Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think sometimes teaching assistants can do more harm than good

130 replies

IfIwannabe1 · 25/10/2022 21:42

I’m not in any way saying this is all TAs or that kids with SEN shouldn’t be entitled to support. However, my own DS is now in his early 20s and has ASD and had a TA when he’s in primary. My DS has a 4 year old who’s just started primary and I’m quite involved- do the school run each day so this is just what I have observed. Firstly, they often have no training or knowledge of ASD (or other forms of SEN) and so a lot of the time their methods can end up inflaming a situation (eg with ASD taking disrespect where none was intended and then trying to discipline which causes a meltdown). Secondly, very often TAs are mums with kids in the school which creates conflicts of interests and can often mean sensitive information about children’s needs can become school gate gossip and can damage a child socially. Finally, they will normally not have any teaching qualifications or academic experience so can sometimes end up confusing a child by teaching them something incorrectly or not being able to support them to actually learn content. Of course this isn’t all TAs but even the ones with the very best of intentions can fall into this trap. Does anyone else think this?

OP posts:
Malfi · 25/10/2022 22:43

My daughter is a SEN TA. She has a first-class degree from a top RG university. She would never talk about the pupils.

Bemoredog · 25/10/2022 22:50

IfIwannabe1 · 25/10/2022 21:42

I’m not in any way saying this is all TAs or that kids with SEN shouldn’t be entitled to support. However, my own DS is now in his early 20s and has ASD and had a TA when he’s in primary. My DS has a 4 year old who’s just started primary and I’m quite involved- do the school run each day so this is just what I have observed. Firstly, they often have no training or knowledge of ASD (or other forms of SEN) and so a lot of the time their methods can end up inflaming a situation (eg with ASD taking disrespect where none was intended and then trying to discipline which causes a meltdown). Secondly, very often TAs are mums with kids in the school which creates conflicts of interests and can often mean sensitive information about children’s needs can become school gate gossip and can damage a child socially. Finally, they will normally not have any teaching qualifications or academic experience so can sometimes end up confusing a child by teaching them something incorrectly or not being able to support them to actually learn content. Of course this isn’t all TAs but even the ones with the very best of intentions can fall into this trap. Does anyone else think this?

Surely, this is more an issue of poor recruitment/training at the school.

TA's are also meant to act under the direction of a teacher.

I am a trained (level 3)TA with a lot of SEN training and experience. I earn exactly the same as I did in a supermarket where I had a staff discount and there was no expectation of any unpaid work.

Thatsnotmycar · 25/10/2022 22:56

Freshstarts22 · 25/10/2022 21:54

I think it’s really wrong that children with asd and ehcps are supported by TAs with no decent training on asd. That’s what the funding should be for.

A good EHCP will specify the training staff should have.

oakleaffy · 25/10/2022 22:56

No one employed or volunteering at a school would EVER 'gossip'.
Confidentiality is taken extremely seriously.
Anyone who broke this cardinal rule would surely be out on their ear.

Beautiful3 · 25/10/2022 23:02

I've been a TA, it's hard work and at the time it only paid £11,000 per year! Too much is expected from the TA. Honestly I believe disabled children should attend special schools, where I've worked. There's more training and knowledge regarding disabilities.

roundtable · 25/10/2022 23:03

Yanbu - there is a recruitment crisis and I'm the words of my head 'it's a warm body'.

Part of the reason I'm leaving.

I don't think it does any favours to pretend that every ta is up to it and every teacher is decent. Recent recruitment has been dire.

But the system is broken and the cracks are being papered over.

ldontWanna · 25/10/2022 23:03

The main issue is that TA's are severely underpaid so to pool of candidates is very small at the moment. Many schools struggle to recruit at all . So expecting a highly trained, highly educated candidate is unrealistic. Of course, that doesn't mean they don't exist.

Then there are issues with retention, in part because of the low pay and in part because of workload, being used and abused,added responsibilities, lack of respect etc.

A good school (with a good ethos and a good SLT) however, would support their staff and also ensure they are adequately trained for the role they're in even if it takes a while. That includes disability specific training, deescalation techniques and scripts , reasonable adjustments etc.

A good school would also take any privacy concerns seriously and deal with any breaches.

LargeglassofRosePlease · 25/10/2022 23:06

DifficultBloodyWoman · 25/10/2022 22:00

Also a teacher. This has also been my experience.

Me too. I agree with this ☝️

Thatsnotmycar · 25/10/2022 23:09

FrownedUpon · 25/10/2022 22:11

There’s research showing that 1:1 TA support can be more harmful than helpful for a lot of pupils, I’ve seen a lot of children never develop independence or problem solving skills, because their TA does everything for them & yet parents are screaming for full time 1:1 for their child. Vey irritating.

This is an argument LAs often unsuccessfully try to use at Tribunals, and it rather misrepresents the evidence. Sharples et al., 2015, which the government cite in their guidance, actually found TAs that are sufficiently trained and deployed correctly can have a positive impact on pupil engagement and attainment. Blatchford et al., 2012 is the other study often cited by LAs, but again that doesn’t say 1:1 is harmful, rather it warns about how 1:1 are deployed. A good TA used correctly promotes independence and certainly doesn’t do everything for the child.

LoveMyCats1 · 25/10/2022 23:10

Yanbu my friend just started as a TA as her kids are in the school. She's never done it before and straight away once a week she's left alone with the whole class when the teacher does her planning lessons. She has no idea what she's doing and has complained but apparently there's noobe else to do it. She just let's them play.

Sometimeswinning · 25/10/2022 23:11

I'm a TA. I take work home with me. Chat with other TAs regarding training and ways of handling situations.

We're exhausted at the end of terms because 1:1s (who arent actually 1:1s) are so intense and We're building relationships, forget about the others who also need it, we build it there aswell. 1:1s stipulated by an ehcp are asking where we are! Those who are not disruptive in behaviour, but also failing, parents are asking what we are doing to help.

You doing your school run is not involved. You are clueless.

My teacher considers children with challenging behaviour naughty. Parents should do more. I know this isn't the case so I'm also having to deal with his ego and expectations to be in class and do my interventions!

If only there were more of us!!! But carry on with your small minded mentality. I'll be honest, I'm going back to school next week and I'm dreading it. Not because I don't understand it but because there are too many children to cover. There's your problem!

Icecreamandapplepie · 25/10/2022 23:13

Another experienced teacher here agreeing.

Get a good one, they're worth their weight in gold. On the other hand...

DarkDarkNight · 25/10/2022 23:16

I know a few, one is a HLTA and can’t help but cringe at their spelling and grammar. I think if you’re a TA you should be able to use to/too and their/there/they’re correctly and not use phrases like ‘would of’ or words like brought when they mean bought.

There should be a basic level of education as it could actually be counterproductive.

Thurst · 25/10/2022 23:16

I work with SEN kids in schools most of the primary aged kids come with a 1-1 TA and mostly they are great. However, there are a number of children who are in a weird power dynamic with their TA where it is the TA’s need to be in control that is clearly the driving factor behind the ‘discipline’ and not what works to get the best out of the child. There are also the ‘over prompters’. They don’t give the kids time to think and constantly prompt them often outright giving them answers and ruining any assessment I’m trying to do. I’ve seen some autistic kids who don’t pick up a pen unless someone tells them too as they have become so dependent on being told what to do and not given the structure to work independently at all.

Sometimeswinning · 25/10/2022 23:26

DarkDarkNight · 25/10/2022 23:16

I know a few, one is a HLTA and can’t help but cringe at their spelling and grammar. I think if you’re a TA you should be able to use to/too and their/there/they’re correctly and not use phrases like ‘would of’ or words like brought when they mean bought.

There should be a basic level of education as it could actually be counterproductive.

Is this your biggest issue?? Where's your school? Any jobs going? It sounds a breeze!

I need to tell my teacher that this is your issue! He did say my handwritting is too small sometimes. So he may feel your pain!🤣

Veryverysadandold · 25/10/2022 23:28

Ex teacher and ex SEN TA here, notice the ex.
Both jobs made me mentally ill in various ways, but as pp have said, it boils down to underfunding.
Everyone in the system knows it's terrible but nothing changes. My last straw was a meeting where our manager told us it was only going to get worse because they literally couldn't recruit anyone because the wages were better at aldi and it's an easier job.
It broke my heart because I loved the children and was passionate about supporting them but the system seemed to be designed for them to fail. Some TA colleagues I had were brilliant, some didn't help the children much because the school was desperate for staff. The only advice I can think to give anyone is to not vote tory.

owo · 25/10/2022 23:28

I agree. I have 2 autistic children, who both attend special schools and the staff (including TAs) are well trained, and mostly patient and sympathetic.

However, both DC were in mainstream schools previously, and I don't know if it was bad luck (but this was across 3 schools, so unlikely), but the TAs were untrained, ignorant and their behaviour was often way below what I would expect from a random person off the street, nevermind a person employed to work with vulnerable children.

In some cases they did a lot of damage - yelling at children, physically manhandling them when it was totally unnecessary, and saying nasty things to them.

This was to my 2 children, who were nursery or primary age and completely non violent, not badly behaved, as reported by class teachers.

ldontWanna · 25/10/2022 23:32

DarkDarkNight · 25/10/2022 23:16

I know a few, one is a HLTA and can’t help but cringe at their spelling and grammar. I think if you’re a TA you should be able to use to/too and their/there/they’re correctly and not use phrases like ‘would of’ or words like brought when they mean bought.

There should be a basic level of education as it could actually be counterproductive.

There is a basic level of education. It doesn't necessarily help or change anything.

Just like there are plenty of teachers that make those same mistakes , despite going to university.

EddieVeddersfoxymop · 25/10/2022 23:34

As a TA, I'm so sad to read that some people think so little of us. Yes, there are good and bad - like every job. Every TA I know is dedicated, caring, highly trained and goes way above what's in the job description. Personally, I have 2 degrees, trained in all sorts from autism to food hygiene, first aid and dyslexia - the list is endless. I care about my kids so bloody much that I give them everything and often have "nothing " left for my own kids at the end of the day.

I'd hate to think parents at my school viewed us as harmful when we known these little people as well as our own. We are their safe spaces, trusted adults who encourage them, cheer them on and genuinely give a damn about the little successes that happen every day when we support them enough to flourish.

But - we do get paid abysmally and I cannot stay much longer because of that. Myself and many of my TA colleagues that have done the job for years will be lost to other roles because the pay is so poor for the responsibility we take with these wee souls.

hollyivysaurus · 25/10/2022 23:40

The TAs who support my son are wonderful. They have worked so hard with him. And as a secondary teacher I’ve worked with mostly good ones, with some phenomenal ones. Most are bloody invaluable! Last year I had one particularly crackers class with a high level of need and very high energy children and I breathed a sigh of relief each time the TA arrived (she only came for half the lesson) as I was beyond glad to see her!

Puffalicious · 25/10/2022 23:47

Freshstarts22 · 25/10/2022 21:54

I think it’s really wrong that children with asd and ehcps are supported by TAs with no decent training on asd. That’s what the funding should be for.

This.

The PSAs (pupil support assistants where I am) are completely amazing- so caring and essential- but they need paid FAR more and properly trained to be able to do their job even better than they do now. It's shocking what they get paid.

Academically, it must also be really stressful at times (I'm secondary)- having to know how to do so many subjects at a high level.

SnarkyBag · 25/10/2022 23:51

Thatsnotmycar · 25/10/2022 22:56

A good EHCP will specify the training staff should have.

Unfortunately most EHCP’s are shit

Catflapping · 25/10/2022 23:54

You keep saying ‘normally’ or ‘often’ but in my experience of working in schools for 10 years, the situations your describing rarely occur. Not suggesting they can’t, but this definitely isn’t the norm!

SnarkyBag · 25/10/2022 23:59

My son had TA support throughout primary. I would say his reception years TA was exactly as you describe but from yr1 onward his two TA’s who alternated were worth their bloody weight in gold!

His first TA was not kept on after her first year, a good school won’t keep a poor TA so if you’re seeing lots of bad ones then it’s a wider school issue IMO.

LadyWithLapdog · 26/10/2022 00:05

The TAs we’ve had have been amazing. I don’t know how some kids would cope without.

Swipe left for the next trending thread