Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have an abortion without telling DH

449 replies

Rainbowskeepfalling · 01/11/2023 19:57

We have 2 DC, aged 3 and 1. We always knew we wanted 2 children and DH is booked in for a vasectomy in Spring next year. We're both on the same page that we don't want another child.
But we have very different views on termination. Although he says he is pro choice he doesn't feel it's something he personally could do and he's gone as far as to say that if I had a termination, even very early on he would consider that no different to taking a gun and killing one of our daughters now. I disagree massively with this and told him clearly at the time I am so certain in my choice not to have more children that I wouldn't hesitate to have a termination. This was always a hypothetical though.
Except I took a pregnancy test this morning and it was positive. We have been using condoms and I don't remember one splitting so I really don't know how this has happened. I can't have another baby. I can't. I have suffered with hyperemesis in both pregnancies and I can't do it again. I also just do not want another baby. I love my girls more than anything but I don't enjoy the day to days of parenting and each new stage we get to with my youngest I feel a bit more of my life coming back to me and I know myself well enough to know I cannot cope with a third. There is absolutely no hesitation in my mind that I will not go through with this pregnancy.

I don't want to tell DH about it. It's not something that's up for discussion in my mind, I'm not doing it and it's as simple as that. I know that makes me sound horrible and I promise I'm not a horrible person normally but I know myself and I know I can't do this. But DH will want me to. He'll see it as it wasn't planned, it's not ideal but here we are and so let's get on with it. But it's not him that has to be pregnant or give birth or even do the majority of the parenting as I would take the year off and then work part time and have to manage the daily grind far more than him.
He's a wonderful man, he really is. I love him so much but what good can come from telling him if all that will do is hurt him, maybe even make him hate me but even so I know there's nothing he or anyone can say that'll make me change my mind.

OP posts:
Rainbowskeepfalling · 02/11/2023 06:30

Thank you all for your answers, I really do appreciate your views, advice and support (except the anti-abortion gang, I'm stopping reading as soon as it becomes clear what you're saying. I'm not remotely interested in what you have to say).

I'm going to leave now and request this thread is deleted so there's no trail and delete my account. I am going to arrange the termination today for as soon as I can but I promise I have heard all sides of the argument and although I won't change my mind about the termination, I will continue to consider telling DH before it actually goes ahead.

Thank you ❤️

OP posts:
username131024 · 02/11/2023 06:32

@Rainbowskeepfalling - if as you say this is about whether you share important information with your husband, then perhaps put consider what sort of things it would be ok for him to not share with you. If you’re ok with him not sharing things with you because it will be difficult or you’ll have different perspectives then that’s where your relationship is at. If you expect honesty from him then trust him and your relationship to hold this situation.

The very emotive posts re Gestational Slavery and 8lbs babies are not the issue.

The trust within your relationship is something once broken is very hard to repair.

PetsAreBetter · 02/11/2023 06:43

There is no point having the debate whether or not it's a baby. That's something that both sides have differed on and argued about for decades. They will never agree. I have my own opinion but it's neither here nor there since I'm not OP.

Lovehearts82 · 02/11/2023 06:59

Rainbowskeepfalling · 02/11/2023 06:30

Thank you all for your answers, I really do appreciate your views, advice and support (except the anti-abortion gang, I'm stopping reading as soon as it becomes clear what you're saying. I'm not remotely interested in what you have to say).

I'm going to leave now and request this thread is deleted so there's no trail and delete my account. I am going to arrange the termination today for as soon as I can but I promise I have heard all sides of the argument and although I won't change my mind about the termination, I will continue to consider telling DH before it actually goes ahead.

Thank you ❤️

Just wanted to send virtual hugs to you in what is a difficult time, you do what you think is best for you and your family op

ProChoiceOptions · 02/11/2023 06:59

username131024 · 02/11/2023 06:32

@Rainbowskeepfalling - if as you say this is about whether you share important information with your husband, then perhaps put consider what sort of things it would be ok for him to not share with you. If you’re ok with him not sharing things with you because it will be difficult or you’ll have different perspectives then that’s where your relationship is at. If you expect honesty from him then trust him and your relationship to hold this situation.

The very emotive posts re Gestational Slavery and 8lbs babies are not the issue.

The trust within your relationship is something once broken is very hard to repair.

I agree this is the nub of issue for the op. Weighing up the risk of the impact of her DH finding out later (very low but never impossible).

Does the op feel this is a necessary risk to take in order to preserve her right to full body autonomy. At a vulnerable time, the op is genuinely worried there is a risk of some gaslighting or cohesive behaviour from her DH, who has actually stated (whether he realises it or not) that he thinks he’s likely pro-choice when it comes to other women but not for his own wife, as it would be emotionally hard for him. It undoubtedly could be emotionally difficult for him and he may well find he feels differently in reality verses hypothetical - but I feel the op is right to think there is the very real risk if she tells him now of damage to her mental well-being and therefore also big impact on their marriage by him having previous indicated that he thinks he will likely want to challenge her right to body autonomy if he knew. In my opinion, this risk is higher in this set of circumstances than the much smaller (in my opinion) but nevertheless, potential risk that he might feel betrayed by not being told if he ever found out and that damaging their marriage.

Londonscallingme · 02/11/2023 07:00

Rainbowskeepfalling · 02/11/2023 06:30

Thank you all for your answers, I really do appreciate your views, advice and support (except the anti-abortion gang, I'm stopping reading as soon as it becomes clear what you're saying. I'm not remotely interested in what you have to say).

I'm going to leave now and request this thread is deleted so there's no trail and delete my account. I am going to arrange the termination today for as soon as I can but I promise I have heard all sides of the argument and although I won't change my mind about the termination, I will continue to consider telling DH before it actually goes ahead.

Thank you ❤️

Good luck OP. I’m so sorry you are in this situation x

Milkybarsareonmeeeee · 02/11/2023 07:02

OP don’t feel you have to tell your husband. .
If he was to respect it’s your body and choice even with him not agreeing . Then yes you would be telling him .

You feeling you are unable to tell him is on him not you . As your husband he should be your support not someone you have no choice but to keep secrets from .
Is the marriage happy otherwise ?
If pp say he can’t trust you then you can’t trust him to be there for you either .
With a decision this big you should never be bullied into something you don’t want.
Also maybe you take charge of supplying condoms in the future until you sort out another form of contraception.

Good luck.

AngeloMysterioso · 02/11/2023 07:02

If your sister is happy to help you out then it might be worth seeing if you can be at her house from when you’ve taken all the tablets until it’s over. Unless you can guarantee having your home to yourself it’ll be pretty impossible to hide. You’ll also be bleeding for a while afterwards, so if your DH is one of those who is more than vaguely aware of your cycle length he may notice something’s up. Wish you well Flowers

LizzieSiddal · 02/11/2023 07:12

I think I’d have to tell him in case it came out somehow in the future.

However I’d book the termination, then tell him and explain calmly that you cannot go through another pregnancy, it’s just too much for you physically but more importantly mentally. He should support you, if he doesn’t then tbh, you have another reason to have that termination anyway because you’re health should be his priority.

PeppermintMandy · 02/11/2023 07:18

I couldn’t be married to a man who thinks this way. I really think this is one of these issues that makes you incompatible as partners.

Nanaof1 · 02/11/2023 08:04

wtfamireading · 02/11/2023 01:02

@porridgeisbae @porridgeisbae apparently it's "just a clump of cells" but heaven forbid a man is allowed to force an abortion on a woman for those "clump or cells". Only works one way.

Funny how you say that HERE, but on your own thread on another page, you gave the father of your baby NO CHOICE in the matter. He wanted you to terminate. You TOLD him you were going to and then deceived him by not and are now wondering why he isn't running to your side.

I think that's called hypocrisy on your part.

Thatsridiculous · 02/11/2023 08:08

This is so difficult OP.

What I would do today is book the termination privately - there are clinics that will see you quickly.

I have been with my DH since we were young too and our family is complete with two children. He is pro choice but I think if I was to fall pregnant accidentally he would struggle with the thought of a termination - for me, it would be the only option at this stage in our lives. He would also view the baby as an unplanned surprise, not ideal but as we are financially secure etc he would want to go ahead with it. Not because he is anti-abortion. This would create lots and lots of emotive conversations and probably in the end I would feel so bad I would go ahead with the pregnancy. Not because he would ever force me.

The issue for me though is that I would struggle to keep a secret like this from DH. I don’t know that I would cope and I think I would end up telling him.

If you feel you could keep the secret without it destroying YOU, then in your shoes I would not tell him.

waxeswanes · 02/11/2023 08:16

PeppermintMandy · 02/11/2023 07:18

I couldn’t be married to a man who thinks this way. I really think this is one of these issues that makes you incompatible as partners.

Why, though? I'm like the OP's DH, in that I believe 100% in free choice.

But personally, I would find it incredibly painful to go through with an abortion myself. Or if (obviously hypothetically) my husband was bearing my and his baby/foetus/whatever you want to call it, it would really pain me if he chose to get rid of what I see as our child. It seems like a form of murder to me, yes. (Or, for less emotive phrasing, conscious deprivation of current and potential life?)

But I also do believe in the greater good, and in the reality of the situation, I suppose any potential suffering of my partner would take precedence. Or even if there was no suffering and the potential baby was just unwanted by them, then the greater good would lie in the baby ceasing to exist, versus 2 unhappy (partner and baby) lives.

It's not a perfect comparison, but I suppose I see it as akin to culling animals? The foetus is alive and I personally believe has features of personhood, but is still less sentient than a person (and for clarity, less sentient than an animal). So the more sentient person's needs must win.

Anyway, all this is to say that I think the militant "if you show even an ounce of emotion towards the idea of a foetus, then you're not really pro-choice" line I keep seeing on MN is black and white nonsense. I can have personal leanings towards a certain political party, but that doesn't mean I don't believe in democracy or free and fair elections (the overall right to choose). Pro-choice literally just means respecting the overall right to choose either option – it doesn't mean militantly pro-abortion only.

I have unconditionally supported my dear friends through abortions, and who's to say the husband here won't unconditionally support OP based on the new reality of the situation?

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/11/2023 08:18

Is your DH aware that he would want you to sacrifice your physical and mental health for this pregnancy?

that your two DDs would be deprived of a healthy and happy mother for the sake of a pregnancy that is currently not even remotely viable (and considering that a spontaneous abortion/miscarriage is still fairly common this early in pregnancy)?

if you truly believe that the answer to both these questions is yes… well, I can’t help but feel like your marriage is in trouble. And no, your DH is not even remotely pro choice. The fact that he was ok with an abortion in the past - aka when it would have suited him - makes this actually worse imo. And it still does not make him pro-choice. It makes him pro “what suits me”!!

it reads as if he simply wants you to do what he wants / suits him when it comes to pregnancy and childbirth. It seems like genuine patriarchal entitlement to me.

and I would wonder whether some of that attitude might influence how he parents / what values he imparts on your daughters.

But as I said before: in an ideal world you could tell him without having to fear his anger, a lack of forgiveness or him painting you as a murderer (taking a gun to the girls’ head etc).
but that’s not the work you live in.

this is your personal, medical decision. And you have the right to decide how you want to deal with it.
which is why I strongly believe that you should do what what is best for your mental and physical health.

Wishing you a lot of strength and courage. Good luck! Flowers

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/11/2023 08:26

waxeswanes · 02/11/2023 08:16

Why, though? I'm like the OP's DH, in that I believe 100% in free choice.

But personally, I would find it incredibly painful to go through with an abortion myself. Or if (obviously hypothetically) my husband was bearing my and his baby/foetus/whatever you want to call it, it would really pain me if he chose to get rid of what I see as our child. It seems like a form of murder to me, yes. (Or, for less emotive phrasing, conscious deprivation of current and potential life?)

But I also do believe in the greater good, and in the reality of the situation, I suppose any potential suffering of my partner would take precedence. Or even if there was no suffering and the potential baby was just unwanted by them, then the greater good would lie in the baby ceasing to exist, versus 2 unhappy (partner and baby) lives.

It's not a perfect comparison, but I suppose I see it as akin to culling animals? The foetus is alive and I personally believe has features of personhood, but is still less sentient than a person (and for clarity, less sentient than an animal). So the more sentient person's needs must win.

Anyway, all this is to say that I think the militant "if you show even an ounce of emotion towards the idea of a foetus, then you're not really pro-choice" line I keep seeing on MN is black and white nonsense. I can have personal leanings towards a certain political party, but that doesn't mean I don't believe in democracy or free and fair elections (the overall right to choose). Pro-choice literally just means respecting the overall right to choose either option – it doesn't mean militantly pro-abortion only.

I have unconditionally supported my dear friends through abortions, and who's to say the husband here won't unconditionally support OP based on the new reality of the situation?

Edited

I understand that stance and I respect your opinion.

i am pro choice but abortion is still something I struggle with morally.

but OP’s DH made her afraid to confide in him because she fears his anger. Because she feels like he may not forgive her. And because he equated an abortion with murdering their daughters.

That is such a major failing as a husband imo.
and if he felt that strongly about it.. why did he even consent to penetrative sex before his vasectomy?

it sounds like he wanted sex and therefore accepted the risk of pregnancy. But he also wants OP to deal with the aftermath of this how he wants.

just like when they were younger. When he would have considered an abortion to be acceptable…

Mirabai · 02/11/2023 08:31

It’s not just the aftermath of sex it’s the aftermath of the aftermath - dealing with his tantrum while she’s already having to deal with an abortion.

Viviennemary · 02/11/2023 08:33

In the end you have to do what you think is best for you, your other children and your DH under the circumstances. And that might not be the same as what's best for somebody else in the same circumstances. I hope things work out.

Nothanksthanksanyway · 02/11/2023 08:35

I understand 100% why you don't want to go through with it. But a lie like this wedged between you will certainly completely destroy your relationship.

You have to tell him IMO.

SurprisedWithAHorse · 02/11/2023 08:37

Anyway, all this is to say that I think the militant "if you show even an ounce of emotion towards the idea of a foetus, then you're not really pro-choice" line I keep seeing on MN is black and white nonsense.

It's more that if this makes you try to pressure a pregnant woman to go against her choice, that you're not pro choice. Because you're not. It's not supporting her choice to try to pressure, guilt or coerce her into something she doesn't want.

waxeswanes · 02/11/2023 08:41

@PumpkinsAndCoconuts of course none of us know the DH, but I just think that's a lot to extrapolate from hypothetical chit chat in front of the TV.

I posted earlier about how my partner, and immediate birth family, and extended family all have very polarised ideological views (doesn't help that we're all from different countries/cultures) about far-removed political situations, and emotive debates loaded with hyperbole. That doesn't turn any of us into failures as family members or partners.

Ultimately what I've seen every single time, many times, is people immediately scrambling to support anyone 100% anytime an abstract situation becomes reality (eg cross border issues).

Of course, it may be the case that he isn't supportive or he gets angry. I think being sad on his own is fine but he has to be outwardly supportive. Personally, I'd rather know if the person I'm married to prioritises my body as a mere vessel over my happiness and wellbeing — and by "know", I mean I would want to be aware, but also sure. I wouldn't want to falsely project and assume, based on some thoughtless moments in front of the TV. If I was sure, I personally would not be able to continue happily in the relationship – but only if I was sure.

Naunet · 02/11/2023 08:43

username131024 · 02/11/2023 06:32

@Rainbowskeepfalling - if as you say this is about whether you share important information with your husband, then perhaps put consider what sort of things it would be ok for him to not share with you. If you’re ok with him not sharing things with you because it will be difficult or you’ll have different perspectives then that’s where your relationship is at. If you expect honesty from him then trust him and your relationship to hold this situation.

The very emotive posts re Gestational Slavery and 8lbs babies are not the issue.

The trust within your relationship is something once broken is very hard to repair.

Him trying to force her into having a baby she doesn’t want, wouldn’t exactly be great for their marriage either, have you considered that?

Mirabai · 02/11/2023 08:45

Nothanksthanksanyway · 02/11/2023 08:35

I understand 100% why you don't want to go through with it. But a lie like this wedged between you will certainly completely destroy your relationship.

You have to tell him IMO.

It’s his attitude that has created the wedge, and has the potential to destroy the relationship. If she tells him and he can’t accept her decision the marriage is over anyway.

KatBurglar · 02/11/2023 08:45

Wishing you the very best, OP, and I’m sorry you’re in such a difficult situation.

Diamondcurtains · 02/11/2023 08:46

I don’t think you are unreasonable. The only thing I will say is that when I had a termination using the tablets once everything started happening it was difficult. There was a lot of pain and a lot of blood. Can you hide something like that from him?

Naunet · 02/11/2023 08:46

Good luck OP, be kind to yourself. X