Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Because I'm a gypsy

375 replies

Offendedgypsy · 31/08/2022 19:29

Today I was in a bakery and it was empty. I ordered what I wanted and the man behind the counter made small talk as he prepared it. He said to me, referring to my accent "you're not from around here are you?". He smiled as he said it. I simply said yes I've lived here all my life, I'm a gypsy that's probably why I sound different.

After this his entire demeanor changed. No more smiling and small talk, he dropped my order on the counter and made it clear he was in some way upset/offended by my presence.

To be honest I'm no stranger to racism against me and I have more tales of blatant racism than I care to count, but this encounter felt really upsetting.

Everything was fine until he found out my ethnicity. Why are people so hateful against gypsies? Do people seriously still tar us all with the same brush, when the whole world is fighting against racism to other minorities?

I'm just so sick of being one of the only cultures who just have to accept racism.

OP posts:
oakleaffy · 31/08/2022 23:45

Foggydog · 31/08/2022 22:23

I'm sorry that happened to you OP. Some people are twats.

I grew up in the 70s and there was a TV series called Kizzy about a Romany gypsy girl on the BBC. It was a brilliant and popular children's drama and Kizzy was a fearless heroine in the face of racism and bullying from the local community, it was quite daring TV at the time. Everyone at school wanted to live in a gypsy caravan because of that show. It looks very dated now but it's shame they haven't remade it.

nostalgiacentral.com/television/tv-by-decade/tv-shows-1970s/kizzy/

Kizzy was really memorable.

Spawned many “ New Age Travellers “ in 1970’s to buy a Cob and Bow top to travel around the countryside.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 31/08/2022 23:45

My ex-partner came from Liverpool. He was often told things like "better watch my hubcaps then" From the neighbours: "Our car is garaged at night so there is no danger of going to the car one day and finding that all the wheels have gone missing." "Where's your shell suit?" "What's the difference between Batman and a Scouser? Batman can go out without Robin."

And no, I am not comparing this with racism. I am using it as an example of people tarring everyone with the same brush, to use the OP's phrase.

alwaysmovingforwards · 31/08/2022 23:49

I've had about half a dozen encounters with Irish travellers in my time and every single time it has been incredibly negative to the point you just wished your paths had never crossed and that they'd fuck off asap.

But I'm open to giving everyone a chance and no doubt up until now I've just been very, very unlucky!

Llangfairpwllgwingychgogerychwyndroblllantisilio · 31/08/2022 23:49

SproutsAtChristmas · 31/08/2022 19:44

I think there is a huge lack of education about the gypsy and traveller communities in schools so the information people hear is just passed down by the local community and people love to spread negativity! We have a permanent traveller site near us and the children attend our local schools so I think it's a really missed opportunity for cultures to be shared so the misconceptions can be avoided.

^^ this.

I was brought up thinking the worst about travellers. I've educated myself about a lot of things and have a much better understanding of why different things are as they are. What matters most is we are all human and should be equal. But people don't see that. I wish it was easier and quicker to change people's preconceptions. I'd love to sit down and talk to you about your life, your culture, your experiences. Others don't see past a label and a reputation. And I'm really sorry about that. You're not unreasonable. And you should never have been treated so badly.

💐

LangClegsInSpace · 31/08/2022 23:52

user927 · 31/08/2022 22:16

Nobody asked anybody to share their experiences of the gypsy community, though, whether positive or negative. That wasn’t what the thread was about.

But she asked Why are people so hateful against gypsies? So people are just giving their experiences. Granted a lot of the examples are about travellers rather than Roma, but people are just answering her question. If she just wanted a rant about a horrible day she probably should have avoided that question as everyone knows that there are two very different sides/experiences to this debate

Imagine if someone asked, 'why are people so hateful against black people?' and half the replies were, 'here are the reasons I hate black people ...'

Irish Travellers and Romany Gypsies are protected by the Equality Act. It's unlawful to discriminate against them on the grounds of their ethnicity.

Pinkpeony2 · 31/08/2022 23:58

Romany Gypsies turn up every year in my village with large painted carriages, horses etc. They stay for one or two nights. They are friendly and very clean when they leave. And do you know what- the vast majority of the village is absolutely fine with them coming. They are pleasant and say good morning.
Irish travellers also used to come to a big green in our village. Break the gate down to get in. The noise all evening and night from the generator and dogs was extremely antisocial to all the people living around the green. A huge amount of litter and human feces was left. Cost a fortune to clean after they left. If you walked across the green you would be verbally abused even if you just kept your head down. Cars passing the green were pelted with stones and very sadly one person from the village captured a video of an Irish traveller killing a dog and disposing of it nearby. The dog was later found.
The Irish travellers stayed for 8 weeks. They came back every year at the same time until the area was properly secured.
Sadly people get the two ethnic groups mixed up / combine them. Any decent Irish travellers are having their reputation being trashed by those who are extremely antisocial

DixonD · 01/09/2022 00:00

It does seem to be more acceptable to be racist towards gypsies/travellers/Romanies for some reason, more than any other kinds of racism.

I’m proud of my gypsy heritage (my grandfather is a gypsy), and I know I’m not the only one. I’m on a few Facebook groups for researching Romany ancestry and there’s loads of people on there desperately trying to find Romany links.

Perhaps time will change things.

ConfusedGin · 01/09/2022 00:09

Sorry you experienced this OP.

I think part of the problem is that we, as a society, use terms race and ethnicity interchangeably without understanding the difference and interplay between the two.

Using dictionary definitions, race tends to be about physical characteristics like skin colour and hair texture. Ethnicity refers to inward characteristics like shared values, culture and heritage.

So (for me at least), it stands to reason that you have have people of different races sharing an ethnic background just as easily as people who look alike not sharing the same ethnicity.

I have pulled up HR when they commented about a lack of ethnic diversity in our largely white leadership team - I am descended from the Roma community, so whilst I may look the same as many colleagues it doesn't mean we are all the same ethnically.

And I'd put money on this man believing he's not racists if you're both white (assumptions my own). Unfortunately there's a long way to go to make people understand that when we talk about racism it's wider than skin colour. It's about protected characteristics including ethnicity and heritage.

I used to have a colleague from Asian descent who felt it was OK to call things substandard gypo and he continued to do so even after I had explained my family background and why it was inappropriate to say that.

Irishgene · 01/09/2022 00:14

@Offendedgypsy I'm so sorry that you have to deal with that so frequently x

pollyglot · 01/09/2022 00:25

Not sure why you had to bring up your background, though. If you were, like Meghan, bi- or multi-racial, would you comment, if someone remarked on your lustrous dark hair, for example, "oh yes, it's because I'm Black/Chinese/Italian"? If someone says "You're not from around here", why not just say "yes I am, been here all my life."

Mehlani · 01/09/2022 00:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Tutchytutchyfeelyfeely · 01/09/2022 00:46

CrapBag39 · 31/08/2022 19:34

YANBU and he’s a cunt.

This👆

DanielTheGhostGangbanger · 01/09/2022 00:46

I think OP you have your answer.

Lots of people have had extremely negative experiences with Irish travellers, and in many cases this will be their only personal experience. Travellers often describe themselves as gypsies, hence being all lumped together. Many areas still experience real issues when travellers visit their town, and so the negativity persists.

FWIW, I have quite strong Romany gypsy heritage, just a couple of generations back. My mum has lots of wonderful stories about my great grandmother and her family.

Unsociable, unacceptable conduct which persists by a portion of the traveller community will make it very hard for anyone describing themselves as a gypsy. It’s deeply unfair and shouldn’t be the case, but that’s at the heart of it.

It’s also not been helped by xenophobic right-wing Brexiteer types who got whipped up into a frenzy by talk of “pickpocket gypsies” about to flood in from Eastern Europe.

I’m sorry the bakery guy was rude to you. It’s not ok on any level.

Mehlani · 01/09/2022 00:54

Replace the word Gypsies with another race and nobody would even dream of saying it.

They would though.

Let's use English people for arguments sake. Replace English with a more marginalised race If you like.

If English people went around behaving the way a large % of the Irish travelling community do then best believe we would be condemned for it.

I say iritsh travelling community and not gypsy as its groups of the IT community who are responsible for the behaviour that begets the reputation, the gypsies / showmen are tarred with a brush that is nothing to do with them.

Instead of shouting off about racism perhaps the ones responsible for the behaviour, and we know its not a small number of people, should pour some of that energy into taking a stand against the behaviour that drags the rest of the community down.

I don't know of any other ethnicity where such behaviour is so common and I live in the most diverse part of the country.

DanielTheGhostGangbanger · 01/09/2022 01:05

Mehlani · 01/09/2022 00:54

Replace the word Gypsies with another race and nobody would even dream of saying it.

They would though.

Let's use English people for arguments sake. Replace English with a more marginalised race If you like.

If English people went around behaving the way a large % of the Irish travelling community do then best believe we would be condemned for it.

I say iritsh travelling community and not gypsy as its groups of the IT community who are responsible for the behaviour that begets the reputation, the gypsies / showmen are tarred with a brush that is nothing to do with them.

Instead of shouting off about racism perhaps the ones responsible for the behaviour, and we know its not a small number of people, should pour some of that energy into taking a stand against the behaviour that drags the rest of the community down.

I don't know of any other ethnicity where such behaviour is so common and I live in the most diverse part of the country.

I agree with this.

The difficulty is there’s an element of truth in the stereotyping because of the way a portion of the Irish traveller community continue to behave.

Many groups have stereotypes borne out of some truth. Look at the reputation of English holidaymakers - we have a reputation for being boozy and rowdy. Because there’s still a proportion of English people who are, and it perpetuates the stereotype which started years ago when there were real problems with it.

Some stereotypes are borne out of truth. It’s just really shitty if you’re one of the decent ones. A few bad apples and all that…

ilovesooty · 01/09/2022 01:07

I'm sorry you experienced this @Offendedgypsy .

The racist comments on this thread are disgusting too.

JestersTear · 01/09/2022 01:15

@Foggydog
I remember 'Kizzy' as well, based on a book called 'The Diddakoi' which I still have sitting on my bookshelf from when I was young.

JestersTear · 01/09/2022 01:16

I had always assumed that Gypsies were descended from people in Egypt and that Roma were descended from places like Romania and Eastern Europe. Travellers were Irish and/or 'new age' so I feel educated by this thread. Thank you.

OP. I'm sorry to hear about your experience, it should never have happened, and I'm sorry to read some of the racist comments on this thread. I hope you're ok.

stillvicarinatutu · 01/09/2022 01:30

There is a definite distinction between real the real gypsy community and travellers.

I have absolutely no problem with gypsy folk . I'm embarrassed for that shop assistant!

However- the only interaction I've ever had with travellers has been negative, sadly . I'm very much a live and let live sort - and my view may be more biased because I deal with crime and the only experience I've had with travellers is when they've committed crime .

One thing i keep hearing in this forum over and over is within the police one bad Apple spoils the barrel . Over and over .

So maybe that's true for travellers too . The bad apples spoil it for the rest of the travelling community and for gypsies .

When I was a teen is was very common for gypsies to knock selling pegs and heather - i always bought something. One time I invited a lady in for a cuppa , bought some pegs .

Im not racist and im embarrassed for anyone who is .

But there is a reputation that goes with travellers sadly - and that's down to the people who do commit crime within that community. I've dealt with it - had one guy whose cousin was a traveller and still nicked a jcb from him and sold it on . He wouldn't press charges - he said it wasn't worth having his business premises torched . And tbh - I didn't blame him because there was no way a cop could sit outside his business 24/7 . A lot of the drug crime , county lines and gang related crime I see is within the travelling community. If I had a pound for everyone who phoned police saying the travellers are after them for xyz I'd be rich . It's sad . More so for genuine gypsy folk who get tarred with that same brush .
What stands out for me is the case of Andrew Harper , who was literally flayed alive trying to stop 3 travellers stealing a quad bike worth 10k . When he was found in the road , all he had on were hit boots and socks - his uniform has been ripped off while the criminals has swerved all over the road at 30 mph with him caught in the rope they'd used to tow the quad . They laughed in court . I'm part of that police family and that colours my view of certain factions of that community.

I'm very sorry you've been the victim of blatant racism op . But one factions of that community (not gypsy necessarily) court that reputation.

Leafy3 · 01/09/2022 01:44

Sorry you experience such treatment, op.

I used to live in a town on the edge of which was a traveller community, with the typical reputation. I only ever knowingly interacted with one family from there who unfortunately lived up to that reputation but I didn't assume all families from that community would be the same.

I'm really keen to learn about both nomadic groups and would be really interested - and appreciative- should you ever decide to do an AMA.

I'm sure a big part of modern day hostility is because you only ever hear bad press.

Dibbydoos · 01/09/2022 02:02

He was OOO. I would not change if someone I was chatting to said they were a gypsy..
Not making an excuse, but gypsies took my lawnmower off my front garden when I went in to make a cuppa. They took my daughters bike when she came home to pick up a book. They stole my mates phone when she was working in a beauty salon etc. BTW, I lived in a very well to do area in middle England at the time all these events happened during the Horse Fair.

In the case of the experience you had, I don't have a problem with race, I'm mixed race myself. I have a problem with negative behaviour. Sadly, gypsies have repeatedly exhibited unacceptable behaviour ime and the communities they are from take no responsibility.

I'd suggest your community start cleaning up their act, so to speak, so that your community is seen as the positive family friendly community they are.

TheEggChair · 01/09/2022 02:15

I am sorry that you experienced this op but surely you knew the answer to your question? You can’t claim not to know why some people will behave negatively towards gypsies and travellers. It’s not right that you were treated badly because of the antisocial reputation of some of the gypsy & travelling community.

What’s being done internally to correct the behaviour of its anti social members? I live in a town with a significant IT population & there seems to be a reluctance to bring perpetrators to justice. There definitely is a culture of silence within the community & terrible retribution for people who break it. The general, mainstream population are wary of them because of their previous anti social behaviour. Surely this can’t be difficult for you to understand OP?

DinosaurDuvet · 01/09/2022 02:22

I’ve never had the pleasure of meeting any gypsies before but I know a family of travellers and they are kindest, warmest people you could ever hope to meet.

im so sorry you went through this OP ❤️ So hurtful

sashh · 01/09/2022 02:29

ItsJustLittleOlMe · 31/08/2022 20:01

Obviously I don't agree with it and you can't tar all with the same brush. However i think that sometimes it can stem from certain behaviours exhibited by some gypsies. For example, there is usually a spate of antisocial behaviour mainly thefts and other criminal activity, everytime the gypsies are in our town and park up in their usual spot. When they leave, it's usually littered with rubbish and human faeces.

I'm certainly not saying that his or other people's poor attitudes are acceptable because they aren't, but some gypsies do give the entire community a bad name. It's a real shame because I do know a couple of lovely people from the gypsy community.

And there is the problem, gypsies generally leave a place as clean or cleaner than when they arrived.

Not all nomadic people are the same, and Gypsies are a 'race' as defined by the race relations act, whether they travel or not.

There are a variety of traveler communities, what were once called 'tinkers', showmen who travel in the summer with a circus or fun fair, Irish travelers, even communities who use the canals to travel.

OP

I agree with the person who said he is a cunt.

Sorry you have to face this, you shouldn't.

WiddlinDiddlin · 01/09/2022 04:16

PooWeeBum · 31/08/2022 21:46

I am sorry you have had to deal with that. BUT.

my friend owns a pub and she had to close fully for two days due to police advice last week because there was a gypsy event nearby. She really couldn’t afford to close for two days and lose her money, pubs are making zero profit atm, so she researched and found out about how a pub down the road was utterly trashed and thousands of pounds of beer was stolen during the same annual event.

Similarly I have grown up near a Greenland area where gypsies would come and live for two weeks of the year, I had many childhood toys like bikes, slides etc stolen and every time they would come my dads shed and all his tools would be stolen.same for neighbours, plus all the human shit, rubbish and other disgusting things left when they moved on.

There is a crime rate and lawlessness stigma that comes with being a part of the travelling community, and many people fear for their livelihoods and property to be associated with that community, and I don’t blame them.

I was once verbally and physically abused at a bus top for my mobile phone that was stolen by a group of traveller girls, I know they was part of the community because they said they was and also got off on the only stop that serviced a council run traveler site on my way home from work.

whilst I have sympathy for you for being treated like a stain, I have no sympathy for the travelling community at large brave they do nothing to try and improve their reputation.

She 'had to' .. or she chose to follow police advice.

She closed her business as a result of police advice following an incident the previous year.

Not in fact due to something that actually happened to her.

Here's something fewer people will talk about..

Local residents and press flocking to take pictures of rubbish 'left behind' after Romany/traveller events... WHILST the official clean up is taking place or shortly before it can take place. Pictures conveniently not showing the guys going round with a pick up truck and bin bags, tidying up.

Local scrotes using the fact that a family or two have pulled on nearby, as an excuse to go out and rob their neighbours and cause mayhem trashing stuff, because they KNOW who will get the blame.

These aren't one offs either. These are regular occurrences in my part of the world.

Swipe left for the next trending thread