Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shootings 4 ijured in daylight drive by shooting - Stop & Search

374 replies

Abigail69 · 14/01/2023 17:24

AIBU to demand greater powers for police to carry out more stop and searchers?

IMO, stop and search at an officer's discretion without fear of being accused of unfairness eytc should be supported by the majority of people that are lawful.

As long as the police were being honest/fair and doing their job , polite and explained their reasons, I w=uold never have a problem. I may be ticked of if I got stopped two/three times in a couple of weeks but there are certain times of the day/night and areas that need to be targeted

Their si no question that stop and searching reduce crime as gradually those carrying weapons will decrease. Even now, the trouble makers hide their weapons/drugs in prams, roadside bins, parks etc and collect them when needed but many do still carry a weapon/drugs both etc.

When there is a fight for whatever reason, if not one is carrying a weapon, almost certain the person/s will not get seriously injured or worse.

Stop and search of cars is high yielding as when some are stopped for using the phone and trying to drive, I think i read quiet often they are not fully road legal eg, not have a full licence/banned, no insurance, mot etc

As I said, if I got stopped I may get miffed but if the officer was nice/professional and explained etc, I'd accept it. (My parents are not from the uk) (I am aware that like any profession, there are mistakes when this happens they need to be fully investigated by an independent body.)

Today, just read this - see link below - I hope the victims make a full and speedy recovery and the suspects caught and then sent to prison for a long time.

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11635423/Four-people-including-seven-year-old-girl-injured-shooting-outside-funeral-London.html

OP posts:
pointythings · 20/01/2023 09:04

Florenz · 19/01/2023 22:14

Look at all the people on left talking about banning private schools, banning grammar schools. Why not talk about making state schools as good as private schools? Why attack the thing that works as it should do? Look at all the attacks on people who work hard, study hard, and expect their children to do the same. People who piss about at school, spend years unemployed are patronised, sympathised, but these are the people in the wrong, they have wasted their lives and the opportunities presented to them. It's not "societies" fault that they turn to crime, it's their own fault.

I agree that we should make all state schools as good as the best private schools (once again you are being simplistic - there are great state schools and shockingly bad private schools, as you well know). I wouldn't advocate for banning private schools, but I do think they should not be able to dodge tax by labelling themselves charities. They're businesses. There is a post on here from someone who was refused a bursary because they didn't earn enough - that really should say it all.

I'm also not per se against grammar schools, just against the way they are done in the UK - as a one shot deal at 11, no flexibility. The Dutch system is academically selective, but 1) there are opportunities to move streams as a person matures and 2) vocational education is properly valued and funded.

You tackle disengagement with education and work by making education and work pay - right now in the UK there are too many people for whom is doesn't pay because they see the privileged get a hand up that they will never have. Provide genuine equality of opportunity for all and watch the change happen - you still haven't engaged with the point about countries where there is less inequality and also less crime. What is your rationale for refusing change?

Felix125 · 20/01/2023 16:49

Daftasabroom · Today 08:31
@Florenz
How do you jump to that conclusion...????
Because you can't possibly know that a person won't answer a question until you ask the question. So obviously the police will have stopped him in order to question him.
Most criminals? You really are just making stuff up.

What....????

So, you stop this guy as he is walking along this road at night with something under his jacket. You haven't seen or stopped him prior to this and there is no ongoing incident at the time (no recent burglaries etc etc)

You ask him "Where are you off too" "Where have you just come from" "Whats under your jacket"

And he says "Well, I'm not telling you"

You have no grounds to search him. He's not doing anything wrong, he has the right to a private life and unless you have information to state that the item under his jacket is stolen - you're snookered!

You also have to give the object you are looking for when you search someone (GOWISELY) - which you cannot do. You cant just search someone for 'things'

And yes - most criminals won't say anything to you which is going to incriminate themselves. If you think that when stopping this guy he is going to say "Oh yes - I've just been out burgling" you're miles away from the real world!

Daftasabroom · 20/01/2023 16:59

@Florenz absolutely nothing you

Daftasabroom · 20/01/2023 17:07

Felix125 · 20/01/2023 16:49

Daftasabroom · Today 08:31
@Florenz
How do you jump to that conclusion...????
Because you can't possibly know that a person won't answer a question until you ask the question. So obviously the police will have stopped him in order to question him.
Most criminals? You really are just making stuff up.

What....????

So, you stop this guy as he is walking along this road at night with something under his jacket. You haven't seen or stopped him prior to this and there is no ongoing incident at the time (no recent burglaries etc etc)

You ask him "Where are you off too" "Where have you just come from" "Whats under your jacket"

And he says "Well, I'm not telling you"

You have no grounds to search him. He's not doing anything wrong, he has the right to a private life and unless you have information to state that the item under his jacket is stolen - you're snookered!

You also have to give the object you are looking for when you search someone (GOWISELY) - which you cannot do. You cant just search someone for 'things'

And yes - most criminals won't say anything to you which is going to incriminate themselves. If you think that when stopping this guy he is going to say "Oh yes - I've just been out burgling" you're miles away from the real world!

Your post is pure fiction.

Could I suggest you, that if you want to make the world or even your local society better you just get out there and engage.

Felix125 · 20/01/2023 17:12

These are worked examples from the College of Policing used as training.

Another example is:

You're on mobile patrol and you see a youth. He looks at you and immediately walks off in the other direction. You pull up next to him and he stops. he won't say what he has been doing and refuses to give you his name or address etc. Can you search him?

Your colleague walks back to where the youth had been initially stood and hidden in the bush a few meters away is a knife. Can you search him now?

Both answers are no.

The first time - he done nothing wrong at all, so you can't search him

The second time - you have nothing linking him to the knife, the knife could have been there for days or could have been deposited by someone as you were following the youth up the road. You again also have no identified object which you are going to search the youth for - you can't search him for a knife as the knife is up the road with your colleague

So again - you are snookered!

Felix125 · 20/01/2023 17:13

Daftasabroom
Could I suggest you, that if you want to make the world or even your local society better you just get out there and engage.

Yes - I do engage. But I will not bend or break the law to carry out S&S

Unless you can come up with the legal grounds to search him....?

Daftasabroom · 20/01/2023 17:22

@Felix125 your posts are pretty difficult to follow be honest .

s&,s doesn't work, full stop.

Felix125 · 20/01/2023 18:02

I don't mind you asking things to clarify points

In essence, if we carry out S&S by the way we are trained and follow the procedures - its very difficult to find the grounds to search anyone.

Its gets to the point where you need a witness to say to you "....I have just seen that person steal an item from that shop and place it under his jacket"

But then you would be looking to arrest him for theft, based on account given to you and search him after the arrest. which would not be classed as a S&S

Daftasabroom · 20/01/2023 18:05

You talk about "we" so you must be a cop?

Felix125 · 20/01/2023 18:08

correct

Daftasabroom · 21/01/2023 11:49

@Felix125 do you think a massive scale up of stop and search, without any other policy or action, particularly without funding to sure start and children's services, would lead to a significant long term reduction in crime? Violent crime in particular.

Florenz · 21/01/2023 13:25

Nothing can lead to a long term reduction in crime because it can always be undone. But it would lead to a short-term reduction in crime as the stabbers would be locked up and other potential stabbers would stop carrying knives to avoid getting locked up.

pointythings · 21/01/2023 14:17

Nothing can lead to a long term reduction in crime because it can always be undone.

Say what now? You're basically saying we shouldn't try to improve the way our society is run in order to prevent crime because at some point someone might change the system back and make it all go bad again? I mean, we have this thing called democracy. Sort of. So if voters see crime falling under policies that reduce inequality and improve opportunity, policies from which they themselves will benefit, they're going to vote against those and go back to the bad all days? And because of that remote and implausible possibility, we should just not even try to make things better and instead focus on more and more punishment?

I'd say your reasoning is shocking, but I can't because you aren't reasoning.

Daftasabroom · 21/01/2023 15:40

@Florenz Nothing can lead to a long term reduction in crime because it can always be undone.

I suggest you look up the term "false dichotomy".

Florenz · 21/01/2023 15:41

Today's criminals aren't going to be affected by changes to society tomorrow. The police can't do anything about tomorrow. They shouldn't be allowing people to be murdered today in order to theoretically prevent murders down the line. The police can't do anything about inequality and opportunity, and the government can only do so much.

pointythings · 21/01/2023 15:51

So you start by changing the focus of what prison does. Are you aware of the prevalence of mental illness, brain injury and learning difficulties in the prison population as compared to the general population? That is where you start - in prisons, by offering high quality treatment and rehabilitation, and outside prison where you do exactly the same. But of course that would mean investing - however, prison is appallingly expensive too.

A rehabilitative approach to prisoner management has been shown to work in other developed countries - what is your evidence for thinking it would not work here?

And most of all: why are you happy to keep doing the same thing over and over again when it demonstrably does not work?

Florenz · 21/01/2023 16:02

What works is locking criminals up as soon as possible and keeping them locked up as long as possible. That cannot be denied. I don't want to continue what we are currently doing which is far too soft and pays far too much concern for the rights and welfare of criminals who have no regard for the rights and welfare of their victims.

Daftasabroom · 21/01/2023 16:26

@Florenz What works is locking criminals up as soon as possible and keeping them locked up as long as possible. That cannot be denied

And your evidence for this is what? where?

You're making stuff up.

pointythings · 21/01/2023 16:30

@Florenz your thinking is simplistic. Do you or do you not want a society where there are fewer people who commit crimes? Endless cycles of ever harsher punishment do not achieve this. They just cost money and cause more harm. Mind you, your thinking on this is consistent with your thinking on other issues - hardline, extremely authoritarian, right wing. And ineffective.

pointythings · 21/01/2023 16:32

@Daftasabroom the logic is that if someone is in jail, they can't commit crime. Therefore we must put everyone who ever commits a crime in jail, forever, that way we will never have crime again. 🙄

vvork · 21/01/2023 16:34

@Florenz but it literally doesn't work though. I can tell from your posts that you feel passionately about prison and really want it to work how you feel it should, but those feelings are not supported by reality or facts, unfortunately. We can't run a functioning society based on feelings, especially when they are at odds with real life. It's frustrating, I know, and there's plenty of things I feel should be the case when the reality is different, but that's life.

vvork · 21/01/2023 16:36

@pointythings yes there are a finite number of criminals and if we catch em all, Pokémon style, then we'll have completed crime and can progress to the next level of the game. 😉

pointythings · 21/01/2023 16:36

@vvork I don't think I want to know what the next level is...

Florenz · 21/01/2023 16:38

I'm not right wing at all. I just hate crime and criminals, and I don't think they deserve any respect. They are absolute failures in life, that's way they resort to crime. If criminals are locked up at the first possible opportunity, they're off the playing board, they can't do any more harm, they can't have children who will go onto become criminals, they can't influence other people and drag them into a life of crime. Just put them in a cell and lock the door.

pointythings · 21/01/2023 16:43

So no compassion for people with mental illness, brain injury or learning difficulties? No understanding that you can't just lock up everyone who has committed a crime in perpetuity, or that there will always be more criminals (because there will always be more people)? No insight into what it means to live in the real world? No willingness to look at methods that actually work?

Wow.