Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think sometimes teaching assistants can do more harm than good

130 replies

IfIwannabe1 · 25/10/2022 21:42

I’m not in any way saying this is all TAs or that kids with SEN shouldn’t be entitled to support. However, my own DS is now in his early 20s and has ASD and had a TA when he’s in primary. My DS has a 4 year old who’s just started primary and I’m quite involved- do the school run each day so this is just what I have observed. Firstly, they often have no training or knowledge of ASD (or other forms of SEN) and so a lot of the time their methods can end up inflaming a situation (eg with ASD taking disrespect where none was intended and then trying to discipline which causes a meltdown). Secondly, very often TAs are mums with kids in the school which creates conflicts of interests and can often mean sensitive information about children’s needs can become school gate gossip and can damage a child socially. Finally, they will normally not have any teaching qualifications or academic experience so can sometimes end up confusing a child by teaching them something incorrectly or not being able to support them to actually learn content. Of course this isn’t all TAs but even the ones with the very best of intentions can fall into this trap. Does anyone else think this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheHouseonHauntedHill · 26/10/2022 22:49

Op , let's say the ta has no Sen experience, and there was no ta , you will have one teacher,on a treadmill trying to get through x amount of work.

What on earth will that teacher do who ...also won't have any Sen experience? .
The problem isn't the Ta it's that there is no Sen knowledge in so many schools!!
.that's the real problem.

Then let's say the ta is expert in Sen but the teacher isn't ? Who do you think is going to have the final say or influence over that child?

It won't be the ta. ..

I know of a few highly trained ta and they are not understand or utilised in their school at all

Malfi · 26/10/2022 22:46

Puffalicious · 26/10/2022 22:38

Can I politely ask why a teacher would become a TA? The pay and conditions are awful.

While the pay is awful, the conditions may be considered better than those of a teacher by some -less stress, less responsibility, being able to finish work on time, no extra work in evenings or weekends.etc.

Puffalicious · 26/10/2022 22:38

CornishDelight · 26/10/2022 14:49

I am a TA. We get a lot of training on ASC and are lead by the SENCO who most certainly has a lot of expertise. I am an ex teacher with several years of teaching experience. I have 2 children with ASC myself. Several of my colleagues are ex teachers and I have to say all are amazing as regards understanding and handling neurodiversity.If you want examples of poor understanding and handling of autism look at the NHS, it’s dreadful.

Can I politely ask why a teacher would become a TA? The pay and conditions are awful.

Underanothersky · 26/10/2022 17:24

My child's TA is making the difference between her being in nursery and not.

CornishDelight · 26/10/2022 14:49

I am a TA. We get a lot of training on ASC and are lead by the SENCO who most certainly has a lot of expertise. I am an ex teacher with several years of teaching experience. I have 2 children with ASC myself. Several of my colleagues are ex teachers and I have to say all are amazing as regards understanding and handling neurodiversity.If you want examples of poor understanding and handling of autism look at the NHS, it’s dreadful.

Itstarts · 26/10/2022 14:01

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 13:13

Well no, but in those instances those children aren’t being served well.

It may be the lesser of two evils but it isn’t showing TAs are the best solution: the opposite in fact.

Exactly. For my 2 that are out most of the time, being with a TA and completing some work is better then being in class and completing no work and disrupting the other 30+ children.

The impact is directly dependent on TA capability though. Our TAs do have more training then most, and the approach we are using is a strategy for children with PDA, semi-structured schooling. It wouldn't be possible to pay 1:1 teachers in a state mainstream school for this. Of course a 1:1 trained SEN teacher would be best, but that's not possible.

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 13:54

I think this was the issue with the TA provision, @Thatsnotmycar - it was a cheap replacement for actual specialist provision, and as such isn’t hugely effective.

voiceofmarion · 26/10/2022 13:47

I think there is some truth in your statement. TAS can be great if they are on your side or don't have an agenda but some are outright dangerous and a liability. I had one bitch who fed back everything to mgmt and said my behaviour mgmt was not up to scratch etc in a tough class. She was sneaky and it just put me on tenterhooks having her in the class.

