Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think sometimes teaching assistants can do more harm than good

130 replies

IfIwannabe1 · 25/10/2022 21:42

I’m not in any way saying this is all TAs or that kids with SEN shouldn’t be entitled to support. However, my own DS is now in his early 20s and has ASD and had a TA when he’s in primary. My DS has a 4 year old who’s just started primary and I’m quite involved- do the school run each day so this is just what I have observed. Firstly, they often have no training or knowledge of ASD (or other forms of SEN) and so a lot of the time their methods can end up inflaming a situation (eg with ASD taking disrespect where none was intended and then trying to discipline which causes a meltdown). Secondly, very often TAs are mums with kids in the school which creates conflicts of interests and can often mean sensitive information about children’s needs can become school gate gossip and can damage a child socially. Finally, they will normally not have any teaching qualifications or academic experience so can sometimes end up confusing a child by teaching them something incorrectly or not being able to support them to actually learn content. Of course this isn’t all TAs but even the ones with the very best of intentions can fall into this trap. Does anyone else think this?

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 26/10/2022 10:25

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 10:21

@Nanny0gg - no. In a word. I don’t find TA input helpful: that isn’t a personal observation, it is about the role. I’m not therefore going to spend hours running around, tracking people down and so on. It is actually a lot easier for me when they don’t engage, if I’m honest.

Then you don't seem to be considering the children in your class as it's pretty much a given that a proportion of them (even in top sets) may have issues that mean they can't keep up.

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 10:30

That’s where we will disagree @Nanny0gg . I don’t believe the only way to ensure they keep up is through a teaching assistant, who often isn’t a subject specialist anyway. That’s my role, as class teacher. I plan and differentiate and deliver and I am capable of doing that without extra input. Moreover, I find that extra input is detrimental to progress rather than accelerating it.

It is strange how the outlook over the last twenty years has swallowed the view that the only way some children can progress is having an untrained and unqualified adult attached to them.

My own opinion is that the role is badly paid, so to make up for this, immense gratitude is shown. TAs are told how valuable they are and what a good job they do as a replacement for a decent salary, and because it’s said so often everyone starts to believe it.

Repeating myself just in case I am twisted: that’s the role, not the individuals in the role.

dootball · 26/10/2022 10:45

I think there is quite a big difference between TAs at primary and secondary - especially in the lower end of primary - and that accounts for some of the different views on here.

I have taught in a secondary education for quite a while and have would agree than quite a few of the TAs I've had with me have been of no use (or worse than no use) for the class / indivudual.
The big problem I found was that when ever there was a TA who was really good they got given other 'more important' things to do that coming to actual lessons!
Also, plenty of the TAs that we had were unable to do the maths required with bottom set Y10 / Y11 and that makes it more difficult to be of assistance.

However, a couple of years ago I moved to a private school and the TAs are totally amazing - it's one of the biggest differences between state and private for me.

x2boys · 26/10/2022 10:45

Beautiful3 · 25/10/2022 23:02

I've been a TA, it's hard work and at the time it only paid £11,000 per year! Too much is expected from the TA. Honestly I believe disabled children should attend special schools, where I've worked. There's more training and knowledge regarding disabilities.

That's extremely naieve ,my son has complex disabilities and has always gone to a special school from reception, he's now in year 8 ,but the school is packed to rafters as it is as ate all the other LEA special school ,s ( we have two LEA special primary schools and two special high schools) there is not enough places for all children with disabilities and many children with the right support can thrive in mainstream.

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 10:47

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 10:30

That’s where we will disagree @Nanny0gg . I don’t believe the only way to ensure they keep up is through a teaching assistant, who often isn’t a subject specialist anyway. That’s my role, as class teacher. I plan and differentiate and deliver and I am capable of doing that without extra input. Moreover, I find that extra input is detrimental to progress rather than accelerating it.

It is strange how the outlook over the last twenty years has swallowed the view that the only way some children can progress is having an untrained and unqualified adult attached to them.

My own opinion is that the role is badly paid, so to make up for this, immense gratitude is shown. TAs are told how valuable they are and what a good job they do as a replacement for a decent salary, and because it’s said so often everyone starts to believe it.

Repeating myself just in case I am twisted: that’s the role, not the individuals in the role.

How can you ensure the needs of those with 1:1 specified and quantified in their EHCPs are met without a 1:1?

NiceTwin · 26/10/2022 10:49

Talking TA's in high school, they seem to be nothing more than crowd control, unless they are attached to a physically disabled pupil.
The pay isn't enough on the whole to attract educated people, but do they need to be if they are crowd control 🤷🏻

From what I have seen, there are good and bad. The bad can absolutely make the teacher's job more difficult. The good ones are worth their weight in gold.

dootball · 26/10/2022 10:52

@Thatsnotmycar
But isn't that part of the point of the threat - in that some TAs don't do that either?

rrf · 26/10/2022 10:52

@Anotherautumn "My own opinion is that the role is badly paid, so to make up for this, immense gratitude is shown. TAs are told how valuable they are and what a good job they do as a replacement for a decent salary, and because it’s said so often everyone starts to believe it."
I don't agree with the rest of what you've said, but this is certainly true. My issue is that, unless you have a proactive SENCO or head, who insists on staff training, you can SOMETIMES end up a glorified babysitter, or teaching children in ways that are not in line with their capabilities. Instead of making this about the TA, I think we should be looking to those higher up the chain of command who are not providing training in SEN to their staff. Unfortunately though, TAs are often bottom of the food chain and I don't forsee teachers banding together with TAs to make the classroom a better learning environment.

SnarkyBag · 26/10/2022 10:55

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 10:18

The poster I first quoted made a comment, I commented that doesn’t happen if the EHCP is good as training will be specified, which is a fact, simple or not. People can appeal, that is also fact. I didn’t once say the process was simple.

Parents may not have the knowledge which is why I said they should be supported to appeal. Legal advice isn’t necessary, and there are charities that can help fund independent reports if parents can’t afford them and they aren’t eligible for legal aid.

Provision should not be based on whether a parent is capable of fighting the LA.

No it shouldn’t, I didn’t say it should. But unfortunately the current system as it is means DC whose parents know the system, can advocate for their DC and enforce their DC’s rights get better support than those whose parents don’t know what should be provided &/or can’t or don’t, for whatever reason (and there are many, that’s not a criticism of any parents), advocate for their DC and enforce their rights. It shouldn’t be that way, but it is and parents should be supported to appeal.

Nor should parents be made to feel they have somehow failed their child if they don’t know how to navigate the system.

Good job I haven’t said this then.

Like I said I was responding to the over simplistic statement of “parents should appeal then”

You can’t post one sentence and then whinge because people haven’t guessed your full thoughts and opinions on the matter.

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 11:00

dootball · 26/10/2022 10:52

@Thatsnotmycar
But isn't that part of the point of the threat - in that some TAs don't do that either?

A good, trained 1:1 deployed correctly does meet a pupil’s needs if 1:1 is specified and quantified in their EHCP, and research shows can have a positive impact of engagement and attainment. If the 1:1 isn’t trained &/or deployed correctly then that is a different matter to whether 1:1 meets their needs.

Well if a 1:1 is specified and quantified in an EHCP, it has been deemed by someone with more SEN experience than the poster as ‘reasonably required’ (in a legal sense). So, how can they say they are meeting a pupil’s needs if they aren’t providing the support specified and quantified in the EHCP.

ChicaneOvenchips · 26/10/2022 11:02

If a member of school staff broke confidentiality they'd be sacked.

If the child has a diagnosis of ASC often the one to one LSA will be offered training, a cygnet or early bird course which is attended by both parent and LSA. There is also nothing stopping anyone not offered this the opportunity to learn a free level 2 understanding autism course. Unless the school does not support its staff or provide cpd, I find it hard to believe the member of staff will have had no training.

Many LSA's are qualified teachers or hold degrees in education, but are choosing to do the lower paid, lower stress job of the LSA over class teacher.

Having said all this, I have worked in a school where most TA's were unskilled and not trained, but that was 10 years ago and I'd hope things had changed by now (and in my more recent experience they have).

School under funding is a massive problem though, so poor education for all our children is inevitable (not through lack of trying by dedicated, good teachers).

SnarkyBag · 26/10/2022 11:02

rrf · 26/10/2022 10:52

@Anotherautumn "My own opinion is that the role is badly paid, so to make up for this, immense gratitude is shown. TAs are told how valuable they are and what a good job they do as a replacement for a decent salary, and because it’s said so often everyone starts to believe it."
I don't agree with the rest of what you've said, but this is certainly true. My issue is that, unless you have a proactive SENCO or head, who insists on staff training, you can SOMETIMES end up a glorified babysitter, or teaching children in ways that are not in line with their capabilities. Instead of making this about the TA, I think we should be looking to those higher up the chain of command who are not providing training in SEN to their staff. Unfortunately though, TAs are often bottom of the food chain and I don't forsee teachers banding together with TAs to make the classroom a better learning environment.

I agree totally.

There’s an odd culture in schools that the expectation is TA’s and teachers must martyr and sacrifice themselves for the good of the children and the cause. All in lieu of proper salaries, training and reasonable working hours.

I work in education but as an independent practitioner. I charge a reasonable sum for my time and I have to constantly manage expectations from school’s about that. There seems to be this unspoken belief that I will work til midnight to provide additional services and resources unpaid because that’s the culture of schools. I don’t and I won’t!

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 11:03

SnarkyBag · 26/10/2022 10:55

Like I said I was responding to the over simplistic statement of “parents should appeal then”

You can’t post one sentence and then whinge because people haven’t guessed your full thoughts and opinions on the matter.

Good EHCPs do specify the training. Many EHCPs are woolly and vague and aren’t good. The two aren’t mutually exclusive. I didn’t need to make the second point for the first to be an appropriate response to the poster.

Parents can appeal. No, the process isn’t simple. Yes, there is support out there and parents should be encouraged to appeal. Again, the two aren’t mutually exclusive. I didn’t need to expand on my “thoughts and opinions” as the process not being simple wasn’t related to the fact parents can appeal.

Yes DC whose parents know the system and can advocate get better support. No the system isn’t fair and shouldn’t be that way, but it is the current system. Again, the statements aren’t mutually exclusive.

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 11:04

@Thatsnotmycar i don’t send the TA out Smile

If the EHCP says they have 1:1 support then they have 1:1 support. It doesn’t mean that it is helpful.

@dootball that’s really interesting. What do they do that makes such a difference?

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 11:06

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 11:03

Good EHCPs do specify the training. Many EHCPs are woolly and vague and aren’t good. The two aren’t mutually exclusive. I didn’t need to make the second point for the first to be an appropriate response to the poster.

Parents can appeal. No, the process isn’t simple. Yes, there is support out there and parents should be encouraged to appeal. Again, the two aren’t mutually exclusive. I didn’t need to expand on my “thoughts and opinions” as the process not being simple wasn’t related to the fact parents can appeal.

Yes DC whose parents know the system and can advocate get better support. No the system isn’t fair and shouldn’t be that way, but it is the current system. Again, the statements aren’t mutually exclusive.

And actually since you are picking fault with my posts being simplistic. I didn’t post “parents should appeal then” but “They are, but then parents should appeal.” Which has much less attitude than you version ascribes.

thisisme2468 · 26/10/2022 11:06

I’ve experienced a couple of TAs like you described with no compassion and very unprofessional. I’ve also experienced TAs that go above and beyond. My autistic DD ended up having to come out of mainstream school in Y4 as it just wasn’t set up for her needs. And she isnt LD so we have no schools locally that would meet her needs at present.

Butchyrestingface · 26/10/2022 11:06

With the salary (hah!) they're on, TAs are one step above slave labour.

Afraid there would be no above and beyond heroics from me, if I were on their pay. Sad

SnarkyBag · 26/10/2022 11:08

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 11:03

Good EHCPs do specify the training. Many EHCPs are woolly and vague and aren’t good. The two aren’t mutually exclusive. I didn’t need to make the second point for the first to be an appropriate response to the poster.

Parents can appeal. No, the process isn’t simple. Yes, there is support out there and parents should be encouraged to appeal. Again, the two aren’t mutually exclusive. I didn’t need to expand on my “thoughts and opinions” as the process not being simple wasn’t related to the fact parents can appeal.

Yes DC whose parents know the system and can advocate get better support. No the system isn’t fair and shouldn’t be that way, but it is the current system. Again, the statements aren’t mutually exclusive.

I’m not sure you understand what mutually exclusive means tbh.

Anyway I’ll leave you there. Thanks for the debate 😊

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 11:14

I think I understand what @Thatsnotmycar is saying - that if a child’s EHCP states they need 1:1 support, then that’s because they do need it.

I am not sure that’s true, though. I did my GCSEs in 1997 and was back in the classroom in 2002, doing a PGCE and that was when I first came across the idea of 1:1 support - it was part of Blair’s education policy.

But are children with SEN actually better off because of it? Research is vague because we know a lot of children just weren’t diagnosed once.

All I can say is what I see. I don’t honestly believe the children in the classes I’ve taught have progressed because of their teaching assistants. I think there are ways the system could work better certainly, but I don’t think the appearance of a TA is needed as desperately as some posters think it is.

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 11:17

SnarkyBag · 26/10/2022 11:08

I’m not sure you understand what mutually exclusive means tbh.

Anyway I’ll leave you there. Thanks for the debate 😊

Yes, I do.

wonderstuff · 26/10/2022 11:18

Solid research backs up your instincts. If not properly directed and utilised TA can mean child gets less teacher time and as a result gets less quality instruction. I current economic climate I think schools are unlikely to be over using TA support and really having to justify their involvement. At my school my mantra is as little support as possible, as much as needed. We are seeing fewer children arriving at secondary completely dependent on TA support but it has happened that we have children arrive whose primary experience has been to be ‘contained’ by TA with little expectation of them being independent at all.

Good TAs are amazing, we have many fantastic people at my school, well qualified and making a huge difference to kids outcomes. There should be better training, pay and career progression for TAs and unqualified teachers. Like so much in the public sector schools rely on enormous amounts of goodwill. In the current climate fewer people are able to work for so little and we’re really struggling to recruit.

Jules912 · 26/10/2022 11:19

thisisme2468 · 26/10/2022 11:06

I’ve experienced a couple of TAs like you described with no compassion and very unprofessional. I’ve also experienced TAs that go above and beyond. My autistic DD ended up having to come out of mainstream school in Y4 as it just wasn’t set up for her needs. And she isnt LD so we have no schools locally that would meet her needs at present.

Where is she now? I'm hoping my year 2 DD will manage with more support but otherwise we will be in a very similar situation.

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 11:20

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 11:14

I think I understand what @Thatsnotmycar is saying - that if a child’s EHCP states they need 1:1 support, then that’s because they do need it.

I am not sure that’s true, though. I did my GCSEs in 1997 and was back in the classroom in 2002, doing a PGCE and that was when I first came across the idea of 1:1 support - it was part of Blair’s education policy.

But are children with SEN actually better off because of it? Research is vague because we know a lot of children just weren’t diagnosed once.

All I can say is what I see. I don’t honestly believe the children in the classes I’ve taught have progressed because of their teaching assistants. I think there are ways the system could work better certainly, but I don’t think the appearance of a TA is needed as desperately as some posters think it is.

If it’s specified and quantified in the EHCP it has been deemed as reasonably required by a least one expert report as provision in EHCPs is taken from reports, and for many who have to appeal also SENDIST.

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 11:23

I do understand what you mean, @Thatsnotmycar .

I suppose I’m thinking about when my DD had an ear infection. We took her to the GP who prescribed antibiotics: they didn’t work, we were prescribed antibiotics. We took her back. The GP said ‘what do you want me to do?’

I think sometimes it can be like that with the EHCP. If the only extra support available, because of cost or other reason, is a TA, then that’s all they can put forward. It doesn’t mean it helps.

(we went private to see an ENT - ears are fine!)

thisisme2468 · 26/10/2022 11:24

Jules912 · 26/10/2022 11:19

Where is she now? I'm hoping my year 2 DD will manage with more support but otherwise we will be in a very similar situation.

She’s being home educated at the moment. Y5 now so we’ve done a year. No idea where we will go from here. She’s starting to show interest in going back to school. She has an EHCP but that’s not helped.

Swipe left for the next trending thread