Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have an abortion without telling DH

449 replies

Rainbowskeepfalling · 01/11/2023 19:57

We have 2 DC, aged 3 and 1. We always knew we wanted 2 children and DH is booked in for a vasectomy in Spring next year. We're both on the same page that we don't want another child.
But we have very different views on termination. Although he says he is pro choice he doesn't feel it's something he personally could do and he's gone as far as to say that if I had a termination, even very early on he would consider that no different to taking a gun and killing one of our daughters now. I disagree massively with this and told him clearly at the time I am so certain in my choice not to have more children that I wouldn't hesitate to have a termination. This was always a hypothetical though.
Except I took a pregnancy test this morning and it was positive. We have been using condoms and I don't remember one splitting so I really don't know how this has happened. I can't have another baby. I can't. I have suffered with hyperemesis in both pregnancies and I can't do it again. I also just do not want another baby. I love my girls more than anything but I don't enjoy the day to days of parenting and each new stage we get to with my youngest I feel a bit more of my life coming back to me and I know myself well enough to know I cannot cope with a third. There is absolutely no hesitation in my mind that I will not go through with this pregnancy.

I don't want to tell DH about it. It's not something that's up for discussion in my mind, I'm not doing it and it's as simple as that. I know that makes me sound horrible and I promise I'm not a horrible person normally but I know myself and I know I can't do this. But DH will want me to. He'll see it as it wasn't planned, it's not ideal but here we are and so let's get on with it. But it's not him that has to be pregnant or give birth or even do the majority of the parenting as I would take the year off and then work part time and have to manage the daily grind far more than him.
He's a wonderful man, he really is. I love him so much but what good can come from telling him if all that will do is hurt him, maybe even make him hate me but even so I know there's nothing he or anyone can say that'll make me change my mind.

OP posts:
username131024 · 02/11/2023 08:54

@Naunet - yes I had considered that. It hasn’t happened yet so it’s an unknown. He may have other views or bring a different perspective. Not talking about it isn’t better than talking about it either way. She has said she will go through with it regardless- so forced birth isn’t a risk.

sollenwir · 02/11/2023 08:55

The ideal scenario would be that you would get through this together, him accepting that it's ultimately your decision. I am not sure that is possible in this case though, based on what you have written. If you are as convinced as anyone can be that you want to go through with the termination then please don't do it alone - get support from a trusted friend who you know will NEVER reveal this to OH). I have never had a termination but understand that it can be an incredibly hard process emotionally, even if you know you are doing what is right for you.
I wish you well, and hope that you are able to move forward knowing that you have done the best in an incredibly hard situation.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/11/2023 09:02

waxeswanes · 02/11/2023 08:41

@PumpkinsAndCoconuts of course none of us know the DH, but I just think that's a lot to extrapolate from hypothetical chit chat in front of the TV.

I posted earlier about how my partner, and immediate birth family, and extended family all have very polarised ideological views (doesn't help that we're all from different countries/cultures) about far-removed political situations, and emotive debates loaded with hyperbole. That doesn't turn any of us into failures as family members or partners.

Ultimately what I've seen every single time, many times, is people immediately scrambling to support anyone 100% anytime an abstract situation becomes reality (eg cross border issues).

Of course, it may be the case that he isn't supportive or he gets angry. I think being sad on his own is fine but he has to be outwardly supportive. Personally, I'd rather know if the person I'm married to prioritises my body as a mere vessel over my happiness and wellbeing — and by "know", I mean I would want to be aware, but also sure. I wouldn't want to falsely project and assume, based on some thoughtless moments in front of the TV. If I was sure, I personally would not be able to continue happily in the relationship – but only if I was sure.

I hope you are right.

But ultimately I can only go by what OP is saying. OP clearly does not feel like her DH would be "scambling to support her".

But he'll want me to and he'll be upset and possibly angry (because he has no say and whilst technically it's not his baby yet, it is his baby and he has no say) but he won't force me. And I genuinely don't know how supportive he could be if he truly believes as he says that I'm killing our baby.

Although he says he is pro choice he doesn't feel it's something he personally could do and he's gone as far as to say that if I had a termination, even very early on he would consider that no different to taking a gun and killing one of our daughters now.

And there is also the issue that this was not "about far-removed political situations, and emotive debates loaded with hyperbole" but a situation that could very easily occur IRL (as it did now).

Which is something OP and her DH were surely aware of (seeing as they were using condoms, have a vasectomoy appointment booked etc).
And yet her DH apparently repeatedly made it clear where he stood in a manner that made OP feel like she could not confide in him.

Even if OP´s DH would scramble to support her... I feel like this is a very good reminder that we should be very careful when making these kinds of statements.

Sapphire387 · 02/11/2023 09:05

hoobanoobie · 02/11/2023 00:43

@wtfamireading Because if you had, you've have experienced the awful loss of a much wanted and loved baby. To suggest it as an excuse in this case is despicable. Even if she could sell the lie, the husband would mourn the baby who was lost. Miscarriages are utterly destroying. Suggesting that is a smack in the face to everyone on here reading this thread who has suffered a miscarriage.

I've had two miscarriages and zero abortions.

I feel sorry for the OP, if she can't trust her husband enough to tell him because his response would be so awful.

I would not judge her for telling her husband she'd had a miscarriage. It is not a smack in the face to me.

notlucreziaborgia · 02/11/2023 09:31

username131024 · 02/11/2023 08:54

@Naunet - yes I had considered that. It hasn’t happened yet so it’s an unknown. He may have other views or bring a different perspective. Not talking about it isn’t better than talking about it either way. She has said she will go through with it regardless- so forced birth isn’t a risk.

I think not talking about it can indeed be significantly better than talking about it, especially when she has very good reason to believe that he’ll oppose her decision.

I see no reason for her to invite conflict with her husband into her life, which will not just have an impact on them, but on their children too. By not telling him she and her family can continue on with their normal lives.

This really doesn’t have to be a massive burden for her to carry, and there’s no reason for him to find out. Plenty of women have abortions and do indeed move on quite happily.

Sueveneers · 02/11/2023 09:41

notlucreziaborgia · 02/11/2023 09:31

I think not talking about it can indeed be significantly better than talking about it, especially when she has very good reason to believe that he’ll oppose her decision.

I see no reason for her to invite conflict with her husband into her life, which will not just have an impact on them, but on their children too. By not telling him she and her family can continue on with their normal lives.

This really doesn’t have to be a massive burden for her to carry, and there’s no reason for him to find out. Plenty of women have abortions and do indeed move on quite happily.

She lives with him. She will be bleeding for quite awhile, possibly in severe pain, could even be complications. It's not something she can hide, you know? She can't hide this from him. Unless she goes away (leaving him and the children) for a week to 2 weeks, but how will she explain that? This is not a one night stand or some random she doesn't live with. She lives with, and shares a room/bed with this man. I think she will find it incredibly difficult covering this up, he will know something is up with her sick, bleeding and in pain. And she is underestimating him. She needs to tell him as she will need his support at home as she will be incapacitated for days, possibly longer. I think the suggestion that she can hide this and all the pain, bleeding etc for days it entails - from him, is utterly unrealistic and rather delusional.

Imamumgetmeoutofhere · 02/11/2023 09:42

Thinking of you OP

pineapplepinecones · 02/11/2023 09:55

Good luck OP ! I had one and never think about it.

from memory they suggest no sex for a month afterwards so might need to work an excuse for that.

tho maybe it will just be a pill if so early.
and also the pregnancy might not have worked out anyway. A third unwanted with extra needs would be life changing for everyone.

sex not six edit !

Mirabai · 02/11/2023 09:58

@Sueveneers she is underestimating him. She needs to tell him as she will need his support at home as she will be incapacitated for days, possibly longer.

Pfft. She knows him you don’t. From what she says far from supporting her he will kick off when she most needs help.

Mirabai · 02/11/2023 09:59

notlucreziaborgia · 02/11/2023 09:31

I think not talking about it can indeed be significantly better than talking about it, especially when she has very good reason to believe that he’ll oppose her decision.

I see no reason for her to invite conflict with her husband into her life, which will not just have an impact on them, but on their children too. By not telling him she and her family can continue on with their normal lives.

This really doesn’t have to be a massive burden for her to carry, and there’s no reason for him to find out. Plenty of women have abortions and do indeed move on quite happily.

I agree.

All this stuff about what she owes her DH. Meanwhile he apparently doesn’t even owe her respect.

Mirabai · 02/11/2023 09:59

I mean - owing her DH honesty.

notlucreziaborgia · 02/11/2023 09:59

Sueveneers · 02/11/2023 09:41

She lives with him. She will be bleeding for quite awhile, possibly in severe pain, could even be complications. It's not something she can hide, you know? She can't hide this from him. Unless she goes away (leaving him and the children) for a week to 2 weeks, but how will she explain that? This is not a one night stand or some random she doesn't live with. She lives with, and shares a room/bed with this man. I think she will find it incredibly difficult covering this up, he will know something is up with her sick, bleeding and in pain. And she is underestimating him. She needs to tell him as she will need his support at home as she will be incapacitated for days, possibly longer. I think the suggestion that she can hide this and all the pain, bleeding etc for days it entails - from him, is utterly unrealistic and rather delusional.

Edited

That isn’t everyone’s experience of abortion at all. I bled for a day with mine, then spotted slightly the next day. It was akin to a (short) period, and I wasn't incapacitated.

Of course OP may have a different experience, but if she does, would a husband that opposes her decision, be the one best placed to support her when she’s going through it, if he’s angry and upset? Or would that actually make it far more difficult for her?

If OP is worried about the tablets then she has the option of a surgical abortion if she wants.

notlucreziaborgia · 02/11/2023 10:04

She also has the option of telling him she has to have a polyp removed, which would also explain any extended bleeding and abstention from sex.

caringcarer · 02/11/2023 10:07

If you do it you can't tell absolutely no one irl. Because if you do he could find out later and whereas he might be upset with you if you told him then aborted, I don't think he'd ever forgive you for not telling him and doing it behind his back. Personally I'd tell him and tell him you wanted an early abortion and point out it's your body and you're done with babies.

Totalblindnessofthesoul · 02/11/2023 10:10

waxeswanes · 02/11/2023 08:16

Why, though? I'm like the OP's DH, in that I believe 100% in free choice.

But personally, I would find it incredibly painful to go through with an abortion myself. Or if (obviously hypothetically) my husband was bearing my and his baby/foetus/whatever you want to call it, it would really pain me if he chose to get rid of what I see as our child. It seems like a form of murder to me, yes. (Or, for less emotive phrasing, conscious deprivation of current and potential life?)

But I also do believe in the greater good, and in the reality of the situation, I suppose any potential suffering of my partner would take precedence. Or even if there was no suffering and the potential baby was just unwanted by them, then the greater good would lie in the baby ceasing to exist, versus 2 unhappy (partner and baby) lives.

It's not a perfect comparison, but I suppose I see it as akin to culling animals? The foetus is alive and I personally believe has features of personhood, but is still less sentient than a person (and for clarity, less sentient than an animal). So the more sentient person's needs must win.

Anyway, all this is to say that I think the militant "if you show even an ounce of emotion towards the idea of a foetus, then you're not really pro-choice" line I keep seeing on MN is black and white nonsense. I can have personal leanings towards a certain political party, but that doesn't mean I don't believe in democracy or free and fair elections (the overall right to choose). Pro-choice literally just means respecting the overall right to choose either option – it doesn't mean militantly pro-abortion only.

I have unconditionally supported my dear friends through abortions, and who's to say the husband here won't unconditionally support OP based on the new reality of the situation?

Edited

I'm similar, except feel a bit more strongly about it still. I would only abort if the baby had a very significant/incompatibility or life level issue, or pregnancy would likely kill me, even though a further pregnancy would have lifelong health implications for me.

To me, it would be my child, just a very early version. It's death as an embryo/fetus wouldn't be comparable to the death of one of my born children, but it would still be a loss.

I'm very glad that I'm a woman and therefore the fate of my unborn children isn't upto someone else. Whilst I fully agree that it's not upto men, I do feel sorry for them in that it must be hell having to support a woman through the abortion is a wanted child.

Mirabai · 02/11/2023 10:11

notlucreziaborgia · 02/11/2023 10:04

She also has the option of telling him she has to have a polyp removed, which would also explain any extended bleeding and abstention from sex.

Or she’s had a miscarriage.

All of the forced dishonesty is entirely at his door.

Mirabai · 02/11/2023 10:12

By rights she should be furious with him that she’s forced into this horrible position.

notlucreziaborgia · 02/11/2023 10:13

Mirabai · 02/11/2023 10:11

Or she’s had a miscarriage.

All of the forced dishonesty is entirely at his door.

The only risk of that is if he starts grieving, which could make it awkward for OP.

and yes, it is. If she could trust him to be supportive then there would be no need for it. Sadly though, she can’t.

Sueveneers · 02/11/2023 10:14

notlucreziaborgia · 02/11/2023 10:04

She also has the option of telling him she has to have a polyp removed, which would also explain any extended bleeding and abstention from sex.

Except polyp removal requires not just a medical referral for the initial scan, but a GP referral for the removal after it has been scanned, and it's a while to get in, weeks/months. It's not something she can achieve all on the one day, and her husband would have wondered how and when he had time for the scans and GP appointments let alone him not even knowing it was all going on.

Berylswain · 02/11/2023 10:17

A lovely man would support your decision, not guilt trip you into doing what they think is right. He's being coercive and it's emotional blackmail. It's never the man's decision and as you say, it's the woman who does all the work and carries that child inside of her. Men would be having abortions for breakfast if they had to carry the child and do all the work. Male privilege is alive and well sadly. Ignore his misogynist attitude and make the decision for yourself. Your body, your choice:)

waxeswanes · 02/11/2023 10:17

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 02/11/2023 09:02

I hope you are right.

But ultimately I can only go by what OP is saying. OP clearly does not feel like her DH would be "scambling to support her".

But he'll want me to and he'll be upset and possibly angry (because he has no say and whilst technically it's not his baby yet, it is his baby and he has no say) but he won't force me. And I genuinely don't know how supportive he could be if he truly believes as he says that I'm killing our baby.

Although he says he is pro choice he doesn't feel it's something he personally could do and he's gone as far as to say that if I had a termination, even very early on he would consider that no different to taking a gun and killing one of our daughters now.

And there is also the issue that this was not "about far-removed political situations, and emotive debates loaded with hyperbole" but a situation that could very easily occur IRL (as it did now).

Which is something OP and her DH were surely aware of (seeing as they were using condoms, have a vasectomoy appointment booked etc).
And yet her DH apparently repeatedly made it clear where he stood in a manner that made OP feel like she could not confide in him.

Even if OP´s DH would scramble to support her... I feel like this is a very good reminder that we should be very careful when making these kinds of statements.

I think you make an excellent point that we should be very careful when making statements, even in the supposedly hypothetical.

I do want to add, however, that I don't think the DH was just trying to be edgy or some kind of devil's advocate. Clearly, what he was very clumsily and selfishly expressing was his view that abortion is deprivation of life, and the emotional impact it might have on him.

While the phrasing was gory – though I can identify with his perspective, having firsthand witnessed certain graphic images I can't get out of my mind – I do think the sentiment was valid to express. Putting aside the valid consideration of patriarchy within present society, in an alternate universe, how much would I be allowed to say or feel if my husband/partner decided to abort our child in his body? While obviously one probably shouldn't mention guns, it's a delicate line to toe between expressing one's wishes and pressuring, especially when she wasn't pregnant here.

Of course, anyway, the impact on OP should be the primary consideration, and OP's decision must be final. Who's to say that whatever OP said from her POV didn't also stick with him and shake him, in the same way whatever he said stuck with OP?

On my family/partner, I should have said "politicised", not "political", because it includes things like personal and physical procedures as well. I think our atmosphere of debate (wanting to untangle without invalidating coexisting logical and emotional convictions) probably comes with our various job areas in policy/legislation. We enjoy unpicking nuance; I've said earlier that I do think of abortion as a form of murder/culling (of less sentient beings), but morally legitimate. I do respect that in other families, any opinions expressed may have more of an air of finality about them. You're right that tact and nuance are never overrated, for scenarios that may well actualise.

notlucreziaborgia · 02/11/2023 10:18

Sueveneers · 02/11/2023 10:14

Except polyp removal requires not just a medical referral for the initial scan, but a GP referral for the removal after it has been scanned, and it's a while to get in, weeks/months. It's not something she can achieve all on the one day, and her husband would have wondered how and when he had time for the scans and GP appointments let alone him not even knowing it was all going on.

In my experience it can be diagnosed and sorted very quickly, within days, but I don’t know how it works on the NHS🤷🏻‍♀️

She could say she’s going to get any noticeable bleeding from the abortion checked out, and then put it down to a polyp, or an irregular period, afterwards.

LeopardPJS · 02/11/2023 10:26

I’d absolutely terminate and not tell him. Your body, your choice, not his. Sadly it’s his own fault you feel unable to tell him, because he has made it obvious to you that you can’t trust him to support your right to choose in this situation, and that if this situation ever arose in your marriage, he would place you under intense pressure to keep the baby which would be totally unhelpful as you have already made up your mind. The gun to the head of one of your existing children comment is as ridiculous as it is appalling. We’re talking about a bunch of cells. Do what is right for you and don’t feel guilty.

MotherOfDragon20 · 02/11/2023 10:29

If I was in your position I would 100% do it and I wouldn’t tell him. If you need a reason to ease your guilt (and for the record I don’t think you do) then why potentially destroy your happy relationship and family with your children over this, thing of your existing children’s happiness with two parents. No need for him to ever find out your medical history is nobody else’s business even your husband. Get it done and move on.

AmazingSnakeHead · 02/11/2023 10:41

Good luck. I wouldn't tell him. I have never had an abortion, but my DP has similar views to yours and I've taken pregnancy tests knowing that if they were positive I would terminate without telling him. It's your body and it's your decision whether the cells inside it grow into a baby or not.

Swipe left for the next trending thread