Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remove my kids from RHSP lessons?

231 replies

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 07:52

AIBU to ask if I am the only one who wants to do this? Has anyone here done this? Were there any negative consequences?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
SirVixofVixHall · 11/12/2022 12:18

DolphinWars · 11/12/2022 08:07

If you go to FWR boards there are posters who have written letters for this sort of thing, or they could advise with wording.

I agree with you though, and I would withdraw my child from these lessons.
No child should be taught gender as fact.

I agree too, and I would pull my dc out of any lessons teaching this.

SaturnaliaCalling · 11/12/2022 12:21

Any teaching materials that lobby groups like Mermaids, Stonewall and Gendered Intelligence have been anywhere near should be shown to parents, up front, with full transparency, so that parents can make an informed decision about whether their DC is ready to be taught about BDSM, other fetishes, contested theories of 'gender identity' and sex stereotypes, and controversial ideas around childhood sexuality in relation to adult desire.

It's the shroud of secrecy around these teaching materials that is a huge part of the problem.

rogdmum · 11/12/2022 12:26

I can’t speak about sex education in Scottish schools, but some absolutely do push Mermaids as a resource. The Scottish Government has refused to remove Mermaids as a recommended resource from their Transgender Guidance to Schools despite Mermaids current predicament and my daughter’s former school told me “it is not for the school to reject resources recommended by the Scottish Government”- despite them being aware of the safeguarding issues around the Mermaids Youth Forum months before the story broke in the press.

Notanotherone5 · 11/12/2022 12:27

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 09:19

Krakinou - the very problem is that disagreement is not permitted. One example of this was a class in which they were taught that kids were born TQ+ one child put their hand up and said that the internet might have something to do with it, many of the kids in the class agreed and the teacher told them that neither they (the teacher) nor the students were allowed to talk about that. That's not education, that's indoctrination.

So your kid has already had the lesson on gender identity? What are you concerned about - that they are going to have another one?

ScotsLassie322 · 11/12/2022 12:31

Managinggenzoclock · 11/12/2022 11:46

I work in schools across a geographical area. There is huge variation in what is taught even within local areas and even within academy chains. Don’t assume because it’s not happening in your particular school. It’s not scaremongering to suggest parents read carefully the resources. I assume the Op has done so which is why she is concerned and lists specific issues she has.

RSHP is Scottish specific and the lessons are online for all to find easily. This is taught nation wide ( bar Catholic schools).

Honestly don't know why I bother writing on here sometimes - the op clearly doesn't care for reality and just wants to pretend something is happening which isn't.

ScotsLassie322 · 11/12/2022 12:32

SaturnaliaCalling · 11/12/2022 12:21

Any teaching materials that lobby groups like Mermaids, Stonewall and Gendered Intelligence have been anywhere near should be shown to parents, up front, with full transparency, so that parents can make an informed decision about whether their DC is ready to be taught about BDSM, other fetishes, contested theories of 'gender identity' and sex stereotypes, and controversial ideas around childhood sexuality in relation to adult desire.

It's the shroud of secrecy around these teaching materials that is a huge part of the problem.

Google RSHP FFS.

Takes two minutes.

AAT65 · 11/12/2022 12:42

Can't reiterate more strongly that the WHOLE RSHP curriculum is online. Every single bloody lesson for every year stage. I am not teaching anything Mermaids related. You OP are scare mongering.

Underanothersky · 11/12/2022 12:49

AAT65 · 11/12/2022 12:42

Can't reiterate more strongly that the WHOLE RSHP curriculum is online. Every single bloody lesson for every year stage. I am not teaching anything Mermaids related. You OP are scare mongering.

I think you are wasting your time to be honest. People like the OP don't care about what is actually happening they just want to spread their false agenda and outrage.

randomusername02 · 11/12/2022 12:53

the slides for RSHP may be online but there is a vast diffference between what the pictures on the slides show and what words come out of the teachers mouth. When the SG is pushing through legislation that means any man can identify into a womans space, how the fuck are we expected to believe that schools (funded by the SG) arent equally pushing this agenda, especially when to question it is met with accusations of bigotry and transphobia.

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 12:59

Can't reiterate more strongly that the WHOLE RSHP curriculum is online. Every single bloody lesson for every year stage. I am not teaching anything Mermaids related. You OP are scare mongering.

I completely agree.

I am glad there are some sensible posters on this thread as if there are any parents who are slightly naive or unable to do their own research, they could easily believe these lies and pull their children out of lessons which are so incredibly important for them.

I want my child to be taught about consent, grooming, healthy relationships, control, abuse etc - as these are the things which have a massive impact on our children a future, especially females.

You just have to come on MN to see the damage that being in the wrong relationship can do and how many women are stuck in abusive relationships.

There is no point pushing your kid to do well in English, Science and Maths to become a doctor but stop them from doing these sorts of lessons.
If they don’t take care of their MH and self image, they could easily end up in an abusive relationship where they’re not allowed to work anyway.

Stompythedinosaur · 11/12/2022 13:02

I can see no reasonable rationale for trying to restrict dc learning about their own bodies, feelings etc.

Stopping teens hearing about trans issues at school is not going to stop them hearing about them.

You can share your own view at home too. That's what I do when my dc have a religious figure come in to speak about their faith - let the DC know that I don't agree and that they need to make up their own mind about what they think.

I'm not sure why discussion of sex toys with older dc is inappropriate, unless we are going back to the merry old days of "sex is only for reproduction and you aren't meant to enjoy it."

mumonherphone · 11/12/2022 13:07

I went to a primary school where religion was taught as 100% fact and I can remember my year 4 teacher talking about how it was wrong to be gay. (Late 90's) I'm not homophobic or very religious at all because of how I was raised at home. I think the messages you get at home are far more influential than anything taught at school. In your position op, I wouldn't withdraw from the lessons but be ready and waiting to talk about it with a cup of tea when your child gets home to offer your own perspective and awnser any questions.

My own child is year one and we're not there yet with sex education but my only concern is that he will be told things in primary school before I think he's old enough. Once he's old enough to have discussions about sex and gender I'm happy for him to hear different perspectives as well as my own opinion.

BigglyBee · 11/12/2022 13:08

Not every county in Scotland uses the same resources. In the Western Isles, there was such concern about what was being dictated that the entire council voted to use a Catholic resource instead (according to my children, same-sex relationships are mentioned but not really gone into in any depth). Obviously there are problems with that too, but I think they are easier to counteract that gender woo.

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2020/dec/28/western-isles-council-rejects-official-sex-ed-in-favour-of-catholic-teaching

BCBird · 11/12/2022 13:13

I'm.a teacher in England. We are being asked to teach content that previously was taught be specialists.i happy to talk about relationships but am concerned that I might say the wrong thing. I have not been asked to talk about gender yet,nor sex toys. Still time i suppose.

rogdmum · 11/12/2022 13:16

AAT65 · 11/12/2022 12:42

Can't reiterate more strongly that the WHOLE RSHP curriculum is online. Every single bloody lesson for every year stage. I am not teaching anything Mermaids related. You OP are scare mongering.

It’s great that you aren’t, but my personal experience is that some schools absolutely are and are signposting to Mermaids.

newnamethanks · 11/12/2022 13:19

Ridiculous. Are you the parent who had owned the Illustrated Human Body book I found in a charity shop? The one which had the 'naughty' pages glued together. Often think pityingly of the poor child to whom it had belonged. Why do some people think ignorance is something to be celebrated?

MajorCarolDanvers · 11/12/2022 13:19

You can't remove your child from one subject.

You can remove your child from school and either home school or send to a private school instead.

nottheoptics · 11/12/2022 13:21

The full lessons are available on the website. Teachers get all the resources from there. We were told to stick strictly to the script when delivering the lessons, so all they'll be taught is what's on the website. You can view it all in advance. How old is your child? Sounds like you've heard about it but not actually looked at the website yourself.

FancyFran · 11/12/2022 13:22

OP look at the lesson plan online and withdraw your child from any lesson you feel is unacceptable to you.
I have lived experience of a teen with gender dysphoria and it didn't come from sex education. It was trans activists off the Internet. Start now talking about who is what. I have always told my dc sex is fixed. I was hated for it. I stand by it and if you feel the same tell the teacher your thoughts. The numbers of ftm have jumped from some 2000 10 years ago to 20,000+. My child's education was ruined but not by her teachers. I urge you to talk to them often and openly. And my dc has changed their wants and desired future because I gathered all the facts. Good luck.

nottheoptics · 11/12/2022 13:23

Also in my experience if you withdraw them then their friends tell them some version of it in the playground later anyway, and it's never accurate, so they can end up with some really confused information.

OliveWah · 11/12/2022 13:26

Charley50 · 11/12/2022 10:26

@realmsofglory - I work with a lot of young people who identify as the opposite sex. Many of the ones I see are NOT happier once they change their 'gender identity.' They self-harm, they are school refusers, they isolate themselves and won't talk to their peers or adults (as their voice gives away their sex), they withdraw from learning and socialising, they are encouraged to have suicidal ideation and see themselves as victims, which impacts on their mental health. Yes some might be happy, but many are not. The happy ones are obsessed with their identity and get very upset if their actual sex (reality) is referred to. Staff are on eggshells around them.

Most also would grow up to be lesbians if it wasn't for this new ideology. They are so confused about their sexuality, they are excited about being able to take testosterone, they bind their breasts then faint at school. I have seen so much trauma in trans-identifying girls, and boys, but mainly girls. There are no positive lesbian role models being promoted at teens, it is all about being trans. It's terrible.

You're so right about the lack of lesbian role models for young girls. I count my family incredibly lucky that our eldest DD16 has had an openly gay woman (married to a woman, with children) as her Head of Year, all the way through school from year 7. She is in Year 11 now, and is out as a lesbian. She often says that Mrs XYZ is a real inspiration to her, and made it much easier for her to come out - particularly at school, where she does endure taunting and gay slurs, but knows she can always go to her HoY, who totally gets it.

Although as a family we have male gay friends as couples, we don't have any same sex lesbian couples in our lives, so having this example has been invaluable for our eldest DD. She has told me that when she first started to realise she liked girls, she did wonder if she might be trans, but I think having this role model at school made her see it's "ok to be a lesbian". I think, as in your post, young girls seem to think it'll be easier to be accepted as someone who loves women, if they themselves are "seen" as male. We need to support young lesbians, and let them know that being a woman who loves women is completely fine, nothing to be ashamed of and they do not need to start damaging their bodies with binding and unnecessary operations in order to love someone of the same sex

SheWontSheCantShesLeft · 11/12/2022 13:35

Why would you pull them out?

Surely what you do is ask for the specific content and then chat to your children after?

Pulling your children our feels performative. It places stress on teachers who are working really hard and you risk alienating your children by singling them out.

Surely better to explain your position to your children.

neverbeenskiing · 11/12/2022 13:35

I would be circulating information round all of the parents I knew.

What information?? OP has admitted she doesn't know what is being covered in these lessons, she hasn't asked and doesn't intend to!

Helleofabore · 11/12/2022 13:39

I remember during lockdown reading the slide pack my teen was sent home to read for a lesson (yr 10) and it contained the mermaids genderbread man. I took my teen through it myself to make sure there was no ‘wrong body’ narrative and that my teen fully understood that no one can change sex.

neverbeenskiing · 11/12/2022 13:45

the slides for RSHP may be online but there is a vast diffference between what the pictures on the slides show and what words come out of the teachers mouth.

But you could say this about any subject or any topic! Are you going to pull your kids out of every single lesson where there's a chance a Teacher might say something that doesn't align with your own beliefs?