Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

Written warning

166 replies

user1482956724 · 20/11/2026 19:16

I work from home 4 days a week and 1 day a week in the office. There is more than 1 office, the closest over 20 miles away.

I have been having knee issues and due it progressively getting worse, its painful and I need to keep it elevated as much as possible, ice it, heat it etc. Bending it is agony. Been told injection wont work for the pain, need physio and a likely knee replacement. I use walking aids as it can give out at any point.

I provided my boss with a GP fit note that stated no driving, but fit to work from home. My boss told me I'd have to take public transport or a lift. For my knee condition, neither was practical. I asked for temporary 100% wfh until im able to drive. My boss wanted the fit note changed to no travel, even though my note explicitly stated I was fit to work from home. I went back to my GP, said no driving was not accepted, it needed to be no travel because I've been told to elevate, rest etc. Anyway, my GP signed me off work. They are not administrators and my health is their priority.

I handed over (via email) to my boss and HR and stated that I was able and willing to work from home, but they still wanted me in the office. Eventually I insisted on an OH assessment which they resisted on but did give in. Had the assessment and OH again stated, wfh with no travel. So, ive returned to work.

Had my return to work meeting and due to this exceeding trigger points, I had to have a formal meeting. My boss and HR chaired the meeting and I have been given a 1st written warning. So if I take even an afternoon off work for an emergency, or I'm sick, it'll be a 2nd written warning. After that, dismissal. Now, just want to add that i am 61yrs old and I am also registered disabled. The company are aware and they are a Disability Confident Leader.

I feel this is grossly unfair as I simply did what I was asked. It is not my fault that my GP chose to protect my health a sign me off. Am I being delusional?

OP posts:
user1482956724 · Yesterday 12:48

Dogsceptic · Yesterday 12:32

I have an automatic /off course you can carry or an emergency stop in an automatic! If YOU can’t then you need to hand your licence back to DVLA.
And without a car you will save the tax/insurance/servicing/petrol/parking/car finance/fepreciatio that will easily pay for the taxi one day a day a week until the knee op.

Check back please. My car is motability. So £70 a week is not covered by not using my car. I do NOT need to hand my licence back as this is TEMPORARY.

Equally, even if i did own the car, it would still need to be taxed, mot, parked etc.

You may be able to lift and slam your foot down, i cant, but as I'm not mirroring you I'm making excuses. Equally, I never said an emergency stop had anything to do with transmission. What i did say is that my car is automatic and thus, driven using my right leg, which is the side with the problem.

Would you like me to list everything else that I do adapt to as this isn't my sole problem. However, i could have brought up the whole lot if I was so hell bent on making excuses.

OP posts:
user1482956724 · Yesterday 12:54

JustaSongAboutPingPong · Yesterday 12:46

Can I just ask how come you live so far from work OP? Not a trick question Smile

Did you live that far away when you got the job or have they moved the office location or have you moved away?

The company consider any route of 50 miles commutable. There is a huge proportion of staff that live quite a distance from an office. There used to be smaller satellite offices but those closed many years ago.

I joined during covid when everyone worked from home and office attendance was optional. These says they would not be able to have 100% office attendance as insufficient desks available. They have to be booked in advance, sometimes weeks ahead.

OP posts:
JustaSongAboutPingPong · Yesterday 12:57

user1482956724 · Yesterday 12:54

The company consider any route of 50 miles commutable. There is a huge proportion of staff that live quite a distance from an office. There used to be smaller satellite offices but those closed many years ago.

I joined during covid when everyone worked from home and office attendance was optional. These says they would not be able to have 100% office attendance as insufficient desks available. They have to be booked in advance, sometimes weeks ahead.

That’s a very convoluted way of not answering the question OP Smile

I do think your employer isn’t playing fair but I don’t think you’re helping yourself much either.

I hope it works out for you.

user1482956724 · Yesterday 13:00

JustaSongAboutPingPong · Yesterday 12:57

That’s a very convoluted way of not answering the question OP Smile

I do think your employer isn’t playing fair but I don’t think you’re helping yourself much either.

I hope it works out for you.

So tell me how ive not answered the question?

OP posts:
WeDid2 · Yesterday 13:15

I have no doubt your knee is incredibly painful and you have my sympathies - I’ve had knee problems myself. I hope your knee surgery comes soon - my dad has had both his done and he’s very happy with the outcome.

I think why you are getting so much push back are there are some things in your comments that are giving the impression that a motivator for you is your are quite annoyed at your work for just not agreeing you can work from home for all your working week.

And then you do appear to take the extreme on things … like your 20 mile drive to work often has road works and can be a 2hr journey - you only work from the office one day a week what are the odds that on this day there is always going to be road works on such a short strip. Or your knee needs to be elevated so much it’s unsafe for you to be in a cab as you can’t safely wear your seatbelt. But no one can imagine your knee needing to be elevated that much in a day you have to elevate it for the cab journey, even people with the same condition as you.

My point is - I am not trying to call you out on any of these things. What I am trying to show you is if quite a lot of strangers on the internet are picking up from your communication that a few things don’t make sense - and if these strangers are thinking this it’s likely your work place is too.

I suspect you have worked long and hard for this company and you are angry that you feel they are not being more supportive in your hour of need. The whole drs note of you needing them to change the note to say no travel and they then instead apparently ignored you and wrote time off work … appears to not make sense in terms of the dr ignoring what you apparently asked for.

I think it makes sense to follow some good advice you have on here - but also maybe have a think if anger is driving some of your approach to the company that you work for and if that’s really in your best interest in the long run.

Frostynoman · Yesterday 13:28

You’re getting a lot of pushback OP and I think at times you are answering defensively however I completely understand why you are as lots of people want to pick holes in what you’ve said. I’ve lived in places that have had years of road works on the motorway I’ve had to commute on and have on numerous occasions known 3 miles take an hour before now.

Contact ACAS and go from there, your employer are not going about this fairly.

user1482956724 · Yesterday 13:39

WeDid2 · Yesterday 13:15

I have no doubt your knee is incredibly painful and you have my sympathies - I’ve had knee problems myself. I hope your knee surgery comes soon - my dad has had both his done and he’s very happy with the outcome.

I think why you are getting so much push back are there are some things in your comments that are giving the impression that a motivator for you is your are quite annoyed at your work for just not agreeing you can work from home for all your working week.

And then you do appear to take the extreme on things … like your 20 mile drive to work often has road works and can be a 2hr journey - you only work from the office one day a week what are the odds that on this day there is always going to be road works on such a short strip. Or your knee needs to be elevated so much it’s unsafe for you to be in a cab as you can’t safely wear your seatbelt. But no one can imagine your knee needing to be elevated that much in a day you have to elevate it for the cab journey, even people with the same condition as you.

My point is - I am not trying to call you out on any of these things. What I am trying to show you is if quite a lot of strangers on the internet are picking up from your communication that a few things don’t make sense - and if these strangers are thinking this it’s likely your work place is too.

I suspect you have worked long and hard for this company and you are angry that you feel they are not being more supportive in your hour of need. The whole drs note of you needing them to change the note to say no travel and they then instead apparently ignored you and wrote time off work … appears to not make sense in terms of the dr ignoring what you apparently asked for.

I think it makes sense to follow some good advice you have on here - but also maybe have a think if anger is driving some of your approach to the company that you work for and if that’s really in your best interest in the long run.

Edited

If you knew the motorways in question then you would know that the long journeys are mostly a daily thing and in 6 yrs of those routes, getting to or from work without a delay is incredibly rare and more so now with major roadworks into 2028.

My motivator is not that work didnt agree, its about The Equality Act 2010 and disability discrimination. As I have said, I have no control over my GP and the request I made has been provided to work which shows I did not ask not to work.

I can stand, move, do physio approx 15 mins at a time, after doing that, my knee swells up and needs icing. Rinse and repeat throughout the day. But I will mention this when I attend my next physio appointment and ask if I should just ignore the pain, heat and swelling.

My work has a lot more information than is on here in regards to my overall health and disabilities and the impact on my life which is not directly linked to my knee. But does have a collective effect.

I think I must be unusual as its not anger, its about legalities, rights, obligations and discrimination.

OP posts:
Blueseaurchin · Yesterday 13:56

OP I have already commented on the thread but wanted to add please ignore the people who are rejoicing at the fact that you are struggling and are trying to trip you up.

Unfortunately there is an appalling amount of ableism and ignorance of the impact that long term health conditions can have on people.

There is also a lot of dinosaurs who will criticise home working in any thread (usually because they themselves can't work from home and are bitter about anyone who has a job that can be done remotely).

Basically don't feel the need to justify yourself to any of them.

Some people have given you good advice about contacting ACAS and the fact that your employer is being unreasonable to have dragged his feet to refer you to Occupational Health and then refuse to take into account recommendations from both your GP and Occupational Health. And that they are ignoring employment law when is comes to people with disabilities/long term health conditions and reasonable adjustment.

Please focus on that helpful advice and I hope ACAS and Citizen Advice can support you through this.

Anything else is just noise that is not worth giving any attention to.

user1482956724 · Yesterday 14:05

Blueseaurchin · Yesterday 13:56

OP I have already commented on the thread but wanted to add please ignore the people who are rejoicing at the fact that you are struggling and are trying to trip you up.

Unfortunately there is an appalling amount of ableism and ignorance of the impact that long term health conditions can have on people.

There is also a lot of dinosaurs who will criticise home working in any thread (usually because they themselves can't work from home and are bitter about anyone who has a job that can be done remotely).

Basically don't feel the need to justify yourself to any of them.

Some people have given you good advice about contacting ACAS and the fact that your employer is being unreasonable to have dragged his feet to refer you to Occupational Health and then refuse to take into account recommendations from both your GP and Occupational Health. And that they are ignoring employment law when is comes to people with disabilities/long term health conditions and reasonable adjustment.

Please focus on that helpful advice and I hope ACAS and Citizen Advice can support you through this.

Anything else is just noise that is not worth giving any attention to.

Thank you.

I think what i was looking at was, the legal aspects. There is a different side to this which would muddy the waters a great deal. However, i am doing everything I can to get the correct support for myself without having to go down the dark path of humiliating someone despite their attempts to try and show a lack of bias.

I am not that person that chooses to bring others down just because I could. Im trying to keep this as amicable and legal as best I can. But at 61, registered disabled and in a niche employment sector, im not prepared to lose my job over it.

OP posts:
EBearhug · Yesterday 14:13

JustaSongAboutPingPong · Yesterday 12:46

Can I just ask how come you live so far from work OP? Not a trick question Smile

Did you live that far away when you got the job or have they moved the office location or have you moved away?

She's 25 miles away. That's not an unusual commute distance, especially outside of London. It's also not that bad if you only have to be in once a week, even if bad roads make it longer in time.

She can do all her work from home. It would be a reasonable adjustment to allow her to WFH 5 days a week until the relevant medical people deem her recovery sufficient that she can drive or use public transport. That is currently expected to happen, but it won't be overnight.

user1482956724 · Yesterday 14:26

EBearhug · Yesterday 14:13

She's 25 miles away. That's not an unusual commute distance, especially outside of London. It's also not that bad if you only have to be in once a week, even if bad roads make it longer in time.

She can do all her work from home. It would be a reasonable adjustment to allow her to WFH 5 days a week until the relevant medical people deem her recovery sufficient that she can drive or use public transport. That is currently expected to happen, but it won't be overnight.

Thank you.

I live very close to the 2 main motorways to access the 2 closest offices. The offices are quite close to both motorways, however neither is close to public transport links and both require multiple changes. Navigating that whilst also using a walking aid and carrying everything needed for an office day is actually not very easy to do, alongside that the journey time would double. Rush hour commutes on London bound routes would put me in a very unsafe environment due to the sheer volume of other commuters.

Equally, this would impact on my other conditions which are not in question here although the company is fully aware of.

OP posts:
SevenYellowHammers · Yesterday 14:26

user1482956724 · Yesterday 12:22

Thank you. My home set up caters for my disabilities with the correct chair and desk set up including foot rest to support my leg. I also have grab rails to assist when moving so I can mostly, prevent myself from falling.

I do have other disabilities which work are fully aware of. I have always updated my profile section with anything additional, appointments and letters. I am also registered under the county council as disabled and carry a card supporting this.

My disabilities are physical, they do not affect my ability to do my job. Im the most qualified and experienced within the team with excellent KPI and stats figures. Though this warning will downgrade my performance on paper.

Exactly OP, you’re saving them money by working from home.

I’d probably advise you to go off sick altogether.

They are lucky you’re willing to work at all.

Just contact ACAS on Monday and I guarantee they’ll support your reasonable adjustments as prescribed by your highly qualified GP (not a social media keyboard warrior).

Now, this isn’t me telling you what to do or not do but I reckon you should have a rest from all this. Discussing work can be as stressful as doing work and right now, we’re both doing unpaid work to make Mumsnet richer!

I accept some good is done by Mumsnet though and an example is some of the great advice given on here about how to challenge this written warning.

Take care and rest!

user1482956724 · Yesterday 14:30

SevenYellowHammers · Yesterday 14:26

Exactly OP, you’re saving them money by working from home.

I’d probably advise you to go off sick altogether.

They are lucky you’re willing to work at all.

Just contact ACAS on Monday and I guarantee they’ll support your reasonable adjustments as prescribed by your highly qualified GP (not a social media keyboard warrior).

Now, this isn’t me telling you what to do or not do but I reckon you should have a rest from all this. Discussing work can be as stressful as doing work and right now, we’re both doing unpaid work to make Mumsnet richer!

I accept some good is done by Mumsnet though and an example is some of the great advice given on here about how to challenge this written warning.

Take care and rest!

Thank you.

Yes, i am going to step back now. A huge thank you to those that offered very helpful advice and understanding. Its made me feel a lot better and more confident about raising an appeal.

Have a lovely rest of the weekend all.

OP posts:
Imdunfer · Yesterday 14:36

user1482956724 · 20/11/2026 22:57

All they offered was either public transport or a lift. I cant do either currently.

The knee issue is from osteoarthritis which is one of my disability conditions.

I know this is not the point of your thread so this is for others reading it who might get the wrong idea, not for you if you are following medical advice you have been given.

The treatment advised, rest, elevation, ice is the treatment for soft tissue injuries and not normally recommended for arthritis. I have both rheumatoid and osteo arthritis. Recommended treatment is movement, even if you are in pain. Many studies have demonstrated that movement reduces pain and improves mobility.

SylvanMoon · Yesterday 14:36

user1482956724 · Yesterday 13:00

So tell me how ive not answered the question?

@user1482956724 you really should just ignore this poster and anyone else trying to trip you up about how they feel you're "not really unable to work in the office". It's clear you are in the right here and your employer is breaching the law. I'd send the email @BoldlyLeaningPanda suggested earlier and just return to this thread when you've had a resolution to update us all. I hope you get some relief for your knee problem soon (and everything else as much as possible too).

user1482956724 · Yesterday 14:41

Imdunfer · Yesterday 14:36

I know this is not the point of your thread so this is for others reading it who might get the wrong idea, not for you if you are following medical advice you have been given.

The treatment advised, rest, elevation, ice is the treatment for soft tissue injuries and not normally recommended for arthritis. I have both rheumatoid and osteo arthritis. Recommended treatment is movement, even if you are in pain. Many studies have demonstrated that movement reduces pain and improves mobility.

Edited

Note I said the osteo is ONE of my conditions.

OP posts:
user1482956724 · Yesterday 14:41

SylvanMoon · Yesterday 14:36

@user1482956724 you really should just ignore this poster and anyone else trying to trip you up about how they feel you're "not really unable to work in the office". It's clear you are in the right here and your employer is breaching the law. I'd send the email @BoldlyLeaningPanda suggested earlier and just return to this thread when you've had a resolution to update us all. I hope you get some relief for your knee problem soon (and everything else as much as possible too).

Thank you.

I will come back with an update once I know.

OP posts:
PrettyLittleRose · Yesterday 15:30

moonraker0 · Yesterday 11:58

I’m assuming you have informed the DVLA that your doctor has deemed you unfit to drive? There’s a risk of a fine if you don’t inform them.

LOL, the OP has a condition at the moment that makes it very difficult and uncomfortable to drive, and she isn't going to drive for a while. She doesn't need to inform the DVLA of anything.

Would you surrender your driving licence if the GP wrote a fit note for you saying you can't drive for a couple of months?

Yeah I thought not.

@user1482956724 Ignore the naysayers, they're all jealous because you get to work from home.

user1482956724 · Yesterday 15:32

PrettyLittleRose · Yesterday 15:30

LOL, the OP has a condition at the moment that makes it very difficult and uncomfortable to drive, and she isn't going to drive for a while. She doesn't need to inform the DVLA of anything.

Would you surrender your driving licence if the GP wrote a fit note for you saying you can't drive for a couple of months?

Yeah I thought not.

@user1482956724 Ignore the naysayers, they're all jealous because you get to work from home.

Thank you 😊

OP posts:
JustaSongAboutPingPong · Yesterday 15:39

SylvanMoon · Yesterday 14:36

@user1482956724 you really should just ignore this poster and anyone else trying to trip you up about how they feel you're "not really unable to work in the office". It's clear you are in the right here and your employer is breaching the law. I'd send the email @BoldlyLeaningPanda suggested earlier and just return to this thread when you've had a resolution to update us all. I hope you get some relief for your knee problem soon (and everything else as much as possible too).

I wasn’t questioning why she can’t work on the office, I was questioning why she lives so far away.

If, for instance, work had moved offices after she had taken up her employment with them, it may aid her case. But you and the OP just crack on with the everyone else is wrong and the OP should be signed off work narrative.

user1482956724 · Yesterday 15:50

JustaSongAboutPingPong · Yesterday 15:39

I wasn’t questioning why she can’t work on the office, I was questioning why she lives so far away.

If, for instance, work had moved offices after she had taken up her employment with them, it may aid her case. But you and the OP just crack on with the everyone else is wrong and the OP should be signed off work narrative.

What exactly has the job location that i have worked in for 6yrs got to do with anything?

I have already explained it. It isnt my fault you did not understand the explanation given. But you just crack on.

OP posts:
SylvanMoon · Yesterday 15:57

JustaSongAboutPingPong · Yesterday 15:39

I wasn’t questioning why she can’t work on the office, I was questioning why she lives so far away.

If, for instance, work had moved offices after she had taken up her employment with them, it may aid her case. But you and the OP just crack on with the everyone else is wrong and the OP should be signed off work narrative.

First of all, the OP isn't asking to be "signed off work" at all, and secondly, she already explained (if you had RTFT) how the organisation closed various satellite offices and that she joined at a point when everyone was fully WFH. So I, and the OP and others will crack on with you are "wrong".

JustaSongAboutPingPong · Yesterday 16:06

I have read the full thread thank you. I always make a rule of not arguing with people who start to swear so that’s me out.

Birdie2026 · Yesterday 16:09

Have you thought about taking early retirement? It might be worth considering. Your workplace sounds most unpleasant. I hope your knee improves soon and you regain some quality of life.

user1482956724 · Yesterday 16:18

Birdie2026 · Yesterday 16:09

Have you thought about taking early retirement? It might be worth considering. Your workplace sounds most unpleasant. I hope your knee improves soon and you regain some quality of life.

I really wish I could afford to retire. Unfortunately that isnt an option for me right now.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread