Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

Written warning

166 replies

user1482956724 · 20/11/2026 19:16

I work from home 4 days a week and 1 day a week in the office. There is more than 1 office, the closest over 20 miles away.

I have been having knee issues and due it progressively getting worse, its painful and I need to keep it elevated as much as possible, ice it, heat it etc. Bending it is agony. Been told injection wont work for the pain, need physio and a likely knee replacement. I use walking aids as it can give out at any point.

I provided my boss with a GP fit note that stated no driving, but fit to work from home. My boss told me I'd have to take public transport or a lift. For my knee condition, neither was practical. I asked for temporary 100% wfh until im able to drive. My boss wanted the fit note changed to no travel, even though my note explicitly stated I was fit to work from home. I went back to my GP, said no driving was not accepted, it needed to be no travel because I've been told to elevate, rest etc. Anyway, my GP signed me off work. They are not administrators and my health is their priority.

I handed over (via email) to my boss and HR and stated that I was able and willing to work from home, but they still wanted me in the office. Eventually I insisted on an OH assessment which they resisted on but did give in. Had the assessment and OH again stated, wfh with no travel. So, ive returned to work.

Had my return to work meeting and due to this exceeding trigger points, I had to have a formal meeting. My boss and HR chaired the meeting and I have been given a 1st written warning. So if I take even an afternoon off work for an emergency, or I'm sick, it'll be a 2nd written warning. After that, dismissal. Now, just want to add that i am 61yrs old and I am also registered disabled. The company are aware and they are a Disability Confident Leader.

I feel this is grossly unfair as I simply did what I was asked. It is not my fault that my GP chose to protect my health a sign me off. Am I being delusional?

OP posts:
NerdyBird · Yesterday 09:27

This is bonkers. You can work from home and don’t need to be physically in the office to complete your tasks. That is what they pay you for. A temporary wfh period is quite reasonable. I would definitely get some advice from ACAS.

timoteigirl · Yesterday 09:28

Dogsceptic · Yesterday 09:24

But you’d be saving money driving so could just pay for the taxi instead?
How do you manage your daily life if your leg has to be elevated at all times….?
Perhaps they are concerned you might actually not be working all the hours you are contracted for at home?

Edited

Or just to show their power and that they have control over you?

GP's concern is only health. Employers use occ health to see what is recommended at work and they can still decline it.

user1482956724 · Yesterday 09:30

Dogsceptic · Yesterday 09:24

But you’d be saving money driving so could just pay for the taxi instead?
How do you manage your daily life if your leg has to be elevated at all times….?
Perhaps they are concerned you might actually not be working all the hours you are contracted for at home?

Edited

So paying £70 for that 1 day a week is just as cheap as using my car?

They know full well i am doing my contracted hours and often more (not paid).

Safety and Legal Risks

• Seatbelt Effectiveness: Elevation changes how a seatbelt sits across the pelvis and chest, which can reduce restraint effectiveness during sudden braking or a crash.
• Injury Risks: Unnatural leg positions can shift how impact forces travel through the hips, knees, and lower limbs in a collision.
• UK Rules: Drivers must ensure passengers wear seatbelts properly and travel safely. There is a consensus on Quora that improper seating or seatbelt use can lead to legal penalties for the driver.

OP posts:
Blushingm · Yesterday 09:31

user1482956724 · Yesterday 09:22

They were in June. I saw my GP in September and was told, at that appointment to rest, elevate, not drive etc. I informed my boss, she requested the fit note, I provided it, but because it stated no driving and not no travel, my boss wanted it changed.

Now not sure about your GP but they dont get involved in word salads or corporate semantics. My GP only has one concern, my health and wellbeing. I did not ask my GP to sign me off, I advised her that no driving was unacceptable and they wanted no travel. In order to protect me, I was signed off.

You’ve not really answered the question. Are you now completely housebound - no word salad there. If you’re going out for other things - eg shopping, seeing friends/family, dental appointments for example? If so fair enough - but you can’t say you can’t travel to work but you can still go out for other things

Your GP has put no driving because they don’t think you should drive - they’d have written no travel if they didn’t think you should be going anywhere. It’s not semantics or word salad - it’s the driving they don’t want you doing

Blushingm · Yesterday 09:32

user1482956724 · Yesterday 09:30

So paying £70 for that 1 day a week is just as cheap as using my car?

They know full well i am doing my contracted hours and often more (not paid).

Safety and Legal Risks

• Seatbelt Effectiveness: Elevation changes how a seatbelt sits across the pelvis and chest, which can reduce restraint effectiveness during sudden braking or a crash.
• Injury Risks: Unnatural leg positions can shift how impact forces travel through the hips, knees, and lower limbs in a collision.
• UK Rules: Drivers must ensure passengers wear seatbelts properly and travel safely. There is a consensus on Quora that improper seating or seatbelt use can lead to legal penalties for the driver.

You’re not going in a car anywhere at all then?

user1482956724 · Yesterday 09:33

Blushingm · Yesterday 09:31

You’ve not really answered the question. Are you now completely housebound - no word salad there. If you’re going out for other things - eg shopping, seeing friends/family, dental appointments for example? If so fair enough - but you can’t say you can’t travel to work but you can still go out for other things

Your GP has put no driving because they don’t think you should drive - they’d have written no travel if they didn’t think you should be going anywhere. It’s not semantics or word salad - it’s the driving they don’t want you doing

Yes, i am housebound. My daughter i law shops for me, pops in daily and does anything that needs doing. My meals are from Wiltshire farm foods.

OP posts:
user1482956724 · Yesterday 09:36

Blushingm · Yesterday 09:32

You’re not going in a car anywhere at all then?

No. I am housebound.

OP posts:
OneHazelBird · Yesterday 09:40

Join a union.
It may be too late for this written warning but may help you in the future.

I do not know the law around this but if you can’t travel, you can’t travel.

Getting a taxi for a 20 mile round trip is just not feasible and I absolutely would not be doing that.

What is the reason for needing to go into the office?

How long will this be an issue?

It may have been better to take it off sick completely, even the WFH as then this wouldn’t have been a conversation.

My car broke down and I couldn’t get into work.
We worked it out where I could use my AL or just not get paid for the few days I was off - was this not an option?

BoldlyLeaningPanda · Yesterday 09:51

You don't need to "register" in any way to be protected under discrimination law for adverse treatment due to disability.

Under the Equality Act 2010), a person has a disability if they have a physical or mental impairment that has a substantial and long-term adverse effect on their ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities. Your knee condition qualifies and their failure to put reasonable adjustments in place is discriminatory.

Write to your boss and HR something like this

Dear (...)

Further to our meeting and your consequent Written Warning - I believe that this Warning should be withdrawn and you need to reconsider your treatment of my situation or you will be committing Disability Discrimination against me and I will be forced to pursue this further.

Under the Equality Act 2010), a person has a disability if they have a physical or mental impairment that has a substantial and long-term adverse effect on their ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities. My knee condition is clearly covered by this, it is definitely long-term as there is no immediate prospect of a cure for it, and it is putting severe restrictions on my physical movement. My recent absences have been entirely due to your failure to put reasonable adjustments in place to allow me to continue to do my job. This is discriminatory, and all absences related to my knee issue should be entirely disregarded in calculations of trigger points for disciplinary measures. Therefore the Wriiten Warning is entirely inappropriate.

I am highly effective in my role and perform all my tasks to an excellent standard. It is grossly unfair to penalise me for the fact that I can currently only do so whilst working from home.

Yours etc

MargaretThursday · Yesterday 10:07

user1482956724 · Yesterday 09:22

They were in June. I saw my GP in September and was told, at that appointment to rest, elevate, not drive etc. I informed my boss, she requested the fit note, I provided it, but because it stated no driving and not no travel, my boss wanted it changed.

Now not sure about your GP but they dont get involved in word salads or corporate semantics. My GP only has one concern, my health and wellbeing. I did not ask my GP to sign me off, I advised her that no driving was unacceptable and they wanted no travel. In order to protect me, I was signed off.

I think this is the problem.

