Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this parent is setting her daughter up to fail

217 replies

Anonoteacher · 15/06/2023 22:33

I teach in a large all girls secondary school. This is about a year 7 pupil who has no additional needs or medical issues of any kind.
Her mother is a nurse and regularly writes in her planner that she will be staying in her uniform and not getting changed for pe due to “personal female issues”
I think this is such an odd thing for a female nurse to write to a female teacher at a large school for girls.
For one, why are we phrasing it like this continually?
and for two, why are we teaching girls to opt out of sport every time they get a period. Is this normal?
I think the child will end up lacking in resilience as none of the other parents do this and all of the girls have periods.
Would you do this regularly for your daughter?

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 16/06/2023 04:14

Investigate the sports uniform. It needs to change to dark pants/shorts and be long enough in the leg and with an over skirt to allow for bulky pads to leak and not be seen.
Instigate a forum to seek ideas from the students and you be a mover and a shaker.
Promptly make changes at your school to assist the girls' comfort during P.E.

LAMPS1 · 16/06/2023 05:06

OP, sorry I have more questions than answers for your AIBU. But yes, for my daughter, I would do everything I could to help her feel comfortable enough to take part and access the curriculum.

You don’t say if this student is taking part in the PE lesson or not ? Is she simply shying away from getting changed or is she a PE refuser generally?
Neither do you mention if you are the PE teacher or the form teacher or Head of Year ?
Is this note used every single PE lesson or once a month or on a more irregular basis ?

Yes, as her mum I would recognise that sport and exercise is important for her healthy life-style of course, but I’m sure that you as a teacher know it’s not as simple as that. Ruling out SEN and medical issues (that you know about) is just the tip of the iceberg. There are many very real reasons why teen girls shy away from the changing room and taking part in PE lessons. Each and every girl, even in an all girls school, is unique and their problems in puberty can be completely debilitating.
It is a very complex subject which Early Career Teachers of PE are taught to recognise and address with understanding and complete confidentiality as professionals.

As her mum I would hope that the teacher would to try to discreetly understand how my daughter could be helped to take part more comfortably. Maybe you have already done this.

Maireas · 16/06/2023 05:12

LifeIsPainHighness · 15/06/2023 22:36

God I wish my mum had done this.

People who don’t understand what’s it’s like to hate PE with a passion and find it painful and extremely exhausting, both physically and mentally, will never get it - and it’s especially bad when you’re on your period or have one boob growing bigger than the other and have to share a changing room with girls.

I wish schools would stop acting like PE is the be all and bloody end all. Most kids don’t bother with sports after age 16, and it’s one of those things that as a child, if you’re not good at it you’re unlikely to get better. Exercise is important but not to the point that it should be carried out at the expense of pain and discomfort.

I suspect I’ll be in the minority there though.

I think you're right, but we're probably in the minority!

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 16/06/2023 05:22

BreehyHinnyBrinnyHoohyHah · 15/06/2023 22:50

I wish we would do more of this, and acknowledge that for some girls periods are utterly shit and the last thing you want to do is play fecking netball in a pair of gym knickers. I would be up half the night with period pain and often doubled over. I would have loved to have had an understanding parent like this!

Precisely.
I used to feel dizzy, cold, shake-y, couldn't sleep from the pain and sometimes vomited.

And I really wish teachers understood that.

I still remember trying to explain that I couldn't take a test in first period but felt good enough to attend class 3 hours later (my mum luckily wrote me a note for that one. I don't think my teacher believed me. But it is what it is...)

Fiddlefall · 16/06/2023 05:22

Nicecow · 16/06/2023 02:58

I find it ironic that women want to feel empowered and be treated equal, yet also would be happy to use their period as an excuse not to do PE (sure if you are in pain, but many posters here would simply use it as an excuse because they don't like it).

I agree with you that it gives women a bad name. That said, that's based on the premise that we have to justify ourselves to men, which realistically we do in today's context.

Don't want to open a whole can of worms but it's been said that if men had periods, there'd be lots more understanding/exceptions, which I think is true.

Studies (eg with pain simulating devices) show that what many women consider mere period discomfort = what men consider pain.

Re equality – if men had periods (assuming the same gender hierarchy as today, or at least over the past few centuries) men wouldn't be considered inferior to women just because they needed/wanted accommodations for their period discomfort (not necessarily the threshold of extreme pain). It would probably be a badge of honour, in the same way many things associated with masculinity are.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 16/06/2023 05:31

Fiddlefall · 16/06/2023 05:22

I agree with you that it gives women a bad name. That said, that's based on the premise that we have to justify ourselves to men, which realistically we do in today's context.

Don't want to open a whole can of worms but it's been said that if men had periods, there'd be lots more understanding/exceptions, which I think is true.

Studies (eg with pain simulating devices) show that what many women consider mere period discomfort = what men consider pain.

Re equality – if men had periods (assuming the same gender hierarchy as today, or at least over the past few centuries) men wouldn't be considered inferior to women just because they needed/wanted accommodations for their period discomfort (not necessarily the threshold of extreme pain). It would probably be a badge of honour, in the same way many things associated with masculinity are.

The 'women' that use their periods to get out of PE are usually young teenagers/older kids.

many kids/teenagers will use any and all reasons to get out of activities they find annoying / unpleasant etc.

especially school related ones.

I find it a bit OTT to say that this gives women a bad name.

Bur I definitely agree with the rest of cour comment. It's spot on!

And if men/teenage boys could get out of PE because of periods?

Yes, I do believe that quite a few would....

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/06/2023 05:50

I hated PE apart from the multi gym, which arrived in an HGV for several months the last year or two of school. I never liked any team sports so badminton was another one I quite liked.

My dd otoh is very sporty and has picked GCSE PE; I can therefore see both sides of it. Dd changed from state to private after 2 years of secondary. She actually messed around in PE at her state school and showed zero aptitude for sport. but at private, she takes it really seriously. At parents evening the state school PE teacher was shocked that dd is so sporty. It was like she was talking about a different child and dd ended up being placed in bottom set in state school for year 9 (she didn’t complete the year as she switched schools).

PE isn’t a nothing subject contrary to some of the comments. However, students need to be encouraged to engage positively for themselves and each other as it can be good for mental health. DD’s PE teachers at her current school boost the kids and dd’s friends, even the non sporty ones seem to enjoy some aspects of PE at her private school. Not so at all at the state school she left. Even dd doesn’t like every sport either.

As for the girl not doing sport regularly, I would say this would be the time to contact the mum to ask if there are any adjustments you or the school could make to help her participate.

If not, do please believe that periods can be that bad. Mine were and as soon as I went to 6th form I could leave to go home and rest. They got better, or maybe I managed them better as I got older. Probably the latter as my issues and pain were also largely ignored at home.

From this thread, it appears PE is much maligned by many, for the most part for how we were treated at school. Is there any scope to not always be just doing the particular sport but also to act pastorally, to engender cooperation and to take time during the sessions to talk, do team building tasks etc? I know the pressure is on for GCSE PE years. However, there are 3 years prior to this to encourage everyone to want to participate.

JaninaDuszejko · 16/06/2023 06:03

Angrymum22 · 15/06/2023 23:01

And to anyone saying this is none of the teachers business, there are current threads on MN criticising social workers and other responsible adults for not acting sooner in the case of the young boy killed by his mum and her boyfriend.
Damned if they stick their noses in and damned if they don’t.

She's not following any reporting guidelines though, she's gossiping about it on Mumsnet. Nobody would be criticising her if she spoke to her safeguarding lead. But she's not going to speak to a safeguarding lead because she doesn't think there's a safeguarding issue, she's come on MN to slag off a parent for using overly prissy language.

GeorgeMichaelsCat · 16/06/2023 06:05

SlippySarah · 16/06/2023 01:18

I've never met a PE teacher that behaved like a reasonable human being. OP is just another shit PE teacher to add to the list.

My experience as well.

SofiaAmes · 16/06/2023 06:15

Wow, just wow. We are in 2023 and you are actually questioning whether a child is going to fail in life because she isn't getting changed for PE. Do you really have so little imagination or ability to recognize that getting changed for PE is in no way shape or form a good/recognized/valid criteria for judging a child's likelihood to succeed? Never mind the hundreds of good valid reasons why a mother would support her child in that accommodation.

And anyway, how could you possibly know whether the child had any "additional needs or medical issues."

My child couldn't do PE when she had her period...She had an extremely valid medical reason which was none of her teacher's damn business. But despite her being an excellent, well behaved student, her stupid teacher wouldn't take my word for it, so I had to take her out of school for a whole day to get a medical professional to write a letter saying that she couldn't do it. And no, the actual condition was NOT part of that letter. None of the teacher's damn business. And despite that...she is a successful university student working a part time job that involves more physical labor than a decade worth of PE classes. But since she's working a real job, labor laws prevent her boss from asking her why she needs extra breaks.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 16/06/2023 06:17

If PE is still as shit as it was when I was at school, I don't blame her.

Tiktaktoo · 16/06/2023 06:20

I think it’s really unprofessional of you to post this here. You’re a teacher, you must come across this sort of thing all the time. It’s par for the course.

Dayofrain · 16/06/2023 06:26

Very unprofessional putting this on Mumsnet really. Are you actually the PE teacher or just the girls form tutor? There may be much more to this than you realise, if you have genuine concerns use your time to raise them with the PE dept.
Wish my mum had done this for me too. PE made me hate school. I bled through my gym knickers once.

Kidsandcat · 16/06/2023 06:41

The first 2 days of my period is a nightmare with flooding and pain. I go to work on those days but wouldn't go to gym or swim so it makes sense to me.

Zanatdy · 16/06/2023 06:41

Surprised the school allow it as my DD doesn’t do PE as her health isn’t great after her first period led to a blood transfusion and low energy and dizzyness ongoing for years. They’ve been funny with her even though she’s got blood tests to show it. At the end of the day don’t see why she’s being set up to fail as if she didn’t want to go to the gym as an adult when on her period no-one is going to force her are they?

HerbsandSpices · 16/06/2023 06:46

Sport is important. The only thing I learned in PE class was that I hate sports and aren't good at it. It took me many years after leaving school to relearn that I did actually like some sports and were good at those. So many wasted years I could have been enjoying those sports and deriving the benefits, if only school had helped me explore appropriate sports for me. We're not all suited for field athletics and ball games.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 16/06/2023 06:46

What would be helpful is for schools to teach more about the importance of exercise for general physical and mental health. Try to inspire a love of exercise as part of life rather than instilling an ingrained fear. Schools should open up different forms of exercise to those that do not want to play team sports such as football, hockey or netball etc. Offer yoga, gym sessions, fitness classes using dance, swimming walking, running, cycling etc. Make it a time each week where everyone has their time to enjoy their chosen activity.

Bananarepublic · 16/06/2023 06:47

I do think it's important to do exercise but there should be a range of different options, not just traditional sports. Not everyone wants to do those. Things like dance or yoga should also be offered to girls and they may be more keen to do these even with their periods.

CoreyTaylorsSoggyTshirt · 16/06/2023 06:48

I pulled one of my dc out of PE entirely at school, basically due to mental health reasons.

They used the time to study in the library, and were active enough outside of school.

They have just finished doing their first degree through college, and are off to university to get the second, just passed their driving test, have worked 2 jobs for the duration of doing their degree, does volunteer work once a week and is just basically an all round good kid... I don't think I set my kid up to fail, I think I supported them in what they needed so they didn't have that particular stress through school, which has helped immensely.

Bananarepublic · 16/06/2023 06:48

And I say that as someone who loved all the traditional sports. Except in the summer as my body wouldn't just jump high or long or chuck a heavy discus or shotput.

Fairymother · 16/06/2023 06:53

Maybe she gets them very strongly and suffers? I didnt like swimming in school. In fact i just didnt like swimming. My mum signed me off sick because of period every week.
It didnt set me up to fail. I like swimming now and i learnt it outside of school.
They will have their reasons and you shouldnt judge them for it.

SallyWD · 16/06/2023 06:56

LifeIsPainHighness · 15/06/2023 22:36

God I wish my mum had done this.

People who don’t understand what’s it’s like to hate PE with a passion and find it painful and extremely exhausting, both physically and mentally, will never get it - and it’s especially bad when you’re on your period or have one boob growing bigger than the other and have to share a changing room with girls.

I wish schools would stop acting like PE is the be all and bloody end all. Most kids don’t bother with sports after age 16, and it’s one of those things that as a child, if you’re not good at it you’re unlikely to get better. Exercise is important but not to the point that it should be carried out at the expense of pain and discomfort.

I suspect I’ll be in the minority there though.

Same experience for me. I used to feel sick with dread the day before PE. I used to forge notes to get out of it (which of course I got in to trouble for). No one seems to understand what an ordeal it is for some children.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 16/06/2023 06:59

I admit to writing myself notes when the PE teacher wanted us to run around a muddy field on a freezing January morning wearing shorts and a tshirt while they sat wrapped up with a flask of hot chocolate Wink I don't believe that set me up for failure in fact it taught me that there was no way I would be pushed into doing things that were cruel and unnecessary.

Avondale89 · 16/06/2023 07:01

Setting her up to fail because she’s not taking part in PE? Is this a serious question? If it’s anything like my PE lessons were 20 years ago the pupil isn’t missing much. Blatant favouritism and nastiness from bullying teachers, being underdressed and shivering on a wet playground and it put me off exercise for years. I hope it has improved, but I don’t think high school PE is going to make or break anything in this girls life. You’ve confirmed the stereotype of PE teachers being judgmental and overly concerned with the importance of their lessons though.

x2boys · 16/06/2023 07:01

Perhaps if PE was more enjoyable and inclusive to all.,rather than just the sporty,kids ,kids wouldn't be looking for ways to get out of it?I
I hated PE at school
My 16 year old son,who leaves school today hard also always hated PE🙄