Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shootings 4 ijured in daylight drive by shooting - Stop & Search

374 replies

Abigail69 · 14/01/2023 17:24

AIBU to demand greater powers for police to carry out more stop and searchers?

IMO, stop and search at an officer's discretion without fear of being accused of unfairness eytc should be supported by the majority of people that are lawful.

As long as the police were being honest/fair and doing their job , polite and explained their reasons, I w=uold never have a problem. I may be ticked of if I got stopped two/three times in a couple of weeks but there are certain times of the day/night and areas that need to be targeted

Their si no question that stop and searching reduce crime as gradually those carrying weapons will decrease. Even now, the trouble makers hide their weapons/drugs in prams, roadside bins, parks etc and collect them when needed but many do still carry a weapon/drugs both etc.

When there is a fight for whatever reason, if not one is carrying a weapon, almost certain the person/s will not get seriously injured or worse.

Stop and search of cars is high yielding as when some are stopped for using the phone and trying to drive, I think i read quiet often they are not fully road legal eg, not have a full licence/banned, no insurance, mot etc

As I said, if I got stopped I may get miffed but if the officer was nice/professional and explained etc, I'd accept it. (My parents are not from the uk) (I am aware that like any profession, there are mistakes when this happens they need to be fully investigated by an independent body.)

Today, just read this - see link below - I hope the victims make a full and speedy recovery and the suspects caught and then sent to prison for a long time.

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11635423/Four-people-including-seven-year-old-girl-injured-shooting-outside-funeral-London.html

OP posts:
Abigail69 · 17/01/2023 22:50

Florenz · 17/01/2023 20:22

It isn't going to happen under any government anytime soon. Because most people don't want to live in that kind of world.

You are right, every country has different dynamics and only those that lack knowledge about how and why law and order works would support another country policing in their own country.

There are always little bits of what we could give and take is that in many countries, you swear at a police officer, trust me, 99.9% would not do it again as they its zero tolerance to police being abused by drunks, idiots and fools.

I went on a demo, the first and last for me and the amount of swearing at the officers by some was disgusting and I left the demo.

OP posts:
Florenz · 17/01/2023 23:31

Daftasabroom · 17/01/2023 22:12

@Florenz No they are soft and ineffectual. People want the police to be harder on criminals.

But surely it is the job of the police above all to prevent crime. The police do not have the job of judging people, much less handing out harsh punishments according their (or your) whim.

the best way to prevent crime is to lock criminals up so they cannot commit more crimes. We need to crack down on crime 1000%. Forget about the "war on drugs", we need a "war on crime".

MrsTerryPratchett · 17/01/2023 23:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Florenz · 17/01/2023 23:56

How many crimes against innocent people are committed by criminals that are locked in prison? How many crimes against innocent people are committed by criminals that have been released from prison, or who were never jailed at all? If you believe in preventing crime, the statistics will prove what needs to be done.

MrsTerryPratchett · 18/01/2023 00:04

Which is why American with the highest incarceration rates, has such a low crime rate.

Oh wait, that's bollocks. The safest countries include countries with progressive drug policies like Switzerland and Portugal. Because that actually works.

Eyerollcentral · 18/01/2023 00:11

MrsTerryPratchett · 18/01/2023 00:04

Which is why American with the highest incarceration rates, has such a low crime rate.

Oh wait, that's bollocks. The safest countries include countries with progressive drug policies like Switzerland and Portugal. Because that actually works.

That information would be useful except this a fact free zone, sorry 🤷‍♀️ Apparently this has been designated a ranting space for those with little knowledge but a lot of opinions. I admire your stamina @MrsTerryPratchett and your sane, informed contributions

MrsTerryPratchett · 18/01/2023 00:17

It's all for the lurkers @Eyerollcentral

CliffordDanger · 18/01/2023 00:17

@MrsTerryPratchett Ew, don't come here with your dirty, filthy facts!

I for one welcome the illiterate ramblings of the unhinged and won't rest until there's a chokey on every street corner. I'll sit outside with my knitting and tut loudly.

Eyerollcentral · 18/01/2023 00:23

MrsTerryPratchett · 18/01/2023 00:17

It's all for the lurkers @Eyerollcentral

Lol! I just can’t cope with the comments, it’s enough to make you volunteer to be first in line for ‘the noose’

MrsTerryPratchett · 18/01/2023 01:02

CliffordDanger · 18/01/2023 00:17

@MrsTerryPratchett Ew, don't come here with your dirty, filthy facts!

I for one welcome the illiterate ramblings of the unhinged and won't rest until there's a chokey on every street corner. I'll sit outside with my knitting and tut loudly.

Grin
Janesmom · 18/01/2023 03:02

Sadly there’s a lot of misinformation around S&S. It’s a blunt instrument but not a bad one.

If police search a gang of 10 and find one weapon, that’s in itself a 90% failure rate given how the stats are calculated. However, I think most sensible people would see that search as a massive success.

DeeCeeCherry · 18/01/2023 04:03

The funeral was that of the ex wife of Cali drugs cartel gang leader, and their daughter. A tragic incident that Stop and Search would not have prevented because it wouldn't have been implemented in preceding days.

A lot of organised crime gang members are left alone whilst police spend time hassling Black boys. If given more Stop and Search powers they'll increase the harassment.

Aside from that having spent yesterday and today reading about bastard cop Carrick who who was also in the same Whatsapp group as Wayne Couzens, I'm minded that the police cannot be trusted with any more power in any form. Far too corrupt.

Your 'solution' is unworkable, moot point really

mathanxiety · 18/01/2023 04:14

@Janesmom

Stop and search ten young men - sure, find a gun one out of ten times.

But nine times out of ten it yields no result apart from making the youths feel less well disposed toward the police.

There's a cost-benefit analysis here. I'm pretty sure, based on previous sus policies both in the UK and elsewhere, that the cost far outweighs the benefit.

Felix125 · 18/01/2023 09:40

Daftasabroom · 17/01/2023 10:15

The police have the power to stop and search if they have reasonable grounds.

What some people seem to be suggesting is that these powers are extended in some way.

My point is that you would not be able to S&S him just based on that scenario and would have to just let him walk past if you see him.

Abigail69 · 18/01/2023 10:00

Florenz · 17/01/2023 23:31

the best way to prevent crime is to lock criminals up so they cannot commit more crimes. We need to crack down on crime 1000%. Forget about the "war on drugs", we need a "war on crime".

A very sensible comment and may I add, we need to lock everyone up as the Tories said but did not action ie anyone found with a weapon will be locked up but it does not happen. About criminals, you will often find its the few that are often repeat offenders and then locked up ie suspended sentences or locked up for short periods. Something like 3 strikes, ie third time you are locked up, lock up for life I think some USA do that, not sure.

S&S is a deterent to an extent and this needs to be backed up with harsh prosion sentences eg, found carring a weapon, you get locked up min 2 year and then more than that to and inc life depending on the circumstances. Caught the second time, 7 years caught the third time, life. etc Trust me it wont stop all but imo 99% reduction.

OP posts:
Abigail69 · 18/01/2023 10:04

Janesmom · 18/01/2023 03:02

Sadly there’s a lot of misinformation around S&S. It’s a blunt instrument but not a bad one.

If police search a gang of 10 and find one weapon, that’s in itself a 90% failure rate given how the stats are calculated. However, I think most sensible people would see that search as a massive success.

What a brilliant post.
Often as I said before, S&S of a vheilce for a non-working light, small traffic offence at times leads to many other finds. Often as I above and before, it is only a smaller number of people that need to be locked up for a long time to make everyone safer on the streets including the young people that are at times manipulated by older gang leaders. Target leaders, lock them up and give extra social care help to others to help them with education/work etc.

OP posts:
Abigail69 · 18/01/2023 10:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ok, I've let you off before with your abuse - enough is enough and I will have to report this. I said to you before, please do not aim abuse at me just because you are ignorant about S&S but you carry on

OP posts:
pointythings · 18/01/2023 10:33

If police search a gang of 10 and find one weapon, that’s in itself a 90% failure rate given how the stats are calculated. However, I think most sensible people would see that search as a massive success.

It would be a small, short term success with the kind of consequences we are already seeing - the alienation of entire communities. It isn't just criminals who don't trust the police, it is ethnic minority communities of all kinds, because they see their own being disproportionately targeted. And then when crime does take place, nobody will speak out because they have been taught not to trust the police. It hinders investigation of serioius crimes.

I honestly don't understand the people on this thread who aren't interested in the strategies that prevent people from turning to crime in the first place - do you all have some kind of punishment fetish? Do you think that current levels of deprivation and inequality in the UK are a good thing, even though countries with less inequality report less crime and more happiness in their population? Do you not want a police force that people trust and turn to when things go wrong?

@Abigail69 you seem to want a 'three strikes and you're out' kind of law. Since it hasn't reduced crime in the US, why is that? Looking at countries like Norway, it's clear that a rehabilitative model works better in reducing crime. Why do you want to continue and double down on a model that has been shown to not reduce crime?

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 18/01/2023 10:51

Abigail69 · 18/01/2023 10:00

A very sensible comment and may I add, we need to lock everyone up as the Tories said but did not action ie anyone found with a weapon will be locked up but it does not happen. About criminals, you will often find its the few that are often repeat offenders and then locked up ie suspended sentences or locked up for short periods. Something like 3 strikes, ie third time you are locked up, lock up for life I think some USA do that, not sure.

S&S is a deterent to an extent and this needs to be backed up with harsh prosion sentences eg, found carring a weapon, you get locked up min 2 year and then more than that to and inc life depending on the circumstances. Caught the second time, 7 years caught the third time, life. etc Trust me it wont stop all but imo 99% reduction.

Honestly, you clearly know the square root of fuck all about the subject. You should really just accept you're wrong and stop embarrassing yourself.

Your ridiculous three strikes system falls down at the first hurdle as criminal gang leaders don't tend to incriminate themselves and, due to ever increasing poverty and inequality, there is always a fresh supply of foot soldiers to exploit for the dirty work.

All your ill-thought plans would do is increase the number of young people in prison, increase the costs associated with that, and further embed inequalities in poorer communities.

Abigail69 · 18/01/2023 11:23

pointythings · 18/01/2023 10:33

If police search a gang of 10 and find one weapon, that’s in itself a 90% failure rate given how the stats are calculated. However, I think most sensible people would see that search as a massive success.

It would be a small, short term success with the kind of consequences we are already seeing - the alienation of entire communities. It isn't just criminals who don't trust the police, it is ethnic minority communities of all kinds, because they see their own being disproportionately targeted. And then when crime does take place, nobody will speak out because they have been taught not to trust the police. It hinders investigation of serioius crimes.

I honestly don't understand the people on this thread who aren't interested in the strategies that prevent people from turning to crime in the first place - do you all have some kind of punishment fetish? Do you think that current levels of deprivation and inequality in the UK are a good thing, even though countries with less inequality report less crime and more happiness in their population? Do you not want a police force that people trust and turn to when things go wrong?

@Abigail69 you seem to want a 'three strikes and you're out' kind of law. Since it hasn't reduced crime in the US, why is that? Looking at countries like Norway, it's clear that a rehabilitative model works better in reducing crime. Why do you want to continue and double down on a model that has been shown to not reduce crime?

I do, yes, thanks
From what I have seen and heard via media etc, it is often the same people carrying out crimes etc, so i cant see crime not reducing. Along with the other bits i said ie lock up the leaders and get the hangers on jobs/education/help ect but no via some very little, little known charities that help may be half a dozen people a year to what extent i dont know but bigger groups that are clear how many they helped and the outcomes etc

OP posts:
Abigail69 · 18/01/2023 11:25

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 18/01/2023 10:51

Honestly, you clearly know the square root of fuck all about the subject. You should really just accept you're wrong and stop embarrassing yourself.

Your ridiculous three strikes system falls down at the first hurdle as criminal gang leaders don't tend to incriminate themselves and, due to ever increasing poverty and inequality, there is always a fresh supply of foot soldiers to exploit for the dirty work.

All your ill-thought plans would do is increase the number of young people in prison, increase the costs associated with that, and further embed inequalities in poorer communities.

You are clearly lost for words and have no sensible counters hence the abuse.
I honestly feel for you and hope you get the help you dream about

OP posts:
pointythings · 18/01/2023 11:55

@Abigail69 but the three strikes laws have not reduced crime in the US. That's the whole point - they haven't worked.

Look at countries which have democracy and lower crime rates than we do, work out how that is achieved and make some changes. That is how you reduce crime.

Do you know how much it costs the taxpayer to keep people in jail? Meanwhile money invested in preventive strategies pays for itself several times over. Basically you and your kind want to waste money on revenge because it makes you feel good. It's very sad.

Eyerollcentral · 18/01/2023 12:13

Abigail69 · 18/01/2023 11:25

You are clearly lost for words and have no sensible counters hence the abuse.
I honestly feel for you and hope you get the help you dream about

Here’s an alternative, more actual policing in the community. You know the police officers knowing the people in the community they serve and gain the trust of them. Assisting them with problems. Identifying areas where vulnerable young people could get involved with crime and thinking about how to deter them. Rather than at the moment turning up and searching them based on their appearance and repeating that every day in life. That’s a suggestion, what do you think about that?

Kinnorafron · 18/01/2023 12:17

Please stop it - the OP isn't posting in earnest.

pointythings · 18/01/2023 12:22

Kinnorafron · 18/01/2023 12:17

Please stop it - the OP isn't posting in earnest.

Agreed, I'm out. This is either a bad faith post or someone so lacking in human decency it isn't worth engaging.