Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most MIL threads ..

141 replies

Treetrim · 01/01/2023 13:15

Make the MIL look quite normal but the DIL can seem seem odd, unkind , anxious and generally ungrateful.

OP posts:
lovelypidgeon · 01/01/2023 20:46

I think in relation to involvement with young grandchildren some MILs do need to remember that there IS a huge difference between their relationship with their DIL and the DIL's relationship with her own mother. The very early days of motherhood can be difficult- recovering from the physical issues of giving birth, getting to grips with breastfeeding, hormonal changes, lack of sleep etc. I think it's perfectly reasonable that a new mother feels more comfortable having her own mother around when she's dealing with these pretty personal changes than she does having someone she personally isn't as close to around. Too often I think people in general forget that the mother of a new baby has her own right to privacy and dignity. Personally I'm really happy that my DC have a strong relationship with all their grandparents and have enjoyed time alone being spoiled by them once they were old enough but when I felt vulnerable etc the only people I wanted around other than for short visits were DH and my own mother. I think a lot of MIL/DIL conflicts would be resolved more easily if MILs (and their friends and family) could see that this is not personal and doesn't mean that there is a competition between the 2 sets of grandparents from day 1.

Throwncrumbs · 01/01/2023 20:16

I should also add that your son allows you to be treated differently…it’s his home too!

Throwncrumbs · 01/01/2023 20:13

Forthelast · 01/01/2023 18:18

As difficult as that sounds, I would accept that my daughter might be comfortable with me dropping in unannounced but my Dil might prefer a bit of warning as her attitudes may well be different. My mum would be happy to see me in my joggers with the house in a tip but the dynamic would be different with mil who expects things to be a certain way for her darling boy. While I'm sorry you haven't to see them over Christmas and that does sound harsh, I would not take offense at being asked to check it's a good time before coming over. That's not unreasonable. It's a pity you know the arrangement is different with the other Gran but comparison is the thief of joy. You don't help yourself be describing it as having to make an appointment. That kind of prickliness will only exacerbate your dil's feelings of wanting to have things in place before you come over.

As you are a DIL you can only see from your perspective, I’m not going into detail, maybe you will see or feel differently when you become a MIL and you sons wife treats you differently.

Catsstillrock · 01/01/2023 19:50

The ‘fairness’ point is misguided, though. And if as a MIL you are thinking that way you need to stand back and readjust your approach.

focus on making your relationship with you son’s family as good as it can be, don’t track / count whether you are getting the same number of visits / treatment as your DILs own mother.

if they have a good relationship, you’ll never match it, which doesn’t mean you can’t have a good relationship of your own. But it will be different.

if you go in with a competitive (jealous?) mindset you’re creating some of those bad outcomes.

stuff like distance matters too. The poster complaining she’s didn’t see her grandchildren over Xmas gives no context. Where do they live? If it’s under an hour away, maybe she has a point.

We’ve not seen the PILs this Xmas but they live a plan ride away and they and DH left it too late to book (we traveled there every other year).

Forthelast · 01/01/2023 19:17

ancientgran · 01/01/2023 19:11

With one of my DsIL it is the opposite, she says her mother is very critical about the house, how she raises the baby giving lots of unwanted advice etc so she is more relaxed with me, I think our parenting styles are more in tune that she is with her mother as we are both a bit laid back, both breastfed babies where her mum didn't so maybe it is more about personalities sometimes.

Yes, I've known situations like that too. It all seems so easy from the outside looking in - just keep a lid on your thoughts and be kind. That would work regardless.

ancientgran · 01/01/2023 19:11

Forthelast · 01/01/2023 18:18

As difficult as that sounds, I would accept that my daughter might be comfortable with me dropping in unannounced but my Dil might prefer a bit of warning as her attitudes may well be different. My mum would be happy to see me in my joggers with the house in a tip but the dynamic would be different with mil who expects things to be a certain way for her darling boy. While I'm sorry you haven't to see them over Christmas and that does sound harsh, I would not take offense at being asked to check it's a good time before coming over. That's not unreasonable. It's a pity you know the arrangement is different with the other Gran but comparison is the thief of joy. You don't help yourself be describing it as having to make an appointment. That kind of prickliness will only exacerbate your dil's feelings of wanting to have things in place before you come over.

With one of my DsIL it is the opposite, she says her mother is very critical about the house, how she raises the baby giving lots of unwanted advice etc so she is more relaxed with me, I think our parenting styles are more in tune that she is with her mother as we are both a bit laid back, both breastfed babies where her mum didn't so maybe it is more about personalities sometimes.

ancientgran · 01/01/2023 19:02

scooobie · 01/01/2023 16:28

As someone who has a the MIL from hell, think childhood abuse which resulted in years of therapy for DH. I find it amusing to listen to others moan on about the annoying things theirs do. Which are often decidedly trivial and tbh I find those who will happily accept loads of childcare and then spend ages slagging off their PIL’s (& the way they look after their children) fairly abhorrent.

I know of one family where the 82 year old MIL picks up from school every day but the Mum hasn’t got a good word to say about her. Most of the vitriol is around the way MIL sometimes brings sweets to pick up. They wouldn’t be able to work without her. To use some cliches they don’t know how lucky they are and you don’t know what you’ve got ‘til it’s gone.

I've done lots of childcare and enabled the parents to save lots of money. My rule is if they are in my house it's my rules and the parents are fine with it as the ground rules are set. I wouldn't do something dangerous so car seats etc are enforced, I wouldn't do something that can't be changed when they leave my house like cutting their hair (although I've been tempted) but if I feel like giving them chips for dinner or a bar of chocolate as a treat I just do it or even watching cartoons when we've been busy and they need to lie on the sofa and chill for half an hour. I think that's the deal when you want free childcare, if you want someone who will pick wild honey berries from the top of a mountain for them then you can pay for it.

The children are well aware that the rules in my house in no way impact on mum and dad's rules, in their house they make the rules and if they say mum and dad don't let me I say that's fine as granny's rules only apply in granny's house.

GettingStuffed · 01/01/2023 18:41

As a MiL I took the view that I love my children and as their spouses love them too we automatically have something in common. Out of 6 grandchildren only one looks after my side and I admit I get a but miffed when DiLs friends say how much she looks like her mum.

I will admit she does have her mum's eyes.

thecatsthecats · 01/01/2023 18:36

Eh, I feel like MILs have the trickier end of the relationship because they have a lot more time to envision how they expect the relationship to be.

My MIL is lovely, but it's her plain and clear wish that her children and her best friend's children all be each other's best friends all live within a mile radius, spend all occasions together, and that all those who marry in forget their birth families and also live in this happy picture. I know this because in overexcited moments she has told me! (well, not the forgetting birth families bit - DH told me about that, she's pushed out his dad's side)

She's not a twat though, so whenever there's a change to this vision, you can see that she has a momentary "Oh shit" feeling, before she tells us that our plans sound lovely.

I think that the best think on both sides is to keep the invites open, and to hear yes and no, even when they are only implied.

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 01/01/2023 18:33

Stunning screamer absolutely and yes it does happen.

But if your child suddenly or gradually cut you off what would you do?

I would be questioning myself, why? Have I said something, do I like their partners? How are we different/alike/ would my company make them feel good or bad??

Am I cheery or am I a little miserable? What's going on for them? Am I respectfull, do I make them feel bad?

Surely for people we really love a little self reflection is the least we can do and then to ask nicely or apologize?

Forthelast · 01/01/2023 18:31

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 01/01/2023 18:24

For the last.

That's also a huge issue...the Dil being lazy, house a mess, washing out ..not dressed nicely.... obviously darling son can't be expected to do these things himself...it's her fault the lazy grasping hussy who used her feminine evil ways to override his unusual intellectual prowess to subdue him.

Yes. The young mother's own mum sees a person that she loves trying her best and tends to get stuck in while the mil tends to take notes and reflect how much better she did it and what a better life her poor tired son would have with a better coper. Not always be any stretch. But it's a natural reaction to care more about your own child. The baby is a lovely excitement to both grandparents but the maternal grandparent is the one whose excitement is tempered as she's more likely to worry about mum and make sure she's doing ok. It comes across as more humane to a vulnerable new mum. Not always but I often read about mils and think where is their compassion. Babies can be awfully difficult. It's not a competition about how much better you did it and it's not going to go well for you if you criticise and centre your own enjoyment.

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 01/01/2023 18:30

Another blooming I guess it depends on whether he's allowed to stick up for his wife?
Some men are in fog and they have a parents who doesn't care for their feelings, only whether they tow their line..

Stunningscreamer · 01/01/2023 18:29

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 01/01/2023 18:28

I think dh’s make a difference here.
My ds is a good dh and supports his dw, at the same time we have a good relationship with our ds and he wouldn’t allow us to be treated badly.
My dsil is the same. He supports his wife, our dd, but also loves his dp’s and has a good relationship with them.
I don’t understand men who throw their parents to the wolves when their dw’s are being unreasonable and I don’t understand men not pulling their parents up if they’re rude to the dil.

Very good point.

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 01/01/2023 18:28

I think dh’s make a difference here.
My ds is a good dh and supports his dw, at the same time we have a good relationship with our ds and he wouldn’t allow us to be treated badly.
My dsil is the same. He supports his wife, our dd, but also loves his dp’s and has a good relationship with them.
I don’t understand men who throw their parents to the wolves when their dw’s are being unreasonable and I don’t understand men not pulling their parents up if they’re rude to the dil.

Stunningscreamer · 01/01/2023 18:25

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 01/01/2023 18:09

This isn't a court of law where there are people to represent both sides?.it's a forum where people come to chat and people let off steam about all sorts of problems.

A huge problem is mother in law's...and I guess mils let off steam on gransnet?

It's a horrible thing to have a child with a man and then realise that his mother hates you and you have to share that child with someone who undermines you at every turn.

Equally though it would be a horrible thing to have a child and bring them up well only to have someone who hates you who comes into their life and excludes you. I'm not saying that that's common, I don't know and I haven't experienced it personally but I do believe it's possible and have read threads that sound that unreasonable.

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 01/01/2023 18:24

For the last.

That's also a huge issue...the Dil being lazy, house a mess, washing out ..not dressed nicely.... obviously darling son can't be expected to do these things himself...it's her fault the lazy grasping hussy who used her feminine evil ways to override his unusual intellectual prowess to subdue him.

Forthelast · 01/01/2023 18:23

sst1234 · 01/01/2023 16:19

It’s surprisingly common. A grandparent having the audacity to feed their child anything other than raw broccoli and tap water sets women off in this forum for some reason.

Yes. Because then you have a child with an upset tummy who won't eat their vegetables. It's a problem!

PurpleParrotfish · 01/01/2023 18:23

In the spirit of scientific enquiry I've looked at the four MIL threads linked as 'similar threads' below. As follows:

“PIL started inviting themselves to stay in our home for between 3-5 days every 3-4 weeks minimum & often would bring extra people we didn't know were coming. They would spend these visits ordering us around, taking over my baby as if they were the parents, undermining me, ignoring what I told them about baby and doing what they wanted anyway, treating us like kids (we are in our 30s and very independent). I was very overwhelmed with all the additional cooking, food shopping, cleaning and laundry that these visits caused.”
... plus a lot more
www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4607025-another-mil-thread

“My MIL ( who I get on very well with and who is a fab grandma ) has seriously pissed me off but as it is almost a one off I feel I should let it slide. But then I'm a resentful old cow so maybe it would be better if I said something.
Incident was that MIL was at our house this morning ( helping as she was asked due to a car issue - she is great like that) and then she asked my 10yo DS "Do you have your bag" - as they were leaving for school - "and have you put your lunch and everything in it?"
My DS answers "yep , it's there at the front door and mum packed it for me"
And then she YELLS ( and she is an ex- school principal, so she can do the loud voice really well)
"You are such a spoilt brat!" Twice.”
www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4594289-i-never-thought-i-would-start-a-mil-thread-but-here-we-are

“MIL only looks after ds once a week and, although very grateful, it’s making me uneasy. Her and FIL don’t listen to guidelines and, when we’ve picked him up, he’s been outside (on the front garden) in his pushchair, alone. He’s not even been out for a walk and left outside to continue sleeping! Just put in the pushchair and expected to sleep.”
www.mumsnet.com/talk/_chat/4636118-mil

“When ever I see my MiL she always makes a comment about my weight or hair or both on some occasions. In the 20 years I have known her not once has she been kind to me she bullies me and says unkind things about me . I have always been kind to her and never given her any reason to be unkind to me . My husband has only just started saying things like like her weight is because of her meds but this is only because I said to him it upsets me . For 18 years he never said anything he just let her carry on even though he knows it upsets me”
www.mumsnet.com/talk/relationships/4564438-mil

As a random-ish sample, make of them what you will, but I'm not sure these bear out the OP's theory that it's usually the DIL being precious and unreasonable.

Stunningscreamer · 01/01/2023 18:22

Catsstillrock · 01/01/2023 15:56

occasionally. But mostly it is, as others have said the MIL being disrespectful / interfering / controlling / trying to re-live their own years of mothering rather than considering that they are a grandmother now and should ask and follow their DILs lead not impose their ideas / choices.

i have a son and think hard about what I have learned from my MIL. It’s a long list of ‘DONTS ’:

  • don’t visit too early after the birth, insist on taking newborn out and then stay out too long.
  • don’t try to undermine breastfeeding (or mothers choice of how to feed her baby. If my DIL bottle feeds I’ll back her all the way)
  • don’t buy load and load of clothes for the children, insist they wear them, ignore children’s choices and tell them off for being ungrateful
  • don’t insist on a long visit to you booked before baby is born, then fill that visit with long days out and many hours in the car, and ask constantly why the baby is crying
  • Don’t wake the baby up when your husband tells you to
  • Don’t appear in your DILs bedroom at 5am saying you should take the newborn
  • dont push your DIL to go out for the evening, promise to call if newborn is distressed and then not call when they’re crying really hard.
  • don’t undermine your sons parenting, tell him to hit his children for discipline, tell him his wife is mothering / parenting wrong.
  • don’t tell your granddaughters they can’t play with cars as they’re a toy for boys
  • dont tell your grandsons they must have short hair otherwise people will think they’re a girl.
  • don’t talk a lot about how your grandchildren ‘don’t resemble anyone in the (your) family’. Strangers frequently tell your DIL her children strongly resemble her, it’s just you that has never noticed that. Or is DIL not part of your family, then?

I agree with absolutely all of these. But there are also a lot of posters along the lines of 'it's only natural to favour your own mother'. And I want my mum there but otherwise I just want it to be our little family for months. Or MiLs they're this, that and the other as if by giving birth to a son you're identical to every other woman who's given birth to a son. It's nonsense.

If you're not interfering or batshit, I think that would be very hurtful to be treated so differently/excluded.

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 01/01/2023 18:21

Blossom I'm sure I was fed custard but that's different in tart form which is quite stodgy

Forthelast · 01/01/2023 18:18

Throwncrumbs · 01/01/2023 17:23

I’m a Mil to my sons wife, I’m only asked to look after the children when her mum can’t do it, I have to phone and make an ‘appointment’ to see my son and grandchildren, her mum comes and goes as she pleases, if I made a comment about ‘I’m not buying for anyone not related to me’ I would be called out for it. I have said I’m not happy about being treated different, and I’m in the wrong. I’ve seen my grandchildren once in 7 weeks, not at all over Christmas…you tell me what’s wrong in this picture, I’m devastated.

As difficult as that sounds, I would accept that my daughter might be comfortable with me dropping in unannounced but my Dil might prefer a bit of warning as her attitudes may well be different. My mum would be happy to see me in my joggers with the house in a tip but the dynamic would be different with mil who expects things to be a certain way for her darling boy. While I'm sorry you haven't to see them over Christmas and that does sound harsh, I would not take offense at being asked to check it's a good time before coming over. That's not unreasonable. It's a pity you know the arrangement is different with the other Gran but comparison is the thief of joy. You don't help yourself be describing it as having to make an appointment. That kind of prickliness will only exacerbate your dil's feelings of wanting to have things in place before you come over.

Ladysodor · 01/01/2023 18:17

I shall be 60 this year, my MIL passed away last year at the age of 87. When I look back at some of the stupid fallouts we had years ago I feel embarrassed. I’m now watching my grown up family leave home and may soon step into the role of MIL, I’m seeing things through new eyes. Thankfully I managed to forge a good relationship with my MIL in later years.
I would say don’t let this phase of your life influence your future too much, not worth it.

elloelloello86 · 01/01/2023 18:16

Lesserspottedmama · 01/01/2023 18:06

I general perception is that the MILs often sound unhelpful and unsupportive which perhaps is the root of the DIL seemingly unreasonable overreactions to small issues. Raising children well is hard work, it does seem as if the current generation who are grandchildren to babies and young kids are not as willing to roll their sleeves up and be hands on in a way that is actually helpful, as much previous generations have done. And more often than not in laws seem to be worse for this than maternal grandparents. Or at least that’s the impression mumsnet gives.
my grandparents were devoted to their grandchildren, they found so much meaning and life satisfaction in investing in us (time more than money) and nurturing us. My kids grandparents are rather a self indulgent lot in comparison..

I agree.

On the day my husband and I told his parents we were expecting, his mother chimed in with "well don't be expecting childcare, I have done my time!" managing to piss me off, and make my husband feel like shit at the same time.

Weirdly, throughout the pregnancy she obsessively would ask how often my mum was planning to see the baby and if she was intending to babysit. I'd reply saying she seems keen to help out when she can, and I'd get a "well, each to their own, but my life is for living now".

And to this day, she makes her annoyance at my mum being around the kids very obvious, yet she doesn't actually want to spend time with them herself. She seems even angry that my mum wants to spend time with them and resents her for it. It's very strange. And has been incredibly difficult for my husband to process.

On top of that, if you looked at her social media you'd think she was a doting grandmother obsessed with her grandkids. When in reality, she's never shown an interest. My kids do love her though, and as they get older I could see them questioning why the attitude is so different from one grandparent to another. Not overly sure how I'd answer.

Flossflower · 01/01/2023 18:15

Forthelast · 01/01/2023 18:11

Sometimes. More often, no, the mil behaviour sounds childish and entitled. Personally I think the mumsnet demographic is ageing and the attitude to dils is shifting as a result.

Maybe the Mumsnet demographic is getting older as the original mum users are now much older, but have stayed.

Forthelast · 01/01/2023 18:11

Sometimes. More often, no, the mil behaviour sounds childish and entitled. Personally I think the mumsnet demographic is ageing and the attitude to dils is shifting as a result.