But it's the same with all colleagues-some are great and some are dangerous. Year heads can be the same, a good one is great for helping but others getting them involved is a nono as they are more of a liability than a help. I suppose it's just knowing who you can/can't trust.

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 13:22

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 13:13

Well no, but in those instances those children aren’t being served well.

It may be the lesser of two evils but it isn’t showing TAs are the best solution: the opposite in fact.

The pupils’ needs may not be being severed well, but many DC, for many reasons, are in MS when that may not be in their best interest. I think that’s a problem with the SEN system rather than a problem with TAs, and unfortunately the government thinking is only going in one direction. But there’s also (mostly!) a right to a mainstream education and some parents do think that being in MS meets their DC’s needs best, even if the pupil spends a large amount of time outside the classroom.

DS3’s needs are best met in a secondary MS, he is happy and thriving, but he has a personalised timetable and spends ~1\3 of the time outside of the classroom 1:1.

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 13:13

Well no, but in those instances those children aren’t being served well.

It may be the lesser of two evils but it isn’t showing TAs are the best solution: the opposite in fact.

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 13:04

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 12:48

@Itstarts - I think that clearly is showing why TA support doesn’t help.

The children with the highest needs are being removed from the classroom teacher and having the curriculum delivered by the TA.

Or it could show MS can’t meet the needs of some pupils regardless of what support is provided but it’s taking time to secure a SS place. Some DC in MS wouldn’t cope in the classroom full time regardless of what support is provided because the environment is too overwhelming/doesn’t meet their needs, that doesn’t mean having the TA doesn’t work/isn’t helpful.

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 13:01

gogohmm · 26/10/2022 12:43

@Itstarts

Not sure how long you have been teaching but it does make me wonder, why are there so many more children with Sen these days? My own daughter (now an adult) has asd, she had school support not 1:1, there were 4 in her class with additional needs. When I was at school it was none (there was a special needs school for the area but it wasn't large so they certainly didn't all go there).

It's not just recognition, it's definitely higher needs and I'm wondering why?

Probably a mixture of things, including better medical care for premature neonates meaning more are surviving but with complex needs, the pandemic hasn’t helped either.

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 12:59

thisisme2468 · 26/10/2022 12:12

I’ve requested it. I’ve tried to get information on it. I’ve requested a personal budget. I’m just getting ignored.

Unfortunately the LA don’t have to agree to an early review and there isn’t the right of appeal so you would have to wait for the annual review (when is it?) or request a reassessment of needs which does come with the right of appeal.

In addition inform the LA by emailing the Director of Children’s services you are no longer EHE and they need to arrange suitable alternative arrangements for DD’s education. You can then force them to provide something, although not to the level of what can be secured via EOTAS.

Not all LAs will give a personal budget to those EHE, and even when they do they
are mostly less than what can be secured via EOTAS.

If you start a thread on the SN boards there’s helpful who can advise and hold your hand.

Carryonmarion · 26/10/2022 12:58

I agree that this is true for some schools. Not SEN, but when my DCs were at their first primary years ago, all TAs were local mums who were also very PTA active types. They did not appear to be well- educated generally or be trained in their TA roles. The school was in an overall pretty affluent area but on the only council estate in the village. The other village school was failing so our's was the one they all wanted to come to. The TAs were all from the affluent areas and were openly judgy/ snobby about the council mums & their children. They also were indiscreet enough to do their gossiping within hearing distance of other parents.

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 12:48

@Itstarts - I think that clearly is showing why TA support doesn’t help.

The children with the highest needs are being removed from the classroom teacher and having the curriculum delivered by the TA.

gogohmm · 26/10/2022 12:43

@Itstarts

Not sure how long you have been teaching but it does make me wonder, why are there so many more children with Sen these days? My own daughter (now an adult) has asd, she had school support not 1:1, there were 4 in her class with additional needs. When I was at school it was none (there was a special needs school for the area but it wasn't large so they certainly didn't all go there).

It's not just recognition, it's definitely higher needs and I'm wondering why?

Itstarts · 26/10/2022 12:29

ldontWanna · 26/10/2022 11:41

Fair enough. Maybe it's different in secondary from primary.

Not in that respect. I'm primary mainstream (UKS2). 8 out of 34 with EHCPs. Another 9 with school support.

3 TAs. 2 1:1s who are actually rarely in class because their children can't cope. I print ppt lesson slides & work and give them a pack each morning. The other TA mostly runs interventions so is in a room next door calling out children 1 at a time or small groups. I still need to manage 6 children with EHCPs and 9 with School support in each lesson.

3 - check in with every 2/3 mins to make sure they are doing the task, not just staring into space.
2 - Check understanding as set the off and correct their misunderstanding immediately.
7 - provide scaffolding or differentiated work so they can achieve (3 different sets of differentiated work because all 7 are working at different stages but can loosely be grouped into 3 groups. Sometimes more, Sometimes less depending on the lesson)
2 - provide extra tasks for inputs because they struggle to engage with talk & discussions and need to just 'do'
1 - completely personalised curriculum. Check in and explain once I've set the rest of the class off.
2 - laptop for extended writing tasks.
4 - dyslexia dictionary
4 - noise cancelling headphones to aid concentration
2 - tasks need chunking

I know that's more then 15. Some children need more than 1 thing. I've probably forgotten some stuff. But this is all my job, not the TAs.

When I was in KS1, I mostly used my TA for reading and interventions out of class.

If a TA is needed for lesson input, then they need to do it outside the classroom so they can go at the child's pace. And that avoids the distraction too. Then come back to class for table work when ready.

But like I said upthread, most of the TAs I've worked with have been brilliant and completely competent to do so.

thisisme2468 · 26/10/2022 12:12

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 11:44

Have you considered EOTAS? DS1 has EOTAS as there isn’t a suitable school.

I’ve requested it. I’ve tried to get information on it. I’ve requested a personal budget. I’m just getting ignored.

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 11:44

thisisme2468 · 26/10/2022 11:24

She’s being home educated at the moment. Y5 now so we’ve done a year. No idea where we will go from here. She’s starting to show interest in going back to school. She has an EHCP but that’s not helped.

Have you considered EOTAS? DS1 has EOTAS as there isn’t a suitable school.

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 11:43

I think primary and secondary are very different, especially infants.

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 11:42

wonderstuff · 26/10/2022 11:28

I’m mainstream secondary and I’ve not seen an EHCP specify 1:1 TA support. They used to be funded in terms of x amount of TA hours and/or X teacher hours, but that never meant 1:1, but was a calculation of the required financial support. My county has phased that out and they now specify a bloc of funding. They will state x intervention happening at x frequency, which might be something 1:1, but that’s not 1:1 in class.

Then you have only seen rubbish EHCPs that are vague and woolly, many are. A good EHCP will specify and quantify provision. Your LA are acting unlawfully if they have a blanket policy of no 1:1 in lessons. DS3 is in MS secondary and has 1:1 for in class and other provision detailed, specified and quantified.

ldontWanna · 26/10/2022 11:41

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 11:38

@ldontWanna - I’ve had this conversation before on MN, and it always does baffle me a bit as it’s just teaching.

in the set up you describe -

So how do you manage a classroom with 10 kids on the SEN register that all have various needs and several things that need to happen daily to help with those needs? Two of them can't focus during input and have no short term memory retention . One has absence seizures so whether he's really listening or not is anyone's guess. One needs a scribe . Two struggle to write anything without an adult keeping them on task and giving them reminders. One kid needs daily OT exercises , especially if a long piece of writing work is planned in.I could keep going. That's without the usual interventions,task boards and now and next boards that need to be filled,checked and changed before every lesson. That's without any behavioural or SEMH issues.

How is one more adult going to change that, is my first question?

For the children who cannot focus and have no short term memory retention, that should be addressed with planning. They need instructions clearly either in front of them (I favour this personally) or the board.

