never felt any pressure to use one.

I do think they can be very useful but I am glad we never had anything to wean off - but I did opt for extended BF to 26 months so in essence I was the substitute.

Dramatic · 28/11/2023 11:24

Some kids need the comfort of sucking on something, my step daughter sucks her two middle fingers, she's now 8 and it's caused huge issues with her teeth and her speech and it's been impossible to stop her.

Dd1 never had a dummy or sucked her thumb

My other three kids have all had a dummy and it was great for them as babies young toddlers. Only used for sleep and illness and taken away when they were about 2, caused no issues with their teeth or speech.

I know which I'd rather 🤷

SandwichSnarfer · 28/11/2023 11:24

AlltheFs · 28/11/2023 11:22

I didn’t use one as I found it easier just to have her latched on - she fed so much that it didn’t seem worth using a dummy.
I never felt any pressure to use one.

I do think they can be very useful but I am glad we never had anything to wean off - but I did opt for extended BF to 26 months so in essence I was the substitute.

Unfortunately, breastfeeding my son well into his second year hasn’t stopped him from becoming a thumb sucker. It would be much easier to wean him off a dummy 😭

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 28/11/2023 11:27

Dummies aren’t a new thing. Also, neither are children’s thumbs.

My advice to you is to step away from google, don’t get too obsessed with doing things by the book/the ‘best’ way, and don’t judge other parents.

SallyWD · 28/11/2023 11:34

I had an extremely fussy baby who would not settle and slept badly. I gave her a dummy and problem solved! She was calm, she settled, she slept better. I put lots of dummies in the cot so she could get one if she lost it. When she was nearly two the dummy fairy came and that was that. No problems at all.

Chickenkeev · 28/11/2023 11:37

Stringagal · 28/11/2023 11:12

Neither of mine had a dummy, but I wished I’d given one to my youngest. She sucked her fingers for years, causing problems with her teeth and a big ugly lumps on her fingers.

We tried everything to get her to stop, in the end I emailed her dentist ahead of an appointment and he quite bluntly showed her photos of children with wonky teeth caused by thumb sucking. He told her when the next tooth fell out she had to stop, and miraculously she did. She was 6 - a dummy would’ve been taken away years before that!

I was still sucking my thumb (covertly!) in secondary school. Needless to say, I ended up with braces. Gave my DD a dodie/dummy, and it was surprisingly easy to wean her off it. It helps when it's not attached to your body 😂

Nevermind31 · 28/11/2023 11:38

Try it, it may change your life. Or it may not - it really depends on your child.

ManateeFair · 28/11/2023 11:40

I genuinely don’t get why you’d give a dummy?

Don't give one, then.

Maxus · 28/11/2023 11:43

FestiveMulledWine · 28/11/2023 11:02

@YorkshirePuddingBelongs yes please, one with a golden ribbon. 🙄

It was a genuine question because so, so many people have told me to give LO a dummy and I don’t get the obsession with them!

It's not an obsession. It's doing what's right and works for your individual baby. All the baby's are different and what works and is right for one won't be for another

LuvSmallDogs · 28/11/2023 11:44

None of mine were dummy babies, despite my best efforts and wasting money on several different kinds. My mum always said dummies look horrible and didn't use them, but I think babies look lovely and a dummy can't change that! If I were you I'd buy a couple of decent ones to try just to see if they help your LO or not.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 28/11/2023 11:45

I did it to reduce risk of SIDs as they were formula fed. My nearly two year old uses them to go to sleep with. Sounds almost a bit judgey this, OP.

Winniespooh · 28/11/2023 11:46

Mine liked it. And frankly I couldn't listen to her screaming and crying every evening when I tried to go for a wee or when I went to make some food or had to put her down for 2 seconds.

WeeBenny · 28/11/2023 11:49

My DS was born at 32 weeks and given one in the nicu to help him develop his suck reflex. I got rid of it when he was 3 with no issues. He only had it for bed from 2

Maray1967 · 28/11/2023 11:51

Try removing a sore cracked thumb from a two year olds mouth at night.

That’s why I was so relieved that DS2, unlike his older brother, loved his dummies.

Dummies helped both of mine self soothe in the first few weeks. I had no intention of using them - our brilliant mw suggested them when I was over feeding them.

DS2 had no speech issues and his dental issues (shark tooth) have nothing to do with dummy use according to our dentist.

Looplee123 · 28/11/2023 11:53

I wanted to use a dummy as a preventative measure for SIDS but my son wouldn’t take one. Now it’s not that he doesn’t have a dummy it’s that he uses me as a dummy!

FestiveMulledWine · 28/11/2023 12:35

So there wasn’t a problem sleeping of night? That’s my biggest concern.

OP posts:
Maxus · 28/11/2023 12:59

FestiveMulledWine · 28/11/2023 12:35

So there wasn’t a problem sleeping of night? That’s my biggest concern.

Newborns and baby's are supposed to wake in the night for feeding. Don't let that put you off getting a dummy. My new born son , now teenager kept me awake all night as a newborn using me as a dummy, as soon as I gave him a dummy he slept between feeds using his dummy. He still woke every 2 hours to feed but at least I got some sleep between feeds thanks to the dummy.

MaryShelley1818 · 28/11/2023 13:01

FestiveMulledWine · 28/11/2023 12:35

So there wasn’t a problem sleeping of night? That’s my biggest concern.

Absolutely none for either of mine.
They would suck them until they fell asleep then after a while spit them out.
As they got a little older they knew to place them under their pillow when they got up until bedtime.

ShortColdandGrey · 28/11/2023 13:12

My daughter was given a dummy in hospital due to being premature. Because she was born so early it was to help her to feed from breast/bottle instead of being tube fed. You don't see the need in a dummy so don't use the. Why other people use them is none of your business. FYI having a dummy didn't give my daughter speech/teeth issues. It didn't cause her to be more fussy, and she slept through the night fine. Just stop judging other parents choices.

Circularargument · 28/11/2023 13:24

FestiveMulledWine · 28/11/2023 11:02

@YorkshirePuddingBelongs yes please, one with a golden ribbon. 🙄

It was a genuine question because so, so many people have told me to give LO a dummy and I don’t get the obsession with them!

If you don't want to, don't. Both mine were thumb suckers, and no their teeth are perfect.