Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this parent is setting her daughter up to fail

217 replies

Anonoteacher · 15/06/2023 22:33

I teach in a large all girls secondary school. This is about a year 7 pupil who has no additional needs or medical issues of any kind.
Her mother is a nurse and regularly writes in her planner that she will be staying in her uniform and not getting changed for pe due to “personal female issues”
I think this is such an odd thing for a female nurse to write to a female teacher at a large school for girls.
For one, why are we phrasing it like this continually?
and for two, why are we teaching girls to opt out of sport every time they get a period. Is this normal?
I think the child will end up lacking in resilience as none of the other parents do this and all of the girls have periods.
Would you do this regularly for your daughter?

OP posts:
Glitterblue · 16/06/2023 09:28

It could be for any reason. I remember being so completely miserable every PE lesson because as well as hating PE with a passion, we all had to have showers, from the age of 9 to 13, we had to hang our towels up on pegs where we were getting changed and go naked to and from the shower - and the PE teacher also showered with us 🙈 It was absolute torture and wrong on so many levels. I doubt they’d do that now but even just getting changed in a communal changing room would be horrific for many girls, including my daughter. Thankfully they go to school in their PE kit on PE days because I know we’d have a lot of issues otherwise.

SockGoddess · 16/06/2023 09:32

It would be 10 years after school that I wanted to try any type of fitness activity.

Yes I relate to that too, it was over 10 years for me. I walked, cycled and went swimming, but I wouldn’t go near organised classes. When I finally did, when a friend invited me to go to yoga with her, I really had to psych myself up to go in the changing area with everyone else as the memories of bullying in that context really got to me.

It’s one of these things where schools will bend over backwards to shout about inclusion and well being blah blah blah but somehow not see kids suffering right in front of them and think about how they could change things to help those who dread PE to feel better and get exercise without the stress. It’s extra hard for girls dealing with periods, but it badly affects awkward, non-sporty boys as well.

SockGoddess · 16/06/2023 09:37

i do think many PE teachers are bullies, I certainly encountered plenty in my own school years. If you become a PE teacher I’m guessing you probably weren’t the shy, sensitive, non-sporty or ND kid yourself, and that may be why they often have no tolerance for kids who don’t like PE.

But in their defence, they shouldn’t all be tarred with the same brush. Despite hating PE, my DD does love one of her PE teachers who is one of the few teachers she can talk to and who she feels cares about her.

JudgeJ · 16/06/2023 09:39

GottaGirlcrush · 15/06/2023 22:35

Probably not but then I wouldn't be slagging off pupils parents online either!

Oh yes, let's stick to teacher slagging shall we?

SockGoddess · 16/06/2023 09:47

People wouldn’t moan about teachers if they didn’t have experience of cruel, stupid or uncaring teachers. Most people do, and especially so for PE teachers. At the same time most people have lovely memories of nice teachers and are grateful to those teachers who are nice to their kids. They’re not a sacred caste. We can talk about the bad ones.

PE teachers being unsympathetic or even cruel, humiliating kids who aren’t good at sport, or being clueless about why not everyone loves PE, is a large contributing factor to the problem of many kids hating PE. It doesn’t mean they’re all like that but it is common enough that most people have experienced it. Are you saying that must not be mentioned? Why?

carduelis · 16/06/2023 10:16

SockGoddess · 16/06/2023 09:37

i do think many PE teachers are bullies, I certainly encountered plenty in my own school years. If you become a PE teacher I’m guessing you probably weren’t the shy, sensitive, non-sporty or ND kid yourself, and that may be why they often have no tolerance for kids who don’t like PE.

But in their defence, they shouldn’t all be tarred with the same brush. Despite hating PE, my DD does love one of her PE teachers who is one of the few teachers she can talk to and who she feels cares about her.

I read a thread on Twitter once that was started by someone who was training to become a PE teacher. She said she recognised how many adults grew up hating exercise because they’d had such an awful experience of PE and she wanted to know what she could do to make sure that didn’t happen. More PE teachers need to think like this - at least there’s one good one out there somewhere!

carduelis · 16/06/2023 10:22

SockGoddess · 16/06/2023 09:47

People wouldn’t moan about teachers if they didn’t have experience of cruel, stupid or uncaring teachers. Most people do, and especially so for PE teachers. At the same time most people have lovely memories of nice teachers and are grateful to those teachers who are nice to their kids. They’re not a sacred caste. We can talk about the bad ones.

PE teachers being unsympathetic or even cruel, humiliating kids who aren’t good at sport, or being clueless about why not everyone loves PE, is a large contributing factor to the problem of many kids hating PE. It doesn’t mean they’re all like that but it is common enough that most people have experienced it. Are you saying that must not be mentioned? Why?

This just highlights the paradox that teachers are massively influential (for better or worse) yet teaching is seen as a low-status job. A good or bad teacher can affect a child’s perception of a subject for life but it’s thought of as a menial job that people do if they can’t do anything else (“those who can’t, teach”). I can’t help thinking if it were better paid, better respected, and had better conditions (ie teachers weren’t expected to do 5000 other things a day on top of actually teaching), it might attract and retain more of the sort of people who could genuinely have a really positive effect on the people they teach.

BrunchMonster · 16/06/2023 10:35

Whatelsecouldibecalled · 16/06/2023 08:29

@BrunchMonster I do get that some people have it very bad. Myself included. As a young women they were even worse.

I'm just saying how do you navigate that. You get a note from child A mum saying A needs to be excused from PE due to period. Child B questions why she can't sit out too if child A is. Can teachers tell child B child A private information? Or not? Will child B let it go? Child B now refusing to take part 'cos child A doesn't have to' is child B punished or accepted that it's appropriate to choose to opt out. Teacher now picking on Child B? Whilst this is happening what's happening with the other 28 girls who may or may not be on their period?

Raging angry parent ringing from child B teacher 'forcing them to do PE'. Raging angry email from Child A mum that 'teacher shamed DD by announcing period to other child and discussing her personal information'

If child A is in so much pain and discomfort should they be in school at all?

Should heads be hauling female staff over the coals re sickness related to menstruation? Should there be a seperate policy? When policies dictate 2 day absence allowed in 12 month rolling term (with Fridays and Mondays doubled weighted)

You can manage it in the same way as any other personal information. Children might get told Child A is ill, that's all they need to know unless Child A tells them more. If other girls are that badly affected, they could also get notes on the appropriate days. It was usually reasonably obvious by looking at me that I was somewhat unwell. It doesn't mean I couldn't sometimes be in school for part of the time, but was too weak to do PE ,for example, or more likely to faint. Yes, often I did have to miss school or get sent home. If other children are also badly affected, they can also get medical notes from parents or doctors.

No, I don't think heads should be hauling anyone over the coals for sickness related absence - that seems a strange policy for anyone. Why would they? If people are ill, for a morning or an afternoon or two days, they are ill. It doesn't always happen every month, and not to everyone.

Telling people it's 'not allowed' isn't going to change the fact that some people get badly affected. You sound like you really think people are trying it on, but accommodating girls who are ill isn't going to change whether others do or not. If they aren't accommodated, they may have to just miss the whole day of school, which is surely worse.

Whenwillitallmakesense · 16/06/2023 10:58

Wow, 9 pages and OP still didn't return yet the debate still rages on

OhForFucksFuckingSake · 16/06/2023 10:59

LifeIsPainHighness · 15/06/2023 22:36

God I wish my mum had done this.

People who don’t understand what’s it’s like to hate PE with a passion and find it painful and extremely exhausting, both physically and mentally, will never get it - and it’s especially bad when you’re on your period or have one boob growing bigger than the other and have to share a changing room with girls.

I wish schools would stop acting like PE is the be all and bloody end all. Most kids don’t bother with sports after age 16, and it’s one of those things that as a child, if you’re not good at it you’re unlikely to get better. Exercise is important but not to the point that it should be carried out at the expense of pain and discomfort.

I suspect I’ll be in the minority there though.

I agree.

OP I can understand you being a bit WTF at a nurse using such twee language to describe what you're assuming is a period. But perhaps she writes it that way because her daughter is embarrassed for you to know that's specifically why.

PE is mortifying at that age. I'd started my periods by year 7 but not everyone else had. I couldn't use tampons so had these bulky sanitary pads, my flow was all over the place so I never knew what would be a heavy day or a light day. Trying to get changed in front of a room full of peers - some of whom may be your bullies, or girls you just don't get in with that well - when your body is going through puberty is extremely uncomfortable. Especially with a pad sticking out your knickers and then being eyeballed as some medical curiosity but the girls who hadn't yet started their periods or started to get breasts.

Also we weren't allowed to wear leggings or jogging bottoms. We had to wear gym knickers and tiny skirts, so everyone could see your arse and if you leaked it would be obvious.

I used to pull every trick in the book to get out of PE because of the hell of the changing room experience. What's sad is that I was actually quite sporty. What stopped me from excelling was not squeamishness about periods or prudishness about language. It was the school not understanding or being empathetic to how difficult the experience was for girls that age.

So many more girls would be able to access sports at school if there was guaranteed privacy when changing and they could wear shorts or joggers. Those two things would make so much difference. I don't know why schools don't sort it out if they're as bothered as they say they are.

carduelis · 16/06/2023 11:01

Also, given many schools send kids home or put them in isolation for days at a time for having bows on their shoes/hair 1mm too short/grey rather than black socks, you would think missing a PE lesson due to an actual physical problem wouldn’t be that big a deal…

Catsmere · 16/06/2023 12:56

carduelis · 16/06/2023 08:54

There was a thread on here recently about letting a very anxious child miss sports day and lots of the replies insisted this child would never develop any resilience and would go through life thinking they never had to do anything they didn’t want to so it would appear that yes, missing a few PE lessons does indeed equate to total life failure.

You’d think from MN that participation in school sports was the single biggest determiner of character and predictor of future success - rather than just, you know, putting people off exercise for life, which it did for me.

It did that to me, too!

Some of the attitudes about it sound like they’re out of the sort of Girls’ Adventure Stories written in the 1920s and 30s, where the main character is a jolly sporty type and hockey whizz (or aspires to be) at a boarding school.

JazbayGrapes · 16/06/2023 13:33

Also, given many schools send kids home or put them in isolation for days at a time for having bows on their shoes/hair 1mm too short/grey rather than black socks, you would think missing a PE lesson due to an actual physical problem wouldn’t be that big a deal…

This.
Also school PE and sports are largely overrated in regard to future fitness.
Teachers really need to get over themselves.

Fiddlefall · 16/06/2023 14:01

LifeIsPainHighness · 16/06/2023 07:26

How does it ‘give women a bad name’? I’m genuinely confused - are women on periods a bad thing??

Reading the quote might help, as well as not fixating on a single line of an entire chunk I wrote largely caveating and disputing the opening line.

afterdropshock · 16/06/2023 14:07

Are you sure it is the mother writing it and not the girl? Seems strange in this day and age, I'd have thought she would email and explain. Why don't you phone her?

carduelis · 16/06/2023 14:52

Catsmere · 16/06/2023 12:56

It did that to me, too!

Some of the attitudes about it sound like they’re out of the sort of Girls’ Adventure Stories written in the 1920s and 30s, where the main character is a jolly sporty type and hockey whizz (or aspires to be) at a boarding school.

It’s worse than that though, it’s this insistence that making kids do things that seriously distress them when those things don’t have to be done is somehow good for them. It’s tossing the word “resilience” around when really we mean “making kids put up with stuff they shouldn’t really have to put up with for the sake of it” . It‘s the idea that letting them miss one thing they are truly desperate to avoid will automatically mean they will be unable to cope with anything remotely difficult or distasteful for their entire lives. Perhaps I have an unusually poor grasp of human psychology, but I just cannot see any benefit in making kids suffer needlessly.

Catsmere · 16/06/2023 22:18

@carduelis well said.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread