Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think sometimes teaching assistants can do more harm than good

130 replies

IfIwannabe1 · 25/10/2022 21:42

I’m not in any way saying this is all TAs or that kids with SEN shouldn’t be entitled to support. However, my own DS is now in his early 20s and has ASD and had a TA when he’s in primary. My DS has a 4 year old who’s just started primary and I’m quite involved- do the school run each day so this is just what I have observed. Firstly, they often have no training or knowledge of ASD (or other forms of SEN) and so a lot of the time their methods can end up inflaming a situation (eg with ASD taking disrespect where none was intended and then trying to discipline which causes a meltdown). Secondly, very often TAs are mums with kids in the school which creates conflicts of interests and can often mean sensitive information about children’s needs can become school gate gossip and can damage a child socially. Finally, they will normally not have any teaching qualifications or academic experience so can sometimes end up confusing a child by teaching them something incorrectly or not being able to support them to actually learn content. Of course this isn’t all TAs but even the ones with the very best of intentions can fall into this trap. Does anyone else think this?

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 25/10/2022 21:48

I've never known a TA work in the same school that their children attend and no way would a TA 'gossip' to other parents about a child in their care.
What you are describing as a TA doesn't sound like any I have had experience with.

Whizzi24 · 25/10/2022 21:51

So in what way would the child with ASD be better supported by having no additional adults in the class?

Teaching assistants have a professional duty to keep their work life separate from their family life. I have worked with many TAs who have children in the same school. They never share sensitive information about children with other parents and if they did they woild be subject to disciplinary procedures.

Screwcorona · 25/10/2022 21:51

They are paid minimum wage...you're expectations are too high. I don't see the issues you have with any I've come across either. Most just genuinely want to help the children learn.

Jules912 · 25/10/2022 21:53

At my kids school TAs are not allowed to work in the same class ( and ideally not in the same year) as their own children even if they're a 1 to 1 for another child. However this is a big school, I can see how a smaller school wouldn't have enough TAs to shuffle around like this.

PortiaWithNoBreaks · 25/10/2022 21:53

Does your grandson have ASD as well or are you referring to your experiences with your son?

If you hear any sensitive or confidential information bandied about you need to report it to the head teacher. No staff should be gossiping about private matters.

It does sound like your expectations maybe need to be adjusted. It’s quite a low paying job and the entry requirements are low. You need to report to the class teacher anything that you find concerning regarding the behaviour of any TA.

Freshstarts22 · 25/10/2022 21:54

I think it’s really wrong that children with asd and ehcps are supported by TAs with no decent training on asd. That’s what the funding should be for.

PeekAtYou · 25/10/2022 21:57

TAs are on minimum wage. If they had teaching qualifications then they'd do a better paid job. If you think TAs should be trained better then lobby your MP. State education is chronically underfunded.

Somebody on here said that when they were in teacher training , there was only one afternoon of instruction in Special needs. That's all SN. I was shocked but it also made sense because it's reflective of how society treats people with different needs.

LimeTwists · 25/10/2022 21:57

As a very experienced teacher, I agree. I have had some TAs who have been absolute gems but also some who have told my pupils incorrect things and some allocated to pupils with needs that the TA has no training in or experience of. However, the job isn’t terribly well paid and it would be unreasonable of a school to expect to offer a low salary and still expect all sorts of knowledge. I’m usually just glad if anyone comes into my lesson to help at all!

JanePrentiss · 25/10/2022 21:58

A Ta should have rele ant training regarding a child's needs. All classroom staff should be aware of the need to know information from an EHCP or MSP, In depth if they becone a 1-1.

Any Ta should know not to discuss a child out of school and be aware of boundaries newreen staff and parent roles. School gate gossip should not be taking place from a school member of staff.

BritishDesiGirl · 25/10/2022 21:58

School gate gossip. It is against the rules to discuss anything related to children with anyone outside of the school. Even as a mum of children attending said school it is strictly confidential.

I'm a teacher and l never discussed children with their parents outside school. They had to call the school or arrange a meeting.

TAs or LSAs are trained to recognize the different forms of SEN and work very hard to ensure children's needs are being met. They are not there to do the teachers job. It is up to the the teacher to provide differentiated work for students. To recognise what their needs are and to work with the SEN to bridge the gap ( l call it) so that the young person can access the curriculum.

Academic or teaching qualifications- they don't need to have these they are not teachers. Also children are taught different things, differently all the time. When a Maths teacher teaches something one way, another might use a different method.

Teachers can all fall into the " traps" you have described. You sound very condescending.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 25/10/2022 22:00

LimeTwists · 25/10/2022 21:57

As a very experienced teacher, I agree. I have had some TAs who have been absolute gems but also some who have told my pupils incorrect things and some allocated to pupils with needs that the TA has no training in or experience of. However, the job isn’t terribly well paid and it would be unreasonable of a school to expect to offer a low salary and still expect all sorts of knowledge. I’m usually just glad if anyone comes into my lesson to help at all!

Also a teacher. This has also been my experience.

TwitTw00 · 25/10/2022 22:01

I've never worked in a school where training on ASD wasn't available for the TAs who most needed it. Also it's far from universal for TAs to teach at the school their children attend, to the extent I'd say that's the exception not the norm. It should be a higher paying role to attract good candidates though.

ihatethefuckingmuffin · 25/10/2022 22:01

Many tas I know especially 1-1 are ex teachers. Still want to work in a school but without mall the additional interference with their home/life balance.

Tas have signed contracts that include something about privacy. Gossip should be reported to the head every single time.

Tas who are 1-1 have had specific training either at their current school, previous school or privately.

If a TA is teaching back practices learning wise it’s on the teacher to pull them up.

Inset days are also attended by tas. A good school will also use some of this time to ensure methods used are practiced across the school.

BrendaHope · 25/10/2022 22:02

I don't think teachers have much training in SEN, if so, its very little.

Autumnisclose · 25/10/2022 22:02

I agree with you OP and I have had first hand experience of a gossiping TA who shouldn't be within a mile of a child with SEN.

Itstarts · 25/10/2022 22:04

98% of TAs, no. They are amazing.

2% (as with any job) create more problems then it's worth.

(Just an estimate. No, I have no figures to back that up)

In 11 years of teaching, I've only worked with 1 useless TA who just made my job 10x more difficult.

Every other TA I have ever worked with, either directly, or just as a colleague, have always understood the need for discretion and wouldn't dream of gossip, even when they've been parents at the school. If a TA is 1:1 with a child with ASD, they should have had ASD training. Ideally all TAs should, but I know that's not always the case. If they haven't, that's not the TAs fault, it's the school's responsibility to train them.

BrendaHope · 25/10/2022 22:04

I worked as a TA, have a good degree and experience parenting a child with SEN, which probably amounts to more knowledge of SEN than some of the less experienced teachers.

Upwiththelark76 · 25/10/2022 22:06

Youl be lucky to have any tas the way it’s going . Tas do an amazing job and we need to demand they get the pay and the status they deserve . Education would be a lot poorer without them .

FrownedUpon · 25/10/2022 22:11

There’s research showing that 1:1 TA support can be more harmful than helpful for a lot of pupils, I’ve seen a lot of children never develop independence or problem solving skills, because their TA does everything for them & yet parents are screaming for full time 1:1 for their child. Vey irritating.

leccybill · 25/10/2022 22:11

Teacher here (secondary).
Work with some brilliant ones - pro-active, knowledgeable, interested in the child, work with integrity. I've told them they'd make brilliant teachers! They don't fancy it.

Also, work with a few very poor ones. Really just sit and watch my lesson, go and get their coat and bag 5 min before the end so they can go for a cig as soon as the bell goes.

And a few inbetween. Ex-teachers are great. Young lads can take a good bit of 'steering' but eventually become great TAs.

You have to remember it's a minimum wage job. Sadly.

AntlerRose · 25/10/2022 22:17

To be honest i think SEN TAs should have an actual career path. With training and cpd and a proper salary. I appreciate the training might best be delivered whilst working and doing day release for a year or two, but i find the idea that our most vulnerable children with often complex needs get so much education delivered by a low paid job with no specific qualifications a real shame. In my sons ehcp we had to get specific training for staff written in to it, but not everyone does manage this.

I think if, as a country, we have decided on inclusion as the way forward, then we need to recognise that with specific sen qualifications with contracts more simikar to teacher onnes so the 18k a year is actually that and not pro rata. Someone said in ireland the sen tas get a proper salary.

Skiphopbump · 25/10/2022 22:20

My DS has had a few TAs over the years. The best one, who he had for a few years, taught him to read and provided him with growing independence and self esteem.

A couple just kept him ticking along. In primary his allocated TA was moved to another child and a year group TA was asked to step in - she didn’t want to but was forced too and all parents knew as she was a parent and didn’t keep the fact quiet.
At secondary he had a couple of good ones and one in particular who felt that she was wasting her time supporting DS!

We’ve had a variety from amazing (who we are still in touch with) to quite frankly damaging.

FarmerRefuted · 25/10/2022 22:22

I'm a former TA. While a TA doesn't have to have any specific qualifications, every school I've ever encountered expects a level two qualification as a minimum with the expectation that you are working towards (or willing to work towards) a level three diploma in supporting teaching and learning. SEN is discussed in all units of the level three qualification, including a specific unit on SEN support. Where an EHCP references specific provision for an individual child then training should be offered (and in my experience, almost always is) for example a child who had specific reference to Lego therapy in their EHCP, the LA arranged for someone from their SEND team to provide training in how to deliver this, ditto circle of friends, sensory circuits, etc. I had specific training relating to SALT due to supporting a child who needed this, a former colleague had training in Makaton to support a child who communicated using it.

Parent-volunteers everywhere I've worked are always put in classes away from their DC, even in small schools, due to the conflict of interest. I have never met a TA who has worked in their own child's class but if individual schools are doing this then that's a fault of those individual schools rather than indicative of the profession as a whole.

TAs fill a valuable role in supporting children who need more time and attention than one teacher can provide and who need support in order to access the same opportunities as the other children. Just because you've apparently met some shit ones doesn't mean they're all shit.

BarnacleNora · 25/10/2022 22:37

I'm a TA. I'm also an ex teacher who decided to step 'down' professionally and not have the stress and admin that being a teacher brings. I am extremely qualified and experienced in SEN and when I was teaching worked almost exclusively in SEN schools. I also have two children with SEN!

I agree that some TAs are inexperienced but that's not their fault. There's no training or qualification requirements although of course a decent school will make sure the right candidates are hired or invest in training. There is of course a massive funding crisis going on in education right now, as well as a huge hiring crisis. Plus a lot of children with SEN who really should be in a specialist provision but there's no space so they're stuck in mainstream with adults doing the best they can in unsuitable premises, class sizes and resources (stressful and unfair for all concerned, especially the children)

And in all honesty it can go the other way. I've had many an experience of a teacher not knowing what they're doing with SEN (because yes, the initial training is woeful and some teachers just don't keep up with cpd or don't have a chance to). So SO many times I've had a teacher take over what I've been doing with a child and interfere and make a situation worse without actually asking what I'm doing or what the aim is with my behaviour intervention. I'm a valuable resource, I know what I'm doing, it's why I've been hired-just use me rather than undermining me and making everything worse! Or, frustratingly I would get everything to do with SEN passed over to me, the planning, the interventions, everything. I would have to have a polite but firm conversation about the fact that I'm not there to plan and that this isn't a TA's job. Sadly this was happening even before I was a qualified teacher and 18 and fresh out of school-some teachers really just want to wash their hands of SEN pupils and it is a problem but one that should be resolved by alerting heads of year/school etc.

Anybody, parent or not who was discussing specific school or child issues outside of school would be facing instant disciplinary. It's a very standard clause in every contract and a common theme of inset day training. Hence why I have been very clear not to name specific examples from my current employment (or whether there are or aren't any!)

Anyway ultimately the issue is funding. Funding for better training for teachers and TAs. Better pay for all to make the job more attractive (I make about £7000 after tax and it is a hard job despite the 'easy' hours. Plus my wages then get topped up by in work benefits which doesn't seem to make much sense seeing as we're always the very maligned group who are 'trashing' the economy Hmm). Better and more specialist provision for SEN pupils who need it. We need to value education far more than we currently do and we need to value it for every child, not just those who are the perfectly average mainstream pupil.

Katapolts · 25/10/2022 22:40

A lot of this comes down to the teacher (and school).

Some teachers are very good at teaching children with SEN and utilising TA time in the best way to support the child.

Often unfortunately children with SEN are a bit of an afterthought on the planning and the teacher just expects the TA to 'manage' or 'occupy' the child with little thought as to what they are actually learning.