Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

why is it a taboo to ‘ benefit bash ‘ on mn ?. See below for context.

300 replies

Aprilborne · 28/04/2023 10:21

To be clear , am not talking about people on low wages / those wiith caring commitments/ Mental health or physical difficulties . Am talking about work avoidant people who expect benefits as a lifestyle on the back of others .

Yes it is harder now . Yes its a small group of the population .

But .. why is it taboo to discuss this on mn ?

Yes there are businesses who massively tax avoid , but two wrongs dont make a right.

Its a view I know is held in rl … is it that no one dare say these things on mn .. or is it something else. ???

To be clear -I am only talking about those who abuse the system, make it a ‘ my benefits’ way of being .

In my career ( in part with the benefits system) I have been told by some , the small group I am talking about ,that they wouldn't get out of bed for my wage . ( assuming they know what i got paid ! )

I realise it is much much harder to do this now , thats a good thing I just want to know why it seems to be a taboo subject specially on mn .

Yes -know some people will see this as goading.. however , I feel that the perceived majority of opinion dominates , and there is nothing wrong with discussing subjects that appear to be defined as taboo . ?

OP posts:
IClaudine · 28/04/2023 14:52

A seperate issue but a friend recently applied for job seekers allowance (despite a good redundancy package, plenty or money, partner working etc) and it does seem bizarre giving £80 a week to someone in a comfortable financial position. Shes very actively looking for jobs so completely doing what she should be, but just seems like we’re pouring money down the drain.

That will be because she is claiming contribution based JSA, which she is entitled to because she has paid NI contributions. Fear not though, it is only paid for six months, so money won't be "poured down the drain" indefinitely in her case.

Beezknees · 28/04/2023 14:52

Porkandbeans1 · 28/04/2023 14:47

Kind of but voters do get some say. Why do you think UC was roled out, harsher sanctions were out in place and disability benefits are now harder to get? Because a large amount of voters were unhappy with the system and felt people were taking advantage.

Sure. I still find it patronising and I'm fed up of people who think they're better than others telling me how hard I work and that they're fine with me claiming benefits. I don't want anyone's approval, I want fair wages so I don't bloody have to claim UC!

IClaudine · 28/04/2023 14:54

IClaudine · 28/04/2023 14:52

A seperate issue but a friend recently applied for job seekers allowance (despite a good redundancy package, plenty or money, partner working etc) and it does seem bizarre giving £80 a week to someone in a comfortable financial position. Shes very actively looking for jobs so completely doing what she should be, but just seems like we’re pouring money down the drain.

That will be because she is claiming contribution based JSA, which she is entitled to because she has paid NI contributions. Fear not though, it is only paid for six months, so money won't be "poured down the drain" indefinitely in her case.

Sorry, meant to qoute Hellybelly84 there, the first para is what she said, second is my response

IClaudine · 28/04/2023 14:54

Quote. FFS.

albapunk · 28/04/2023 14:57

One of the reasons the company I work for is so short staffed is because new staff get the job then instantly want to drop to 16 hours to keep benefits. Nobody wants to take a full time job, starting salary is 22k. I have been told by a few they earn more than this by working 16 hours only.

My abusive ex cheated the system for years with various fabricated illnesses.

A school friend has 5 children to 3 different men, has never worked, and current baby daddy works but doesn't live there. They can afford much more than us, as a childless couple.

I am someone who is in the "squeezed middle" and earn enough between me and my partner to pay our bills, and have a little extra, but a little. We don't have children as we cannot afford them, rising bills meant our costs have increased from a situation were we were pretty comfortable. As I say. We do okay. But it is frustrating.

I don't grudge anyone who genuinely needs help their benefits, but I do grudge that SOME do use it as lifestyle choice whilst many can barely scape by on 2 full time wages. I have claimed in the past myself.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 28/04/2023 14:57

user1497207191 · 28/04/2023 10:50

Well yes, but unfortunately, certainly under the tax credit system, a fair number of people "gamed" the system by setting up "fake" self employments, to justify working the required number of hours (16 I think) despite not actually earning any income from it, such as market stalls, ebay and websites, etc. They set up the simplest possible "business" and engineered it so that they broke even or made just a small profit, and as long as they could "prove" the 16 hours, they got tax credits at the maximum amount due to the low profit/income!

I had a number of clients who did it and they were very upfront and honest with me as to why they were doing it. They had no interest in getting a "proper" job and working for people, having to work fixed hours, shifts, or whatever, and a part time "hobby" business was ideal for them. The most popular type of "business" was selling sweets at car boot sales or indoor market, i.e. buy large bags from the wholesaler and sell them in smaller bags - a very simple business, low upfront investment (less than a hundred pounds to buy enough large bags of sweets to give a decent range of products to sell), time consuming enough to "prove" 16 hours, make just enough "profit" to cover the market fees, travel, etc. Other people did similar, buying cheap "tat" from wholesalers to sell!

It's why we now have the "minimum income floor" where benefits are based "as if" a business earns the owner the minimum wage for the hours they claim to work, as a direct response to the abuse of the system.

Wasn't that pretty much encouraged though? Helped keep unemployment figures low.

Until too many did it and they had to clamp down on it. Same as with disability benefits in the 90's.

LadyMuckingabout · 28/04/2023 14:57

@Bringonthesunshineporfavor I must admit I’m not happy that someone doing an MA is getting universal credit. Are they doing a phd next?

albapunk · 28/04/2023 14:58

Beezknees · 28/04/2023 14:52

Sure. I still find it patronising and I'm fed up of people who think they're better than others telling me how hard I work and that they're fine with me claiming benefits. I don't want anyone's approval, I want fair wages so I don't bloody have to claim UC!

Fair wages is an important issue too. It would dramatically help with the benefits situation and also out those that do cheat the system.

Beezknees · 28/04/2023 15:01

albapunk · 28/04/2023 14:57

One of the reasons the company I work for is so short staffed is because new staff get the job then instantly want to drop to 16 hours to keep benefits. Nobody wants to take a full time job, starting salary is 22k. I have been told by a few they earn more than this by working 16 hours only.

My abusive ex cheated the system for years with various fabricated illnesses.

A school friend has 5 children to 3 different men, has never worked, and current baby daddy works but doesn't live there. They can afford much more than us, as a childless couple.

I am someone who is in the "squeezed middle" and earn enough between me and my partner to pay our bills, and have a little extra, but a little. We don't have children as we cannot afford them, rising bills meant our costs have increased from a situation were we were pretty comfortable. As I say. We do okay. But it is frustrating.

I don't grudge anyone who genuinely needs help their benefits, but I do grudge that SOME do use it as lifestyle choice whilst many can barely scape by on 2 full time wages. I have claimed in the past myself.

The 16 hour thing is NOT TRUE at all. That was the case on the old tax credits system, UC is a whole different kettle of fish. The more hours you work, the better off you are.

newnamethanks · 28/04/2023 15:01

Bank Holiday weekend OP, you lucky thing, 3 whole days to spend trashing other people you've never met and never will. Do enjoy it.

Gilead · 28/04/2023 15:09

@Reality I’m a bleeding heart socialist, I’m on benefits so I know what it’s like. Your use however of the ‘bleeding heart’ trope is perhaps misinterpreted by you, those people in the middle class bubble are still allowed to be concerned about disabled people on job seekers because the government ensures that those who need it don’t get it but get a lower benefit. There are people with learning disabilities who should be getting a couple of hundred a week, but are getting 75 quid because job seekers officers no longer direct people to the right places.
As for your example, I too have one. Chap I’m trying to help at the moment, just turned fifty, has a form of dementia, forgets appointment, unable to express himself adequately at times, wanders. Gets weekly phone calls about attending for job interviews and was refused PiP. It’s the middle classes that leave their bubble and volunteer to help people like him. But you concentrate on judging your neighbours.

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 15:14

albapunk · 28/04/2023 14:58

Fair wages is an important issue too. It would dramatically help with the benefits situation and also out those that do cheat the system.

Those that cheat or game the system don’t want fair wages, they want free money while spending their time doing nothing

5128gap · 28/04/2023 15:19

Sillysheep · 28/04/2023 14:17

Me and DH figured out after having our kids that we were better off on benefits so he quit his job. Why would we work for less it's not scamming as that's what we were told we were entitled to

Goodness. It must have been tough for you during the higher level sanction period for voluntarily leaving a job. Also quite difficult for him to avoid sanctions on an ongoing basis for refusing to look for work. I can't imagine how poorly paid he must have been for that to be worth more than his wage with a UC top up. I'd be interested in the figures and what happened with the sanctions.

Beezknees · 28/04/2023 15:23

I just did a calculation out of interest and I could still get UC even if I earned £40k, that's with zero childcare costs and my rent of only £500pm. I'd have to earn over £50k to get off UC completely.

berksandbeyond · 28/04/2023 15:29

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 28/04/2023 10:44

You didn’t clearly communicate that though did you? You said that it shouldn’t be a choice to work part time and claim UC.

So what about single parents who have no help when it comes to childcare? Should they not be able to work three or four days worth of 10-2 shifts so that they can drop and pick up their child from school? I’m sure if someone chose to remain unemployed you’d also have an opinion on that

They can choose to work those hours if they like but why should benefits pay for it?

if you can’t afford that lifestyle, you shouldn’t have it

Aprilborne · 28/04/2023 15:31

newnamethanks no i am not trashing people ive never met . I , in oart work with them . To help them with quite a few aspects of their life .
i am saying that it seems to be a taboo on mumsnet to acknowledge that some people abuse the system .. I feel a voice should be allowed to those not happy with this and the fact that they often get shut down on mums net .
for eg a family who i was working with was running a well paid business - cant give details- whilst claiming for his wife and 7 kids . Kids were dressed beautifully , but not fed . Priorities .
It takes a lot of time to work with people with views that it is ok to abuse the aystem - amongst other things .it is not that they cant work or disenfranchised all the time .

