Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this parent is setting her daughter up to fail

217 replies

Anonoteacher · 15/06/2023 22:33

I teach in a large all girls secondary school. This is about a year 7 pupil who has no additional needs or medical issues of any kind.
Her mother is a nurse and regularly writes in her planner that she will be staying in her uniform and not getting changed for pe due to “personal female issues”
I think this is such an odd thing for a female nurse to write to a female teacher at a large school for girls.
For one, why are we phrasing it like this continually?
and for two, why are we teaching girls to opt out of sport every time they get a period. Is this normal?
I think the child will end up lacking in resilience as none of the other parents do this and all of the girls have periods.
Would you do this regularly for your daughter?

OP posts:
Fiddlefall · 16/06/2023 00:51

I'm also quite taken aback by the arrogance of a teacher thinking they're more medically well-informed than a medical professional.

Dorrmouse · 16/06/2023 01:00

One of the happiest days of my life was when I no longer had to put up with jolly hockey stick PE types making me feel totally useless. I took extra GCSEs to get out of games, I loathed them, and the pompous battleaxe teachers, so much. How do you know this child has no medical issues? Are you privy to her entire medical history?

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 16/06/2023 01:10

I think the child will end up lacking in resilience as none of the other parents do this and all of the girls have periods.

Would you do this regularly for your daughter?

I did it regularly for one of mine.

She despised PE. She had horrible periods.

Far from teaching her a lack of resilience it taught her that prioritising (in this case preventing PE from making her feel so shit she missed maths, English or the likes) is not only acceptable, but advisable.

It also taught her that she was listened to and reasonable/well thought out points were considered and respected.

She was active. She was fit and a healthy weight. She took part in exercise out of school, but solo or with just one other person (playing squash for example) which fitted her introverted personality.

NumberTheory · 16/06/2023 01:12

I agree with you OP, that a period is not a good reason not to do PE as standard practice.

However, I think PE in schools has long history of treating students, especially girls, with nothing but contempt in the name of building character. And parents remember that from their time in school so I think great many of them are only too happy to provide their children with an excuse not to do it.

SlippySarah · 16/06/2023 01:18

I've never met a PE teacher that behaved like a reasonable human being. OP is just another shit PE teacher to add to the list.

Franknotfrancis · 16/06/2023 01:40

Catsmere · 16/06/2023 00:33

An impressive disaster at that, sitting smoking!

My PE teacher once tried to humiliate us into compliance by making anyone who’d “forgotten” her uniform (I say her because I don’t remember if any of the boys joined in) wear a black rubbish bag instead. Didn’t work, we thought it was funny. She was a moron who never grasped that asthmatics can’t just be sent to run around the oval, or that if you are short sighted and wearing glasses it’s fucking frightening to have a basketball thrown at your face (and glasses were made of actual glass back then) and jumping on the vaulting horse just isn’t going to happen.

It’s insane isn’t it. A black bin bag is literally abuse by proxy, it’s the old school Victorian method of shaming kids into compliance using bullying . It’s barbaric. My rough comprehensive in the nineties contained enough ‘good souls’ from ‘shit’ homes that we took no nonsense and any attempt at bullying from the staff was met with anarchy. We had a nonce music teacher once, he didn’t last very long. We had a detention once for kids that hadn’t worn the new uniform ( a uniform that was expensive and ridiculous ) there was an exodus of kids out of the hall window that afternoon aswell, some of us stopped to moon the deputy head. Funny how nearly everyone ended up doing okay in life after the uniform protest. My Facebook is full of mooning window escapees that have great families and careers now. My own daughter is famous at her school for a protest which involved her being disgusted that kids were being dragged in between exams when they were shattered ( special school for ND ) so she turned up in her pyjamas and dressing gown and as a result yr 11 we’re allowed to go home. When I got that call I didn’t know whether to be embarrassed or proud , I settled on proud.

MysteryBelle · 16/06/2023 01:45

Her daughter is having a difficult time with her periods and it helps for her mother to get her excused from changing clothes in PE. One of the girls, or a group of them, may have said something to her that embarrassed her or was cruel, you simply don’t know.

Don’t make a big deal of it. Children and preteens and teens can be very sensitive and get mortified, it is reassuring to this girl that her mother is kindly supporting her. It’s not going to affect her resilience.

Basically just go with it, op. It’s not your daughter and she may need this sort of support for a good reason.

FluffyFlannery · 16/06/2023 01:49

My mother would write notes so I could avoid PE too. I hated the classes. Always did. I’ve had a pretty successful life, have danced since young (and teach dance now). Not everyone is sporty or appreciates it. So what 🤷‍♀️

Indoorcatmum · 16/06/2023 02:00

Compulsery sports is horrific and should be abolished. I don't blame her and I would do the same.

I still shudder thinking about PE 17 years later!
It's made me hate sports to this day.

Being red faced and sweaty and hormonal is vile.

Some people aren't sporty and it's humiliating to have to do it.

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 16/06/2023 02:04

LaMarschallin · 15/06/2023 22:51

LifeIsPainHighness

I suspect I’ll be in the minority there though.

Well, you're certainly not alone.
Hated games and turned up with as many notes as I could persuade my mother to write.
Eventually, the games teacher decided that, as punishment, I should have to take extra French conversation if I wasn't running/jumping/hitting stuff/throwing stuff.

Oh dear. Poor moi...Smile

I did two extra O levels in Latin and Ancient History to get out of PE. 😁It put me off sport for life!

Franknotfrancis · 16/06/2023 02:13

@Indoorcatmum
couldn’t agree more. It’s different to other subjects because it puts you on display and exposes your body. Something most teens are already wrestling with. This and drama/ performing arts. Should all be optional in my opinion. I had an awful time at school with anxiety and bullying and these things were horrific for me, oddly enough, after school I fronted a band and danced, sang and played guitar for a couple of years. But I could never,ever in a million years have been able to undress or perform in that environment I couldn’t play sports among my bullies that’s for sure . I joined the ‘smoking in the woods’ cohort which I only regret now because I’m still smoking. My oldest was a ‘good at everything kid’ my youngest is an ‘amazing at some things’ and ‘just can’t do that’ child and I stand by him, he won’t be pushed to do anything In The name of compliance . Shame burns deep when you’re young . No need for it.

FluffyFlannery · 16/06/2023 02:13

Indoorcatmum · 16/06/2023 02:00

Compulsery sports is horrific and should be abolished. I don't blame her and I would do the same.

I still shudder thinking about PE 17 years later!
It's made me hate sports to this day.

Being red faced and sweaty and hormonal is vile.

Some people aren't sporty and it's humiliating to have to do it.

I’m with you 100%!

LifeIsPainHighness · 16/06/2023 02:22

Franknotfrancis · 16/06/2023 02:13

@Indoorcatmum
couldn’t agree more. It’s different to other subjects because it puts you on display and exposes your body. Something most teens are already wrestling with. This and drama/ performing arts. Should all be optional in my opinion. I had an awful time at school with anxiety and bullying and these things were horrific for me, oddly enough, after school I fronted a band and danced, sang and played guitar for a couple of years. But I could never,ever in a million years have been able to undress or perform in that environment I couldn’t play sports among my bullies that’s for sure . I joined the ‘smoking in the woods’ cohort which I only regret now because I’m still smoking. My oldest was a ‘good at everything kid’ my youngest is an ‘amazing at some things’ and ‘just can’t do that’ child and I stand by him, he won’t be pushed to do anything In The name of compliance . Shame burns deep when you’re young . No need for it.

I agree and also there is IME an extra power imbalance with PE teachers because they have control over children when they’re at their physically weakest.

I never met a PE teacher who wasn’t a bully.
They also ALL sucked up to the sporty kids, the captains and vice captains whilst treating others with contempt - which IME is problematic because the captains and sporty kids were almost always the biggest bullies in the school. Who probably went on to teach PE themselves.

Im now at the point of looking at secondary school info for 10yo DD and some places round here happily report how they have 4 hours a week of PE - I think this should be cut in half and more focus on the arts. In which everyone can have a place…even if you can’t sing/dance/act/play an instrument there’s costume design, staging, lighting, runner work, script writing, research etc. The list is endless. I think we’d have much happier pupils in schools of focus shifted away from competitive sports and onto something much more inclusive.

BitterAndTwistedChoreDodger · 16/06/2023 02:25

This thread is a Dummy's guide to why teens and young women give up sport at an early age.

JandalsAlways · 16/06/2023 02:36

I hated PE and would have loved it if my mum and done this so I didn't have to do it. I'm glad she didn't though, because life is actually pretty tough and you don't always get what you want and you often have to do things you don't like doing.

Franknotfrancis · 16/06/2023 02:40

@LifeIsPainHighness
exactly this. The teenage years are the worst time to try and indoctrinate kids into sports and performing arts unless they are already obsessed. My own family is a prime example, champion boxer, figure skater and rugby player, as soon as my son was presented to the family at 2.5 years old as a tall and chunky strong boy they were ‘oh he’s a rugby player’ no he’s fucking not, actually he’s an artist, he paints, he’s a musician because he’s a boss little drummer… I push him to swim because where we live that’s a life skill but other than that he doesn’t need to prove to the world that he’s any kind of athlete , he’s majestic as he is, and I absolutely hate this culture of sports being some kind of measure of someone’s resilience and determination. I get that being a sportsperson takes a lot of resilience and determination , but so does being a musician or an artist or a scientist. All these other disciplines respect each other but the sport people and PE teacher psychology doesn’t , they thrive on physical competition which to me is weird. My uncle is a PE teacher , head of department now, and he’s always been an absolute weirdo tbh. He has strange measures of people, his idea of success involves jumping or running to an impressive extent, well how, in realistic terms does that really implicate a happy and successful life? How does this translate in to true happiness and fulfilment?

HerbsandSpices · 16/06/2023 02:45

testingtesting · 16/06/2023 00:24

OP you're a male teacher, aren't you?

In my experience, the female PE teachers are the worst and the ones that expect you to woman up the most.

Nicecow · 16/06/2023 02:58

I find it ironic that women want to feel empowered and be treated equal, yet also would be happy to use their period as an excuse not to do PE (sure if you are in pain, but many posters here would simply use it as an excuse because they don't like it).

Franknotfrancis · 16/06/2023 03:01

@HerbsandSpices
the female PE teachers were awful. They lacked empathy for the experiences that the girls were experiencing , very much a ‘if you’re breathing you can participate’ mentality. And I think many of us were very much of the ‘you can go fuck yourself’ mentality and our friends would support us . With boys , with male PE teachers they could cut a bit deeper because an insult to your athleticism, to your physical strength is an attack on your masculinity at a time when boys were competitive and not supportive , so it was probably more soul destroying for them. Either way, it’s a shit thing to do and it should be abolished in my opinion.

WiddlinDiddlin · 16/06/2023 03:12

What the fuck is this insistence that being forced to do sports when you feel shit or its humiliating in that particular context, is vital for resilience, all about?

Certain Mumsnetters seem absolutely obsessed with it - you know theres loads of things kids experience that will teach resilience, they won't all turn into melting wet lettuces because someone let them swerve sports day or PE/Games!

My games teachers learned the hard way what making me do exercise when I had my period would achieve. I vomited, reliably, and pretty explosively and with little warning. My periods also lasted 7/8 days at times so if I was really unlucky this could cover PE, Games and PE again the next week. Two cycles of that and they decided I could indeed sit it out. I think spraying the rowing machine with vomit was the final straw really.

Lacucuracha · 16/06/2023 03:34

Anonoteacher · 15/06/2023 22:33

I teach in a large all girls secondary school. This is about a year 7 pupil who has no additional needs or medical issues of any kind.
Her mother is a nurse and regularly writes in her planner that she will be staying in her uniform and not getting changed for pe due to “personal female issues”
I think this is such an odd thing for a female nurse to write to a female teacher at a large school for girls.
For one, why are we phrasing it like this continually?
and for two, why are we teaching girls to opt out of sport every time they get a period. Is this normal?
I think the child will end up lacking in resilience as none of the other parents do this and all of the girls have periods.
Would you do this regularly for your daughter?

She doesn’t have to tell you she’s on her period, if that’s what it is. Why do you feel entitled to know?

I didn’t anything out of PE at school. I do walking/gym/yoga now but nothing that I was made to do in PE.

sashh · 16/06/2023 03:38

I'm not going to repeat the lines about painful and heavy periods I'm just going to add that as well as that have you considered

a) she might be in too much pain to actually get changed?

b) she might not actually fit in to her PE kit.

I used to put on half a stone the week before my period, my belly was visibly bloated.

I'm another who hated PE at school, out of school I was doing Ju Jitsu twice a week.

changeme4this · 16/06/2023 03:48

I did it once for our DD when she was due to go to a compulsory school camp. She was a very heavy bleeder in her early years and wouldn't have been able to access a private toilet or shower had she needed to. In the meanwhile the (female) teacher taking the group completely ignored my letter explaining the circumstance.

On the flip side my GG used to write those letters for DM every week. She is now wheel chair bound due to lack of muscle support and her hospital have to use a substantial sling to move DM from her chair to toilet, shower chair etc.

So I can understand both points of view.

Scirocco · 16/06/2023 03:57

@Anonoteacher , unless you're the girl or one of her parents, you don't know what's going on for her. You say she has no medical issues but all you know is that you aren't aware of any. There could easily be things you don't know - I certainly wouldn't have wanted all my teachers knowing my medical history when it wasn't necessary.

If you're the PE teacher, or her pastoral care tutor, maybe you could ask her or her mum if there's anything you or the school can do to support her, but otherwise leave her alone.

And no, missing PE at school isn't going to set her up to fail. Lots of people miss PE regularly (and I don't blame them, it's frequently terrible and embarrassing) and do just fine in life.

Grumpusaurus · 16/06/2023 04:06

Err, some periods are excruciatingly painful and debilitating. How dense do you have to be to question an actual nurse!