Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have an abortion without telling DH

449 replies

Rainbowskeepfalling · 01/11/2023 19:57

We have 2 DC, aged 3 and 1. We always knew we wanted 2 children and DH is booked in for a vasectomy in Spring next year. We're both on the same page that we don't want another child.
But we have very different views on termination. Although he says he is pro choice he doesn't feel it's something he personally could do and he's gone as far as to say that if I had a termination, even very early on he would consider that no different to taking a gun and killing one of our daughters now. I disagree massively with this and told him clearly at the time I am so certain in my choice not to have more children that I wouldn't hesitate to have a termination. This was always a hypothetical though.
Except I took a pregnancy test this morning and it was positive. We have been using condoms and I don't remember one splitting so I really don't know how this has happened. I can't have another baby. I can't. I have suffered with hyperemesis in both pregnancies and I can't do it again. I also just do not want another baby. I love my girls more than anything but I don't enjoy the day to days of parenting and each new stage we get to with my youngest I feel a bit more of my life coming back to me and I know myself well enough to know I cannot cope with a third. There is absolutely no hesitation in my mind that I will not go through with this pregnancy.

I don't want to tell DH about it. It's not something that's up for discussion in my mind, I'm not doing it and it's as simple as that. I know that makes me sound horrible and I promise I'm not a horrible person normally but I know myself and I know I can't do this. But DH will want me to. He'll see it as it wasn't planned, it's not ideal but here we are and so let's get on with it. But it's not him that has to be pregnant or give birth or even do the majority of the parenting as I would take the year off and then work part time and have to manage the daily grind far more than him.
He's a wonderful man, he really is. I love him so much but what good can come from telling him if all that will do is hurt him, maybe even make him hate me but even so I know there's nothing he or anyone can say that'll make me change my mind.

OP posts:
Estermay · 02/11/2023 01:16

What do you think of the quarter of women in the UK who have at least one abortion during their life? In the older age range it is one third of women.

SouthLondonMum22 · 02/11/2023 01:17

wtfamireading · 02/11/2023 01:13

@SouthLondonMum22 is that what your doctor referred to your baby as, when you felt like you were miscarrying?

No, doctors (generally) have a good bedside manner. It doesn't make the science any less correct just as at an abortion appointment, they wouldn't say baby and would use the correct scientific term.

wtfamireading · 02/11/2023 01:18

Estermay · 02/11/2023 01:14

So it's handmaiden tale then? You will have a baby whether you want one or not. Who cares how you feel. Who cares if it will negatively impact your existing kids. Just give birth asif you are not a real person so what you want means zero.

Don't be daft. The women in the Handmaids tale were raped as the whole of the country was suffering low infertility. So they where stolen/kidnapped and forced to have sex with the aim of having a child for the man and the women of the household - because one of both had infertility.

Having sex with your husband and falling pregnant in a relationship with two other kids that you are their mother and they aren't stolen.....

Obviously not the Handmaids take.

SouthLondonMum22 · 02/11/2023 01:18

wtfamireading · 02/11/2023 01:15

You had consensual sex. It's a result of sex.

So is an abortion.

wtfamireading · 02/11/2023 01:19

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

wtfamireading · 02/11/2023 01:19

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

Estermay · 02/11/2023 01:21

We don't know if an early pregnancy is viable. Early miscarriages are common.
But so what. Call it whatever you want. A woman can still decide to have am abortion, feel relief, and it be straightforward.

Estermay · 02/11/2023 01:22

OP I am sorry your thread has been derailed by anti abortionists. Hope you are okay.

SouthLondonMum22 · 02/11/2023 01:23

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

Why do you think the medical terms exist? Just for shits and giggles? They exist because they are factual terms.

Again, it's basic biology. I was taught it in Year 6.

The abortion ends a pregnancy, who knows if it was going to be a viable or healthy one. It's irrelevant anyway.

Killing children is illegal. An abortion before 24 weeks isn't.

NameChangeForThisPost234 · 02/11/2023 01:23

OP, I'm so sorry that you're having such a tough time.

This might sound a bit left field but have you considered mentioning that a 'friend' has confided in you about an unwanted pregnancy and say everything you've said here about the reasons for wanting a termination. Gauge his reaction and then see if, once his personal emotions aren't involved, he can see that it's for the best. If he still suggests 'friend' should keep the pregnancy, you can keep quiet and he never needs to know it was you.

Although, I do think you'll need support for the procedure/aftercare so hope you can find that in someone other than him.

All the best, OP.

myopinionmatters · 02/11/2023 01:24

He's weird. It is nothing like killing a child you have met. The fetus is just cells clumping together to form a human.
Do what's best for you

Tighginn · 02/11/2023 01:28

The impact a termination has on your mental health, futher down the line will be felt by your husband, it will change the dynamics of your relationship forever and he will never fully understand why. My child I terminated would have been 18 on 5\11\23. I never thought I would feel or still be feeling the way I do now about it.

myopinionmatters · 02/11/2023 01:29

wtfamireading · 02/11/2023 01:02

@porridgeisbae @porridgeisbae apparently it's "just a clump of cells" but heaven forbid a man is allowed to force an abortion on a woman for those "clump or cells". Only works one way.

Because it's not a man's choice what a woman does with her body. A woman has to carry the baby and likely take 70% of the responsibility.
And it is a clump of cells, it doesnt have a name, gender. Abortion past a certain time I don't agree with but early on isn't a big deal.

user1492757084 · 02/11/2023 01:32

Why only condoms if you knew of this vital juxtaposition that could end your family unit?
You will not be able to keep this a secret.
Which is easier - the guilt and secrecy and divorce .. or the third child?
I think you should make the decision together. You have options including adoption, termination, third child or a miscarriage. All options would be better with support and no deceipt.

Timeflieswhenyourehavingfun · 02/11/2023 01:38

@wtfamireading

No one needs an explanation, particularly from someone who has displayed no understanding of the biology of feral period terminology, what an abortion is.

You keep mocking posters for saying ‘ it’s just a bunch of cells’,
Yet in the early weeks it is medically and scientifically referred to as a Zygote which is a bunch of cells.

NameChangeForThisPost234 · 02/11/2023 01:39

This is really not helpful for OP in any way, but I wrote my reply before reading any of the comments. And after seeing the first few now, I'm wondering why people are saying OP's DH isn't pro choice? Maybe this is different because I'm a women, but think every woman has her own right to choose whether or not to continue a pregnancy. However, if I were to have a unplanned pregnancy now, I wouldn't be able to go through with an abortion. I had an early miscarriage when we were trying for our second baby and it broke me. My own DHusband kept telling me that the 'baby' was just a ball of cells but to me it was a baby right from the second I saw those two lines. So, I completely relate to OP's DH on this. This surely doesn't make me any less pro-choice because I personally wouldn't want to abort my own pregnancy? And I am fully aware that in OP's case, DH wouldn't be carrying the baby so it is different. I am however, questioning my own ability to call myself pro choice as I completely relate to DH on this (and would probably have felt differently, like him, if we were to get pregnant early in our relationship and would have definitely terminated back then. I just couldn't do it now).

PetsAreBetter · 02/11/2023 01:43

porridgeisbae · 02/11/2023 00:52

@SouthLondonMum22 In a few weeks the LO will have a heartbeat OP could see on a scan. Left to grow inside their mum from now onwards, they would become a human like any one of us here.

I saw a heartbeat on a scan at 5.5 weeks. That's 3.5 weeks after conception. That's not the issue though as OP has already made up her mind. The question is whether she should not tell her husband.

I say she should because I think such a secret would be poison to a marriage. If I found out such a thing later down the track, it would be worse than if I knew straight away because I can forgive a lot, but not deception. If you can't share this sort of thing and receive support, the marriage is weak to start with. DH is allowed to be sad and disappointed but that doesn't mean he can't support. I know a man who was devastated and still made sure his partner was fully supported.

Timeflieswhenyourehavingfun · 02/11/2023 01:52

fetal period terminology

OP, sorry your thread got derailed.

In answer to your question, I don’t think you are being unreasonable to not tell your husband you are terminating the pregnancy.

His comparing having an abortion to taking a shotgun and killing one of your children is a horrible and frankly ridiculous comment to make, so I understand why you feel you have to do this one your own.

Anotherparkingthread · 02/11/2023 01:57

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 02/11/2023 00:36

Are you seriously claiming that women's medical decisions are comparable to the criminal offence that is murder or the breach of marriage vows that is infidelity?

