Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To question a colleague's childcare arrangements?

130 replies

Seaswimmingforthesoul · 21/08/2023 12:03

I'm a senior manager and my direct reports are able to work remotely but with an expectation that they work in the office at least 1 day per week.
I have a member of my team who is relatively new. So far she is very productive, and has settled in really well, the team really like her and I've been impressed with her output.
It's become increasingly obvious to me however that she has her 2 very young children at home with her whilst she's working, and she shares childcare with her partner who also works full time, but works shifts. She has directly told me this is the case this week. I've so far turned a blind eye to this as she is so productive, but I noticed last week she didn't work from the office at all, and I suspect this week will be similar from conversations we have had this morning.
I am very flexible with my team and very understanding about issues with childcare etc. However, this is directly against company policy, and from experience i know how incredibly hard it is to work from home with small children.
I'm really unsure what to do. I really don't think it's acceptable to be your child's main carer whilst also working full time.
Should I speak to her about it informally? Im not sure what can be done about it. She has told me outright they can't afford childcare, which I find surprising as her job is pretty well paid and their partner is in a good job too. Whilst i sympathise with the cost of childcare (i have DC of my own)I do feel that it's unreasonable to do childcare on company time.
What should I do?

OP posts:
OnceAgainWithFeeling · 21/08/2023 12:28

Mariposa26 · 21/08/2023 12:27

Also an HR Director and my concern is about productivity, performance and retention of good talent rather than policy for policy’s sake. You describe her as very productive - so aside from failing to attend the office (which to me is the main problem here) what issue is this causing? To me, we should be pragmatic and treat people as adults until their performance suffers. Would you prefer she left if she can’t afford childcare? I think that’s what you should ask yourself.

How are you managing WTD in this scenario?

Dolores87 · 21/08/2023 12:29

As long as she puts the work in and gets all her work done I would continue to turn a blind eye to it. I honestly can not see the problem for the company if she is getting her work done and on time and is present in all meetings she needs to be.

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 21/08/2023 12:29

Also concerns about H+S liabilities if you’ve effectively accepted there being young children in her main workplace.

redrighthand83 · 21/08/2023 12:29

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 21/08/2023 12:06

HR Director here. You need to have the conversation. This isn’t okay and if you’ve policies forbidding it then she needs to be made aware of those.

It is absolutely not possible to work productively, look after young children and maintain your well-being all at the same time. You need to discuss this with her and give her a deadline to sort out proper childcare. (Have dealt with this umpteen times since Covid.)

But she is being productive? It is right there in the OP. There are no performance concerns.

Inform chat needed to just remind her of company policy and give time for her to find suitable childcare.

I would have presumed that perhaps this is an issue because it's the school holidays?

confusedinlondon · 21/08/2023 12:30

You're not going to help her well being by making her rush around trying to sort out childcare.

I don't understand why so many managers suddenly become concerned about their employees well being and company policy when it comes to wfh but turn a blind eye when an employee works well over their contracted hours week after week.

Halfemptyhalfling · 21/08/2023 12:30

From my experience they need to be coming up to year 1 at school eg nearly 6 before people can effectively work from home. If she is working effectively then her partner must be looking after them most of the time. New parents now have huge rent and mortgages and astronomical childcare fees for under 3s (and fewer nurseries) and much higher train fares for commutes. In today's world unlikely she will have more children so her commitment to work will grow as the children get older. So if you speak to her do so in a supportive way.

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 21/08/2023 12:31

redrighthand83 · 21/08/2023 12:29

But she is being productive? It is right there in the OP. There are no performance concerns.

Inform chat needed to just remind her of company policy and give time for her to find suitable childcare.

I would have presumed that perhaps this is an issue because it's the school holidays?

See my later posts. If her productivity is as a result of late working there could very easily be a breach of employment legislation.

are there other policies you’d turn a blind eye to? Internet usage? Fiddling expenses?

redrighthand83 · 21/08/2023 12:31

confusedinlondon · 21/08/2023 12:30

You're not going to help her well being by making her rush around trying to sort out childcare.

I don't understand why so many managers suddenly become concerned about their employees well being and company policy when it comes to wfh but turn a blind eye when an employee works well over their contracted hours week after week.

THIS!

Boomboom22 · 21/08/2023 12:32

What odd posts about WTD. Unless you are in an office job quite low level I think most people have autonomy and work when necessary. Admin might be done at 11pm then work at 8.30.
Jesus, these people have never met teachers clearly.

Seaswimmingforthesoul · 21/08/2023 12:32

Frabbits · 21/08/2023 12:16

Which is of absolutely no concern to you and should not impact your decision making on this in any way at all.

Chill your boots! I never said it would! 🙄 Where in any of my messages have I come across as someone as unreasonable as that? Smh

OP posts:
theemmadilemma · 21/08/2023 12:33

Mariposa26 · 21/08/2023 12:27

Also an HR Director and my concern is about productivity, performance and retention of good talent rather than policy for policy’s sake. You describe her as very productive - so aside from failing to attend the office (which to me is the main problem here) what issue is this causing? To me, we should be pragmatic and treat people as adults until their performance suffers. Would you prefer she left if she can’t afford childcare? I think that’s what you should ask yourself.

There are times where it's possible to be flexible to keep talent, and times when it's not possible because allowing one person to bend all rules is detrimental to the rest of the team.

In team where all are supposed to be working to the same policies, you have to weigh in the over all effect.

youveturnedupwelldone · 21/08/2023 12:33

If it's against the policy it's an easy conversation to have, also with the one day from the office, it's it's company policy easy to do.

On the childcare one actually her productivity is a red herring - it might appear to be working for her but I bet there's an element of new job best foot forward which will then drop off as she gets more comfortable. I see the not working from an office as the first sign of this. She knows full well what she should be doing, she's waiting to see what you will do if she doesn't comply.

Also, I bet others in the team know what's going on and are annoyed by it, whether they say it or not.

The longer you leave it the harder it is to broach the subject because of it was a problem you would have raised it already....

Is she on probation? One of the key questions really is what are you going to do if she doesn't do what you need/want her to. Will your managers/HR back you up if it comes to it?

I know you're an experienced manager, but I will say that you can only be a "nice manager" until someone takes the piss like this, then you need to demonstrate you can also be a "firm manager" ie that you will apply the policies. Once you start 'turning a blind eye' to things you become known as a pushover and lose credibility.

SchoolBlazers · 21/08/2023 12:34

"She can't afford childcare".

No, she CAN afford childcare, she would just rather not pay for it if she can get away with it. I think there are probably thousands in her position, working all the hours to try to get stuff done, not giving 100% to their job or their kids. But most are at least trying to keep it a secret, not being as brazen and open.

Frabbits · 21/08/2023 12:35

Seaswimmingforthesoul · 21/08/2023 12:32

Chill your boots! I never said it would! 🙄 Where in any of my messages have I come across as someone as unreasonable as that? Smh

You bought it up as an argument as to why this person can't wfh with kids in the house. You, not me.

A lot of this depends on the age of the kids which you have not revealed.

caerdydd12 · 21/08/2023 12:37

You need to be sure she's responsible for childcare while working. Just the kids being at home isn't enough, especially if you know her partner works shifts. I work from home full time and my daughter is here most of the time, but my partner drops his hours over the holidays so when I'm working he isn't. You can't go in just assuming that because they're at home she's the one doing the childcare.

redskytwonight · 21/08/2023 12:38

I'd be concerned about the fact that her productivity is as good as you think it is.

It's simply not possible to be as productive with small children underfoot as it is without them.

So, she's either working stupid hours to keep up (which will not be good for her long term well being or morale) or something is going somewhere. If it's like my workplace there are quite a few employees that are very good at producing stuff for their manager but it's because they are not doing other less visible parts of their job or colleagues are picking up the slack.

I agree you need to bring up the contravention to customer policy. It's not your responsibility to pay her bills.

jeaux90 · 21/08/2023 12:39

It's the summer holidays and many of us are juggling and you are not concerned with her productivity.

I'm a senior manager, and whilst policies can be useful I'd say treating everyone the same is sometimes the most unfair thing to do.

I'd wait until term time resumes. See what happens then.

How young are the kids?

BCSurvivor · 21/08/2023 12:39

You mention she's part of a team.
Productive or not, what happens if someone else decides not to come into the office one day a week?
Are you going to treat them differently?

Comefromaway · 21/08/2023 12:40

The problem is the precedent it sets.

Even if she is productive at the moment she might not be in the future (as her children get older they might develop more challenging behaviour etc etc. Then if someone lese gets wind of it it will be very difficult to say no to them if you have already set a precedent with her.

Howandwhy · 21/08/2023 12:40

Do you have a flexible working or family friendly policy? You could offer her flexible working so that she covers her hours/work after the kids have gone to bed on the days her partner is not watching them.

As you have said she's already productive, this should not be a problem.

She does need to come in 1 day per week as per your policy, but I would come with an approach of concern, checking that she's ok due to her not coming in on the agreed date to find out if there's a reason for this/if she's struggling. You must follow the policy but with a view to possible reasonable adjustments depending on what she tells you.

donkra · 21/08/2023 12:40

Frabbits · 21/08/2023 12:35

You bought it up as an argument as to why this person can't wfh with kids in the house. You, not me.

A lot of this depends on the age of the kids which you have not revealed.

Corporate policies typically specify the age under which childcare is required - often 10-11ish. OP says the employee is in violation of the policy. So obviously her DC are sub this age.

ProfessorSlocombe · 21/08/2023 12:43

One day, a child will be injured, or come to harm while their parent is WFH and also looking after them. At which point the companies WFH policies, procedures and culture will come under the spotlight.

Houseneedsalift · 21/08/2023 12:45

I'd say depends on the age of the kids. My 11 year old is pretty self sufficient but was a nightmare during covid and I worked a lot of evenings making up work but I never gave up breakfast and after school club when they went back and am still surprised how many people need to go and do the school run at 3.30

Peony654 · 21/08/2023 12:45

Address it soon. It's made easier if it's company policy to come in one day a week, and she hasn't done that, and if company policy doesn't allow working from home whilst looking after children. It's not fair to others and will be spotted soon.

Peony654 · 21/08/2023 12:46

And you did say 'very young' children, assuming pre school, that is definitely not OK. Fair enough later primary or secondary where they entertain themselves. It's very unfair to the children as well