Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

denied flexible working?

59 replies

ThatFairPombear · 17/11/2026 08:32

sorry this is a long one

hi all, i was hoping someone may be able to give any advice.

I work in the NHS in a mental health community team and it is a patient facing role however when i applied for the role it was advertised as hybrid however on my first day i was told they no longer offer hybrid in that particular team (even though most of the other teams across the trust continued to work from home) my manager just decided to scrap it in our team. so then all wfh had to be agreed with a flexible working application, the past 3 years i’ve been there there has been several parents wfh 2 days a week and so they proved it was possible, yes we are patient facing but we have a huge amount of admin that could be done remotely. So i returned to work September 14th and on the very first day i spoke to my manager and explained i wanted to make a flexible working application for thursday and friday at home due to childcare, i made it very clear that i would not be at home with my child but it was more so to balance the commute as thurs and friday our childminder only offered 10-3.30pm. So he verbally said should be fine, said hr ‘throw’ everything at mothers with children etc, but he told me to hold off with the application as we were undergoing a community transformation. So spoke to him several more times each time he was very positive about it and said it was fine with him etc, i submitted my application on the 21st of October, was told i had to meet with the director of HR who essentially said i was asking for to much: Now i would be annoyed but accepting of this is wfh wasn’t the norm in our trust and how i have friends all across the trust who continue to wfh in an informal and casual basis with no flexible working applications, no meeting the with the HR director etc and when i asked her why this was she explained that the new CEO wants to get rid of all flexible working in the trust (blanket rule?) my manager later told me that the trust have spoken to all the unions and explained they are going to end flexible working and don’t want grievances and the unions have supported this. so all they could offer me was going part time reducing my salary by half, when there are parents including fathers who continue to work from home. Im so disappointed and frankly very angry. Any advice would be helpful. is this legal?!

OP posts:
QuiteAnExperiencedManager · 17/11/2026 14:23

Changed my username for this response, but I've been an NHS manager for some years.

Firstly. Read the trust policy. There will be a flexible working policy likely supported by a process and guidance for managers. In particular understand the 8 reasons a request may be declined, these are the only reasons a request can be declined.

Make your request. In it set out what you want and the impact on your work and the team. The trust then has 2 months to provide a formal response, this is a legal requirement.

If it's turned down appeal the decision ensuring you fully understand which of the 8 grounds it's declined under. When you attend the appeal meeting make sure you've got a good union rep with you.

On the restructure point, the trust must be actively restructuring to use this as a reason to decline. Stating it's something they 'may' do in the future is insufficient. You have mentioned what other people do. This is of absolutely no relevance to your situation. Requests must be dealt with in the order they're received, so if others working from home (or in any other way flexibly) means your request cannot be accommodated you can't appeal on grounds of fairness.

Many managers struggle with this, but the best way to make your case is know the law and follow the process.

Good luck

LostInTheDream · 17/11/2026 14:35

For a formal flexible working request there are 8 statutory reasons to reject.

"the new CEO wants to get rid of all flexible working in the trust (blanket rule?)" is not one of those reasons on its own.

They need to tell you exactly what that reason is.
Usually when you submit a request you have to think about what impact it will have on your team and on your work. I don't think that the NHS would be different to other organisations with this regard (as mine have been similar on public and private sector).

Whilst what other people are doing informally or formally doesn't really have any bearing, it will make some of the reasonings they might give seem less plausible.

WFH on an informal basis is not the same as a flexible working request. It is your legal right to make a firmal flexible working request and they really do need to give proper reasoning about why your request is too much based on the 8 reasons specified that they are allowed to reject.

I do think it's easy for them to say those reasons are present, and I'd want that assessment to be evidence based to some extent. Seek support of your union.

I'd also ask if they are open to a trial if it feels a bit hypothetical.

Ireallywantadoughnut36 · 17/11/2026 14:45

They should send you a letter explaining why, and you can appeal this- it's individual, so don't appeal with "other people do this", instead appeal with a response to the business requirement that they've flagged.
I'd also discuss with your manager, whilst it isn't as confirmed as a flexible working agreement, surely if it genuinely is just admin those days, can you and he agree you (generally) wfh those days? I've never had my wfh agreements made contractually or through a flexible working request, I've always done it ad hoc and my managers have always just respected that my work is done. Given your manager had been OK with it, can you ask to do at least one of the admin days from home and see how it goes? I appreciate it doesn't solve the hours issue or if they change things around they will be able to insist you come in, but it'd be fine short term.

somanythingssolittletime · 17/11/2026 14:45

What’s the business reason they denied the flexible work request? The law is clear, there are very specific reasons to decline it. But you can’t base your request on “other people do it”. You have to provide a plan on how you will be covering your work during wfh/reduced hours and who will cover your remaining tasks or patient facing responsibilities when you aren’t on site or online.

Cadenza12 · 17/11/2026 15:05

You've ignored the best response which is to consult with your union. You need to join if you're not a member. The chances of the trust getting rid of flexible working practices are just about zero.

GaaNeen · 17/11/2026 15:12

The business reason will be service delivery there will be patients to be seen
when clinicians are doing admin, they will still need to be available to respond to clinical needs that arise
OP is working with the most severe
end of mental
health community care

SparklyGingerMum · 17/11/2026 15:25

I can't imagine the unions just accepting this change without any consultations and a detriment to their members. If I were you I would be looking to speak to your union rep before you do any thing else.

Chilly80 · 17/11/2026 15:45

SparklyGingerMum · 17/11/2026 15:25

I can't imagine the unions just accepting this change without any consultations and a detriment to their members. If I were you I would be looking to speak to your union rep before you do any thing else.

Yes this definitely sounds fishy.

Also saying they are scrapping all flexible working. Asking for a flexible working arrangement is a law although it doesn't have to be agreed they have to have a business justification to reject it.

Foodylicious · 17/11/2026 16:14

ThatFairPombear · 17/11/2026 09:45

the thing is there has been no written letters this has all been in persons meetings either via teams or in person. I am not sure if i made it clear, but i offered to reduce my hours to 10-3, so i dont need to make up missing hours as my pay would be reduced

They have to provide you with a written response to the flexible working application citing clear business reasons why they are not able to support your request.
I hope your union is supporting you with this?

Foodylicious · 17/11/2026 16:19

One of the reasons they may not support that reduction in hours, is that they likely can't fill those hours, so that would stand as a business reason (if that is true).
You might be in a better position if you can ask for compressed hours, and work longer on some of your other days.

Alternatively, if they cannot support you working reduced hours on a Friday at all (separating this from wfh for a moment) then you could ask for a temporary reduction in hours whilst you find alternative childcare.

How have you been managing the last few weeks?

LatteLady · 17/11/2026 17:14

Union and Freedom to Speak Up Guardian are your starting points on this. Also, check if there have been any announcement from your new CEO... I rather doubt it...

ItsMeee00 · 17/11/2026 17:16

NHS worker here, my team (I’m not the manager) still have a very hybrid working model however the mental health team in the same building have been stopped WFH by their team lead and have to either be on visits or in the office to do admin etc. I would imagine a lot of teams will be stopped WFH before long, it was never a thing until Covid and if you had children you worked your hours accordingly, clinical staff even more so.

CatA27 · 17/11/2026 17:20

I havent read the whole thread so dont know if someone else has mentioned this but google "changes to flexible working law"

Oxymorons · 17/11/2026 17:35

ThatFairPombear · 17/11/2026 09:45

the thing is there has been no written letters this has all been in persons meetings either via teams or in person. I am not sure if i made it clear, but i offered to reduce my hours to 10-3, so i dont need to make up missing hours as my pay would be reduced

That's not right if you have completed the flexible working application. It would be reasonable to have a discussion following their decision to refuse or allow, but that would have to be accompanied by the decision letter. So that's strike 1
Strike 2, the person who gave you feedback said the CEO wants to stop working from home. So if there hadn't been an official decision on this, followed by revised HR policies, this is very wrong.
This is more an issue of not following HR policies to the letter and that includes recording of a flexible working decision and working from home policies
Get thee to your Union. Good luck

Southernsunflower · 17/11/2026 17:57

Speak to Acas,or maternity action if you’ve recently returned from Mat leave. have they offered you a trial or any alternatives? could you offer to do 1 day rather than 2? Also look at case law relating to indirect sex discrimination, the law is changing around flexible working coming in to force next year. I had a similar situation last year it’s stressful! Hope you get sorted!

Vse500 · 17/11/2026 18:48

It’s a job that is a patient facing role. Whether you have admin to do or not, surely you can see why they are beginning to phase wfh out for jobs like this.