I said this is what her husband feels about it morally. If you cannot separate somebody else's morals from your beliefs then you need to work on that elsewhere as that isn't what is being discussed here. The law is irrelevant as I said op should do as she wishes but if her husband feels it would be murder he has the right to know that he would consider his wife to be a murderer.

fridaynight1 · 02/11/2023 02:00

OP you have made your mind up and you know how your husband would react so I think it would be cruel to tell him.
Good luck to you. I know it's not a decision you have made lightly.
Don't tell him.

EtiennePalmiere · 02/11/2023 03:26

wtfamireading · 02/11/2023 01:02

@porridgeisbae @porridgeisbae apparently it's "just a clump of cells" but heaven forbid a man is allowed to force an abortion on a woman for those "clump or cells". Only works one way.

Yes, it's called bodily autonomy. Like a woman can get her tubes tied if she wants, but she can't force a man to have a vasectomy.

Sueveneers · 02/11/2023 04:31

I would have the termination and not tell him.

But please do so with the knowledge that he just may find out eventually. You could have problems down there at some later stage, and your medical history may come up, especially if (I presume) he is Next Of Kin. He 95% probably won't find out, but it's a gamble and he just may. You really don't know. So you're taking a gamble he will never find out. Do it with the knowledge you will be sitting on a big secret and you're taking that risk. Oh and that includes any future medical appointments with you with the GP/specialists he may attend with you now or in the later years.

Sueveneers · 02/11/2023 04:44

Just now reading right through all others responses, I agree no matter what, do NOT tell your sister! Whatever you do, do not do that. You might be shocked, she may not react how you think. She may blackmail you to tell him. Look; unless she has 1000000% told you that 'if you got pregnant and wanted to terminate I would not tell your husband', you're taking a risk there, too. This is something you have to go through totally 100% on your own. 100% on your own with no one else knowing but you. It's enough risk that it will be recorded in your medical history forever.

Sueveneers · 02/11/2023 05:01

Babochan88 · 01/11/2023 22:43

If you so this it’ll be an absolute betrayal to your husband. You can try and justify it, but it could cause irreparable damage.

All life whether planned or not is precious and should be allowed to thrive.

All life whether planned or not is precious and should be allowed to thrive.

Not at the expense of the born actual woman. All actual born life is precious. The rights of women who exist are precious. Something with no sentience or brainstem or nerve receptors isn't a life that has equal rights to the actual human being whose health and life is at risk.

Sueveneers · 02/11/2023 05:18

waxeswanes · 01/11/2023 23:15

Just to add on, your later updates (he's ok with an abortion for earlier years, he would never force you to keep the baby, etc) definitely show he's not an absolutist. The gun thing (a very American hypothetical anyway) was said in the context of a debate in front of a TV!

My husband and I, and even my parents and siblings and I, have very staunchly different views on lots of things. Our debates have also been polarised and full of hyperbole. But when push comes to shove, I can't think of a single time when the issue became real where people didn't set aside their personal beliefs to become 100% genuinely supportive and loving. I know my loved ones will always willingly prioritise me and my wellbeing.

Might get jumped on for this but I definitely think the majority of MN comes from a place of "relationship scarcity" where they can't possibly imagine relationships of love and respect. I know gender and structural inequality exists, but I think people tend to jump straight to abusive and toxic / LTB situations based on very little. Do give your husband a chance – it might not work out if he does resent you, but the alternative is you forever resenting him in secret anyway.

I would personally give him a chance and tell him. I know from personal experience, multiple times, that people's abstract political/philosophical/religious beliefs can change when their own loved ones are at stake.

and

(he's ok with an abortion for earlier years, he would never force you to keep the baby, etc) definitely show he's not an absolutist. The gun thing (a very American hypothetical anyway) was said in the context of a debate in front of a TV!

and

Our debates have also been polarised and full of hyperbole. But when push comes to shove, I can't think of a single time when the issue became real where people didn't set aside their personal beliefs to become 100% genuinely supportive and loving. I know my loved ones will always willingly prioritise me and my wellbeing.

I agree with this. Is it perhaps possible OP that your husband was giving a casual answer to an abstract issue in the moment and if he was forced to consider the reality of what it would mean for you (and him) that he would be possibly far more eager and supportive than you actually think?

Swipe left for the next trending thread