Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shootings 4 ijured in daylight drive by shooting - Stop & Search

374 replies

Abigail69 · 14/01/2023 17:24

AIBU to demand greater powers for police to carry out more stop and searchers?

IMO, stop and search at an officer's discretion without fear of being accused of unfairness eytc should be supported by the majority of people that are lawful.

As long as the police were being honest/fair and doing their job , polite and explained their reasons, I w=uold never have a problem. I may be ticked of if I got stopped two/three times in a couple of weeks but there are certain times of the day/night and areas that need to be targeted

Their si no question that stop and searching reduce crime as gradually those carrying weapons will decrease. Even now, the trouble makers hide their weapons/drugs in prams, roadside bins, parks etc and collect them when needed but many do still carry a weapon/drugs both etc.

When there is a fight for whatever reason, if not one is carrying a weapon, almost certain the person/s will not get seriously injured or worse.

Stop and search of cars is high yielding as when some are stopped for using the phone and trying to drive, I think i read quiet often they are not fully road legal eg, not have a full licence/banned, no insurance, mot etc

As I said, if I got stopped I may get miffed but if the officer was nice/professional and explained etc, I'd accept it. (My parents are not from the uk) (I am aware that like any profession, there are mistakes when this happens they need to be fully investigated by an independent body.)

Today, just read this - see link below - I hope the victims make a full and speedy recovery and the suspects caught and then sent to prison for a long time.

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11635423/Four-people-including-seven-year-old-girl-injured-shooting-outside-funeral-London.html

OP posts:
Florenz · 21/01/2023 16:48

There would be a lot less crime if we jailed all criminals. And it would cost a lot less than the current situation.

MrsTerryPratchett · 21/01/2023 16:48

Florenz · 21/01/2023 16:38

I'm not right wing at all. I just hate crime and criminals, and I don't think they deserve any respect. They are absolute failures in life, that's way they resort to crime. If criminals are locked up at the first possible opportunity, they're off the playing board, they can't do any more harm, they can't have children who will go onto become criminals, they can't influence other people and drag them into a life of crime. Just put them in a cell and lock the door.

I used to work with offenders years ago. One of the TWOCers, a total dingbat, was on a trip away with me, other staff and several other offenders. There was an emergency, really serious. He put himself in harm's way to make sure everyone got out. He saved me personally from at least serious burns. Possibly worse. One of the other staff was utterly useless and ran. It isn't the only time one of the people I've worked with, homeless, addicted, offending history, has helped me. And not the only time that one of the 'good' people has failed.

Life isn't black and white. I understand it's a happy place to think it is; put everyone in little boxes, with you in one and THEM in another. The truth is that life is messy, lots of people could be good given the chance, could be bad given another.

I've thought a lot about that young man over the years. Wondered if that taste of being a hero did anything to turn him around. He was just an adrenaline junkie, ADHD, terrible impulse control, poor parenting and a shitty area to grow up in. In another place he'd be a paramedic, in the forces, a police officer FGS.

I hate crime too. I just think there are better, cheaper, more ethical and practical ways to stop it. Unless revenge is your only metric, there are better ways than prison.

HikingforScenery · 21/01/2023 16:52

Abigail69 · 14/01/2023 17:39

No but I'm not white and have experience first hand around 30 years ago rudness. However, I now feel that times have changed and with the advent of mobile phones/cams/cctv and police officers wearing cams, it is the way forward

When me and my OH got stopped, unfairly in our view as we did not breach a red light - the officer was having none of it and we stayed calm and soon understood it was no good arguing. We complained to the chief of please in a cnocse manner and explained the facts and that the officer may have not had a good angle view and gussed. We were sent an apology. IMO, if we argued and argued the officer would have called up backup etc. Even when we went down with the papers to the police station, the cahp at the front desk, at best lacked skills but the man/woman at the top saw through this, It should not have happened and I hear you but I'm fed up with the street crime/etc.

30 years ago
Of course the majority of black families would support this too if their last experiences were 30 years ago

pointythings · 21/01/2023 16:54

@Florenz you are comparing the wrong things. The cost of preventing crime and reducing reoffending is far less than the cost of keeping an ever increasing permanent prison population. That is the comparison you should be making.

But you aren't interested in facts, only in your own irrational emotions and need for vengeance. Black and white thinking is for stupid people.

Florenz · 21/01/2023 16:54

It's not about revenge, it's about doing the most efficient thing to prevent crime. And that is how criminals and crime need to be dealt with, as a problem that needs to be dealt with efficiently. Make it very clear in advance, from this point onwards, this is what will happen if you break the law. This is the law, read it, learn it, understand it. If you want to be put in a cell until you die, go ahead, break the law. It's your choice.

Florenz · 21/01/2023 16:55

pointythings · 21/01/2023 16:54

@Florenz you are comparing the wrong things. The cost of preventing crime and reducing reoffending is far less than the cost of keeping an ever increasing permanent prison population. That is the comparison you should be making.

But you aren't interested in facts, only in your own irrational emotions and need for vengeance. Black and white thinking is for stupid people.

It wouldn't be ever increasing. People would realise that there are now real consequences to becoming a criminal and crime would plummet. It isn't that expensive to keep prisoners locked up in a cell, it's all the other stuff that costs money.

pointythings · 21/01/2023 16:56

Are you for real?

The US has the death penalty. And that has been proven to not be a deterrent. Where is your evidence that life sentences for everything would be?

Not to mention that it is impractical, unaffordable and a criminal waste. It's not efficient, it's stupid.

pointythings · 21/01/2023 16:57

I know you don't want evidence, but have some anyway

MrsTerryPratchett · 21/01/2023 17:06

Florenz · 21/01/2023 16:54

It's not about revenge, it's about doing the most efficient thing to prevent crime. And that is how criminals and crime need to be dealt with, as a problem that needs to be dealt with efficiently. Make it very clear in advance, from this point onwards, this is what will happen if you break the law. This is the law, read it, learn it, understand it. If you want to be put in a cell until you die, go ahead, break the law. It's your choice.

Did you read my post at all? Do you not care that people can and do change, and be productive and important people in the world?

I'm trying to understand. Does it come from a place of fear? Or do you just lack empathy and are unable to imagine a world in which you might make poor choices. I suggest you read some psychology. We are almost all capable of evil in the right circumstances. The Stanford Prison experiment, the Migram experiment, many others. It is a very rare person who will always do the right thing.

And since you lack empathy, the chances are you wouldn't be on the side of the angels if it came to it. People who are rule-bound, obedient, authoritarian and black and white tend to be the first to embrace fascism.

It is important to make a world where evil is less able to flourish, because otherwise perfectly lovely people, with pleasant and polite cultures, like the Germans and Cambodians, create true evil in the world. It's not a coincidence that genocidal regimes almost always start with criminals. Because no one cares.

Florenz · 21/01/2023 17:54

Everyone makes poor choices from time to time. Not everyone turns to crime. Mass murderers make poor choices. No-one would ever say that they could be rehabilitated. It's nonsense. I don't care about sob stories from individuals, we need to do what works best for society as a whole. Society meaning law-abiders, not criminals who are by their very nature, anti-social.

pointythings · 21/01/2023 18:07

@Florenz if you can't see that @MrsTerryPratchett 's story completely negates your utterly simplistic view of human nature then there is no hope for you. People are complex. They change, grow and evolve. If you can't see that, you are the one with the problem.

Florenz · 21/01/2023 18:46

It doesn't matter. You can't treat criminals with kid gloves on the basis that one in a thousand might be able to turn their life around. Not when the other 999 will rob, rape, kill and cause misery to law-abiders.

pointythings · 21/01/2023 19:04

Data on rehabilitation suggests it's a lot better than 1/1000. But you carry on with your simplistic thinking. You may not think of yourself as right wing, but you sure as hell are authoritarian.

Florenz · 21/01/2023 20:03

Is it better than 1/1? Even if it's 999/1000, the one innocent person who would be saved is worth more than the 999 criminals that can be redeemed.

pointythings · 21/01/2023 20:18

And of course in your world nobody will ever commit a murder again, having seen the 'deterrent' that's in place. How naive. Putting people in jail forever for a first crime will not save anyone because new criminals will be born, existing people will turn to crime and all of that will happen because this world is a complex place that exists in shades of grey.

I can only assume that you have first hand experience of being the victim of a crime, which has left you angry and embittered. Which is sad, but your views will not help the situation at all.

MrsTerryPratchett · 21/01/2023 20:18

Florenz · 21/01/2023 18:46

It doesn't matter. You can't treat criminals with kid gloves on the basis that one in a thousand might be able to turn their life around. Not when the other 999 will rob, rape, kill and cause misery to law-abiders.

About 1 in 3 men in the UK have a criminal record (depending how you count it). Vaguely similar in the US, massively less in some countries (Canada/Scandi countries). 15% of adult male African Americans have been to prison. Two points:

If you locked them all up for life you'd run out of money in about ten minutes (that's ignoring the fact that you wouldn't be able to legally, morally, practically or any other -ly).

It also proves that the vast majority of people do stop offending and lead uneventful lives. Because otherwise we'd be fending off criminals everywhere we turned. The recidivism rate for some crimes is high and I do think we need to deal with them differently (CSA, rape etc.) but in the main idiot male teenagers do stupid things and grow out of them.

You'd be amazed how many upstanding members of society have records, addiction histories etc. They wouldn't tell you of course. But they tell me.

Florenz · 21/01/2023 20:42

MrsTerryPratchett · 21/01/2023 20:18

About 1 in 3 men in the UK have a criminal record (depending how you count it). Vaguely similar in the US, massively less in some countries (Canada/Scandi countries). 15% of adult male African Americans have been to prison. Two points:

If you locked them all up for life you'd run out of money in about ten minutes (that's ignoring the fact that you wouldn't be able to legally, morally, practically or any other -ly).

It also proves that the vast majority of people do stop offending and lead uneventful lives. Because otherwise we'd be fending off criminals everywhere we turned. The recidivism rate for some crimes is high and I do think we need to deal with them differently (CSA, rape etc.) but in the main idiot male teenagers do stupid things and grow out of them.

You'd be amazed how many upstanding members of society have records, addiction histories etc. They wouldn't tell you of course. But they tell me.

You don't get it and probably never will but I'll attempt to explain.

Those statistics are meaningless because they are representative of how things are now. Not as they would be if we treated crime seriously and started locking people away. You'd probably have a month or two before some people got the message, and saw other criminals locked away with no possibility of release. But after that? Crime would practically disappear. With all criminals removed from the society the entire culture of crime would be obsolete. People would be able to go about their lives without any fear of crime, police could properly do their jobs again, be community officers. Other countries would see what was happening and follow suit in short order. Criminal kingpins would probably flee to the third world but they could be hunted down and killed fairly quickly. The world would be a very different, but much nice place. And it would be relatively easy to do. The real question is, why are so many people against it? The answer is because there are too many influential people making a fortune out of crime and the effects that crime has on people, making them feel scared and needing protection.

MrsTerryPratchett · 21/01/2023 20:45

You don't get it and probably never will but I'll attempt to explain.

And you are talking utter and complete bollocks. I'm out.

pointythings · 21/01/2023 20:48

Yeah, I'm out too. I don't want to live in a dystopian novel. Please never run for office.

Daftasabroom · 21/01/2023 21:25

@Florenz Criminal kingpins would probably flee to the third world but they could be hunted down and killed fairly quickly

You really aren't on planet earth.

Florenz · 21/01/2023 21:51

How is a world without crime "dystopian"? It's the opposite, it's utopian.

Felix125 · 22/01/2023 11:01

Daftasabroom · 21/01/2023 11:49

@Felix125 do you think a massive scale up of stop and search, without any other policy or action, particularly without funding to sure start and children's services, would lead to a significant long term reduction in crime? Violent crime in particular.

Potentially yes - years ago when S&S was was not scrutinized as much, we would target well known thiefs & burglars and S&S them all the time especially on nights. We disrupted them to the point that they couldn't move - and the crime rates for burglary and similar offences dropped through the floor.

Now - we are heavily scrutinized on S&S and we can't do it unless you have sufficient grounds etc etc

The argument would be - the police should be allowed to S&S anyone they want without grounds or necessity. But society doesn't want that, so we have rules on S&S which we have to follow now to the letter.

Now, crime rate is through the roof where we are and criminals know how to 'get around' any potential S&S

NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/01/2023 11:15

Florenz · 21/01/2023 16:48

There would be a lot less crime if we jailed all criminals. And it would cost a lot less than the current situation.

No, there wouldn't. There would be an exponential increase in murder, for a start, because the stakes were higher - no leaving a robbery victim alive to potentially identify their assailant, rape and sexual abuse victims silenced permanently, police officers killed everytime, bystanders caught in every arrest attempt, jurors targeted to make it something they don't want to do at any cost (which would be doubly negative because by refusing out of fear, they'd automatically become criminals themselves - are you suggesting doing away with trial by jury?), the old attitude of might as well be hung for a sheep as a lamb, anyone in power can consolidate it by making opposition a criminal offence - it would be totalitarian and utterly dystopian.

ThePhilamperist · 26/01/2023 09:34

pointythings · 21/01/2023 16:43

So no compassion for people with mental illness, brain injury or learning difficulties? No understanding that you can't just lock up everyone who has committed a crime in perpetuity, or that there will always be more criminals (because there will always be more people)? No insight into what it means to live in the real world? No willingness to look at methods that actually work?

Wow.

No one said that. Officers are trained up to ID those people gruops you emntioned and if the case, when if they get to court reports are seeked.

Do you not want a safer UK?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread