Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Because I'm a gypsy

375 replies

Offendedgypsy · 31/08/2022 19:29

Today I was in a bakery and it was empty. I ordered what I wanted and the man behind the counter made small talk as he prepared it. He said to me, referring to my accent "you're not from around here are you?". He smiled as he said it. I simply said yes I've lived here all my life, I'm a gypsy that's probably why I sound different.

After this his entire demeanor changed. No more smiling and small talk, he dropped my order on the counter and made it clear he was in some way upset/offended by my presence.

To be honest I'm no stranger to racism against me and I have more tales of blatant racism than I care to count, but this encounter felt really upsetting.

Everything was fine until he found out my ethnicity. Why are people so hateful against gypsies? Do people seriously still tar us all with the same brush, when the whole world is fighting against racism to other minorities?

I'm just so sick of being one of the only cultures who just have to accept racism.

OP posts:
Freedom2023 · 01/09/2022 10:05

I usually think that threads like this can be useful in educating people about GRT communities but I honestly think this thread should be deleted.
A lot of the posts are just blatantly racist and of those that are supportive of the OP, many add the caveat 'but Irish Travellers' etc.
It always happens on these types of threads, it becomes a place where people can express their hatred of the Irish Traveller community without feeling bad because they're also defending the Gypsy community.

wellhelloitsme · 01/09/2022 10:05

Especially one girl I remember once primary school was done she wasn't allowed to continue education which I understand however she honestly could have went on to have a fantastic education.

I assume they were from a traveller rather than gypsy family, so not part of OP's heritage, but just wanted to say this makes me so sad. These poor girls having the opportunity for an education entirely removed from them 😞

ArabellaScott · 01/09/2022 10:05

Making racist comments about Irish travellers is just as bad as making racist comments about gypsies. There is no ethnic group its okay to be racist about.

ArabellaScott · 01/09/2022 10:06

Freedom2023 · 01/09/2022 10:05

I usually think that threads like this can be useful in educating people about GRT communities but I honestly think this thread should be deleted.
A lot of the posts are just blatantly racist and of those that are supportive of the OP, many add the caveat 'but Irish Travellers' etc.
It always happens on these types of threads, it becomes a place where people can express their hatred of the Irish Traveller community without feeling bad because they're also defending the Gypsy community.

I half agree - it is horrible but eye opening to see that so many people think it's just fine to be prejudiced against a group so long as you are really specific about defining them.

ArabellaScott · 01/09/2022 10:07

FWIW, there are several different groups within 'travellers', too - yes Irish travellers, we also have Highland travellers in Scotland with their own history, traditions, language and culture, and showpeople ditto.

HappyMackerel · 01/09/2022 10:08

So sorry OP. How utterly horrible for you. This is very wrong and shouldn't be acceptable.

zingally · 01/09/2022 10:08

He was horribly rude and it shouldn't have happened.

For what it's worth, I work with gypsy/traveller families quite a lot (mostly the mums and kids though), and I've only ever had good experiences.

apintortwo · 01/09/2022 10:24

I'm not sue what you were tryigng to achieve at the bakery OP

Were you trying to provoke a reaction from this unsuspecting man so that you could speak to Head Office and get him disciplined or sacked? That would have been calculating and vile

Why did you not discuss what you do for a living, where you work or where you live for instance? Wouldn't it have been more appropriate? Why did you feel the need to say that you are a gypsy or discuss your ethnicity with a stranger? It's odd that this man would not have heard your accent before.

The aim of your thread is also confusing OP. Haven't you realised that there's a thread about someone being offended every day by something minor, followed by a flurry of posters expressing sympathy? Isn't it clear to you by now what a lot of MN posters think about the scenario you describe?

wellhelloitsme · 01/09/2022 10:27

wellhelloitsme · 01/09/2022 10:05

Especially one girl I remember once primary school was done she wasn't allowed to continue education which I understand however she honestly could have went on to have a fantastic education.

I assume they were from a traveller rather than gypsy family, so not part of OP's heritage, but just wanted to say this makes me so sad. These poor girls having the opportunity for an education entirely removed from them 😞

Sorry caught up a bit and just saw you left school at 12 too, OP.

It makes me desperately sad to think of girls being pulled out of school at that age. And boys, if they are too, obviously.

Is it something that still happens often now? I thought it was illegal?

Agrudge · 01/09/2022 10:28

I dont think I've had any interactions with gypsys.

Irish travelers I've had plenty and 98% of the time its been negative. I've never seen a illegal camp site where they have been left tidy. I've know councils to give out bin bags and other supplies but still leave the fields + common grounds like a tip.

They have been known to drive cars + quad bikes at speed around the common . Police turn a blind eye so they dont provoke them. But if I was to do the same the police would be after me.

They have reputation and I'm not sure it 100% unfounded .

I'm sure they are not all like this ,but in my experience alot are.

In my line of work when I have any interactions with irish travelers I dont treat them any differently until I'm given a reason to.

FirewomanSam · 01/09/2022 10:30

Willyoujustbequiet · 01/09/2022 09:48

I apologise if I've offended anyone but Google strongly suggests this word is used as a slur and countless videos and posts from the community on Tik Tok and other SM state how offensive they consider it and ask that people respect that and not use it.

I was therefore very surprised to see the OP use it to describe themselves.

My understanding (correct me if I’m
wrong, OP and others with more knowledge of this than me) is that ‘gypsy’ isn’t offensive if the person you’re talking about is actually a Romany gypsy and identifies as such, but someone who isn’t a gypsy (e.g someone from the Irish or showman traveller communities) might get offended at being called a gypsy when they are not.

It would be like calling anyone who looks East Asian ‘Chinese’. Being called Chinese of course isn’t offensive if you’re actually from China, but you might be offended at being repeatedly referred to as Chinese if you’re actually Thai or Japanese or Korean.

SharpLily · 01/09/2022 10:37

Offendedgypsy · 31/08/2022 19:29

Today I was in a bakery and it was empty. I ordered what I wanted and the man behind the counter made small talk as he prepared it. He said to me, referring to my accent "you're not from around here are you?". He smiled as he said it. I simply said yes I've lived here all my life, I'm a gypsy that's probably why I sound different.

After this his entire demeanor changed. No more smiling and small talk, he dropped my order on the counter and made it clear he was in some way upset/offended by my presence.

To be honest I'm no stranger to racism against me and I have more tales of blatant racism than I care to count, but this encounter felt really upsetting.

Everything was fine until he found out my ethnicity. Why are people so hateful against gypsies? Do people seriously still tar us all with the same brush, when the whole world is fighting against racism to other minorities?

I'm just so sick of being one of the only cultures who just have to accept racism.

Well the thread has got quite out of hand. I am one of those who had a post deleted for detailing my negative experiences, but as others have said, you asked why people feel negative towards your community and rightly or wrongly, people have their reasons. I have been very clear that my experiences, which include being related by marriage, have been overwhelmingly and fearfully negative but I would also like to be clear that had you come into my place of work or I had met you anywhere else, I wouldn't have treated you any differently for finding out your ethnicity. I would have treated you well as I would/do anyone, of any ethnicity unless and until given a personal reason to do otherwise. What the man did to you was unpleasant and unnecessary and I can perfectly accept how hurt you were by it.

However can you really not accept what people are saying about their experiences? As another poster explained, it seems to be about percentages. There's not another single ethnicity where 100% of my personal experiences have been negative, that's what I've found notable. People say you wouldn't talk about black/Muslim/Asian people the same way but like everyone else, I've met twatty black arseholes, twatty Muslim arseholes and twatty Asian arseholes but no, I don't judge their whole communities by it because they are the minority, not the 100%. I also admit that yes, I judge Brits in Benidorm and fans of Yaxley-Lennon. Frankly, like most of us, I judge people whose behaviour I have experienced negatively whatever their race or ethnicity. Bad behaviour is bad behaviour no matter who is doing it. But I can only think of one societal group which has not shown me one single positive interaction.

As far as noting the differences between IT/Roma etc, I admit that I couldn't look at someone and know which community they're from. On the other hand I am from a mixed background and I don't for a minute expect people to be clear on what exactly is involved in that. I accept that to white British I look 'a bit foreign'. I don't think it's racist for people to lack in depth knowledge about every specific societal group.

TheEggChair · 01/09/2022 10:39

Offendedgypsy · 01/09/2022 08:16

@notyourmummy Tyson fury is an English Romany Gypsy, not an Irish traveller

I always thought Tyson Fury was from an IT background as the article here claims.

inews.co.uk/sport/boxing/tyson-fury-why-the-gypsy-king-nickname-irish-traveller-heritage-explained-397590

I'm a bit confused now because Tyson Fury calls himself a Gypsy even though he's meant to have IT heritage. The op has stated that the Roma and Irish Travellers are separate groups. The IT are not regarded as Gypsy by the Roma but as travellers. The term seems to be interchangeable between the communities.

eldora · 01/09/2022 10:45

Offendedgypsy · 01/09/2022 08:16

@notyourmummy Tyson fury is an English Romany Gypsy, not an Irish traveller

But he does describe himself as an Irish Traveller, in various interviews. He has roots in Ireland.

TheEggChair · 01/09/2022 10:48

eldora · 01/09/2022 10:45

But he does describe himself as an Irish Traveller, in various interviews. He has roots in Ireland.

In the article I linked to, Fury describes himself as a Gypsy even though he acknowledges his IT roots. In his head, it might be the one and the same though who knows.

Yummyplumthanksmum · 01/09/2022 10:52

I'm very sorry you have been through this. My husband is from the travelling community and has struggled with these attitudes his whole life, and still does. It does seem that racism is still accepted when it is aimed at gypsy or traveller people.

A lot of examples here on this thread.

I agree that the Gypsy Wedding shows etc don't help, as well as ridiculously racist shows like the Traveller Crime documentary by Dispatches.

But what a lot of people may not realise is that these prejudices run deeper and are a lot more serious than just those TV shows. My husband's family have known people whose caravans etc have been set on fire with their families in them. And faced a lot of violence.

I have not been through what you have, but having seen and heard about the way people have treated my husband all his life, I really empathise.

Attitudes really need to change on this.

Offendedgypsy · 01/09/2022 10:53

I'm not sue what you were tryigng to achieve at the bakery OP

I was trying to achieve the purchase of a sandwich and a biscuit.

OP posts:
Offendedgypsy · 01/09/2022 10:54

eldora · 01/09/2022 10:45

But he does describe himself as an Irish Traveller, in various interviews. He has roots in Ireland.

We know the family, they are English gypsies and have some links to Irish travellers

OP posts:
Notwiththebullshizz · 01/09/2022 10:58

Its shit, it really is. 3 of my closest friends are travellers, one of them I've known 20+ years along with her entire family. They are all wonderful people who decided to change their lives for the better when something terrible happened in their family. I used to work in a shop which was located very close to a traveller community and unfortunately there were ALOT of men and women from this particular community who came into the shop and stole non stop there was nothing anyone could do through fear of getting hurt (the threats made were insane).

But it is exactly that, just a particular bunch, I dont for one second think all travellers are the same and would never tar all with the same brush. I actually spoke to my close friends about this community and they all said the same... they're scum and make us all look bad.

I'm so sorry you've been subjected to this kind of blanket racism, just know that those who spew racism are the MINORITY and are hated for it by the majority for sure.

TheEggChair · 01/09/2022 10:58

The article says his parents came over from Ireland when they were young.

eldora · 01/09/2022 11:00

Offendedgypsy · 01/09/2022 10:54

We know the family, they are English gypsies and have some links to Irish travellers

But that’s not true. Tyson says:

*“All my people are from Ireland. I was born in Manchester but I am Irish. I have lived in Ireland, visited all my life and when I fight I represent Ireland,"

Born in Manchester, Fury has always felt a closer connection to Ireland, where his father and grandfather were born. He comes from Irish traveling stock and is related to The Fureys, a famous traditional music group, and Andy Lee, an Irish boxer.*

www.irishcentral.com/roots/genealogy/tyson-fury-irish-roots.amp

DownNative · 01/09/2022 12:17

eldora · 01/09/2022 11:00

But that’s not true. Tyson says:

*“All my people are from Ireland. I was born in Manchester but I am Irish. I have lived in Ireland, visited all my life and when I fight I represent Ireland,"

Born in Manchester, Fury has always felt a closer connection to Ireland, where his father and grandfather were born. He comes from Irish traveling stock and is related to The Fureys, a famous traditional music group, and Andy Lee, an Irish boxer.*

www.irishcentral.com/roots/genealogy/tyson-fury-irish-roots.amp

I'm not sure why you want to pigeonhole Tyson Fury solely as Irish there, but he isn't.

His mother is a Protestant from Belfast while his father is a Catholic from County Galway. This demonstrates he has Ulster-British and Irish ancestral heritage. At the same time, it demonstrates Fury doesn't have sole Irish Traveller ancestry.

Fury very obviously doesn't strictly "represent Ireland" solely as the attached image demonstrates. His gloves would suggest both sets of identities, really.

Fury has a British passport and isn't eligible for an Irish passport since he couldn't prove eligibility.

@Offendedgypsy isn't incorrect in saying "they are English gypsies and have some links to Irish Travellers."

Given his mother's Protestant background, Fury will have a considerable non-Irish Traveller heritage.

Because I'm a gypsy
Because I'm a gypsy
eldora · 01/09/2022 12:21

@DownNative I'm not trying to pigeon hole him as anything, I have links to other countries too. It seems to be OP who wants to pigeon hole him as English.

OP said he has some links to ITs, when that is a gross simplification, given what Tyson has said about Ireland and his own dad and grand father being born there.

DownNative · 01/09/2022 12:32

eldora · 01/09/2022 12:21

@DownNative I'm not trying to pigeon hole him as anything, I have links to other countries too. It seems to be OP who wants to pigeon hole him as English.

OP said he has some links to ITs, when that is a gross simplification, given what Tyson has said about Ireland and his own dad and grand father being born there.

Except the OP wasn't actually incorrect in stating Fury was "English gypsies and have some links to Irish Travellers".

A quick look at his ancestry would quickly indicate the phrase "some links to Irish Travellers" is correct, in fact.

It would be his fathers line where Fury has some Traveller link, but not on his Mother's Protestant line.

Likewise, Fury is incorrect in stating "all my people are from Ireland". If by "Ireland" he means the Republic of Ireland, he's incorrect. If by "Ireland" he means the Island of Ireland, he's incorrect too on account of his Mother's Protestant ancestral line.

His mother is from Belfast, Northern Ireland. Go back far enough and Fury will find his Protestant ancestors would have largely come from Scotland and/or England.

The gross oversimplification would actually be Tyson's "all my people are from Ireland" comment.

He can't even get an Irish passport which says a lot.

BuggerationFlavouredCrisps · 01/09/2022 12:34

Slippersnotshoes · 01/09/2022 09:11

@MajorCarolDanvers are you for real?? I have a problem with the antisocial behaviour which many of the irish travelling community display wherever they go and wherever they are!! Their behaviour is what makes them unlikeable not the fact that they are travellers. Come back and tell me I'm a racist once you've had interactions with travellers and almost had your property stolen and been told you are going to have your house burnt down with your children inside you muppet.

You’re the Muppet here.

How is your rant about Irish Travellers remotely relevant to a thread about Romany Gypsies?

They are two completely separate and distinct cultures and not genetically related at all.

“I met a French woman who burgled my house so therefore all white European women are thieves.” You’ve got more in common genetically with the French woman so presumably you must be the same and also a thief?

Can you not see that your ignorance of cultural differences between two very distinct ethnic groups (along with many others on this thread) is what perpetuates unfair criticism of Romany Gypsies?

Swipe left for the next trending thread