Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To question a colleague's childcare arrangements?

130 replies

Seaswimmingforthesoul · 21/08/2023 12:03

I'm a senior manager and my direct reports are able to work remotely but with an expectation that they work in the office at least 1 day per week.
I have a member of my team who is relatively new. So far she is very productive, and has settled in really well, the team really like her and I've been impressed with her output.
It's become increasingly obvious to me however that she has her 2 very young children at home with her whilst she's working, and she shares childcare with her partner who also works full time, but works shifts. She has directly told me this is the case this week. I've so far turned a blind eye to this as she is so productive, but I noticed last week she didn't work from the office at all, and I suspect this week will be similar from conversations we have had this morning.
I am very flexible with my team and very understanding about issues with childcare etc. However, this is directly against company policy, and from experience i know how incredibly hard it is to work from home with small children.
I'm really unsure what to do. I really don't think it's acceptable to be your child's main carer whilst also working full time.
Should I speak to her about it informally? Im not sure what can be done about it. She has told me outright they can't afford childcare, which I find surprising as her job is pretty well paid and their partner is in a good job too. Whilst i sympathise with the cost of childcare (i have DC of my own)I do feel that it's unreasonable to do childcare on company time.
What should I do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OnceAgainWithFeeling · 22/08/2023 21:45

There’s not a day goes by when I am not complimented for my common sense, by the way!

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 22/08/2023 21:45

eastiseastwestiswest · 22/08/2023 20:53

Why does @OnceAgainWithFeeling think they are able to so surely
Predict what is or isn't possible? When my flexible
Working request was rejected I was patronisingly informed they didn't think condensed hours would be possible whilst maintaining my mental health. They however had no response to how to maintain my mental health whilst working 4 days a week for reduced pay and being forced to travel 100s miles into the office.

HR "experts" are always so keen to inform everyone what it is that they need without any real common sense attached.

Why can't people fathom that this way of working might be the only way to maintain her mental health because without working flexibly or limiting childcare costs the other spinning plates may topple.

I won’t go into my personal experience of working 16 hour days 7 days a week in the NHS during the pandemic, but as I say, have dealt with this umpteen times since then. I have covered the legal issues across posts in this thread.

If your home is accepted as a workplace by your employer there are Health and Safety laws that apply. It means if your child has an accident whilst you are working from home the employer could potentially be found at least partially liable. It isn’t possible to be totally focused on work and small children simultaneously.

If the work is flexible and the employee gets up early to do half of it then works late to cover the rest to enable them to look after children during the day they could be in breach of WTD rest breaks (which cannot be opted out of and few exemptions exist in law). These exist to try and support well-being.

I’m mainly employed to keep the employer out of court, which is why I can’t turn a blind eye to this.

https://www.blackadders.co.uk/business-legal-news/2022/06/13/working-parents-working-from-home-what-should-employers-allow/

Working parents working from home: what should employers allow? - Business Legal News from Blackadders Solicitors

Working parents working from home: what should employers allow? . Read the latest business and legal news from Business Legal News from Blackadders Solicitors - commercial law experts.

https://www.blackadders.co.uk/business-legal-news/2022/06/13/working-parents-working-from-home-what-should-employers-allow/

eastiseastwestiswest · 22/08/2023 20:53

Why does @OnceAgainWithFeeling think they are able to so surely
Predict what is or isn't possible? When my flexible
Working request was rejected I was patronisingly informed they didn't think condensed hours would be possible whilst maintaining my mental health. They however had no response to how to maintain my mental health whilst working 4 days a week for reduced pay and being forced to travel 100s miles into the office.

HR "experts" are always so keen to inform everyone what it is that they need without any real common sense attached.

Why can't people fathom that this way of working might be the only way to maintain her mental health because without working flexibly or limiting childcare costs the other spinning plates may topple.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/08/2023 17:49

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 21/08/2023 12:06

HR Director here. You need to have the conversation. This isn’t okay and if you’ve policies forbidding it then she needs to be made aware of those.

It is absolutely not possible to work productively, look after young children and maintain your well-being all at the same time. You need to discuss this with her and give her a deadline to sort out proper childcare. (Have dealt with this umpteen times since Covid.)

This ^^

It may work for now if her productivity's okay, but being new there's a chance she's pulling out all the stops so you'll accept the arrangement despite the company's policies, only to do less and less (and you've already said she's not come into the office for even the minimal one day required)

Best IME to get it sorted now before the issue balloons - and also before others start expecting the same

rookiemere · 21/08/2023 17:18

Firstly unless someone has signed a wfh contract then their employers are allowed to require them to come into the office. We are being asked to come in 2 days a week from September- I already do it - and honestly from the fuss some people are making, I they forget that pre covid it was the norm to be in 4-5 days per week

On the childcare thing, it's a toughie if she's getting through the work and as people have said it's different if it's older DCs for a few days over the school holidays than if it's constant with a preschooler. I personally don't like it - I paid for a CM when my DS was young so that he was appropriately cared for and I could work - but I appreciate times have changed.
I do think you need to advise her on company policy and if that's not to be looking after DCs whilst working that's what it is. I'd not make a big deal of it, but I would let her know.

Boomboom22 · 21/08/2023 17:02

They really should be able to though.
What a horrendous attitude that someone should have to pick up others slack because they are basically incompetent. No way if you meet your targets and beyond doing 75% hrs and some slacker does not meet theirs should you take on their work without a pay rise. That is not a reasonable adjustment it is taking the utter piss out of the good higher skilled worker.

Comefromaway · 21/08/2023 15:13

Those talking about equality and equity just don't get it. Employment tribunals often refer to things that have become "custom & practice", you can't make exceptions for one person and then not do the same for another without potential discrimination.

Eg. x is a parent so we will allow this but y is also a parent but we won't allow the same. (very simplistic but it's what you have to think.)

a has a disability so we will allow this because she is a good worker but B has the same disability but we won't allow the same because we don't think they are as good a worker.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 21/08/2023 15:04

Teateaandmoretea · 21/08/2023 14:54

I do think it’s childish.

You got lots they didn’t, quality time to spend with your DC. Bizarre you resent that.

Huh? No I didn’t - I don’t have DC! And I get time off because I took a pay cut to work fewer hours. They get to work the same reduced hours but not take a pay cut. Why wouldn’t I resent that?!

AnneAnon · 21/08/2023 15:02

Teateaandmoretea · 21/08/2023 14:27

What does that have to do with anything? If both parents work the same hours they will need more childcare than parents who work different hours. They could be getting paid more/ have accrued more holiday.

This as always is a completely disingenuous debate, centred on the poor employer and the welfare of children when the main driver is the green eyed monster. Life isn’t fair, most people discover that by the age of about 10.

Lol tell me you’re not a manager without telling me you’re not a manager.

I don’t think anyone is suggesting that parents who work different hours would need less childcare. I don’t think anyone is suggesting she should pay for childcare if her husband is not working and is watching them, and she just happens to be in the house. No one is having any issue with that.

The issue is when people claim to be working full time with young children at home, who they are solely responsible for.

Teateaandmoretea · 21/08/2023 14:54

fitzwilliamdarcy · 21/08/2023 14:36

To right I’m jealous @Teateaandmoretea - I had to go part time and take a pay cut to reduce my hours. Yet several of my colleagues are working below their contracted hours because they’re wfh with young children, yet still being paid full time.

Management are spineless and “turning a blind eye” to be nice and family friendly. Damn right it isn’t fair - and I don’t think it’s remotely childish that I feel annoyed about it.

I do think it’s childish.

You got lots they didn’t, quality time to spend with your DC. Bizarre you resent that.

Frabbits · 21/08/2023 14:38

AnneAnon · 21/08/2023 14:15

I don’t disagree in principle that policies should be reviewed where they don’t work, and also a lot depends on the age/abilities of the children involved, but there is no way a company is going to agree to have a policy that allows people to have small children at home while they are working. It’s completely irresponsible.

I tried to work full time during lockdown with two preschoolers at home. It is not a sustainable way of working. It is torture. No one is benefitting from that.

I am based at home, but I go into the office twice a week because there are significant benefits to the team in us getting together in person sometimes. It’s good for the trainees in particular and that’s important to us. The company recognises the benefits of this and have made a business decision to “encourage” attendance once or twice a week with the rest of your team. That’s their call. it’s unfair to exempt people from a requirement to come into the office because they have their kids at home and it doesn’t work for them. Childcare is not the company’s problem.

And yeah they’re free to leave but I think you’d be fairly hard pushed to find many employers who aren’t moving in the direction of some mandatory time in the office. One day a week isn’t exactly a big ask.

There's obviously a big difference between preschoolers who can't really look after themselves for any length of time, and kids in primary school past the age of about 7 or 8.

I don't see the harm in a kid getting in from school at say 3.30 and having to occupy themselves for an hour or 2 while a parent works, if they aren't distubing the parent. I mean, they will doubtless be left to their own devices for other reasons during the week and weekend anyway, so why is work so special?

fitzwilliamdarcy · 21/08/2023 14:36

To right I’m jealous @Teateaandmoretea - I had to go part time and take a pay cut to reduce my hours. Yet several of my colleagues are working below their contracted hours because they’re wfh with young children, yet still being paid full time.

Management are spineless and “turning a blind eye” to be nice and family friendly. Damn right it isn’t fair - and I don’t think it’s remotely childish that I feel annoyed about it.

Mainly · 21/08/2023 14:33

Both my partner and I go out to work and pay a small fortune in nursery fees for 2 due to it, so good on her.
I find requirements to be in the office however many days per week for a job that can be done from home ridiculous. She's very productive at home, what difference is there going into the office?
I have a friend whose WFH job is changing to "2 days a week in the office" shortly. No reason, and he finds it more distracting in a busy office. Him and many of his colleagues are now applying for the majority of jobs with similar companies that are completely WFH.