Your boss has seen "no driving" and wants it confirmed that you cannot travel. Sounds like they would have been happy to give flexibility wfh if your fit certificate said "no travel".
That may be because they've had others in the situation where their fit note says they can't drive and they have come in - so they're at risk of people challenging it.
But instead of coming back with "no travel", which would allow you to wfh, you've gone for being signed off.
Why?

I'm not sure what changed between the "I can wfh fine if you let me" to "because you asked for clarification on the travel I now can't wfh". I know you say you didn't ask the GP you off, but what did you actually say to make them change?

I'm sure you can see how odd it looks.

WeDid2 · Yesterday 10:11

I am very confused - 24hr elevation would risk blood clots surely? I’m shocked your medically guidance is full elevation 24/7 and so doesn’t allow you to drive.
you have spoken of how elevating is dangerous when driving rather than saying you can’t drive due to this being your right knee and it can’t move the pedals on an automatic car - so I am guessing it’s your left knee

user1482956724 · Yesterday 10:18

MargaretThursday · Yesterday 10:07

I think this is the problem.

Your boss has seen "no driving" and wants it confirmed that you cannot travel. Sounds like they would have been happy to give flexibility wfh if your fit certificate said "no travel".
That may be because they've had others in the situation where their fit note says they can't drive and they have come in - so they're at risk of people challenging it.
But instead of coming back with "no travel", which would allow you to wfh, you've gone for being signed off.
Why?

I'm not sure what changed between the "I can wfh fine if you let me" to "because you asked for clarification on the travel I now can't wfh". I know you say you didn't ask the GP you off, but what did you actually say to make them change?

I'm sure you can see how odd it looks.

I advised my GP that no driving was not accepted and they wanted no travel. My GP chose to sign me off.

My initial fit note very clearly stated that I was able to work from home. The wfh aspect of the note was ignored. My boss is fully aware I am waiting for a knee replacement. I have zero cartilage left, so my joint is bone on bone and I also have loose bone chips in the joint and yes, I did send the evidence of this.

OP posts:
JustaSongAboutPingPong · Yesterday 10:21

MargaretThursday · Yesterday 10:07

I think this is the problem.

Your boss has seen "no driving" and wants it confirmed that you cannot travel. Sounds like they would have been happy to give flexibility wfh if your fit certificate said "no travel".
That may be because they've had others in the situation where their fit note says they can't drive and they have come in - so they're at risk of people challenging it.
But instead of coming back with "no travel", which would allow you to wfh, you've gone for being signed off.
Why?

I'm not sure what changed between the "I can wfh fine if you let me" to "because you asked for clarification on the travel I now can't wfh". I know you say you didn't ask the GP you off, but what did you actually say to make them change?

I'm sure you can see how odd it looks.

It does look really odd and I can imagine they’re a hard time from your colleagues.

We’ve recently had a very similar situation at work and to say that it causes resentment in the team is a bit of an understatement. You were asked to change your Fit Note to “unable to travel” and instead you went off sick.

I’m assuming that your disability alters your trigger points but you’ll still have trigger points?

I have 3 conditions that are classed as disabilities under the act. One is arthritis, same as you. I’ve not missed one day with it so far. Perhaps in lucky but I do spend time making sure my weight is fine, that I have physio as soon as the pain increases, that I keep relatively active and I look after my gut health as this has such a dramatic effect on the pain and swelling.

MargaretThursday · Yesterday 10:23

user1482956724 · Yesterday 10:18

I advised my GP that no driving was not accepted and they wanted no travel. My GP chose to sign me off.

My initial fit note very clearly stated that I was able to work from home. The wfh aspect of the note was ignored. My boss is fully aware I am waiting for a knee replacement. I have zero cartilage left, so my joint is bone on bone and I also have loose bone chips in the joint and yes, I did send the evidence of this.

But from what I can tell, if your fit note had said "no travel" then your boss would be happy for you to wfh.
And you/your GP was happy for you to wfh too.

So why did it go to signed off instead? That's what they're concerned about.

You must be able to see how that looks. Perhaps ask your GP to explain why they were initially happy for you to work at home, but now are not. It can't be simply that work asked for the fit note to be changed to "no travel" if they were happy for you to wfh before.

user1482956724 · Yesterday 10:23

WeDid2 · Yesterday 10:11

I am very confused - 24hr elevation would risk blood clots surely? I’m shocked your medically guidance is full elevation 24/7 and so doesn’t allow you to drive.
you have spoken of how elevating is dangerous when driving rather than saying you can’t drive due to this being your right knee and it can’t move the pedals on an automatic car - so I am guessing it’s your left knee

I also said there is a rotation of heat and ice. Yes, there requires some movement which should be followed with ice application. I also wear medical compression stocking.

Its my right knee. My car is a motability vehicle suited to my needs. It is automatic so I am unable to carry out an emergency stop, equally bending and moving it is painful.

My elevation comments were in relation to using a taxi, it is unsafe to sit sideways with the leg elevated.

OP posts:
WeDid2 · Yesterday 10:28

maybe its worth looking into a mobility car that allows you to drive without using your legs. My friend in a wheel chair has controls where she just uses her hands.

user1482956724 · Yesterday 10:29

JustaSongAboutPingPong · Yesterday 10:21

It does look really odd and I can imagine they’re a hard time from your colleagues.

We’ve recently had a very similar situation at work and to say that it causes resentment in the team is a bit of an understatement. You were asked to change your Fit Note to “unable to travel” and instead you went off sick.

I’m assuming that your disability alters your trigger points but you’ll still have trigger points?

I have 3 conditions that are classed as disabilities under the act. One is arthritis, same as you. I’ve not missed one day with it so far. Perhaps in lucky but I do spend time making sure my weight is fine, that I have physio as soon as the pain increases, that I keep relatively active and I look after my gut health as this has such a dramatic effect on the pain and swelling.

Yes, I do look after myself thank you. I am not overweight and have always kept mobile. My disabilities (there is a list) have never caused sickness from work prior to this.

As stated, I have zero cartilage, so my joint is bone on bone, I also have loose bone fragments in the joint. Are you aware just how painful that is, how the joint literally gives out.

I do not control what choices my GP makes, her concern is my health and wellbeing.

OP posts:
user1482956724 · Yesterday 10:31

WeDid2 · Yesterday 10:28

maybe its worth looking into a mobility car that allows you to drive without using your legs. My friend in a wheel chair has controls where she just uses her hands.

My issue is temporary. The whole process to change my current car is expensive and takes a lot of time. Motability cannot just change my car overnight and not for a temporary issue.

OP posts:
Pearlstillsinging · Yesterday 10:36

Yourcousinrachel · Yesterday 01:03

Your employer is acting unfairly using standard attendance triggers. Osteoarthritis would count as a disability under equality act 2010. Employer not allowed to penalise you for disability related absence. You are entitled to reasonable adjustments.

Under the Acas disability definition, a condition is a legal disability if it is a physical or mental impairment with a substantial and long-term negative effect on your ability to do normal day-to-day activities:
Long-term: It has lasted, or is likely to last, at least 12 months. Because osteoarthritis is a chronic, progressive condition, it almost always meets this test.

Your employer should adjust absence trigger points or record disability related leave separately to standard sickness.
They got the occ health assessment confirming you can work from home , no travel, so why have they ignored that reasonable adjustment that was recommended?

If you havent got a copy of the absence policy, please get it.

1/ Please speak to the Acas helpline(0300 123 1100 or Arthritis UK.
2/ Please appeal the warning asap.
State clearly that:

  1. The absences are linked to osteoarthritis, which is a disability under the Equality Act 2010.
  2. Occupational Health specifically recommended working from home and no travel.
  3. Issuing a warning without implementing those reasonable adjustments—or adjusting absence trigger points—is unfair and potentially discriminatory.
  4. Request that the first written warning be removed, that the OH recommendations (WFH and no travel) be implemented immediately and that disability-related absences be excluded from standard sickness triggers.

Include somewhere in the letter that you had some difficulty persuading them to agree to occ health assessment originally, and ask why having finally agreed it, they have decided to ignore the specific recommendations made by occ health. Ask them to give a full account in writing of their reasons.

Once an employer knows about osteoarthritis, the law expects them to investigate its impact rather than blindly following a standard attendance policy

All of this.
Your employer is being ridiculous, HR is putting them at risk of a Disability Discrimination claim. Speak to ACAS ASAP.

IlovetoKnitandRead · Yesterday 10:38

My knee is in exactly the same condition as yours Op and I have been prescribed physio exercises, gentle swimming and an urgent knee replacement. At no time was I told to elevate my leg 24/7 a day. I am still, driving and going about my day and yes the pain is excruciating at times. I am shocked that you were signed off work and told not to drive. The waiting list for knee replacements is quite long. I have managed to get my BMI down and carry in with the exercises as they will strengthen my thigh for after surgery.

JustaSongAboutPingPong · Yesterday 10:41

user1482956724 · Yesterday 10:29

Yes, I do look after myself thank you. I am not overweight and have always kept mobile. My disabilities (there is a list) have never caused sickness from work prior to this.

As stated, I have zero cartilage, so my joint is bone on bone, I also have loose bone fragments in the joint. Are you aware just how painful that is, how the joint literally gives out.

I do not control what choices my GP makes, her concern is my health and wellbeing.

Yes, exactly the same here Smile

user1482956724 · Yesterday 10:49

IlovetoKnitandRead · Yesterday 10:38

My knee is in exactly the same condition as yours Op and I have been prescribed physio exercises, gentle swimming and an urgent knee replacement. At no time was I told to elevate my leg 24/7 a day. I am still, driving and going about my day and yes the pain is excruciating at times. I am shocked that you were signed off work and told not to drive. The waiting list for knee replacements is quite long. I have managed to get my BMI down and carry in with the exercises as they will strengthen my thigh for after surgery.

At no point have a said it has to be elevated 24/7.

I am unable to emergency stop. Can you? Because that is standard driving policy.

I have exercises to do, which are agony, but I do them, when I do, the joint swells, at that point it needs to be elevated and iced. My job is not a short drive away, it is a minimum hour, frequently 2 hour drive due to traffic, road works, congestion etc.

But hats off to you if you can do 2 hr drives with your knee. I am fully aware of building quad muscles to support the joint, especially useful after surgery.

OP posts:
Blushingm · Yesterday 10:55

IlovetoKnitandRead · Yesterday 10:38

My knee is in exactly the same condition as yours Op and I have been prescribed physio exercises, gentle swimming and an urgent knee replacement. At no time was I told to elevate my leg 24/7 a day. I am still, driving and going about my day and yes the pain is excruciating at times. I am shocked that you were signed off work and told not to drive. The waiting list for knee replacements is quite long. I have managed to get my BMI down and carry in with the exercises as they will strengthen my thigh for after surgery.

Elevation Is not the recommended advice for osteoarthritis you’re correct. Many people wear compression stockings too which has no effect on mobility or driving or anything like that. I worked with someone who had a fused knee joint (straight) and could travel by car by putting the seat back to accommodate his straight leg

OP seems to be coming out with excuses

Blushingm · Yesterday 10:56

user1482956724 · Yesterday 10:49

At no point have a said it has to be elevated 24/7.

I am unable to emergency stop. Can you? Because that is standard driving policy.

I have exercises to do, which are agony, but I do them, when I do, the joint swells, at that point it needs to be elevated and iced. My job is not a short drive away, it is a minimum hour, frequently 2 hour drive due to traffic, road works, congestion etc.

But hats off to you if you can do 2 hr drives with your knee. I am fully aware of building quad muscles to support the joint, especially useful after surgery.

You said it was a 25 minute journey in taxi in a previous post

user1482956724 · Yesterday 10:58

Blushingm · Yesterday 10:55

Elevation Is not the recommended advice for osteoarthritis you’re correct. Many people wear compression stockings too which has no effect on mobility or driving or anything like that. I worked with someone who had a fused knee joint (straight) and could travel by car by putting the seat back to accommodate his straight leg

OP seems to be coming out with excuses

Awww ok. Can I please see your medical qualifications and transcript from your conversation with my practitioner.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread