Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Because I'm a gypsy

375 replies

Offendedgypsy · 31/08/2022 19:29

Today I was in a bakery and it was empty. I ordered what I wanted and the man behind the counter made small talk as he prepared it. He said to me, referring to my accent "you're not from around here are you?". He smiled as he said it. I simply said yes I've lived here all my life, I'm a gypsy that's probably why I sound different.

After this his entire demeanor changed. No more smiling and small talk, he dropped my order on the counter and made it clear he was in some way upset/offended by my presence.

To be honest I'm no stranger to racism against me and I have more tales of blatant racism than I care to count, but this encounter felt really upsetting.

Everything was fine until he found out my ethnicity. Why are people so hateful against gypsies? Do people seriously still tar us all with the same brush, when the whole world is fighting against racism to other minorities?

I'm just so sick of being one of the only cultures who just have to accept racism.

OP posts:
eldora · 01/09/2022 12:51

DownNative · 01/09/2022 12:32

Except the OP wasn't actually incorrect in stating Fury was "English gypsies and have some links to Irish Travellers".

A quick look at his ancestry would quickly indicate the phrase "some links to Irish Travellers" is correct, in fact.

It would be his fathers line where Fury has some Traveller link, but not on his Mother's Protestant line.

Likewise, Fury is incorrect in stating "all my people are from Ireland". If by "Ireland" he means the Republic of Ireland, he's incorrect. If by "Ireland" he means the Island of Ireland, he's incorrect too on account of his Mother's Protestant ancestral line.

His mother is from Belfast, Northern Ireland. Go back far enough and Fury will find his Protestant ancestors would have largely come from Scotland and/or England.

The gross oversimplification would actually be Tyson's "all my people are from Ireland" comment.

He can't even get an Irish passport which says a lot.

The point is 'some links' sounds like he has a friend or two in Ireland, whe in actual fact his dad and grandfather are from County Galway, Ireland, and you've just told me his mum is from Northern Ireland.

That's not some links, that's his ancestry Confused

KatRee · 01/09/2022 13:05

I can't believe people are telling the OP that she shouldn't mention her background, especially when it was directly relevant to the question she was asked about her accent! The guy in the bakery drew attention to it and enquired and OP gave an explanation

If I'm in my hometown and someone asks if I'm from round there as I don't have the accent, I'm going to say, 'yes, but I've lived in London for years' by way of explanation. There's nothing odd about offering a quick explanation to a query. Why should OP have to censor herself to avoid triggering people who are prejudiced?

Laiste · 01/09/2022 13:07

The line between Irish Traveller and Gypsy is a blurred one, then.

Having read the whole thing that is mainly what i've taken from this thread.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 01/09/2022 13:11

That was shit behaviour from him.

I accept people for who they are.

I'm sorry for his ignorance.

Unfortunately you're correct, all travellers are very much discriminated against for the actions of some members from the community that left the reputation of travellers in tatters.

DownNative · 01/09/2022 13:18

eldora · 01/09/2022 12:51

The point is 'some links' sounds like he has a friend or two in Ireland, whe in actual fact his dad and grandfather are from County Galway, Ireland, and you've just told me his mum is from Northern Ireland.

That's not some links, that's his ancestry Confused

I'm not sure why you're struggling to understand the crucial distinctions here.

Fury's mother being a Protestant from Belfast in Northern Ireland tells us all they weren't "Irish Travellers"!

Just because a person has ancestry in Northern Ireland or the Republic of Ireland, it is NOT a given they also have Irish Traveller ancestry.

Fury's ancestry tells us the ONLY Irish Traveller link he has is ONLY through his father's line.

That fits the statement "have some Irish Traveller links"! If Fury had it across matrilineal AND patrilineal lines, then and only then would you be correct in saying "that's his ancestry!" as though it's completely full of Traveller ancestry!

Since Fury doesn't, you aren't correct. His actual ancestry is Protestant and Catholic spanning the British Isles with some Traveller ancestry in the mix.

You do realise that Irish, Northern Irish and Irish Traveller are all separate identities, right? All are separated on census forms in the UK and ROI, right?

Grasp the distinctions first before anything else.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 01/09/2022 13:34

Not only that, but the OP is a Gypsy which is a totally different ethnicity to Irish Travellers, so your rant is even more ridiculous.

A lot of people don’t know the difference between a Gypsy or Irish travellers.

A Gypsy is a Gypsy to many people.

Both self refer as gypsies,
they're both are protected by the same discrimination act.

They both have different expectations when it comes to schooling.

Both live a unique lifestyles that have very similar cultural backgrounds.

Both lived away from society.

I live in an area that has always had travelling communities locally.

and many Irish travellers are now married to roma Gypsies.

I won't get into the rights and wrongs of certain people within the communities behaviour.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 01/09/2022 13:37

They both have different expectations when it comes to schooling.
From the schools POV I mean, absences etc aren't investigated like the school would investigate attendance of non traveller DC.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 01/09/2022 13:43

Tyson Furey is an Irish traveller. NI and English travellers from Irish ancestors also identify as Irish travellers.

There isn't Republic, NI, English travellers.

When Dh was a young child in Belfast Catholic the travelling community often defended the catholics and gave his dad odd jobs to make money as they identified as Irish too during the troubles.

When travellers misbehave in the UK they're branded Irish traveller not English travellers.

DownNative · 01/09/2022 14:02

EmeraldShamrock1 · 01/09/2022 13:43

Tyson Furey is an Irish traveller. NI and English travellers from Irish ancestors also identify as Irish travellers.

There isn't Republic, NI, English travellers.

When Dh was a young child in Belfast Catholic the travelling community often defended the catholics and gave his dad odd jobs to make money as they identified as Irish too during the troubles.

When travellers misbehave in the UK they're branded Irish traveller not English travellers.

As already shown, Fury is a British national with Catholic, Protestant and Irish Traveller ancestry.

His gloves with the Union Jack, St George's Cross and the colours of the Irish Tricolour attest to that.

Fury wanted a neutral anthem in respect of this when he fought Klitschko, but his opponent vetoed it, IIRC.

Calling himself Gypsy King will be a good part of the reason people view gypsy and traveller as interchangeable terms too. He's widely referred to as both.

Thatsthatthen87 · 01/09/2022 14:34

In my experience, no one dislikes travellers because of their race, it's everything to do with the fact that
, where I live, the areas around the sites are shit holes from the (sometimes literal) shit that's dumped there, they set up camp next to kids' playgrounds despite not being allowed to legally and there is extreme antisocial behaviour to the extent that pubs have had to close after being trashed during certain events.

I don't even know if a lot of people realise that it's a race issue or that they are being racist by complaining about them.

Thatsthatthen87 · 01/09/2022 14:37

Obviously, that's not me saying the guy in the bakery was right to be a dick to OP. Just in case that needs clarifying.

Hydrangeatea · 01/09/2022 14:59

How horrible for you :( (

We have 2 families of travellers living in our village and the children often use the term Gorja when they walk or cycle past you, they feel threatening as they say it. They always out stare at you and continue to stare at you as you have gone past, even though I have "known" them and lived in this area for over 20 years.

Some of them also use antisocial behaviour which they believe is acceptable but other residents don't feel it is acceptable so there is a general feeling of resentment towards them as a group of people. They allow their dog to bark constantly in the garden day and night as it is kept in an outside kennel, they park all over the small bits of green opposite their house with endless cars, pick up trucks, breakdown vehicles, broken down cars etc. They leave untaxed, uninsured cars all over the village in other streets, laybys etc - I even saw one of their broken down cars in a verge this morning, complete eye sore! They have taken over 2 fields with way too many horses and don't look after the land so it is full of poo, rubbish (the rubbish also spills over onto the footpaths and bridleways outside the fields they have taken over, piles of wood for bonfires, broken down stables, old cars, trailers, pick up trucks you name it. I have walked past this field to see the children urinating, the father urinating. They have chased my dog out of this field when she popped under the fence one day (it's not their field). They fly graze their horses on bits of land over the village which costs the council money removing. They drive their horses and carts so hard and fast around the village they have damaged cars and property, not to mention the treatment to the horses. They regularly don't water their horses and the villagers have to do it. I have witnessed cruelty to their animals in 1) tying a puppy to a piece of string and dragging it around after a car "for fun" and 2) kicking one of their ponies in the leg until it fell over - and much much more.

Not all of them behave in this way and some of them are nice and respectful of the village they live in. I regularly chat to them, have given them bits and bobs through the local freeads etc, they've also done some garden work for me. But unfortunately like in all societies some of them behave anti socially and then they all get tarred with the same brush. Infuriating as it may be, it's understandable how it happens.

Crumpleton · 01/09/2022 15:06

Thatsthatthen87 · 01/09/2022 14:34

In my experience, no one dislikes travellers because of their race, it's everything to do with the fact that
, where I live, the areas around the sites are shit holes from the (sometimes literal) shit that's dumped there, they set up camp next to kids' playgrounds despite not being allowed to legally and there is extreme antisocial behaviour to the extent that pubs have had to close after being trashed during certain events.

I don't even know if a lot of people realise that it's a race issue or that they are being racist by complaining about them.

Is it a race issue though?
Is the word racist being thrown around and used in the wrong context now?

Recently planning has been put in locally to extend an already large mosque, there's realistically no room and objections from ALL local creeds were made for many valid reasons...
People called it racist, looking for something that wasn't there.

Can you be a racist purely because you don't agree with another's opinion?

Can you be racist because you've looked at someone in a strange way or because you genuinely just don't like a person?
You're never going to get on with everyone in life.

In all honesty I think a majority of people have seen first hand at how SOME of the Gypsy/Travelling community behave and it's not always a pretty site.

NaLatchoDrom · 01/09/2022 15:11

Offendedgypsy · 01/09/2022 09:07

You'll never meet a gypsy who finds the word offensive, it's what we are and we are very proud of it.

Obviously I haven't seen the videos but it's likely that the people in the videos are either Irish travellers, or people claiming to be Romany Gypsy when there not.

We get a lot of people who want to be gypsies which is strange considering its no easy ride

I'll be honest I'd have cut small talk with you short too, because you don't get to speak for everyone.

We all, including me, carry our own prejudices and beliefs. Some of us still live and breathe Romnipen while trying to negotiate it in our modern world.

Many of us are very proud of exactly who we are and have no desire to be called Gypsy thanks. But if you choose to use it, it's a capital G.

It's a shortening of Little Egyptian. It had it's uses to hide behind for survival hundreds of years ago and if that's what you've been taught to call yourself and you don't like the way it gets translated then maybe it's time to reclaim who you are?

If you know your ethnic origins are Romany and your family have been intermarrying in England for three generations or more then you are Romanichal or Romany for short, protected under the equality act and if you speak it, (as language has suffered) you speak your own distinct dialect and use the English alphabet alone when writing.

Many of us are other branches and remain suprised to hear the word Gypsy added to Romani or used instead outside of dark humor within the community. Why would we voluntarily aid our own eradication?

I wish you well, we each tread our own path, but also to remember some of us have been fighting these battles for decades, and know and have lived through most (or all) of the whole post war history of developments and parliamentary acts.

We have fought for and over our civil rights, education rights, base school rights, language suppression, social services prejudice, religious discrimination, activism funding, forced assimilation, government, LA, and LEA manipulation, hostile environment policies, deportation, criminalisation, EU politics, and so, so, much more as well as repeated splintering and how and why the Gadje conspired to have everyone renamed as Traveler and confused as each other, and how those that took the funding helped.

There are reasons many of us refuse to be called Gypsy or Traveler or any name that lumps us in as some stereotypical fantasy and whatever the majority Gadje culture wants us to be.

Yummyplumthanksmum · 01/09/2022 15:13

@Crumpleton yes, it is a race issue covered by the Equality Act

EmeraldShamrock1 · 01/09/2022 15:15

As already shown, Fury is a British national with Catholic, Protestant and Irish Traveller ancestry.

Yes he is, like many British nationals whose ancestors arrived in the UK generations before them, they also identify with their culture while being a British national.

Fury's father arrived from Ireland forgetting generations before them.

I'd imagine it was a interesting run away marriage for his parents ATT when religious tensions where at an all time high in NI.

My uncle married a protestant lady from Belfast in the early 80's they fled to the UK too.

lollipoprainbow · 01/09/2022 15:29

@Crumpleton well said

apintortwo · 01/09/2022 15:50

I'm not surprised you are so upset about this encounter because it was such blatant racial discrimination...Make a formal complaint

And what would the OP be reporting exactly? She went in to purchase 'a sandwich and a biscuit' and was duly served, the same as any other customer.

The baker was most likely a decent man just doing his job, whose only fault was to fail to look at the OP endearingly after she volunteered unsolicited information.

I wouldn't be surprised if people in the future were advised to keep quiet and not engage - as you may run the risk of losing your job for not gushing over a self obsessed cultural warrior customer

lollipoprainbow · 01/09/2022 15:51

@apintortwo 👏👏

lollipoprainbow · 01/09/2022 15:53

@apintortwo calling the guy a cunt and baying for him to lose his job is unacceptable. The hysteria here is ridiculous.

DownNative · 01/09/2022 15:58

EmeraldShamrock1 · 01/09/2022 13:43

Tyson Furey is an Irish traveller. NI and English travellers from Irish ancestors also identify as Irish travellers.

There isn't Republic, NI, English travellers.

When Dh was a young child in Belfast Catholic the travelling community often defended the catholics and gave his dad odd jobs to make money as they identified as Irish too during the troubles.

When travellers misbehave in the UK they're branded Irish traveller not English travellers.

On the contrary, the UK does diffentiate between Irish, Scottish, English and Welsh gypsies and travellers as the attached image demonstrates. This is the meaning of the classification "Gypsy and Irish Traveller". It doesn't mean they all have Irish Traveller roots, but does suggest there is often interrelationships there as there is between English, Scottish, Northern Irish, Welsh and Irish.

The Roma get their own category too separate from Gypsies or Irish Travellers.

Because I'm a gypsy
DownNative · 01/09/2022 16:09

EmeraldShamrock1 · 01/09/2022 15:15

As already shown, Fury is a British national with Catholic, Protestant and Irish Traveller ancestry.

Yes he is, like many British nationals whose ancestors arrived in the UK generations before them, they also identify with their culture while being a British national.

Fury's father arrived from Ireland forgetting generations before them.

I'd imagine it was a interesting run away marriage for his parents ATT when religious tensions where at an all time high in NI.

My uncle married a protestant lady from Belfast in the early 80's they fled to the UK too.

My point there is Fury's ancestry WASN'T as a new incomer to the UK as his mother's Protestant line would have left Great Britain for what was then called Ireland.

His ancestry is like mine sans Irish Travellers as I have none. My Catholic aunt married my Protestant uncle in the late 1970s, IIRC. They never left Northern Ireland for Great Britain even though my uncle's parents did not approve of his marrying a Catholic albeit a Catholic Unionist.

Fury doesn't have one solitary identity which has been the point all along. Hence, the requirement to list all the identities he has as condensed in British and Irish.

he's a British national, but is NOT an Irish national.

Abitofalark · 01/09/2022 16:55

Yes, Fury is English born, with Irish and Northern Irish heritage from his parents. The gypsy king as he calls himself, is an English gypsy.

939300EJL · 02/09/2022 00:42

I can only speak how I see.
From personal experience I have had positive thoughts ie my daughter at school with three girls who’s Dad was definitely a traveler…all three now have professional jobs and all went to grammar school.The son is definitely going the traveller lifestyle..think he has actually had a good education and hopefully he will use it to educate others !

ldontWanna · 02/09/2022 07:57

apintortwo · 01/09/2022 15:50

I'm not surprised you are so upset about this encounter because it was such blatant racial discrimination...Make a formal complaint

And what would the OP be reporting exactly? She went in to purchase 'a sandwich and a biscuit' and was duly served, the same as any other customer.

The baker was most likely a decent man just doing his job, whose only fault was to fail to look at the OP endearingly after she volunteered unsolicited information.

I wouldn't be surprised if people in the future were advised to keep quiet and not engage - as you may run the risk of losing your job for not gushing over a self obsessed cultural warrior customer

Unsolicited? He asked her about her accent and where she is from. She answered.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread