Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have an abortion without telling DH

449 replies

Rainbowskeepfalling · 01/11/2023 19:57

We have 2 DC, aged 3 and 1. We always knew we wanted 2 children and DH is booked in for a vasectomy in Spring next year. We're both on the same page that we don't want another child.
But we have very different views on termination. Although he says he is pro choice he doesn't feel it's something he personally could do and he's gone as far as to say that if I had a termination, even very early on he would consider that no different to taking a gun and killing one of our daughters now. I disagree massively with this and told him clearly at the time I am so certain in my choice not to have more children that I wouldn't hesitate to have a termination. This was always a hypothetical though.
Except I took a pregnancy test this morning and it was positive. We have been using condoms and I don't remember one splitting so I really don't know how this has happened. I can't have another baby. I can't. I have suffered with hyperemesis in both pregnancies and I can't do it again. I also just do not want another baby. I love my girls more than anything but I don't enjoy the day to days of parenting and each new stage we get to with my youngest I feel a bit more of my life coming back to me and I know myself well enough to know I cannot cope with a third. There is absolutely no hesitation in my mind that I will not go through with this pregnancy.

I don't want to tell DH about it. It's not something that's up for discussion in my mind, I'm not doing it and it's as simple as that. I know that makes me sound horrible and I promise I'm not a horrible person normally but I know myself and I know I can't do this. But DH will want me to. He'll see it as it wasn't planned, it's not ideal but here we are and so let's get on with it. But it's not him that has to be pregnant or give birth or even do the majority of the parenting as I would take the year off and then work part time and have to manage the daily grind far more than him.
He's a wonderful man, he really is. I love him so much but what good can come from telling him if all that will do is hurt him, maybe even make him hate me but even so I know there's nothing he or anyone can say that'll make me change my mind.

OP posts:
whattodo22222 · 02/11/2023 10:55

OP I think you should tell your husband because you may need his support. I recently had a medical termination at home, overnight, at 5.5 weeks pregnant. It was very painful and kept me awake all night. I couldn't have coped with my 1 year old alone, she still wakes several times a night. I then continued to bleed for 6 weeks as I had retained products. I know it's awful, but if he refuses to support you then it really raises big questions about what sort of a partner he is and how he views you as a fellow human being.

Mumof3confused · 02/11/2023 10:59

If you tell him you have a miscarriage, would he want to attend doctors appointments with you?

RedPony1 · 02/11/2023 11:17

Sueveneers · 02/11/2023 09:41

She lives with him. She will be bleeding for quite awhile, possibly in severe pain, could even be complications. It's not something she can hide, you know? She can't hide this from him. Unless she goes away (leaving him and the children) for a week to 2 weeks, but how will she explain that? This is not a one night stand or some random she doesn't live with. She lives with, and shares a room/bed with this man. I think she will find it incredibly difficult covering this up, he will know something is up with her sick, bleeding and in pain. And she is underestimating him. She needs to tell him as she will need his support at home as she will be incapacitated for days, possibly longer. I think the suggestion that she can hide this and all the pain, bleeding etc for days it entails - from him, is utterly unrealistic and rather delusional.

Edited

I wasn't incapacitated. i told NOBODY about mine and had to compete at a horse show the following day because i never missed a show even with broken bones, so not competing would have raised suspicion of some sort.

I didn't need anybody elses support from a decision i made.

Good luck OP. i never think about mine unless these convos come up, and my only feeling is still utter relief.

TedMullins · 02/11/2023 11:25

RedPony1 · 02/11/2023 11:17

I wasn't incapacitated. i told NOBODY about mine and had to compete at a horse show the following day because i never missed a show even with broken bones, so not competing would have raised suspicion of some sort.

I didn't need anybody elses support from a decision i made.

Good luck OP. i never think about mine unless these convos come up, and my only feeling is still utter relief.

Same here. I also wasn’t impacted. I was going through a bad breakup at the time with the impregnator and that was infinitely worse emotionally than the abortion. Call it what you like - a baby, a clump of cells, a magical unicorn - I still wanted it gone. I had a surgical and was out for dinner and drinks with friends the next day.

TheEponymousGrub · 02/11/2023 11:25

Good luck, OP .I think you are probably choosing the only path leading to a good chance of a happy ending. DO NOT TELL HIM. If he wouldn't be OK with it in advance, he's not going to be OK with discovering afterward that you deceived him and still did it.

PeppermintMandy · 02/11/2023 11:27

waxeswanes · 02/11/2023 08:16

Why, though? I'm like the OP's DH, in that I believe 100% in free choice.

But personally, I would find it incredibly painful to go through with an abortion myself. Or if (obviously hypothetically) my husband was bearing my and his baby/foetus/whatever you want to call it, it would really pain me if he chose to get rid of what I see as our child. It seems like a form of murder to me, yes. (Or, for less emotive phrasing, conscious deprivation of current and potential life?)

But I also do believe in the greater good, and in the reality of the situation, I suppose any potential suffering of my partner would take precedence. Or even if there was no suffering and the potential baby was just unwanted by them, then the greater good would lie in the baby ceasing to exist, versus 2 unhappy (partner and baby) lives.

It's not a perfect comparison, but I suppose I see it as akin to culling animals? The foetus is alive and I personally believe has features of personhood, but is still less sentient than a person (and for clarity, less sentient than an animal). So the more sentient person's needs must win.

Anyway, all this is to say that I think the militant "if you show even an ounce of emotion towards the idea of a foetus, then you're not really pro-choice" line I keep seeing on MN is black and white nonsense. I can have personal leanings towards a certain political party, but that doesn't mean I don't believe in democracy or free and fair elections (the overall right to choose). Pro-choice literally just means respecting the overall right to choose either option – it doesn't mean militantly pro-abortion only.

I have unconditionally supported my dear friends through abortions, and who's to say the husband here won't unconditionally support OP based on the new reality of the situation?

Edited

Well that’s the key isn’t it…you actively support a woman’s choice even though you would make a different choice. Although I’d argue if you see someone who has an abortion as a murderer then that’s questionable…

If OP is so worried that telling her husband could end her marriage then it makes sense not to marry someone who wouldn’t stand by you if you chose an abortion when you know that’s a choice you’d make.

It isn’t about supporting a friend or a family member. It’s about standing with and 100% supporting and being on the same page with the very person you are in a sexual and romantic relationship with. You didn’t impregnate your friends. They weren’t aborting your baby so how you felt about it is completely irrelevant. It was nothing to do with you. You have no skin the game.

I’m happy I’m married to someone who I would not have to ask Mumsnet if I should tell him I’m having an abortion or not because he would 100% support my decision and be with me every step of the way. I think that’s vitally important. It’s a huge decision.

notlucreziaborgia · 02/11/2023 11:31

Except it seems that when she married him it was a choice he’d support her in making. It’s since having children that he’s changed his mind.

Dutch1e · 02/11/2023 11:52

Just wanted to send you a lovely big hug before this thread disappears.

Reading your description of DH I'd probably take the gamble of telling him the situation before you have the termination. Strong views held by good people often change when it's happening in real time to someone they love, and giving him the chance to prove himself a good support could really strengthen your relationship, even if he grieves.

Whatever you decide, an internet stranger is thinking of you and fervently wishing you well.

calyrex · 02/11/2023 14:13

Babochan88 · 01/11/2023 22:43

If you so this it’ll be an absolute betrayal to your husband. You can try and justify it, but it could cause irreparable damage.

All life whether planned or not is precious and should be allowed to thrive.

Her feeling pressured to go through with an unwanted pregnancy would also cause irreparable damage.

And no, it shouldn't always be "allowed to thrive" if that involves someone elses body.

IslandsInTheSunshine · 02/11/2023 15:08

@Rainbowskeepfalling IF you read this in time, please be aware that early abortions are done with medication. (I know someone who used that method.)
It's like a heavy period and you could- if you want to- describe it was a miscarriage if he found you in discomfort.

The earlier you act, the easier if that is what you want.

Also, if he wants the snip why not do it privately? It doesn't cost much and could be done very quickly.

habibtiii · 02/11/2023 15:13

Don’t tell him. Have the termination knowing it’s 100% the right thing for you. Then put it to the back of your mind and don’t think about.

Lemonyfuckit · 02/11/2023 15:22

Chattybot · 01/11/2023 20:13

If you do it in secret and IF he finds out, your marriage may well be over.

BUT if you tell him and do it against his will, sounds like your marriage may be over anyway.

And if you have the baby, you will resent both him and the baby and your life will be shite. I don't give much for your marriage's chances with that level of resentment.

So actually I think the best thing to do is exactly what you're planning to do. You all have a bigger chance at happiness that way.

This.

I absolutely think your body your choice whether you have the abortion, he doesn't actually get a say in that. BUT it sounds like he feels he should have a say, and so telling him could end up ending your marriage, given you're clear you're having the abortion anyway.

Obviously yes feeling like you need to keep a secret is difficult - arguably you shouldn't be put in this position that you feel you have to keep a secret, and no doubt if you have the abortion, don't tell him, and he finds out later he'll argue that YOU were the one in the wrong, when really you've been put in the position of having no choice but to keep this secret.

So yes, I'm leaning - do what you feel you need to do, and if you don't want to tell him, then don't. He shouldn't ever find out unless you tell him, so this way has the highest chance of keeping you all happy.

waxeswanes · 02/11/2023 15:47

@PeppermintMandy 'Although I’d argue if you see someone who has an abortion as a murderer then that’s questionable…'

It was actually precisely this narrow little mindset I was rejecting in one of my posts.

In my view, you can absolutely believe abortion constitutes deprivation of life, but is still morally legitimate and/or necessary (owing to other principles such as the greater good, bodily autonomy, gender equality, etc) and should still be the subject of free choice. Some very imperfect parallels – and abortion is far milder on this continuum – I might draw: euthanasia and animal culling, both of which I am a proponent of.

It might surprise you to learn that the "just a bunch of cells" line isn't actually scientific consensus in any form whatsoever, but is in fact closely associated with American political factions. Doctors, scientists and philosophers can't agree on when a foetus gains sufficient personhood.

I work in legislation and policy, whilst my DH works in policy as well (at the intersection of healthcare, neuroscience in particular). I personally subscribe to the brain-life theory which places sentience relatively early – indeed, much earlier than the current abortion cutoff, but that doesn't translate to me advocating for an earlier shift – when the brain begins to function in a way comparable to that of live beings. Policy-wise, someone has to debate and draft the laws regarding the abortion cutoff (or indeed, regarding whether there should even be one, or if abortion should be allowed freely up till some part of the baby emerges into the outer world, and the numerous definitions and repercussions relating to that); the question of sentience is not an "evil" taboo topic of the far right where thought experiments must not venture.

The other thing about such politicised absolutism is that people are essentially forced into falsely binary camps. If you don't dismiss the foetus as just a "bunch of cells", then you're a dirty pro-lifer. While there are thankfully women who feel no attachment or negative emotions around an abortion – and we shouldn't try to project nonexistent negative emotions or guilt onto them, which I do acknowledge as an existing problem – the psychological impact of an abortion is well-documented. This enforced black and white pigeonholing has a negative and dismissive impact on women who might find the process grief-inducing, but are told they shouldn't be.

Summergarden · 02/11/2023 16:21

I’d do exactly the same thing as you OP.

Best of luck with it, if you get a choice as to which type of termination I’d definitely recommend the surgical method as it’s guaranteed to work and no pain or discomfort- I was back at work hours later. Whereas the medical method using pessaries take a lot longer, more discomfort and success rate is lower (annoyingly it didn’t work for me, hence also having surgery). Surgical would be a lot easier to conceal from your DH.

Mumof3confused · 02/11/2023 16:37

Nowadays it is done by taking a series of tablets up until about 10 weeks gestation, after that it is medically managed.

notlucreziaborgia · 02/11/2023 18:12

Mumof3confused · 02/11/2023 16:37

Nowadays it is done by taking a series of tablets up until about 10 weeks gestation, after that it is medically managed.

You can still opt for surgical termination before then.

AcrossthePond55 · 02/11/2023 18:13

@Rainbowskeepfalling

Peace to you and best wishes for the future.

Yesyoucant · 03/11/2023 01:49

jm9138 · 01/11/2023 20:05

I don't really understand why you have posted on AIBU. You ended by saying nothing anyone can say will make you change your mind. So not sure what you want other than confirmation of your choice (so put it in chats or relationships) or an argument.

Perhaps just a bit of support? Why is there always this shit on here? It's obvious she won't be able to talk about this IRL and turns somewhere else for support for this... have a look at yourself, will you?

OP you do exactly what you need to. You're not being unreasonable but understand how you might feel guilty etc. It's your body and if I were you I'd be doing the exact same thing. All the very best.

Ontheperiphery79 · 03/11/2023 02:39

Just do it.

Don't tell him don't tell anyone else, as it's just burdening other people with your secret. And, that way, no-one stands a chance of letting it slip.

Babochan88 · 03/11/2023 09:08

Honestly in shock at the responses on here? Scary to think how we have become as a society.

To make such a life changing decision without consulting your partner is crazy. If my husband made a big life decision without telling me I’d be appalled. That poor husband…makes it clear why most marriages end in divorce…

Introvertedbuthappy · 03/11/2023 09:11

Hi OP, I had a surgical abortion on Monday and 10 years ago had a medical one. Would recommend a surgical one, all done and dusted in 20 minutes and back at work the next day. Sending you lots of strength.

Introvertedbuthappy · 03/11/2023 09:14

Also didn't need pain relief, not even that much bleeding after, some really hysterical descriptions here of abortions by women who clearly haven't had one. Honestly, I've had more painful periods.

coffeeaddict77 · 03/11/2023 09:24

You don't have to tell him anymore than you would about any other medical procedure. It's your body and your choice. Most people probably would but probably more for the support if anything. You know you aren't going to get that from him so can see why you don't want to mention it.

Tandora · 03/11/2023 09:26

Although he says he is pro choice he doesn't feel it's something he personally could do

Rolling my eyes so hard at this. Of course he couldn’t “personally” do this, as he’s not biological capable of getting pregnant.
what a knob. 🤦🏼‍♀️

coffeeaddict77 · 03/11/2023 09:32

Babochan88 · 03/11/2023 09:08

Honestly in shock at the responses on here? Scary to think how we have become as a society.

To make such a life changing decision without consulting your partner is crazy. If my husband made a big life decision without telling me I’d be appalled. That poor husband…makes it clear why most marriages end in divorce…

The decision to have an abortion is not "life changing" as nothing will change as a result and things will continue as before. It would only be a life changing decision if OP had the baby.

Swipe left for the next trending thread