Hocuspocuspreparatus · 17/11/2026 18:58

May I ask which trust is it? This is the norm
in NHS, it happens all the time, they sound positive and then rejection come straight in with all the form HR meetings etc. unfortunately, its a culture in NHS. Check what the trust website its saying and what is their policy, as 100% all trust have flexible working policy and People Promise: The NHS People Promise
At the heart of the workforce strategy is the NHS People Promise, which outlines what NHS staff can expect from each other. It focuses on seven key commitments: 1, 2]

  • We are compassionate and inclusive
  • We are recognised and rewarded
  • We each have a voice that counts
  • We are safe and healthy
  • We are always learning
  • We work flexibly
  • We are a team

NHS England » Our NHS People Promise

NHS England » Our NHS People Promise

https://www.google.com/goto?url=CAESkwEBxCJF18iWVydaJeqckanUbuq1xd7mcqNUH4L3Gxb-QGlV1AJZgEy6BhkVbifAJAMO-yc2H0qmuUMMJIF-iyz9oTuZHkefEX6uh40hCt33qstM_4Dz3Vvq7p9cn1a4SIou-94_nGopskRDMtWv-1PSEzcWmcRKHd6aj9Azeiib6sPSvYqDHUeODONwiTt41c08wfg

mybiggreenfrog · 17/11/2026 19:20

Have you had the reasons for declining your request in writing? If not ask for them. If you have them what we're they?

Join a different union!

Tokek · 17/11/2026 20:24

ItsMeee00 · 17/11/2026 17:16

NHS worker here, my team (I’m not the manager) still have a very hybrid working model however the mental health team in the same building have been stopped WFH by their team lead and have to either be on visits or in the office to do admin etc. I would imagine a lot of teams will be stopped WFH before long, it was never a thing until Covid and if you had children you worked your hours accordingly, clinical staff even more so.

Not true. I worked and had MH placements in a couple of trusts before COVID and hybrid working was the norm. As long as you were getting your patient contacts and follow up work done, it didn't matter if you were going home or to the office after to do the latter.

The OP's situation seems different though, as "WFH" for her seems to mean being at home the whole time. For many CMHT members, it means admin at home but still going out on visits. Not sure why OP you couldn't do that? There may be less of an issue with you not seeing patients on certain days then. But yeah, as everyone else has said speak to your union first, it sounds very off that they've apparently agreed to a new arrangement without consultation.

TY78910 · 17/11/2026 20:32

They need to formally reject it in writing and tell you why exactly citing one of the (6 or 7 can’t remember exactly) reasons. For example: we can’t offer you Thursdays WFH, because 40% of our team already do so, meaning we are unable to meet all patient facing / office based tasks.

Taking emotion out of it (and I don’t doubt that it’s frustrating and seems unfair), a business doesn’t need to grant FW changes if it negatively impacts the operation. If a high level of staff have an agreement in place for the same day, they may not be able to support your request - not everyone can have the same thing.

Your manager was highly unprofessional in what he said verbally. Even though this may be the perception, it does not mean it’s reality.

When I consider people’s FW requests, I don’t have a full picture until I partner with several other departments that have the data to see what is actually possible. I could never on the face of it tell someone ‘yeah should be fine’ before running it through scheduling and HR first.

tenterden · 17/11/2026 20:34

I would speak to your union rep, they are usually great at supporting with flexible working requests.

SylvanMoon · 17/11/2026 20:38

I would get straight onto your union about this, especially if as has been communicated to you, a future change is being mooted. It hasn't happened yet, so you should be within your statutory rights to request it and be granted it. Good luck.

nc43214321 · 17/11/2026 20:41

Sure there is new legislation on the way for flexible working.

Bedtimeread · 17/11/2026 20:46

I don’t understand how they can decline it but allow others to do it. I think that’s where you need to speak to the union- it’s got to be fair and equitable x

ItsMeee00 · 17/11/2026 20:46

Tokek · 17/11/2026 20:24

Not true. I worked and had MH placements in a couple of trusts before COVID and hybrid working was the norm. As long as you were getting your patient contacts and follow up work done, it didn't matter if you were going home or to the office after to do the latter.

The OP's situation seems different though, as "WFH" for her seems to mean being at home the whole time. For many CMHT members, it means admin at home but still going out on visits. Not sure why OP you couldn't do that? There may be less of an issue with you not seeing patients on certain days then. But yeah, as everyone else has said speak to your union first, it sounds very off that they've apparently agreed to a new arrangement without consultation.

That’s your take Tokek I was stating what I know of the office/Trust that I’ve worked in for the last 17.5 years, everywhere is different so don’t blanket say not true when it most definitely is otherwise I wouldn’t have given by opinion based on my everyday working experience, which as I originally said has changed dramatically since Covid.

Swipe left for the next trending thread