Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To question a colleague's childcare arrangements?

130 replies

Seaswimmingforthesoul · 21/08/2023 12:03

I'm a senior manager and my direct reports are able to work remotely but with an expectation that they work in the office at least 1 day per week.
I have a member of my team who is relatively new. So far she is very productive, and has settled in really well, the team really like her and I've been impressed with her output.
It's become increasingly obvious to me however that she has her 2 very young children at home with her whilst she's working, and she shares childcare with her partner who also works full time, but works shifts. She has directly told me this is the case this week. I've so far turned a blind eye to this as she is so productive, but I noticed last week she didn't work from the office at all, and I suspect this week will be similar from conversations we have had this morning.
I am very flexible with my team and very understanding about issues with childcare etc. However, this is directly against company policy, and from experience i know how incredibly hard it is to work from home with small children.
I'm really unsure what to do. I really don't think it's acceptable to be your child's main carer whilst also working full time.
Should I speak to her about it informally? Im not sure what can be done about it. She has told me outright they can't afford childcare, which I find surprising as her job is pretty well paid and their partner is in a good job too. Whilst i sympathise with the cost of childcare (i have DC of my own)I do feel that it's unreasonable to do childcare on company time.
What should I do?

OP posts:
Peony654 · 21/08/2023 12:48

And I think the issue about productivity is a bit irrelevant, it's more about consistency of treatment of employees. It could get very tricky if you let her get away with it because of good performance, but then what about another employee who has performance issues.

EsmeSusanOgg · 21/08/2023 12:48

WhenLifeGivesYouLimes · 21/08/2023 12:14

Exactly how young are the children? If they're school age and this is only a school holiday problem which is nearly over for this year and will get easier every subsequent summer then I'd be tempted to turn a blind eye until September and suggest that she does a couple of extra office days then.

If they're nursery age and this will be a 52 week a year problem then you are going to have to intervene.

This.

AnneAnon · 21/08/2023 12:50

Turn a blind eye is terrible advice. What about all the other mugs in the workplace who actually are paying for childcare?

I pay for childcare and I’d be annoyed if my colleague, with the exact same job and targets etc as me, was allowed to work from home with her kids underfoot. It’s either fine for everyone or it’s not.

Frabbits · 21/08/2023 12:50

donkra · 21/08/2023 12:40

Corporate policies typically specify the age under which childcare is required - often 10-11ish. OP says the employee is in violation of the policy. So obviously her DC are sub this age.

Not necesarily. Nothing in my contract about having kids at home when I'm working.

If the only issue is that the employee hasn't been able to come into the office a day during the holidays but is otherwise doing her job, then I fail to see why there is much of a problem.

Zimunya · 21/08/2023 12:53

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 21/08/2023 12:06

HR Director here. You need to have the conversation. This isn’t okay and if you’ve policies forbidding it then she needs to be made aware of those.

It is absolutely not possible to work productively, look after young children and maintain your well-being all at the same time. You need to discuss this with her and give her a deadline to sort out proper childcare. (Have dealt with this umpteen times since Covid.)

Agree with this. On the face of it there's no harm, but if you turn a blind eye when she ignores one company policy, then there will be an expectation that you turn a blind eye when other memebers of your team break other company policies. Then you've completely lost the respect of your team.

Teateaandmoretea · 21/08/2023 12:53

redskytwonight · 21/08/2023 12:38

I'd be concerned about the fact that her productivity is as good as you think it is.

It's simply not possible to be as productive with small children underfoot as it is without them.

So, she's either working stupid hours to keep up (which will not be good for her long term well being or morale) or something is going somewhere. If it's like my workplace there are quite a few employees that are very good at producing stuff for their manager but it's because they are not doing other less visible parts of their job or colleagues are picking up the slack.

I agree you need to bring up the contravention to customer policy. It's not your responsibility to pay her bills.

Employees aren't homogeneous inputs. Some people can do the work in 75% of the time and others take 125% of the time. Its why presenteeism is a joke - the ones who work overtime are usually the weaker team members ime.

I think a lot of this debate is about jealousy of those who have flexibility.

PurplePansy05 · 21/08/2023 12:53

Is it the case her partner is looking after them when she's working though? If do, I don't see the problem with that. If she's productive then it sounds like she's not doing the childcare herself, otherwise it'd be impossible to juggle. Do you have reasons to believe otherwise?

In relation to coming in to the office once a week, ask her directly why she isn't coming in this week and remind her this is a company policy.

crosstheriver · 21/08/2023 12:53

I would turn a blind eye for a one-off (e.g. if the kids were sick and nursery wouldn’t take them). Absolutely not on an ongoing basis.

Apart from her breach of contract and your failure to safeguard her welfare (someone looking after kids full-time and working full-time is headed towards burnout if doing both properly), this will break your wider team. There is nothing like a perceived injustice as to how someone else is being treated to get others team members looking for another job.

Nip this in the bud.

Howandwhy · 21/08/2023 12:54

confusedinlondon · 21/08/2023 12:30

You're not going to help her well being by making her rush around trying to sort out childcare.

I don't understand why so many managers suddenly become concerned about their employees well being and company policy when it comes to wfh but turn a blind eye when an employee works well over their contracted hours week after week.

THIS...nobody is concerned about over working well over your hours or not taking lunch etc, until you go off long term sick.

BlowDryRat · 21/08/2023 12:55

I had this issue with a new member of my team, who was looking after a toddler during working hours. I scheduled a meeting with him, told him his dips in productivity and jumping in and out of meetings had been noticed and that he needed to be in the office 4 days a week. He wasn't happy about it at first but he's been a model employee since then (over a year later). The discussion needs to happen.

ProfessorSlocombe · 21/08/2023 12:55

I think a lot of this debate is about jealousy of those who have flexibility.

Maybe. My point is that you aren't keeping your children safe - especially if they are very young - if you are working. It's one or the other.

Riverbananacarrot · 21/08/2023 12:55

My advice would be to have the conversation and document in a 121, explain and refer to the policies and give her a reasonable time frame to get childcare put in place.
If she says she can't because of the cost them you need to explain that she is in breach of the polices and loop HR in.
Also I would address the working from office one day a week, is this mandatory or the company would like to have.
If it's mandatory you can insist on it but if it's not then you have no push back on this point

Please don't be ambiguous or unclear be firm and very clear and put it in writing.

My manager is awful and phrases things I'm a terrible way and she then pushes back on me for not doing something even thought she was unclear.

DinnaeFashYersel · 21/08/2023 12:56

So far she is very productive, and has settled in really well, the team really like her and I've been impressed with her output

So what is the problem then?

Wenfy · 21/08/2023 12:58

Read that policy in and out before talking to her: what does it actually say? I work in a company where the policy is also to be in the office one day a week. But dispensations are allowed if supported by senior managers, logged in HR and reviewed annually. If she’s productive at home the last thing you want to do is drag her to the office for her to then clock watch.

Womencanlift · 21/08/2023 12:59

Only one day a week in the office is generous. Most people I know, including me, are in at least twice a week now (very likely in some cases because of people taking the piss)

If it’s company policy then of course you need to address otherwise you will lose credibility with the rest of your team who will start to get pissed off that they are having to do something that somebody else is getting away with. That will be a bigger issue if they start leaving because they are pissed off

I know it’s harsh but whether she can or can’t afford childcare isn’t really you or the company’s concern if she took the job knowing what was expected of her

Wenfy · 21/08/2023 12:59

Riverbananacarrot · 21/08/2023 12:55

My advice would be to have the conversation and document in a 121, explain and refer to the policies and give her a reasonable time frame to get childcare put in place.
If she says she can't because of the cost them you need to explain that she is in breach of the polices and loop HR in.
Also I would address the working from office one day a week, is this mandatory or the company would like to have.
If it's mandatory you can insist on it but if it's not then you have no push back on this point

Please don't be ambiguous or unclear be firm and very clear and put it in writing.

My manager is awful and phrases things I'm a terrible way and she then pushes back on me for not doing something even thought she was unclear.

Senior managers are expected to make dispensations to policy where required. This won’t be a simple grunt / low level decision of ‘oh you aren’t following policy sort it out or get fired’.

eastiseastwestiswest · 21/08/2023 13:00

Seaswimmingforthesoul · 21/08/2023 12:14

Thanks everyone. That was what my gut was telling me. I need to talk to her about it and she needs to arrange childcare.

I think I was just so shocked that someone would think it was OK to do that and be so open about it, it's thrown me a bit. I'm an experienced manager (honestly! 🤣) But this has quite shocked me!

I feel, like the HR director suggested, that it is likely a post-covid mentality.

Sorry but what on earth is the issue if she is being productive and impressive and gets on with the team?

I absolutely hate this sort of old fashioned, box ticking, assumptions based attitude. She's probably working longer and later and more efficiently because she knows she has a point to prove and she values the fact that you're allowing her the flexibility she needs.

If you impose some arbitrary rules on her she will
Probably leave and you will end up with someone who plays by the rules but who is less efficient and not as good at their job. Is that what you want?

The reasons she can't afford childcare are frankly none of your business unless she's not performing.

redskytwonight · 21/08/2023 13:02

Teateaandmoretea · 21/08/2023 12:53

Employees aren't homogeneous inputs. Some people can do the work in 75% of the time and others take 125% of the time. Its why presenteeism is a joke - the ones who work overtime are usually the weaker team members ime.

I think a lot of this debate is about jealousy of those who have flexibility.

Exactly - which is why she should be expected to work to the best of her abilities, not versus some imaginary company target. If she's doing the work in 75% of the time and skiving off for the other 25%, then she should be tasked with doing some of the work of the employee who works more slowly is struggling with.

As I said in PP I have a lot of colleagues who are very good at impressing management whilst slacking in other areas. I'd like to know what the team really think.

Teateaandmoretea · 21/08/2023 13:02

ProfessorSlocombe · 21/08/2023 12:55

I think a lot of this debate is about jealousy of those who have flexibility.

Maybe. My point is that you aren't keeping your children safe - especially if they are very young - if you are working. It's one or the other.

But this is up to the parents to judge not randoms online. My own children are older now.

On the flip side though, my employer expects me to WFH - and other people who live here 'distracting' me are part of that. I never ever WFH till they closed my office.

DH is self employed, he'd have collected DD2 from school at 7/8 and then would have worked until tea time. The ludicrous suggestion is that my employer could apparently have insisted on after school club.....

weirdoboelady · 21/08/2023 13:03

Non parent senior manager here. The childcare arrangements are none of the company's business unless they are demonstrably affecting output (which they are not, in this case) or unless the employee reveals something so serious that the children are demonstrably at risk of abuse/injury, in which case there is a legal responsibility to report.

The company is weekly requiring attendance at the office, and this requirement is not being met. This needs addressing.

My own approach would initially be an informal one - 'you really DO need to come in. I'm not raising the issue of childcare as I regard you telling me about your lack of it as an informal notification, so I'm pretending I haven't heard that. You are a grown up, and your work output is fine. Informally I am worried you don't have childcare in place, but I don't feel I should discuss how you parent your children. However, you do need to be here as required by policy.'

Teateaandmoretea · 21/08/2023 13:04

redskytwonight · 21/08/2023 13:02

Exactly - which is why she should be expected to work to the best of her abilities, not versus some imaginary company target. If she's doing the work in 75% of the time and skiving off for the other 25%, then she should be tasked with doing some of the work of the employee who works more slowly is struggling with.

As I said in PP I have a lot of colleagues who are very good at impressing management whilst slacking in other areas. I'd like to know what the team really think.

And there are a lot of people who impress no one because they just aren't particularly strong at the job that they do and their output/ delivery is on the line of whether they are competent or not. Maybe you're one of those.

ProfessorSlocombe · 21/08/2023 13:05

Sorry but what on earth is the issue if she is being productive and impressive and gets on with the team?

But the children aren't being cared for. Because if the are, why do we need childcare at all ?

And while there may be some who say "what business is that of the company", you would be amazed what can suddenly become a companies business when there is a hefty lawsuit doing the rounds. Starting with the fact that if it emerged a company was not applying it's own rules it could be seen as tacit approval of the situation. And thus risk making the company partly vicariously liable.

The law may be an ass. But donkeys can kick.

Goneroundthetwist · 21/08/2023 13:05

Mariposa26 · 21/08/2023 12:27

Also an HR Director and my concern is about productivity, performance and retention of good talent rather than policy for policy’s sake. You describe her as very productive - so aside from failing to attend the office (which to me is the main problem here) what issue is this causing? To me, we should be pragmatic and treat people as adults until their performance suffers. Would you prefer she left if she can’t afford childcare? I think that’s what you should ask yourself.

Finally, a sensible comment.

To those complaining about fairness, equity and making things equal for all employees is not necessarily the same thing.

Teateaandmoretea · 21/08/2023 13:07

ProfessorSlocombe · 21/08/2023 13:05

Sorry but what on earth is the issue if she is being productive and impressive and gets on with the team?

But the children aren't being cared for. Because if the are, why do we need childcare at all ?

And while there may be some who say "what business is that of the company", you would be amazed what can suddenly become a companies business when there is a hefty lawsuit doing the rounds. Starting with the fact that if it emerged a company was not applying it's own rules it could be seen as tacit approval of the situation. And thus risk making the company partly vicariously liable.

The law may be an ass. But donkeys can kick.

So you've decided that her children are being neglected based on an internet post? Her DH works shifts so is presumably around a lot of the time the OP is actually working.

The company is weekly requiring attendance at the office, and this requirement is not being met. This needs addressing.

^^This if it matters to the team and everyone else does it is the key thing.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 21/08/2023 13:08

If you impose some arbitrary rules on her she will
Probably leave and you will end up with someone who plays by the rules but who is less efficient and not as good at their job. Is that what you want?

How on earth do you know? She could well end up with someone who is very efficient because they ensure that their children are being cared for during working hours. Or indeed someone without children at all.

The world isn’t made up of wonderful ‘WFH with kids’ mums and useless wasters, you know.