Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To remove my kids from RHSP lessons?

231 replies

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 07:52

AIBU to ask if I am the only one who wants to do this? Has anyone here done this? Were there any negative consequences?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 10:43

I have just had a quick scan at RHSP.Scot and I cannot find anything that has been mentioned on here.

Please can someone direct me to where it says about lesbians with penis or forced sexual contact as right now it just seems like scare tactics.

OMG12 · 11/12/2022 10:44

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 10:39

I’m not in Scotland but I have taught PSHE myself and I would be reluctant to pull mine out without seeing the curriculum plan first.

The fact that you think the school is going to hide certain areas of the lesson plans from you, tells me your kids need to be in those lessons.

Firstly, you are not in the right frame of mind if you think that the school is conspiring against you by not including certain things.
Secondly, you are obviously not going to answer your kids questions yourself and so they need to be in an environment where they can ask and not be shut down by you.

This is a topic that isn’t going to go away by ignoring it - in fact you’re going to make it worse.

Like sex, drugs, porn etc if no one talks about it and makes it forbidden, they’re going to search it up on the internet and then find God knows what on there.

In the PSHE lessons we do cover transgender issues but they’re a tiny part of a much bigger picture.
I’ve never pushed any ideology onto any student and I don’t know any teacher that would - why would they?

The emphasis is on being happy in yourself and not having gender stereotypes and if someone wants to wear pink or blue then you treat them with the same respect you’d treat anyone else.

At the end of the day your kids are free to research it up on the internet by themselves but the internet is full of people who are fully for or fully against these issues - not the best thing for a self conscious teen.

A classroom is usually a much more unbiased view.

How would you answer a girl who says she doesn’t want a boy in her changing room seeing her naked or sharing a room on a trip just because he sees himself as a girl when you teach those lessons?

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 10:47

How would you answer a girl who says she doesn’t want a boy in her changing room seeing her naked or sharing a room on a trip just because he sees himself as a girl when you teach those lessons?

I would say that boys and girls do not share the same changing room (unless it’s primary school) as this doesn’t happen in secondary school.

And if there is any reason why an individual doesn’t feel comfortable getting changed in front of their peers then they can use the individual changing room or do things like come in wearing their PE top under their shirt like most teens do.

Helleofabore · 11/12/2022 10:49

realmsofglory · 11/12/2022 10:14

my sixth form dd has 2 girls in her year group who identify as boys and 1 who is gender fluid. She says they have gone from being unpleasant , unhappy people to being much happier as 'boys'
Does it really matter what the science is? It has turned around these young people's lives so why is it not okay to send the message to others feeling the same way, that it is ok ?

What are you making that assumption on? That they are happier as ‘boys’? Are they really? Or are there some confounding issues there that you will not know about unless you know those children and their families very well.

“It has turned around these young people's lives so why is it not okay to send the message to others feeling the same way, that it is ok ?”

Because even socially transitioning a child is not a neutral act. I recommend you do some reading around this issue and the potential for social contagion before you think ‘sending the message to others’ is the right thing. I say that as a parent who watched 5 of my teen’s friends, out of a group of 7, declare trans identities at 14.

This is an immense topic and has the potential to lead to life long medical patients. If you are interested, you might like to start with the interim Cass Report. Dr Hilary Cass has made clear that there are many issues around this issue. And that children who have comorbidities such as mental health issues, trauma including sex abuse, children who are diagnosed with ASD or ADHD, are homosexual and other issues are over represented in the current cohort of children and teens seeking transition.

This also includes girls seeking to escape the sexism and objectification that they are around them and in their future.

The majority are girls in this cohort.

It is yet unknown what the % of this cohort will be helped by transition, experts have said that at least 80% will desist by the time they reach adulthood. At what point does affirming a child leave them feeling they have little choice but to continue? When their school records have been changed, their family and friends have celebrated their transition, and everyone has had to adjust to the demands of new names…. If that child realises the impact, at what point are they reluctant to say ‘I am sorry, I got it wrong…’.

To me, that is why it is not okay to have well meaning people teach ideological based and not factual curriculum in school. Until more is known about gender identity in childhood, it should be handled very carefully.

Ofcourseshecan · 11/12/2022 10:51

FOJN · 11/12/2022 08:35

You might find this website useful OP. I'm surprised they are still signposting Mermaids after recent revelations and the Charity Commission investigation, I'd argue that's a significant safeguarding failure.

safeschoolsallianceuk.net/

Yes. I’m surprised a school isn’t taking more notice of this.

OMG12 · 11/12/2022 10:53

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 10:47

How would you answer a girl who says she doesn’t want a boy in her changing room seeing her naked or sharing a room on a trip just because he sees himself as a girl when you teach those lessons?

I would say that boys and girls do not share the same changing room (unless it’s primary school) as this doesn’t happen in secondary school.

And if there is any reason why an individual doesn’t feel comfortable getting changed in front of their peers then they can use the individual changing room or do things like come in wearing their PE top under their shirt like most teens do.

And what about if she uses a gym where men and boys identifying as women use those facilities, should she have to hide away in a cubicle to facilitate the wants of men?

on school trips what is the policy about boys who identify as girls? Which shared rooms would they sleep in?

HermioneWeasley · 11/12/2022 10:55

@realmsofglory because it’s a lie. They are not boys, they are girls and will grow up to be women. If they continue down this path they are highly likely to end up with irreversible medical treatments and permanent damage from breast binding. They should be told there is no wrong way to be a girl - they can fancy other girls, they can have short hair and trousers and any hobbies and interests they like, but their healthy bodies are perfect as they are.

Pumpkin20222 · 11/12/2022 10:55

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 09:19

Krakinou - the very problem is that disagreement is not permitted. One example of this was a class in which they were taught that kids were born TQ+ one child put their hand up and said that the internet might have something to do with it, many of the kids in the class agreed and the teacher told them that neither they (the teacher) nor the students were allowed to talk about that. That's not education, that's indoctrination.

That is scary - I would withdraw based on this type of incident. I would also put it in writing to the school a list of incidents that led to this action.

RudsyFarmer · 11/12/2022 10:56

This indoctrination about gender ideology is coming from everywhere so no I probably wouldn’t. I’d just have a very factual chat at home about what some people believe in the same way I do about religion. I’d emphasise the need to be respectful of other peoples beliefs and I’ve already taught my bear teen to keep a zipped mouth on contentious ‘gotcha’ issues as it’s not worth the hassle.

RudsyFarmer · 11/12/2022 10:57

*near teen

Helleofabore · 11/12/2022 10:58

gogohmm · 11/12/2022 09:39

@Nothingandnowhere

Have you met a trans person in real life? There are people (we have a relative) that even aged 4 knew they felt very different, they felt male but they had a girls body. He's a happy well adjusted 28 year old, so this was long before the explosion of trans stuff in the media etc. trans people have always existed too, there's cases from 300 years ago in literature

Yes. I do know trans people.

And your relative is not representative of the current cohort of teens and children who declare themselves as trans.

Even the authors of the Dutch Protocol, the treatment internationally adopted have admitted that this current cohort is very different.

Please do not base your assumptions on this current cohort on your relative. The first major difference is that your relative is male. And the majority of the current cohort is females. With potentially very difficult motivations for seeking transition

To base much of what is discussed on this thread on an older male transitioner is harmful to our teens.

BravelyStunning · 11/12/2022 11:05

@CarefreeMe · you are gaslighting op: "you are not in the right frame of mind"- how patronising!
do you realise that scotland is a whisper away from self-ID? promoted by sturgeon- so, yes, if the first minister's drunk the koolaid, it's entirely reasonable to be cynical about institutions such as schools
you are not the voice of reason that you think you are
it terrifies me that people like you are teaching pshe- you have no critical thinking skills and are benignly waving through a horrific ideology under the guise of "balance"- just because it's a small area, embedded among other topics doesn't make it more acceptable- how can you not see this!
you dismiss legitimate concerns as paranoid conspiracy theories- it's so easy for you to do that and us poor parents are constantly swimming against the tide- it's exhausting

OMG12 · 11/12/2022 11:12

BravelyStunning · 11/12/2022 11:05

@CarefreeMe · you are gaslighting op: "you are not in the right frame of mind"- how patronising!
do you realise that scotland is a whisper away from self-ID? promoted by sturgeon- so, yes, if the first minister's drunk the koolaid, it's entirely reasonable to be cynical about institutions such as schools
you are not the voice of reason that you think you are
it terrifies me that people like you are teaching pshe- you have no critical thinking skills and are benignly waving through a horrific ideology under the guise of "balance"- just because it's a small area, embedded among other topics doesn't make it more acceptable- how can you not see this!
you dismiss legitimate concerns as paranoid conspiracy theories- it's so easy for you to do that and us poor parents are constantly swimming against the tide- it's exhausting

Unfortunately people such as this don’t want to see it, it’s easier just to go a long with it! Unfortunately, their reluctance ir inability to critically analyse these things is damaging our children and parents need to take a very proactive stance to ensure that such things don’t damage their children. “teachers” like this are Mermaids dream as agents of indoctrination

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 11:16

And what about if she uses a gym where men and boys identifying as women use those facilities, should she have to hide away in a cubicle to facilitate the wants of men?

That would be up to the individual gym and whether it wants to keep its customers or not.

Usually the individual who is uncomfortable changing in their own sex room uses (or should use) the cubicle - not every other person in there.

on school trips what is the policy about boys who identify as girls? Which shared rooms would they sleep in?

Again, this is just scare tactics as it would never happen.
Can you imagine a room full of horny teens on a trip sharing rooms with the opposite sex - it would never happen.

