Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remove my kids from RHSP lessons?

231 replies

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 07:52

AIBU to ask if I am the only one who wants to do this? Has anyone here done this? Were there any negative consequences?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MrsOvertonsWindow · 11/12/2022 11:33

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 11:20

@BravelyStunning Instead of attacking me, why not show me where it says on the website where it says about forced sexual contact or lesbians with a penis????

Or is it just another scare tactic by those who think sex education shouldn’t taught in schools??

As every year there is some reason why people are telling parents to pull their kids out of these lessons and it’s always absolute tripe.

I’m sure a couple of years ago they were saying how they forced the kids to watch porn 🤔

Of course this happens - I worked in a school where a Geography field trip was cancelled after the staff refused to allow a "trans" child to share a room with the opposite sex. The parents got a lobby group to threaten the school with "consequences" if they didn't allow this to happen - so the teachers refused to go on a trip where safeguarding was compromised. The trip was cancelled.

StressedOutMama7808 · 11/12/2022 11:33

BravelyStunning · 11/12/2022 11:28

@OMG12
agree with you re parental proactivity- a lot of these teachers are simply overgrown children themselves- though there are many who see exactly what is going on and want to do the right thing of course- but they're silenced

just read carefree's latest post- not even worth responding- she's fully indoctrinated

'Overgrown children'?

Please don't undermine all teachers based on a few you've come across.

thisismylittlebrotherGeorge · 11/12/2022 11:33

You are quite right OP.
I pulled my primary 5 out this year of specific lessons after reviewing the lesson plan.

This one in particular went in to far too much unnecessary detail for me.

To remove my kids from RHSP lessons?
Helleofabore · 11/12/2022 11:37

This is one of the issues with Girl Guides at the moment.

Overnight accommodation may include a male in a female tent and parents will not know that this potentially could happen because leaders are not allowed to make it known.

That an issue hasn’t happened is probably more to do with leaders actions rather than they strictly adhering to guidelines.

Qazwsxefv · 11/12/2022 11:40

Leaving aside the gender stuff for a moment I don’t think mentioning lube amd sex toys is a bad thing

when safe heterosexual sex is being taught - so “the condoms” bit not the “how babies are made bit” then talking about homosexual sex is just as important and needs to be done at the same time to give it parity and equality. 20yrs ago when we had to put condoms on bananas in a y9 science lesson it was all about straight sex, penises and vaginas only. I found it useful (although i pretended it was mortifying and a lark) as it was the first time I had opened/touched a condom and so did help prepare me a bit. But it would have been totally exclusionary for any LGB people whom were present as it was presented as PIV only. Also really mentioning lube would have made things so much easier - I didn’t know this was a normal thing to need to use until a lot later - thinking that the lube bit should happen biologically - would have saved me from some uncomfortable teenage sex! They Should give out lube with the free condoms!

it is v important that gay boys know they need to use condoms and lube. We’re way way past the 80s - HIV awareness is too low.

lesbian girls also should be included in the lesson although the condom bit is less relevant the sex toys might be

all of this can be taught with no reference to gender at all - we’re taking penises, vaginas and anuses, the gender of the person with the equipment is not needed in discussions about how to use the bits

OMG12 · 11/12/2022 11:40

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 11:16

And what about if she uses a gym where men and boys identifying as women use those facilities, should she have to hide away in a cubicle to facilitate the wants of men?

That would be up to the individual gym and whether it wants to keep its customers or not.

Usually the individual who is uncomfortable changing in their own sex room uses (or should use) the cubicle - not every other person in there.

on school trips what is the policy about boys who identify as girls? Which shared rooms would they sleep in?

Again, this is just scare tactics as it would never happen.
Can you imagine a room full of horny teens on a trip sharing rooms with the opposite sex - it would never happen.

You’re not answering the question though. Let me try and simplify it for you.

should a person with a penis be allowed in the same changing room as girls (and for avoidance of doubt girls do not have penises) It’s a yes or no if that helps!

should children who identify as the opposite sex to their original birth certificate be allowed to share a room with the sex they identify with or should they share a room with people who have same sex stated in their original birth certificate- again the answer is yes or no.

But from your answers that have repeatedly been given means that I would be removing my child from every class you teach until you can learn to be clear with your thoughts.

BravelyStunning · 11/12/2022 11:41

StressedOutMama7808 · 11/12/2022 11:33

'Overgrown children'?

Please don't undermine all teachers based on a few you've come across.

read my post- i didnt say all- i was very careful to note that there are "many" who are sensible and "silenced". i dont know how much clearer i can be

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 11:41

I'm a teacher in England.

Ask for resources because you have a wrong idea.

Yes, we teach about gender ideology but we don't mention Mermaids.

We don't teach about anal sex toys. It's more about consent, safe sex and what to do if you get pregnant.

I agree.

It’s funny how the actual teachers are saying none of this propaganda is actually taught, yet the people who’ve never stepped foot in a school are claiming that it absolutely does.

I can only imagine what would happen if a teacher said about forced sexual contact.
They would be sacked on the spot!

It’s funny how no one on here can link the part of the curriculum where it says anything even similar to the BS that is being spouted on here.

No school trip would be cancelled because one person refuses to share a room with the students of their sex FFS.

HeatwaveToNightshade · 11/12/2022 11:41

RudsyFarmer · 11/12/2022 10:56

This indoctrination about gender ideology is coming from everywhere so no I probably wouldn’t. I’d just have a very factual chat at home about what some people believe in the same way I do about religion. I’d emphasise the need to be respectful of other peoples beliefs and I’ve already taught my bear teen to keep a zipped mouth on contentious ‘gotcha’ issues as it’s not worth the hassle.

This is what I have done. DS1(14) is thankfully very sceptical of gender ideology anyway. He attends the classes and, knowing his school, there is probably a bias towards gender woo, but we have discussed tact and diplomacy around navigating everyday life. A boy in his class identifies as a girl and DS knows how to be respectful. He acknowledges that he can't put himself in this boy's shoes and that it is none of his business. He also understands that girls in his class may well have more to be concerned about and that it is very much their business if it impacts them.

Managinggenzoclock · 11/12/2022 11:44

I would not only withdraw my child I would also encourage others to do so.

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 11:44

should a person with a penis be allowed in the same changing room as girls (and for avoidance of doubt girls do not have penises) It’s a yes or no if that helps!

should children who identify as the opposite sex to their original birth certificate be allowed to share a room with the sex they identify with or should they share a room with people who have same sex stated in their original birth certificate- again the answer is yes or no.

No and No.

This does not happen in schools anyway.

I don’t know where you’re getting your information from but it’s wrong.

I would not let any of my students share with the opposite sex (hello unplanned pregnancy) and no other teacher or parent would either.

Us teachers are parents too.

Do you seriously think we want our children getting changed or sharing a room with a student of the opposite sex?

The answer is yes or no?

MichelleScarn · 11/12/2022 11:46

Usually the individual who is uncomfortable changing in their own sex room uses (or should use) the cubicle - not every other person in there
@CarefreeMe which room is that cubicle in though? The one of their own sex which would make sense, or are they still inserting themselves into the space of the opposite sex?

Managinggenzoclock · 11/12/2022 11:46

I work in schools across a geographical area. There is huge variation in what is taught even within local areas and even within academy chains. Don’t assume because it’s not happening in your particular school. It’s not scaremongering to suggest parents read carefully the resources. I assume the Op has done so which is why she is concerned and lists specific issues she has.

Charley50 · 11/12/2022 11:49

@CarefreeMe
I work in education, an FE College in England, and yes some of those resources are used. I've already said so on the thread.

There is a massive push to normalise trans identity over and above same-sex attraction. As trans, especially in girls, leads to medical and surgical intervention, this is wrong. Or do think that is OK?

It is also wrong to suggest you cm be born in the wrong body, and that you can go in facilities and sports opposite to your sex. Are you ok with that.
This is also being promoted. Another resource that has been used is by the Proud Trust. Check them out.

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 11:51

I assume the Op has done so which is why she is concerned and lists specific issues she has.

That’s the issue.

OP won’t read the lesson content as she thinks they’ll remove some of the content and hide it from her.

It is online and it seems absolutely fine.

Posters keep saying it teaches X, Y, Z but won’t link to where it actually says that.

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 11:55

which room is that cubicle in though? The one of their own sex which would make sense, or are they still inserting themselves into the space of the opposite sex?

From all the ones that I’ve heard about or seen, they are not in either space as they are unisex (so they don’t need as many) and can also used for people with disabilities who may not want to use the communal areas for various reasons.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 11/12/2022 11:57

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 11:41

I'm a teacher in England.

Ask for resources because you have a wrong idea.

Yes, we teach about gender ideology but we don't mention Mermaids.

We don't teach about anal sex toys. It's more about consent, safe sex and what to do if you get pregnant.

I agree.

It’s funny how the actual teachers are saying none of this propaganda is actually taught, yet the people who’ve never stepped foot in a school are claiming that it absolutely does.

I can only imagine what would happen if a teacher said about forced sexual contact.
They would be sacked on the spot!

It’s funny how no one on here can link the part of the curriculum where it says anything even similar to the BS that is being spouted on here.

No school trip would be cancelled because one person refuses to share a room with the students of their sex FFS.

The trip was cancelled. In fact it was a girl self IDing as a boy - new to the school with the other children unaware. The staff were concerned about the response of the teenage boys on the trip if it was discovered that she was a she (they were in single sex dormitories). The letter from the lobby group quoting the made up Stonewall law that she must be allowed to share with the boys put them in an impossible position as they were concerned for her safety should she be outed. They canceled the residential & did a number of day trips instead.

As a teacher of SRE I've read numerous resources for schools produced by many adult groups with a queer theory agenda and far too many of them are are age inappropriate, focus on extreme porn & gender ideology - more concerned with breaking down children's boundaries which is what queer theory is all about.

It's a child's right to have access to informed, age appropriate, factual and sensitive sex / relationships education. They also have the right be protected from those organisations cynically using schools as a vehicle to promote their niche ideological beliefs.

MichelleScarn · 11/12/2022 11:58

@CarefreeMe so you've found what ops school is teaching? Exactly this?
I always am a bit 🤔 when people are repeatedly saying 'why so worried? Nothing to see here, move along now and don't do any of that thinking for yourself to get an opinion'.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 11/12/2022 12:02

Transgender Trend have exposed some dire resources from various groups selling materials for schools and going intothem to advise teachers and sometimes "teach" SRE. Here's their take on the Proud Trust (who got government funding) for SRE resources. If you explore Transgender Trend's website they've researched numerous other organisations :

www.transgendertrend.com/proud-trust-nothing-proud/

IcakethereforeIam · 11/12/2022 12:02

I've read the thread and I'd like to ask that anyone with concerns considers following the link below. It's to a MN thread that links to a Government petition asking for genderwoo to be removed from RSE, but better worded. Please sign it and share it. Also check out some of the other petitions especially the one on the Equality Act

www.mumsnet.com/talk/petitions_noticeboard/4585082-rse-content-on-gender-vs-sex

I believe in Wales they have, or are trying to, make it impossible for parents to withdraw their kids from these lesson. They've introduced, or are trying to, a new curriculum that has genderwoo embedded throughout.

Yes, parents have been refused sight of materials citing copyright, a compromise was worked out but the parent must go into the school.

And it's not just Mermaids. Schools are getting outside organisations in to teach this stuff and many of them seem very dubious. Even, perhaps especially, the ones with child friendly names.

OMG12 · 11/12/2022 12:07

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 11:44

should a person with a penis be allowed in the same changing room as girls (and for avoidance of doubt girls do not have penises) It’s a yes or no if that helps!

should children who identify as the opposite sex to their original birth certificate be allowed to share a room with the sex they identify with or should they share a room with people who have same sex stated in their original birth certificate- again the answer is yes or no.

No and No.

This does not happen in schools anyway.

I don’t know where you’re getting your information from but it’s wrong.

I would not let any of my students share with the opposite sex (hello unplanned pregnancy) and no other teacher or parent would either.

Us teachers are parents too.

Do you seriously think we want our children getting changed or sharing a room with a student of the opposite sex?

The answer is yes or no?

Well the answer isn’t yes or no because “we” I assume refers to all teachers, not all teachers think the same, so the answer would be that some teachers hold ideologies which override the protection and wishes of other children.

I was trying to clarify whether you were a teacher who held those views.

it is not just about what happens in schools it is also about preparing children for the outside world where these things definitely happen (as they do in some schools - see other posts). Sex doesn’t happen in the classroom yet you teach children how to navigate that. How are you teaching that girl to navigate having a make bodied person in her changing room? To hide herself away to facilitate that man’s wishes or to stand up and tell the men (however ever they identify) that they should not be there.

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 12:12

@MichelleScarn

so you've found what ops school is teaching? Exactly this?

No because OP won’t ask - which in my book is a bit odd but nvm.

From the curriculum which the majority of schools follow (unless it’s a different school which OP would have probably mentioned) there is nothing untoward on it and it’s the same old BS we hear every year about why you should pull your kids out of these lessons.
This year it’s transgender issues.
Im not sure next year it will be something else.

Why do people think teachers are all peado, porn obsessed, surgery forcing, S&M addicts.

We are parents too.

We do not want our children exposed to certain things either.

Do people seriously think I would be happy with my autistic daughter being taught that forced sexual contact is ok?
Or that she should share a single sex space with a bunch of men?

Why have I not pulled my DD out of these lessons then?
Because these things aren’t taught and it’s just scare tactics.

oakleaffy · 11/12/2022 12:13

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 08:12

I'm in Scotland yes.

I'm not concerned about the teaching of reproduction, I'd be very happy if these lessons stuck to facts and evidence but unfortunately they seem to be a highly politicised lobbying group. Schoolchildren don't need to learn about sex toys.

Completely agree.
Sex toys and lube isn't necessary to know about at a young age. Ditto 'Mermaids'.

Justonecat · 11/12/2022 12:13

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 08:03

I was going to ask about the lessons, but I know I won't like what they contain and then that opens up a dialogue where I have to outline my concerns and the schools are already primed to receive any concerns as bigotry so I'd rather just avoid all that

I was just hoping someone else might have done similar

We did. Dd is in the library during those lessons. Our school tends to give a heads up in advance when these lessons are about to be held and so far it’s worked well.

This was partly at the request of Dd, who was in year 7 at the time and was beginning to feel really over informed by all the graphic sex discussions. I don’t believe one size fits all, and these discussions should be child led. Pushing this on children before they are ready for it is bad.

I also question why schools are giving detailed instructions for sex and contraceptives, yet fail to discuss the age of consent, which was the case for dd. Crazy if you ask me

Justonecat · 11/12/2022 12:18

But OP to answer you questions about how this was received by the school, in our case there was zero discussion, they didn’t question us over this at all. Dd is a late bloomer physically so maybe that helped them see our point in some ways. She hasn’t started puberty yet and these discussions felt premature for her.

She attends a big state secondary school.