OP posts:
Aprilborne · 28/04/2023 15:34

I am not against benefits .
Relative who is disabled is well cared for on them . Its is those who play the system or support the idea that it is ok to play the system , that i feel people should be able to speak about .

OP posts:
Hellybelly84 · 28/04/2023 15:38

Why is it patronising to say hard working people who still cant pay the bills should get benefits (im taliking about two people working or a single mum working all the hours). I have no problem with their wages being topped up to help ease the financial pressure.

Those who CHOOSE not to work (and can work) should get absolutely nothing. Literally nothing. Soon be off to find a job that way…

Maverickess · 28/04/2023 15:42

berksandbeyond · 28/04/2023 15:29

They can choose to work those hours if they like but why should benefits pay for it?

if you can’t afford that lifestyle, you shouldn’t have it

Who provides childcare outside of core school hours?
Is the absent parent made to? Or do the kids fend for themselves?
If there's wrap around care available, you can claim up to 80% back I believe under a certain income - still funded by benefits, add in holiday/inset days/bank holidays/weekend cover and with the price of childcare, it's probably very comparable in what's paid out to supporting someone working part time and recieving a top up.

IClaudine · 28/04/2023 15:42

Aprilborne · 28/04/2023 15:34

I am not against benefits .
Relative who is disabled is well cared for on them . Its is those who play the system or support the idea that it is ok to play the system , that i feel people should be able to speak about .

Well people are "speaking out" in this thread which you started?

If you mean people should be able to pile hate on benefit recipients without being challenged, that is another matter.

Hellybelly84 · 28/04/2023 15:43

IClaudine · 28/04/2023 14:52

A seperate issue but a friend recently applied for job seekers allowance (despite a good redundancy package, plenty or money, partner working etc) and it does seem bizarre giving £80 a week to someone in a comfortable financial position. Shes very actively looking for jobs so completely doing what she should be, but just seems like we’re pouring money down the drain.

That will be because she is claiming contribution based JSA, which she is entitled to because she has paid NI contributions. Fear not though, it is only paid for six months, so money won't be "poured down the drain" indefinitely in her case.

I dont begrudge her it, shes a really hard worker and I imagine she will be back in work within a month or two.

It just seems like a waste of money though as the £80 has no impact on her getting a job. She has savings, redundancy, partner working in a good job, interviews online so its not even for transport cost.

Its just an example of where surely we should look at someones entire household income before we give out money of any kind.

Maverickess · 28/04/2023 15:49

Aprilborne · 28/04/2023 15:34

I am not against benefits .
Relative who is disabled is well cared for on them . Its is those who play the system or support the idea that it is ok to play the system , that i feel people should be able to speak about .

People are speaking about it though, on this thread and this isn't the first and won't be the last on the subject.
Or is it more that you would just like everyone to agree with you and see those that don't as shutting down the discussion or making it 'taboo'?
The issue is how you tell the difference between genuine people needing help and those 'playing the system' because an absence of knowing the facts can make it look like someone is playing the system when they're not.
My first post here illustrated that and I bet if one of my neighbours had posted with what they considered the facts they absolutely knew of my situation from what they could see of my life, then I too would have been 'playing the system' according to many.
The actual facts though were completely different.

5128gap · 28/04/2023 15:51

Hellybelly84 · 28/04/2023 15:38

Why is it patronising to say hard working people who still cant pay the bills should get benefits (im taliking about two people working or a single mum working all the hours). I have no problem with their wages being topped up to help ease the financial pressure.

Those who CHOOSE not to work (and can work) should get absolutely nothing. Literally nothing. Soon be off to find a job that way…

It doesn't work like that. Plenty of people get their benefits stopped for various reasons. There are a lot of ongoing hoops to jump through to manage a claim, which can be beyond the capacity (and yes, sometimes the motivation) of some claimants. When their money stops they don't go out and get jobs, it's the opposite. A downward spiral. Also, what about those with children? No one can surely support seeing children go without the necessities, so if their parents are provided with no money and can't/won't earn it, realistically how are they to be cared for? Looking after a child in the care system is a great deal more costly than paying benefits to their parents.

KittyAlfred · 28/04/2023 15:52

Coffeeandbourbons · 28/04/2023 13:14

I was agreeing with you. When I shared your opinion posters accused me of gobbling up propaganda by the right wing media. So I was asking if you (as a GP that such media despises!) are also peddling right wing propaganda, because clearly you’re not.

But nobody will comment on your post as it’s e inconvenient truth stated by somebody who has lived experience of this and has no affinity (presumably) with the daily Mail that they can blame your views on

Ah sorry, I misunderstood.

KittyAlfred · 28/04/2023 15:56

Sillysheep · 28/04/2023 14:17

Me and DH figured out after having our kids that we were better off on benefits so he quit his job. Why would we work for less it's not scamming as that's what we were told we were entitled to

Do you not have to show that you’re looking for work in order to get benefit, unless you have a disability ?