CharlotteBog · 21/08/2023 14:33

I'd be concerned if senior management in my work needed to ask MN for advice!

Agree. Imagine if you spotted your own manager discussing your work on MN!

Teateaandmoretea · 21/08/2023 14:27

AnneAnon · 21/08/2023 13:41

And if you were a colleague of hers who was paying for childcare? How do you think you’d feel about that?

What does that have to do with anything? If both parents work the same hours they will need more childcare than parents who work different hours. They could be getting paid more/ have accrued more holiday.

This as always is a completely disingenuous debate, centred on the poor employer and the welfare of children when the main driver is the green eyed monster. Life isn’t fair, most people discover that by the age of about 10.

Curtains70 · 21/08/2023 14:25

I thought you were going to say a colleague who you work with was doing this so then I'd say stay out of it and management will deal with it.

However you say you're senior management so surely you have experience in dealing with difficult conversions and HR policies to follow for such situations?

I'd be concerned if senior management in my work needed to ask MN for advice!

AnneAnon · 21/08/2023 14:15

Frabbits · 21/08/2023 13:50

Then the correct course of action by a decent company is to review policies that clearly aren't working.

If there is no need for people to be in the office x days a week, review the policy, don't just blindly enforce it.

If people have kids old enough to occupy themselves while someone is at work, then review any policy forbidding it, don't just blindly enforce it.

Otherwise, employees will just go to companies that do have a grown up approach.

I don’t disagree in principle that policies should be reviewed where they don’t work, and also a lot depends on the age/abilities of the children involved, but there is no way a company is going to agree to have a policy that allows people to have small children at home while they are working. It’s completely irresponsible.

I tried to work full time during lockdown with two preschoolers at home. It is not a sustainable way of working. It is torture. No one is benefitting from that.

I am based at home, but I go into the office twice a week because there are significant benefits to the team in us getting together in person sometimes. It’s good for the trainees in particular and that’s important to us. The company recognises the benefits of this and have made a business decision to “encourage” attendance once or twice a week with the rest of your team. That’s their call. it’s unfair to exempt people from a requirement to come into the office because they have their kids at home and it doesn’t work for them. Childcare is not the company’s problem.

And yeah they’re free to leave but I think you’d be fairly hard pushed to find many employers who aren’t moving in the direction of some mandatory time in the office. One day a week isn’t exactly a big ask.

Frabbits · 21/08/2023 13:50

ProfessorSlocombe · 21/08/2023 13:15

My company has such a policy, and it means that often times people are in offices literally by themselves on say a Friday

I trust there is a sound lone worker policy in place ?

🙄

Yes.

Frabbits · 21/08/2023 13:50

AnneAnon · 21/08/2023 13:41

And if you were a colleague of hers who was paying for childcare? How do you think you’d feel about that?

Then the correct course of action by a decent company is to review policies that clearly aren't working.

If there is no need for people to be in the office x days a week, review the policy, don't just blindly enforce it.

If people have kids old enough to occupy themselves while someone is at work, then review any policy forbidding it, don't just blindly enforce it.

Otherwise, employees will just go to companies that do have a grown up approach.

AnneAnon · 21/08/2023 13:41

Hankunamatata · 21/08/2023 13:26

I'm not a fan bit if she is being productive and good output then up to her. I would be reminding her she needs to be in the office one day a week

And if you were a colleague of hers who was paying for childcare? How do you think you’d feel about that?

Hankunamatata · 21/08/2023 13:26

I'm not a fan bit if she is being productive and good output then up to her. I would be reminding her she needs to be in the office one day a week

redskytwonight · 21/08/2023 13:24

Teateaandmoretea · 21/08/2023 13:04

And there are a lot of people who impress no one because they just aren't particularly strong at the job that they do and their output/ delivery is on the line of whether they are competent or not. Maybe you're one of those.

Sorry to disappoint you - actually I'm doing 2 people's work partly to pick up the slack of others (recognised by my management) and partly because I have knowledge and experience that others don't.

Maybe that's why I think others should actually pull their weight?

ProfessorSlocombe · 21/08/2023 13:15

My company has such a policy, and it means that often times people are in offices literally by themselves on say a Friday

I trust there is a sound lone worker policy in place ?

drpet49 · 21/08/2023 13:14

Heyisforhorses · 21/08/2023 12:12

Address it before it's noticed in your team. Childcare shouldn't be the problem of the company when it has a policy. We had one member of our team give up childcare when wfh came into play and while her work was done, the damage the resentment did with the rest of us was irreversible as the manager just didn't want to deal with it. Sort it now or risk losing the respect of your team.

This. Then you’ll get in trouble for allowing it against company policy and favouring and giving special treatment to 1 employee.

She has some front on her- starting a
new job and already taking the piss.

theemmadilemma · 21/08/2023 13:14

The people all over this thread telling OP to make an exception for one person because they aren't under performing have clearly never managed a team.

It's simply not that simple people!!