Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this parent is setting her daughter up to fail

217 replies

Anonoteacher · 15/06/2023 22:33

I teach in a large all girls secondary school. This is about a year 7 pupil who has no additional needs or medical issues of any kind.
Her mother is a nurse and regularly writes in her planner that she will be staying in her uniform and not getting changed for pe due to “personal female issues”
I think this is such an odd thing for a female nurse to write to a female teacher at a large school for girls.
For one, why are we phrasing it like this continually?
and for two, why are we teaching girls to opt out of sport every time they get a period. Is this normal?
I think the child will end up lacking in resilience as none of the other parents do this and all of the girls have periods.
Would you do this regularly for your daughter?

OP posts:
MrsMikeDrop · 16/06/2023 07:02

Bananarepublic · 16/06/2023 06:47

I do think it's important to do exercise but there should be a range of different options, not just traditional sports. Not everyone wants to do those. Things like dance or yoga should also be offered to girls and they may be more keen to do these even with their periods.

I like this. I hated PE so much, but equally I think it's quite lame to get a note to get out of it if you're not legitimately sick. I also think many people, including myself are not very fit so it would have been good to perhaps find something else to enjoy as I hated athletics (team sports I found fun).

BravoMyDear · 16/06/2023 07:04

This is incredibly unprofessional of you.

Avondale89 · 16/06/2023 07:04

SilverGlitterBaubles · 16/06/2023 06:46

What would be helpful is for schools to teach more about the importance of exercise for general physical and mental health. Try to inspire a love of exercise as part of life rather than instilling an ingrained fear. Schools should open up different forms of exercise to those that do not want to play team sports such as football, hockey or netball etc. Offer yoga, gym sessions, fitness classes using dance, swimming walking, running, cycling etc. Make it a time each week where everyone has their time to enjoy their chosen activity.

I completely agree. I love yoga, Pilates and the gym as an adult. Still despise hockey and netball. PE was just an hour of ritual humiliation for those of us with little to no hand eye coordination.

CornishAdventures · 16/06/2023 07:04

As an adult whose periods have become far less intense post having a child the last thing I want to do is exercise at that time of the month. Maybe some stretches or a walk maximum, definitely not exercise I don’t get a choice to choose when not feeling my best

For some women periods are so intense they can’t function properly and our NHS is so stretched that support is hard to get.

Perhaps there is information you are not aware of or perhaps this mum is supporting and respecting her daughter, teaching her daughter to take care of herself and her well-being

x2boys · 16/06/2023 07:05

Avondale89 · 16/06/2023 07:01

Setting her up to fail because she’s not taking part in PE? Is this a serious question? If it’s anything like my PE lessons were 20 years ago the pupil isn’t missing much. Blatant favouritism and nastiness from bullying teachers, being underdressed and shivering on a wet playground and it put me off exercise for years. I hope it has improved, but I don’t think high school PE is going to make or break anything in this girls life. You’ve confirmed the stereotype of PE teachers being judgmental and overly concerned with the importance of their lessons though.

Sadly not according to my son ,he hates it try always do football ,he's has no.interest in football 🙄
It's his last exam today so he leaves school today,thankfully the misery of PE,is over for him.

Brefugee · 16/06/2023 07:14

i have questions:
Where how do they change? she's young, I'm guessing she's using towels rather than tampons or a mooncup? what kind of sport? does she have pains or other awful feelings (bloating, sudden onset period poo?)
what do they wear for sport? or PE? are boys involved?

Stop being judgy and maybe speak to the mum?

CompletelyOverwhelmedAgain · 16/06/2023 07:14

LifeIsPainHighness · 15/06/2023 22:36

God I wish my mum had done this.

People who don’t understand what’s it’s like to hate PE with a passion and find it painful and extremely exhausting, both physically and mentally, will never get it - and it’s especially bad when you’re on your period or have one boob growing bigger than the other and have to share a changing room with girls.

I wish schools would stop acting like PE is the be all and bloody end all. Most kids don’t bother with sports after age 16, and it’s one of those things that as a child, if you’re not good at it you’re unlikely to get better. Exercise is important but not to the point that it should be carried out at the expense of pain and discomfort.

I suspect I’ll be in the minority there though.

I think a balance would be good - P.E. until 12ish then other forms of exercise available like walking / hiking.

Vast majority of P.E. when I was at school was standing around waiting for a 'turn' with limited equipment or messing around in the changing rooms...

MissingMoominMamma · 16/06/2023 07:15

LifeIsPainHighness · 16/06/2023 02:22

I agree and also there is IME an extra power imbalance with PE teachers because they have control over children when they’re at their physically weakest.

I never met a PE teacher who wasn’t a bully.
They also ALL sucked up to the sporty kids, the captains and vice captains whilst treating others with contempt - which IME is problematic because the captains and sporty kids were almost always the biggest bullies in the school. Who probably went on to teach PE themselves.

Im now at the point of looking at secondary school info for 10yo DD and some places round here happily report how they have 4 hours a week of PE - I think this should be cut in half and more focus on the arts. In which everyone can have a place…even if you can’t sing/dance/act/play an instrument there’s costume design, staging, lighting, runner work, script writing, research etc. The list is endless. I think we’d have much happier pupils in schools of focus shifted away from competitive sports and onto something much more inclusive.

Some kids need it though. We picked a school that had a sport heavy curriculum because my adhd DS needed it. He thrives where there is movement and a set of rules.

I needed lone sports when I was young (still do). I loved cross country, but couldn’t cope with anything where I had to interact with another person, or be part of a team. If cycling had been an option, I’d have been in my element.

Perhaps we should be giving kids more personal choice. Drama or sport, rather than cutting one for the other?

Noicant · 16/06/2023 07:20

My periods at that age were crippling and I flooded a lot. It was awful being at school and basically soaked in blood and in extreme pain. Just being physically present was a bit of an ask. i would never get a note though, I’d just suffer through. Doctor wasn’t much help. My Dad even gave me a whiskey with my hot water bottle (I was 13 and he doesn’t drink) to try to help at one point. Tbf the wording is a bit silly though, I’d be very direct about it if it was DD.

my period only improved after I had DD (late 30’s!).

JaninaDuszejko · 16/06/2023 07:21

BitterAndTwistedChoreDodger · 16/06/2023 02:25

This thread is a Dummy's guide to why teens and young women give up sport at an early age.

It is, isn't it. My DDs are both sporty so we've not had any issues (DD1 has period pain that makes her vomit but knows exercise helps and has played league games when she's had terrible pains before the game but the adrenaline takes over. She chooses to do that of course so different from school sport) but it's such a missed opportunity to get kids to think about building exercise into their day. The sporty kids are doing loads of competitive sport outside school (and in the teenage years they are very much about identifying and nurturing the elite sportspeople) so I think school PE should be concentrating on exposing the kids to lots of different forms of exercise in a way that allows all kids to participate. From what the DDs tell me there is some streaming in their PE lessons and they do some yoga and the dance videos you find on line as well as the more classic sports so their school is trying to do that.

If it was up to me (limitless budget obviously) an hour of exercise would be built into the school day but there would be a big emphasis on exposing the kids to lots of different options at different levels. Hard though because either you have the entire school doing exercise before or after school so that there are lots of options or it's timetabled into the normal day and there's an element of compulsion so the kids have to do things they don't like some of the time.

LifeIsPainHighness · 16/06/2023 07:22

changeme4this · 16/06/2023 03:48

I did it once for our DD when she was due to go to a compulsory school camp. She was a very heavy bleeder in her early years and wouldn't have been able to access a private toilet or shower had she needed to. In the meanwhile the (female) teacher taking the group completely ignored my letter explaining the circumstance.

On the flip side my GG used to write those letters for DM every week. She is now wheel chair bound due to lack of muscle support and her hospital have to use a substantial sling to move DM from her chair to toilet, shower chair etc.

So I can understand both points of view.

FGS your mum isn’t in a wheelchair because she skipped PE!

Simonlebonbon · 16/06/2023 07:25

Not setting her up to fail, setting her up to know she doesn't have to do something that causes her physical discomfort.

She could have endo.
She could have extreme anxiety.
She could have hypermobility.
She could struggle with getting unchanged due to her motor skills.
She could have 100 million reasons and when teachers post students problems online regardless of it being anonymous, you can still understand why mum keeps it vague.

If you suspect abuse, self harm, eating disorder etc, then go to safe guarding lead, if you think it's simply she isn't comfortable doing PE, then find her something else to do.

LifeIsPainHighness · 16/06/2023 07:25

I find it ironic that women want to feel empowered and be treated equal, yet also would be happy to use their period as an excuse not to do PE

@Nicecow im not sure you know what the word ‘equality’ means but it doesn’t apply here does it because boys don’t get periods. Ironically if they did they’d probably get sanctioned time off school - girls just have to put up with it.

CantBeArsedOrAsked · 16/06/2023 07:26

I always found PE a complete waste of time and would have loved my mother to have got me out of it somehow.
Getting changed into and out of gym clothes, and having to have a communal shower was humiliating. I was hopeless at games, the rules of hockey were incomprehensible to me and I was always the last to be picked for a team.

LifeIsPainHighness · 16/06/2023 07:26

Fiddlefall · 16/06/2023 05:22

I agree with you that it gives women a bad name. That said, that's based on the premise that we have to justify ourselves to men, which realistically we do in today's context.

Don't want to open a whole can of worms but it's been said that if men had periods, there'd be lots more understanding/exceptions, which I think is true.

Studies (eg with pain simulating devices) show that what many women consider mere period discomfort = what men consider pain.

Re equality – if men had periods (assuming the same gender hierarchy as today, or at least over the past few centuries) men wouldn't be considered inferior to women just because they needed/wanted accommodations for their period discomfort (not necessarily the threshold of extreme pain). It would probably be a badge of honour, in the same way many things associated with masculinity are.

How does it ‘give women a bad name’? I’m genuinely confused - are women on periods a bad thing??

Maireas · 16/06/2023 07:27

I had no excuse as a teenager. I just couldn't be arsed. Any sport bores me rigid and I'd rather have my teeth drilled than go to a gym. However, I'm very active and reasonably fit. I know many PE teachers are conscious of the issues and do their best, but if you lack confidence and feel self conscious it can be a nightmare.

CharChar91 · 16/06/2023 07:28

Without jumping to conclusions could there be anything she might need help with that she's not getting at home? Welfare support? Seeing a nurse? Safeguarding issue?

changeme4this · 16/06/2023 07:28

LifeIsPainHighness · 16/06/2023 07:22

FGS your mum isn’t in a wheelchair because she skipped PE!

She is in a wheelchair because she has continually failed to adhere to advice to take exercise.

don’t try to give advice where you have no expertise or knowledge!

CaptainMyCaptain · 16/06/2023 07:32

People are assuming the OP is the PE teacher. She says she 'works in a school ' she could be office staff receiving the note or a nosey TA who is not involved at all.

BrunchMonster · 16/06/2023 07:32

another one here with horrendous periods at that age, really awful, painful, could turn into vomiting and migraines, total aching in legs, couldn't have done PE at all.

And I'd have been embarrassed if my mum used the word 'period' with my teachers in a note, so could easily have asked her to write something else that seemed more subtle to me, even if it wasn't to the teacher!

ladydimitrescu · 16/06/2023 07:33

I started my Periods aged 9, and by the time I started secondary school I experienced flooding, fainting and dizziness and severe cramps. It was difficult enough to attend school some months, let alone do PE.
YAB massively unreasonable, have no idea of this girls circumstances, and are shockingly unprofessional slagging a student and her parent off online.

NatureNurture85 · 16/06/2023 07:34

I think we forget as women to treat each other kindly. This mother is doing what’s best for her daughter at that time. There is a great podcast by Mindy Pelz about your cycle and when’s best to do certain types of exercise. There is a lot to be said for nurturing your body through your period. Protecting your limited energy reserves. The start of your cycle is great for cardio/active exercises.

SockGoddess · 16/06/2023 07:34

My DD really struggles with school PE. The reasons are because she feels humiliated and embarrassed having to “perform” physically in front of others, she hates physical contact with people she doesn’t like/is scared of (with good reason), and making them do competitive sport makes her feel shown up. When it’s dance or fitness like yoga, she’s fine. She also is happy to go swimming, climb a hill etc even on her period. You can’t assume it’s about laziness or “using a period as an excuse”. Both in my own experience and my DCs’, it’s often because many PE teachers are unsympathetic and have little time for anyone who’s not good at competitive sport, and because schools don’t give those kids other options. I’d make PE multi-option so you could choose to join a dance lesson or hill walk group and kids could get exercise without having to compete under pressure.

Maireas · 16/06/2023 07:37

I think you're right, @SockGoddess because failing at PE is obvious, and it's humiliating. My classes can make mistakes in my lessons and it's only obvious to them and me. Plus it usually doesn't prevent a good outcome. PE is much more of a public performance. If you fail to catch a ball or kick a ball, it's obvious to all.

ilovesushi · 16/06/2023 07:37

Could the girl be writing the notes? I would always email the teacher not write in the planner.