Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To question a colleague's childcare arrangements?

130 replies

Seaswimmingforthesoul · 21/08/2023 12:03

I'm a senior manager and my direct reports are able to work remotely but with an expectation that they work in the office at least 1 day per week.
I have a member of my team who is relatively new. So far she is very productive, and has settled in really well, the team really like her and I've been impressed with her output.
It's become increasingly obvious to me however that she has her 2 very young children at home with her whilst she's working, and she shares childcare with her partner who also works full time, but works shifts. She has directly told me this is the case this week. I've so far turned a blind eye to this as she is so productive, but I noticed last week she didn't work from the office at all, and I suspect this week will be similar from conversations we have had this morning.
I am very flexible with my team and very understanding about issues with childcare etc. However, this is directly against company policy, and from experience i know how incredibly hard it is to work from home with small children.
I'm really unsure what to do. I really don't think it's acceptable to be your child's main carer whilst also working full time.
Should I speak to her about it informally? Im not sure what can be done about it. She has told me outright they can't afford childcare, which I find surprising as her job is pretty well paid and their partner is in a good job too. Whilst i sympathise with the cost of childcare (i have DC of my own)I do feel that it's unreasonable to do childcare on company time.
What should I do?

OP posts:
rookiemere · 21/08/2023 17:18

Firstly unless someone has signed a wfh contract then their employers are allowed to require them to come into the office. We are being asked to come in 2 days a week from September- I already do it - and honestly from the fuss some people are making, I they forget that pre covid it was the norm to be in 4-5 days per week

On the childcare thing, it's a toughie if she's getting through the work and as people have said it's different if it's older DCs for a few days over the school holidays than if it's constant with a preschooler. I personally don't like it - I paid for a CM when my DS was young so that he was appropriately cared for and I could work - but I appreciate times have changed.
I do think you need to advise her on company policy and if that's not to be looking after DCs whilst working that's what it is. I'd not make a big deal of it, but I would let her know.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/08/2023 17:49

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 21/08/2023 12:06

HR Director here. You need to have the conversation. This isn’t okay and if you’ve policies forbidding it then she needs to be made aware of those.

It is absolutely not possible to work productively, look after young children and maintain your well-being all at the same time. You need to discuss this with her and give her a deadline to sort out proper childcare. (Have dealt with this umpteen times since Covid.)

This ^^

It may work for now if her productivity's okay, but being new there's a chance she's pulling out all the stops so you'll accept the arrangement despite the company's policies, only to do less and less (and you've already said she's not come into the office for even the minimal one day required)

Best IME to get it sorted now before the issue balloons - and also before others start expecting the same

eastiseastwestiswest · 22/08/2023 20:53

Why does @OnceAgainWithFeeling think they are able to so surely
Predict what is or isn't possible? When my flexible
Working request was rejected I was patronisingly informed they didn't think condensed hours would be possible whilst maintaining my mental health. They however had no response to how to maintain my mental health whilst working 4 days a week for reduced pay and being forced to travel 100s miles into the office.

HR "experts" are always so keen to inform everyone what it is that they need without any real common sense attached.

Why can't people fathom that this way of working might be the only way to maintain her mental health because without working flexibly or limiting childcare costs the other spinning plates may topple.

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 22/08/2023 21:45

eastiseastwestiswest · 22/08/2023 20:53

Why does @OnceAgainWithFeeling think they are able to so surely
Predict what is or isn't possible? When my flexible
Working request was rejected I was patronisingly informed they didn't think condensed hours would be possible whilst maintaining my mental health. They however had no response to how to maintain my mental health whilst working 4 days a week for reduced pay and being forced to travel 100s miles into the office.

HR "experts" are always so keen to inform everyone what it is that they need without any real common sense attached.

Why can't people fathom that this way of working might be the only way to maintain her mental health because without working flexibly or limiting childcare costs the other spinning plates may topple.

I won’t go into my personal experience of working 16 hour days 7 days a week in the NHS during the pandemic, but as I say, have dealt with this umpteen times since then. I have covered the legal issues across posts in this thread.

If your home is accepted as a workplace by your employer there are Health and Safety laws that apply. It means if your child has an accident whilst you are working from home the employer could potentially be found at least partially liable. It isn’t possible to be totally focused on work and small children simultaneously.

If the work is flexible and the employee gets up early to do half of it then works late to cover the rest to enable them to look after children during the day they could be in breach of WTD rest breaks (which cannot be opted out of and few exemptions exist in law). These exist to try and support well-being.

I’m mainly employed to keep the employer out of court, which is why I can’t turn a blind eye to this.

https://www.blackadders.co.uk/business-legal-news/2022/06/13/working-parents-working-from-home-what-should-employers-allow/

Working parents working from home: what should employers allow? - Business Legal News from Blackadders Solicitors

Working parents working from home: what should employers allow? . Read the latest business and legal news from Business Legal News from Blackadders Solicitors - commercial law experts.

https://www.blackadders.co.uk/business-legal-news/2022/06/13/working-parents-working-from-home-what-should-employers-allow/

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 22/08/2023 21:45

There’s not a day goes by when I am not complimented for my common sense, by the way!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread