Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shootings 4 ijured in daylight drive by shooting - Stop & Search

374 replies

Abigail69 · 14/01/2023 17:24

AIBU to demand greater powers for police to carry out more stop and searchers?

IMO, stop and search at an officer's discretion without fear of being accused of unfairness eytc should be supported by the majority of people that are lawful.

As long as the police were being honest/fair and doing their job , polite and explained their reasons, I w=uold never have a problem. I may be ticked of if I got stopped two/three times in a couple of weeks but there are certain times of the day/night and areas that need to be targeted

Their si no question that stop and searching reduce crime as gradually those carrying weapons will decrease. Even now, the trouble makers hide their weapons/drugs in prams, roadside bins, parks etc and collect them when needed but many do still carry a weapon/drugs both etc.

When there is a fight for whatever reason, if not one is carrying a weapon, almost certain the person/s will not get seriously injured or worse.

Stop and search of cars is high yielding as when some are stopped for using the phone and trying to drive, I think i read quiet often they are not fully road legal eg, not have a full licence/banned, no insurance, mot etc

As I said, if I got stopped I may get miffed but if the officer was nice/professional and explained etc, I'd accept it. (My parents are not from the uk) (I am aware that like any profession, there are mistakes when this happens they need to be fully investigated by an independent body.)

Today, just read this - see link below - I hope the victims make a full and speedy recovery and the suspects caught and then sent to prison for a long time.

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11635423/Four-people-including-seven-year-old-girl-injured-shooting-outside-funeral-London.html

OP posts:
Abigail69 · 16/01/2023 16:50

Just4ThisThread · 16/01/2023 13:00

commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/sn03878/

There is little evidence to suggest that stop and search provides an effective deterrent to offending.

www.crimeandjustice.org.uk/publications/does-stop-and-search-reduce-crime#:~:text=Based%20on%20London-wide%20data%20from%20the%20last%20ten,or%20criminal%20damages.%20Some%20of%20the%20findings%20include%3A

Based on London-wide data from the last ten years, the report finds little evidence of impact of stop and search on violent crime and non-domestic violent crime.

As expected, links I posted are ignored, ie victims' mothers seeking more S&S and S&S can reduce the murder rate. Both links are in this thread but I will post a comment from met cheif

www.standard.co.uk/news/london/stop-and-search-met-police-london-crime-sir-mark-rowley-b1052213.html

S
top and search can cut the number of attempted murders by “50 per cent or more” in the worst crime hotspots, the Met Commissioner has declared in a new defence of the controversial tactic.
Sir Mark Rowley said the statistic came from new research for the Oxford Journal of Policing that showed the value of searching suspects for weapons as a life-saving tool.
He added that the Met also had “countless examples of offenders being discovered to have dangerous weapons” during stop and searches, as well as “tools for burglary and drugs”.
He emphasised, however, that the Met - which has faced persistent criticism over its use of stop

OP posts:
Just4ThisThread · 16/01/2023 17:04

Abigail69 · 16/01/2023 16:50

As expected, links I posted are ignored, ie victims' mothers seeking more S&S and S&S can reduce the murder rate. Both links are in this thread but I will post a comment from met cheif

www.standard.co.uk/news/london/stop-and-search-met-police-london-crime-sir-mark-rowley-b1052213.html

S
top and search can cut the number of attempted murders by “50 per cent or more” in the worst crime hotspots, the Met Commissioner has declared in a new defence of the controversial tactic.
Sir Mark Rowley said the statistic came from new research for the Oxford Journal of Policing that showed the value of searching suspects for weapons as a life-saving tool.
He added that the Met also had “countless examples of offenders being discovered to have dangerous weapons” during stop and searches, as well as “tools for burglary and drugs”.
He emphasised, however, that the Met - which has faced persistent criticism over its use of stop

I read your link, did you?

It states that stop and search CAN reduce crime, if it wasn’t for the challenges you’ve conveniently cropped from your copy and paste.

pointythings · 16/01/2023 17:10

Have another bad apple from me

Or rather, a whole barrel full - because this man had had complaints made against him for decades and they were all ignored. Every officer and worker in the Met who shielded this man is just as bad. That's not one bad apple, it's dozens. In a single force.

So no, I don't want them to have more powers. The solution? @MrsTerryPratchett suggested it right at the beginning of the thread - but you authoritarians don't actually want to help people improve their lives.

Daftasabroom · 16/01/2023 17:10

Abigail69 · 16/01/2023 16:50

As expected, links I posted are ignored, ie victims' mothers seeking more S&S and S&S can reduce the murder rate. Both links are in this thread but I will post a comment from met cheif

www.standard.co.uk/news/london/stop-and-search-met-police-london-crime-sir-mark-rowley-b1052213.html

S
top and search can cut the number of attempted murders by “50 per cent or more” in the worst crime hotspots, the Met Commissioner has declared in a new defence of the controversial tactic.
Sir Mark Rowley said the statistic came from new research for the Oxford Journal of Policing that showed the value of searching suspects for weapons as a life-saving tool.
He added that the Met also had “countless examples of offenders being discovered to have dangerous weapons” during stop and searches, as well as “tools for burglary and drugs”.
He emphasised, however, that the Met - which has faced persistent criticism over its use of stop

While I have huge sympathy for the victims of crime, that doesn't necessarily make them experts on the cause and prevention of crime. Equally Sir Mark Rowley's comment was that S&S may possibly reduce crime rates. You are now quoting both these opinions as facts. They are a very long way from facts.

And you may be surprised to know that the Oxford Journal of Policing has been Policing: a Journal of Policy and Practice since 2014, I'd be very very wary where reporters can't even get their sources right, or, their sources are massively out of date.

Eyerollcentral · 16/01/2023 17:14

Yes @Daftasabroom ’While I have huge sympathy for the victims of crime, that doesn't necessarily make them experts on the cause and prevention of crime.’ is a point you would think is fairly obvious.

Daftasabroom · 16/01/2023 17:22

@Abigail69 I've taken ten minutes to look for the actual academic report(s) cited by Sir MR, and since the Oxford Journal of Policing doesn't seem to exist this has been a little frustrating.

However if you would like to back up assertions you might find some peer reviewed evidence Here (I couldn't BTW.)

Felix125 · 16/01/2023 17:37

S&S powers are quite tight at present.

If you see a well known thief running down the street carrying a large item under his jacket, can you S&S him - No

If you see well known burglar miles from his home address walking around a suburban street at 3 in the morning, can you S&S him - No

If you pull a car over and it stinks of cannabis, can you search the car & occupants - No

If a youth in a red top carrying a knife walks past your house and he meets up with 10 youths at the bottom of the street, can S&S be used to search the other 9 youths if the knife isn't found on the one in the red top - No

Pumperthepumper · 16/01/2023 17:54

People are too quick of the mark to blame the police. I've been to my motherland and several other countries, and trust me the police talk with their hands/guns/sticks etc. However, we do live in England and we are all british citizens and want the best from our police.

I don’t live in England. They think Carrick might be one of the most prolific rapists in the UK. The MET police is completely unfit for purpose. These are the people you want to give more powers to @Abigail69

MrsTerryPratchett · 16/01/2023 18:08

Eyerollcentral · 16/01/2023 17:14

Yes @Daftasabroom ’While I have huge sympathy for the victims of crime, that doesn't necessarily make them experts on the cause and prevention of crime.’ is a point you would think is fairly obvious.

This.

When I was burgled my dad wanted to string the offenders up by their thumbs. But I've seen victims of extreme violence suggesting counselling for the perpetrators.

The job of the justice and prevention systems should be to reduce crime and deal with it when it happens. Not do what victims want.

pointythings · 16/01/2023 18:19

However, we do live in England and we are all british citizens and want the best from our police.

Not everyone who lives in England (or elsewhere in the UK) is a British citizen. Many of us come from countries where the police functions well and does not have these issues.

TimeForTeaAndG · 16/01/2023 18:42

pointythings · 16/01/2023 18:19

However, we do live in England and we are all british citizens and want the best from our police.

Not everyone who lives in England (or elsewhere in the UK) is a British citizen. Many of us come from countries where the police functions well and does not have these issues.

I'm a British citizen. I want total reform of the police. I want funding for mental health services, community building, provision for appropriate social carers to attend calls from distressed people who don't actually need the police, safe houses for addicts (I can't remember what they're called, where they can have clean needles etc).

I want to treat the causes of crime, not just treat everyone like a criminal in case they might be.

pointythings · 16/01/2023 18:49

@TimeForTeaAndG the mental health Trust I used to work for have just started a pilot for specialist mental health workers to ride along with the police - this is the sort of thing we need to trial and reform, along with all the things suggested by @MrsTerryPratchett . Root and branch reform of the police is an essential part of this. Just handing them more power is not.

Where I come from, policing is a degree level profession.

MrsTerryPratchett · 16/01/2023 18:56

pointythings · 16/01/2023 18:49

@TimeForTeaAndG the mental health Trust I used to work for have just started a pilot for specialist mental health workers to ride along with the police - this is the sort of thing we need to trial and reform, along with all the things suggested by @MrsTerryPratchett . Root and branch reform of the police is an essential part of this. Just handing them more power is not.

Where I come from, policing is a degree level profession.

PM me because I've worked a little with integrated MH/Police teams in other places and seen some of the success/pitfalls.

PatrickBasedman · 16/01/2023 19:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

ClivePowermax · 16/01/2023 19:11

@PatrickBasedman I don't know where PP is from but Norway definitely exists, for example.

pointythings · 16/01/2023 19:53

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

It's life in the Netherlands. It works like a degree apprenticeship, so you learn on the job and follow the course. Duration to qualify for full police constable training is 4 years. To be a detective it's a masters level qualification. Whichever qualification you do, it takes a further 9 months on top to be firearms certified (because all qualified police in the Netherlands carry a firearm).

Abigail69 · 16/01/2023 19:53

pointythings · 16/01/2023 18:19

However, we do live in England and we are all british citizens and want the best from our police.

Not everyone who lives in England (or elsewhere in the UK) is a British citizen. Many of us come from countries where the police functions well and does not have these issues.

Please share with us the great policing of another country that is comparable with the way we live in Egnland

OP posts:
pointythings · 16/01/2023 19:54

@MrsTerryPratchett I don't work for them any more, but I still follow them - it's Cambridgeshire and Peterborough Foundation Trust and it's on their public facing website.

I doubt they're doing this without having contacted other areas where it's been tried.

pointythings · 16/01/2023 19:56

@Abigail69 define 'comparable'. I'm from the Netherlands, which is something less of an utter shitshow than the UK because we don't have FPTP and Tories, but it has a well right of centre government and is a developed Western European country, so will that do you?

Abigail69 · 16/01/2023 19:57

TimeForTeaAndG · 16/01/2023 18:42

I'm a British citizen. I want total reform of the police. I want funding for mental health services, community building, provision for appropriate social carers to attend calls from distressed people who don't actually need the police, safe houses for addicts (I can't remember what they're called, where they can have clean needles etc).

I want to treat the causes of crime, not just treat everyone like a criminal in case they might be.

Where will you get the money to pay for that and how much is it?

I want England/UK to be crime free but what I want and get are two different things. Therefore we need to be realistic within the realms of affordability.

So what you propose to cut down the number of people carrying guns/knives/drugs and gang related crime etc.

OP posts:
Florenz · 16/01/2023 20:01

It isn't the job of the police to be social workers. It is the job of the police to fight crime. It is the responsibility of citizens to be law-abiding adults and to raise their children to be the same. If they fail to do this, it is their fault alone. Not the police, not "society", not anyone else who they want to blame. Theirs alone.

MrsTerryPratchett · 16/01/2023 20:08

Please share with us the great policing of another country that is comparable with the way we live in Egnland

Why when you have ignored sensible suggestions? What's the point?

MrsTerryPratchett · 16/01/2023 20:10

Florenz · 16/01/2023 20:01

It isn't the job of the police to be social workers. It is the job of the police to fight crime. It is the responsibility of citizens to be law-abiding adults and to raise their children to be the same. If they fail to do this, it is their fault alone. Not the police, not "society", not anyone else who they want to blame. Theirs alone.

No, but by it's nature police work means a great deal of contact with those who need social work/healthcare/supports. So why not be efficient and remove silos and barriers.

Integrated teams have worked well but they aren't everywhere. Why not do what actually works?

Pumperthepumper · 16/01/2023 20:10

Florenz · 16/01/2023 20:01

It isn't the job of the police to be social workers. It is the job of the police to fight crime. It is the responsibility of citizens to be law-abiding adults and to raise their children to be the same. If they fail to do this, it is their fault alone. Not the police, not "society", not anyone else who they want to blame. Theirs alone.

So what happens to the kids who are not raised to be law abiding citizens? Too bad for them, they should have had better parents?

Abigail69 · 17/01/2023 09:22

MrsTerryPratchett · 16/01/2023 20:08

Please share with us the great policing of another country that is comparable with the way we live in Egnland

Why when you have ignored sensible suggestions? What's the point?

As I expected, no credible alternative S&S to the several requests I made.
Then this, bleating on about how bad England's police is and unable to give even one country where policing is better.
I and many others, close to 50% on the polls here and I guess more IRL support S&S as long as its done with care and without prejudice as it gets results, good results.

Several here that want to blame the police for everything and forget that parents too have a responsibility and they have no effective alternative to S&S.

OP posts: