Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remove my kids from RHSP lessons?

231 replies

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 07:52

AIBU to ask if I am the only one who wants to do this? Has anyone here done this? Were there any negative consequences?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Msloverlover · 11/12/2022 08:27

If you don’t agree with the teaching on gender identity, then that’s your call. I don’t agree with my school’s teachings on Christianity. But when my child is at home we discuss the fact that this is one perspective, one belief system and there are many more open to her. Closing down a child’s opportunity to be educated in such an important area as sex and relationships (particularly because of the prevalence of porn) I would consider to be extremely risky.

I could in no way trust myself to educate my child to the degree that is needed in these areas without the support of schools. They are witnessing day in and day out the kind of exposures children are getting, and tailoring their education accordingly. I did not grow up with the influences they have, therefore I feel that the advice and education I can give could be woefully behind the times.

Msloverlover · 11/12/2022 08:28

TidyDancer · 11/12/2022 08:25

This isn't a trusted source though is it? Given the content of what they push, how could it be?

This is one area of a HUGE subject. To take a child out of all lessons as a response to this is massive overkill.

Dacadactyl · 11/12/2022 08:29

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 08:01

It is the pushing of gender ideaology, linking to Mermaids in their resources etc, it's very very one sided, and their resources include very grownup things like advising that lubricant enhances the use of anal sex toys. I know my kids are surrounded by pornsick teens as it is and their innocence is long gone but these practices don't need to be endorsed by school.

I would be picketing the bloody school. Thats outrageous.

Sonyrecording · 11/12/2022 08:30

I understand your concerns. However I'm not sure what the benefit of taking them out of the classes will be, when their friends will just come out and tell them all about it.

Thereluctantgrownup · 11/12/2022 08:31

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 08:01

It is the pushing of gender ideaology, linking to Mermaids in their resources etc, it's very very one sided, and their resources include very grownup things like advising that lubricant enhances the use of anal sex toys. I know my kids are surrounded by pornsick teens as it is and their innocence is long gone but these practices don't need to be endorsed by school.

Are you sure that this is what is discussed in these lessons?

What is the problem with children learning that some people feel they are born in the wrong body? It doesn't mean that your children are going to decide this applies to them too!

Sex and relationship education (not just the scientific/biological aspect) of reproduction is so important for children. The more they know, the more they are able to keep themselves safe from harm, abuse and inappropriate relationships as they grow up!

Phyllistyne · 11/12/2022 08:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

FOJN · 11/12/2022 08:35

You might find this website useful OP. I'm surprised they are still signposting Mermaids after recent revelations and the Charity Commission investigation, I'd argue that's a significant safeguarding failure.

safeschoolsallianceuk.net/

TidyDancer · 11/12/2022 08:36

@Thereluctantgrownup gender ideology should not be taught as fact. Children rightly or wrongly (and in this case it is very much wrongly) unconsciously place a lot of faith in what they are taught in a school setting and a parent will not always be able to effectively undo the incorrect information they are given.

Dreamwhisper · 11/12/2022 08:37

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 08:01

It is the pushing of gender ideaology, linking to Mermaids in their resources etc, it's very very one sided, and their resources include very grownup things like advising that lubricant enhances the use of anal sex toys. I know my kids are surrounded by pornsick teens as it is and their innocence is long gone but these practices don't need to be endorsed by school.

Is this verifiable? Does anyone have the link that leads to the sex toy thing?

I don't know much about these charities; I've scoured their website but I can't see anything of the sort.

Reading their FAQ page it is clear that they are controversial though.

SirMingeALot · 11/12/2022 08:37

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 08:01

It is the pushing of gender ideaology, linking to Mermaids in their resources etc, it's very very one sided, and their resources include very grownup things like advising that lubricant enhances the use of anal sex toys. I know my kids are surrounded by pornsick teens as it is and their innocence is long gone but these practices don't need to be endorsed by school.

I'd start by raising my concerns that they're linking to Mermaids given the Charity Commission investigation and Breslow paedo support issue. See what school say to that.

Imthegingerbreadwoman · 11/12/2022 08:38

What year does this happen? Mybelsest is in year 5 and they have had basic sex Ed. I'm in England though. But I'm not wanting them to dicuss all the gender identity etc at such a young age. They don't need to even be thinking about this! Secondary school I can come to terms with but primary up to I think maybe year 8 they can just stick to reproduction etc. But that's my opinion

My friends daughter had some of this in year 6 and she came out of the lesson terribly confused where as she was none the wiser before.

ForfuckssakeEXHstopbeingatwat · 11/12/2022 08:40

There's a big difference between saying some people in God, some people believe you can change sex and become a woman / man and saying God does exist and it possible to change sex. The first are presented as a range of beliefs which can be taught as part of a discussion and helps students to understand why others may make choices they wouldn't. The second is misleading, wrong and shouldn't happen in a RS or Sex Ed lesson (I teach both).

As to sex toys etc, I think it's fine, for older students, to be told that sex isn't always easy or like they see in films and there are things that consenting adults use to help, enhance the experience but actually, beyond contraception methods and lubricant which has a fairly boring, mechanical but important function, I wouldn't be teaching about other toys. Teaching time is limited and it goes further than is needed at school.

I don't know the rules in Scotland re withdrawing and I get your concerns about being labelled bigoted. I would talk to your child at home and widen the viewpoint.

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 08:40

I don't trust anyone who holds metaphysical beliefs like "born in the wrong body". People I have spoken to agree and are shocked, but do nothing. It seems like the only rational response.

Even handed treatment of the Stonewall riots for instance would include the assault on Fred Sargeant at Pride - it doesn't. It does an absolute disservice to gay and lesbian children and young people and I am very confident I can give my kids a more evidence based, even handed education on these issues. Having to counteract propaganda they're getting from school makes this infinitely more complex and I don't like having to undermine the authority of teachers who are tasked with imposing this stuff. Learning requires a trust and attachment with teachers, drilling my kids on how XYX that they're being taught is either untrue or a gross distortion is confusing for them - they're there to be educated

OP posts:
Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 08:45

The former chief executive of this organisation was convicted for serious pedophilia

OP posts:
SpicyFoodRocks · 11/12/2022 08:46

I would just ask them what they were taught and have my own discussion with them later. Sharing my own views and beliefs and correcting anything I was not comfortable with. I reckon that would be a more useful educational experience overall than removing them from classes entirely.

I am surprised they are being taught about sex toys and don’t think it’s necessary. But I also don’t think it will scar them and would just silently eye-roll.

ExhaustedFlamingo · 11/12/2022 08:46

I don't especially care about them learning about sex toys etc. Feels a bit OTT perhaps (depending on the age) but I couldn't get worked up about this tbh.

However, teaching gender ideology as a fact and telling children that a woman can legitimately have a penis - I object to this very strongly. Gender ideology is harming young gay teens by pushing them towards adopting alternative gender identities rather than embracing their sexuality. Neither Stonewall or Mermaids offer balanced or honest information - and if the school is following their ideology, I'd have very significant concerns indeed.

ScotsLassie322 · 11/12/2022 08:47

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 08:01

It is the pushing of gender ideaology, linking to Mermaids in their resources etc, it's very very one sided, and their resources include very grownup things like advising that lubricant enhances the use of anal sex toys. I know my kids are surrounded by pornsick teens as it is and their innocence is long gone but these practices don't need to be endorsed by school.

What lesson is that in? Can you link here?
I'm a teacher and the lessons are all online. I must have missed that one.

Oh, you haven't seen 'the lesson' you're referring to? Is that right?

MargotChateau · 11/12/2022 08:48

Hmmm. I went to a Christian school then a non religious school (all scholarship schools so this was my parents choice for best schools academically rather than spiritually).

I am probably an anomaly, but I wasn’t allowed by my mother to do what we called Sex Ed, at any point during my schooling. I was popular, had two long term boyfriends at school, and waited till I felt ‘ready’ for sex when I turned 18 after I’d left school and had my first long term adult relationship.

I’m on the fence, if teens want to have sex etc than better they are informed to do it safely, but then how much does it encourage them? For me my mums tactic worked, I didn’t feel ready, it wasn’t normalised in my family to have sex before adulthood. My mother also told me sex has big adult consequences I wasn’t ready for, mental health, sexually transmitted diseases, and parenthood and I agreed with her tbh. I’d blame my disinterest in sex with boyfriends on my mother’s strictness.

It all really depends on the child. I was focused on academic success, and didn’t want anything to detract from getting into a good university. Gender and sexuality wasn’t a topic that was much discussed by adults or teens in the late 90’s in the schools I attended. There was one girl at my school who transitioned from female to male before I transferred to another school, and no one batted an eyelid, she (now he) then moved to a boys school. She was the youngest person in our country to change genders in our country, but no one seemed to care and she remained friends with all her old friends including me.

Now everything is available on the internet, teens have their own phones and the privacy to make calls to helplines etc like Mermaids if they want to ask questions. We were far too polite and didn’t ask our friend who transitioned any questions, it was just something she (then he) did and we actually weren’t that bothered (much more interested in Dolly Magazine and getting our paws on sketchers platform sneakers and hard candy nail polish and ring sets .

sorry if that’s unhelpful! 😂

FlamingJingleBells · 11/12/2022 08:50

www.bayswatersupport.org.uk/

PaterPower · 11/12/2022 08:50

”The more they know, the more they are able to keep themselves safe from harm, abuse and inappropriate relationships as they grow up!”

Unless what they’re ‘taught’ (indoctrinated in) is harmful in itself and is more about chipping away at safeguarding and the boundaries of children and young adults, than it is about providing neutral / useful information.

ValancyRedfern · 11/12/2022 08:50

In England you're only allowed to withdraw children from the 'sex' bit, so can't withdraw them from being taught it's possible to be born in the wrong body, and reinforcing gender stereotypes, despite that being explicitly against DfE guidelines. I'm not sure what the rule is in Scotland, but I would say first port of call is to raise the issue and ask to see full lesson plans. If they plead confidentiality, say you will come into school to look at them. Keep fighting. I'm a teacher and try my hardest but parent power is so much more powerful. Lots of help available from Feminism forum here and Safe Schools Alliance Website.

Beginningless · 11/12/2022 08:53

What is the problem with children learning that some people feel they are born in the wrong body? It doesn't mean that your children are going to decide this applies to them too!

If it were just this, like teaching your child about faith/belief - ‘some people have an idea that they have been born in the wrong body dear, and usually it’s because they have other issues affecting their sense of identity. We must never be horrible to someone because of what they believe, but it’s not possible for a human to change sex’. Absolutely fine. I have no problem.

But in schools, especially Scottish schools, they are teaching it as fact that anyone might want to change sex when they are older. This involves irreversible medical treatments. Lies are being told that they are reversible. By apparently sensible/ trustworthy institutions. The modern medical scandal of our time. The point is we need as few children as possible to decide this applies to them, because the damage to their body and mind is great.

It’s very sad that anyone is so confused about themselves that they think they can change sex. And that society supports that delusion. And even more sad they wait years for appropriate treatment and then just get affirmed, without adequate exploration of the underlying reasons they are so confused. As a society we need to be fucking rioting about this, our children are being harmed.

Imthegingerbreadwoman · 11/12/2022 08:54

So I just googled mermaids. Expecting the first couple of things to be about well mermaids, the fairy tale kind. Except the very first thing that popped up was mermaids as in the sex Ed etc. So now little kids who innocently Google mermaids wanting colouring pictures or to watch a video etc will get this too look at first of all. Good choice of name eh!

neverbeenskiing · 11/12/2022 08:56

I was going to ask about the lessons, but I know I won't like what they contain

Hang on, I'm confused. You want to pull your DC out of the lessons, but you don't know what is going to be taught in the lessons as you haven't asked? But you don't want to ask because you assume you won't like the answer? This makes no sense.

Swipe left for the next trending thread