DomPom47 · 11/12/2022 11:19

You can’t withdraw from the relationships aspects of the curriculum e.g different family types, healthy vs unhealthy relationships but you can withdraw from sex aspect e.g Sri’s and contraception. I would advise you go and speak to the schools PSHE coordinator and ask to see a few lessons. Going from my own childrens school experience and nieces and nephews their lessons have always been age appropriate and et well led by the teachers. Based in London of that makes any difference.

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 11:20

@BravelyStunning Instead of attacking me, why not show me where it says on the website where it says about forced sexual contact or lesbians with a penis????

Or is it just another scare tactic by those who think sex education shouldn’t taught in schools??

As every year there is some reason why people are telling parents to pull their kids out of these lessons and it’s always absolute tripe.

I’m sure a couple of years ago they were saying how they forced the kids to watch porn 🤔

Hellno44 · 11/12/2022 11:20

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 08:01

It is the pushing of gender ideaology, linking to Mermaids in their resources etc, it's very very one sided, and their resources include very grownup things like advising that lubricant enhances the use of anal sex toys. I know my kids are surrounded by pornsick teens as it is and their innocence is long gone but these practices don't need to be endorsed by school.

As a parent why can't you discuss these things with your kids. Talk though what they ate learning about. Tell them what makes you uncomfortable and why. Have a dialogue. All the other kids are going to talk about what they are learning.

BlueMediterranean · 11/12/2022 11:23

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 08:01

It is the pushing of gender ideaology, linking to Mermaids in their resources etc, it's very very one sided, and their resources include very grownup things like advising that lubricant enhances the use of anal sex toys. I know my kids are surrounded by pornsick teens as it is and their innocence is long gone but these practices don't need to be endorsed by school.

I'm a teacher in England.

Ask for resources because you have a wrong idea.

Yes, we teach about gender ideology but we don't mention Mermaids.

We don't teach about anal sex toys. It's more about consent, safe sex and what to do if you get pregnant.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 11/12/2022 11:24

Sadly parents are the last defence in ensuring that children get balanced views and not the lobby group dominated approach that children can be born in the wrong body with drugs and surgery curing their teenage angst.

Safe Schools Alliance have countless resources to help parents challenge schools and make sure that there's an age appropriate, balanced approach to SRE, not the porn soaked, fact free, anti women and girls narrative that's been pushed by groups like Mermaids, Stonewall etc:

safeschoolsallianceuk.net/

Charley50 · 11/12/2022 11:26

CarefreeMe · 11/12/2022 11:16

And what about if she uses a gym where men and boys identifying as women use those facilities, should she have to hide away in a cubicle to facilitate the wants of men?

That would be up to the individual gym and whether it wants to keep its customers or not.

Usually the individual who is uncomfortable changing in their own sex room uses (or should use) the cubicle - not every other person in there.

on school trips what is the policy about boys who identify as girls? Which shared rooms would they sleep in?

Again, this is just scare tactics as it would never happen.
Can you imagine a room full of horny teens on a trip sharing rooms with the opposite sex - it would never happen.

Actually those things have happened and schools use resources which promote them happening. The EDI person in my workplace used ( and shared with all other staff) resources from Gendered Intelligence which state that a young person should be in teams and use the facilities that they 'identify with.'

FrancescaContini · 11/12/2022 11:26

Nothingandnowhere · 11/12/2022 08:01

It is the pushing of gender ideaology, linking to Mermaids in their resources etc, it's very very one sided, and their resources include very grownup things like advising that lubricant enhances the use of anal sex toys. I know my kids are surrounded by pornsick teens as it is and their innocence is long gone but these practices don't need to be endorsed by school.

Nope. Totally unacceptable to push this on children. I’d be livid.

BravelyStunning · 11/12/2022 11:28

@OMG12
agree with you re parental proactivity- a lot of these teachers are simply overgrown children themselves- though there are many who see exactly what is going on and want to do the right thing of course- but they're silenced

just read carefree's latest post- not even worth responding- she's fully indoctrinated

FOJN · 11/12/2022 11:29

Can you direct me to where lesbians (or anybody) are forced to have sexual relations?

There are lots of examples of lesbians being abused for excluding transwoman (males) from their dating pool. Here is just one article from the BBC.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-57853385

Stonewall CEO, Nancy Kelly (a lesbian) branded lesbians who don't do penis as sexual fascists.

The "cotton ceiling" must be nearly a decade old, Google it.

The less said about Riley Dennis the better.

FOJN · 11/12/2022 11:30

Sexual racists not fascists.

Charley50 · 11/12/2022 11:33

@BlueMediterranean - but even the subject of consent and safe sex etc have been 'queered' and the language used in them uncoupled from actual sex, by many of the external providers.
I don't know who you use but Brook have been users by my workplace. They call girls 'cervix-owners.' Other companies don't acknowledge that issues with consent are primarily a male being 'pushy' or worse with females issue, and have case studies where females are trying to force themselves on males.

PHSE has just generally been corrupted and you have to be very careful which provider you use if you don't want ideologically captured resources used.

Swipe left for the next trending thread