If one needs a scribe then they would need a TA, but I am very dubious about this. Laptop would probably work better unless very severe physical need, especially for the child who needs OT exercises.

The adult keeping the child on task is me. I know it probably sounds as if I am being unnecessarily argumentative but the above group aren’t going to be magically transformed by another adult. If three kids don’t listen and can’t take anything in, one adult endlessly repeating instructions doesn’t really hugely help. It’s distracting for the others too. Much better for that being incorporated into planning.

Add to that group a child with medical needs that needs regular supervision,checks and treatment when needed. Sometimes several times a day. She also can't read or write and has behavioural issues and is known as a runner/hider

I can quite see that a child with medical needs requires support. But a child who genuinely can’t neither read nor write - as opposed to having poor reading and writing skills - if they really can’t do either at all - a mainstream secondary isn’t the place they can flourish.

Of course you have all the other kids in the class that come with their own issues and difficulties,even if that is just not getting the topic of that lesson

Yes - that’s my job too.

Fair enough. Maybe it's different in secondary from primary.

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 11:41

@AntlerRose yes absolutely. I should have specified that really.

Thatsnotmycar · 26/10/2022 11:39

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 11:23

I do understand what you mean, @Thatsnotmycar .

I suppose I’m thinking about when my DD had an ear infection. We took her to the GP who prescribed antibiotics: they didn’t work, we were prescribed antibiotics. We took her back. The GP said ‘what do you want me to do?’

I think sometimes it can be like that with the EHCP. If the only extra support available, because of cost or other reason, is a TA, then that’s all they can put forward. It doesn’t mean it helps.

(we went private to see an ENT - ears are fine!)

I see what you mean, and maybe to an extent it was it the past, I don’t know. But as the system currently is with many parents having to appeal it won’t be included unless it is actually needed. With an EHCP a TA wouldn’t be the only provision that could be included, and shouldn’t be included just because it’s easier/cheaper. The professionals assessing also have a responsibility to their profession to act professionally and stating provision is required when it isn’t is unprofessional.

In a good EHCP TA support will only be one part of the provision with e.g. therapies also being included. And yes many EHCPs are not good, but that doesn’t change the fact good EHCPs do provide more.

Anotherautumn · 26/10/2022 11:38

@ldontWanna - I’ve had this conversation before on MN, and it always does baffle me a bit as it’s just teaching.

in the set up you describe -

So how do you manage a classroom with 10 kids on the SEN register that all have various needs and several things that need to happen daily to help with those needs? Two of them can't focus during input and have no short term memory retention . One has absence seizures so whether he's really listening or not is anyone's guess. One needs a scribe . Two struggle to write anything without an adult keeping them on task and giving them reminders. One kid needs daily OT exercises , especially if a long piece of writing work is planned in.I could keep going. That's without the usual interventions,task boards and now and next boards that need to be filled,checked and changed before every lesson. That's without any behavioural or SEMH issues.

How is one more adult going to change that, is my first question?

For the children who cannot focus and have no short term memory retention, that should be addressed with planning. They need instructions clearly either in front of them (I favour this personally) or the board.

If one needs a scribe then they would need a TA, but I am very dubious about this. Laptop would probably work better unless very severe physical need, especially for the child who needs OT exercises.

The adult keeping the child on task is me. I know it probably sounds as if I am being unnecessarily argumentative but the above group aren’t going to be magically transformed by another adult. If three kids don’t listen and can’t take anything in, one adult endlessly repeating instructions doesn’t really hugely help. It’s distracting for the others too. Much better for that being incorporated into planning.

Add to that group a child with medical needs that needs regular supervision,checks and treatment when needed. Sometimes several times a day. She also can't read or write and has behavioural issues and is known as a runner/hider

I can quite see that a child with medical needs requires support. But a child who genuinely can’t neither read nor write - as opposed to having poor reading and writing skills - if they really can’t do either at all - a mainstream secondary isn’t the place they can flourish.

Of course you have all the other kids in the class that come with their own issues and difficulties,even if that is just not getting the topic of that lesson

Yes - that’s my job too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread