Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

denied flexible working?

59 replies

ThatFairPombear · 17/11/2026 08:32

sorry this is a long one

hi all, i was hoping someone may be able to give any advice.

I work in the NHS in a mental health community team and it is a patient facing role however when i applied for the role it was advertised as hybrid however on my first day i was told they no longer offer hybrid in that particular team (even though most of the other teams across the trust continued to work from home) my manager just decided to scrap it in our team. so then all wfh had to be agreed with a flexible working application, the past 3 years i’ve been there there has been several parents wfh 2 days a week and so they proved it was possible, yes we are patient facing but we have a huge amount of admin that could be done remotely. So i returned to work September 14th and on the very first day i spoke to my manager and explained i wanted to make a flexible working application for thursday and friday at home due to childcare, i made it very clear that i would not be at home with my child but it was more so to balance the commute as thurs and friday our childminder only offered 10-3.30pm. So he verbally said should be fine, said hr ‘throw’ everything at mothers with children etc, but he told me to hold off with the application as we were undergoing a community transformation. So spoke to him several more times each time he was very positive about it and said it was fine with him etc, i submitted my application on the 21st of October, was told i had to meet with the director of HR who essentially said i was asking for to much: Now i would be annoyed but accepting of this is wfh wasn’t the norm in our trust and how i have friends all across the trust who continue to wfh in an informal and casual basis with no flexible working applications, no meeting the with the HR director etc and when i asked her why this was she explained that the new CEO wants to get rid of all flexible working in the trust (blanket rule?) my manager later told me that the trust have spoken to all the unions and explained they are going to end flexible working and don’t want grievances and the unions have supported this. so all they could offer me was going part time reducing my salary by half, when there are parents including fathers who continue to work from home. Im so disappointed and frankly very angry. Any advice would be helpful. is this legal?!

OP posts:
LivingDeadGirlUK · 17/11/2026 08:36

I would speak to your union as that sounds like BS to me!

Rosesarere · 17/11/2026 08:40

Would the hours you are wanting to work from home normally be patient facing? 2 days wf when you have a patient facing role seems a huge amount of hours spent at home and not patient facing?

ThatFairPombear · 17/11/2026 08:44

Rosesarere · 17/11/2026 08:40

Would the hours you are wanting to work from home normally be patient facing? 2 days wf when you have a patient facing role seems a huge amount of hours spent at home and not patient facing?

Not necessarily, like i said we have huge amounts of admin i would say we are 50/50 patient facing and admin. And staff have and still are doing it for the last 3 years, and it was never an issue then. I would be patient facing 22.5 hours a week, that’s significant.

OP posts:
Overthebow · 17/11/2026 08:45

Are the people in your team that wfh doing so on the days you want to? Maybe there’s not capacity for you to wfh those days too? Have you tried asking for different days?

Overthebow · 17/11/2026 08:46

Also what are your working hours on Thursday and Fridays? If childminder is 10-3.30 you’d only realistically be working 10.15 to 3.15, is that all you have to do those days?

ThatFairPombear · 17/11/2026 08:48

Overthebow · 17/11/2026 08:45

Are the people in your team that wfh doing so on the days you want to? Maybe there’s not capacity for you to wfh those days too? Have you tried asking for different days?

nope nobody is working from home on the both days i need, i asked my manager and initially he said it was fine. The director of HR explained that there are often teams where there is no one on site on a friday but that’s certainly not my team and surely that’s a issue of bad management and should be dealt with as an individual case rather than blanket rule?

OP posts:
ThatFairPombear · 17/11/2026 08:49

Overthebow · 17/11/2026 08:46

Also what are your working hours on Thursday and Fridays? If childminder is 10-3.30 you’d only realistically be working 10.15 to 3.15, is that all you have to do those days?

yes i agreed that i would wfh 10-3 on thursday and friday so reducing my hours but they still denied this.

OP posts:
GaaNeen · 17/11/2026 08:55

I wonder if the trust have plans to review the existing job plans and get more staff increasing their clinical contact hours so less WFH
it is not true that admin will be 50% of your job plans
of that IS true that is crazy
B7 will be 70% clinical contacts
you can’t really work in community mental health and rely on WFH - the patients / service must come first
what role / band are you ?

ThatFairPombear · 17/11/2026 09:13

GaaNeen · 17/11/2026 08:55

I wonder if the trust have plans to review the existing job plans and get more staff increasing their clinical contact hours so less WFH
it is not true that admin will be 50% of your job plans
of that IS true that is crazy
B7 will be 70% clinical contacts
you can’t really work in community mental health and rely on WFH - the patients / service must come first
what role / band are you ?

so, i proposed that i would work 7.5 hours mon - wednesday in the office patient facing, 5 hours thursday and friday at home. That’s a total of 32.5 hours, 70% of that is 22.75 so there is my 70% patient facing time. I am a band 7 but that’s irrelevant when two other parents both band 7 wfh from home one two days a week one one day a week.

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 17/11/2026 09:18

Overthebow · 17/11/2026 08:46

Also what are your working hours on Thursday and Fridays? If childminder is 10-3.30 you’d only realistically be working 10.15 to 3.15, is that all you have to do those days?

If it’s admin, she can also be doing work outwith working hours. Thats what “flexible” means.

Overthebow · 17/11/2026 09:22

BoredZelda · 17/11/2026 09:18

If it’s admin, she can also be doing work outwith working hours. Thats what “flexible” means.

Depends on the job role and if need to be available for calls. In my job for example I can work flexibly to an extent but I do need to be available most working hours, I wouldn’t be able to have an arrangement where I finished at 3pm and then caught up in the evening every week, but once in a while it would be fine.

GaaNeen · 17/11/2026 09:24

ThatFairPombear · 17/11/2026 09:13

so, i proposed that i would work 7.5 hours mon - wednesday in the office patient facing, 5 hours thursday and friday at home. That’s a total of 32.5 hours, 70% of that is 22.75 so there is my 70% patient facing time. I am a band 7 but that’s irrelevant when two other parents both band 7 wfh from home one two days a week one one day a week.

Depends what their job plans are -
clinicians can have different responsibilities of course
and I suspect as part of your transformation process their WFH arrangements are unlikely to be set in stone -
CMHT is not the place for you if your childcare relies on WFH -

Quicktastyandfilling · 17/11/2026 09:24

It sounds like senior managament thinks wfh is not the way they want to go going forward. They can't change the agreements with your colleagues that are already in place but they can deny future requests. It sucks OP and they risk loosing experienced staff.

ThatFairPombear · 17/11/2026 09:25

Overthebow · 17/11/2026 09:22

Depends on the job role and if need to be available for calls. In my job for example I can work flexibly to an extent but I do need to be available most working hours, I wouldn’t be able to have an arrangement where I finished at 3pm and then caught up in the evening every week, but once in a while it would be fine.

understand, but we have a flexible working policy and it states that our hours can be compressed, part time, etc. I think the latest we could work would be 6, but i would be working 35.2 hours a week, it’s not an issue of hours because the only thing they could offer me was part time work lol

OP posts:
rwalker · 17/11/2026 09:26

Flexible working agreement are individual you need to stop comparing
from the business sense wfh takes out flexibility to switch you from office to patient facing
it’s sounds like they aren’t rescinding in existing arrangements but not doing any new ones

GaaNeen · 17/11/2026 09:28

Quicktastyandfilling · 17/11/2026 09:24

It sounds like senior managament thinks wfh is not the way they want to go going forward. They can't change the agreements with your colleagues that are already in place but they can deny future requests. It sucks OP and they risk loosing experienced staff.

True. Remember the work place is community mental health -
these are the patients with the most severe mental health disorders
people are rightly concerned about the difficulties getting themselves and loved ones into mental health services
how does that balance with OP who said 50% of her time is admin and wants to work from home -
she has since changed that to 30% admin so something does not sit right here -

Unsurer · 17/11/2026 09:32

I would speak to your Union. I am of the mind that if flexibility can be offered, it should be offered.

However, I had my children long before Covid and I must say that as a manager, some of the carry on from the mothers in my department is quite ridiculous

MyLifeInBooks · 17/11/2026 09:41

@ThatFairPombear what was the exact wording in your letter from HR. I think that's important here as there are only a handful of situations where flexible working can be denied.

Generally, your childcare is your problem. One question does come up: When would you make up the missing hours? Realistically you need to look for a childcare setting that covers your working hours on Thursday & Friday. I read between the lines that your request was denied because there is some concern about meeting the contracted hours... correct me if I am wrong.

ThatFairPombear · 17/11/2026 09:43

Unsurer · 17/11/2026 09:32

I would speak to your Union. I am of the mind that if flexibility can be offered, it should be offered.

However, I had my children long before Covid and I must say that as a manager, some of the carry on from the mothers in my department is quite ridiculous

totally agree!! there are plenty of people including mothers than take the p* HOWEVER staff making requests made for genuine reasons with willingness to compromise / reduce some of my pay should not be penalized because of poor management across the trust, it feels very disproportionate

OP posts:
ThatFairPombear · 17/11/2026 09:45

MyLifeInBooks · 17/11/2026 09:41

@ThatFairPombear what was the exact wording in your letter from HR. I think that's important here as there are only a handful of situations where flexible working can be denied.

Generally, your childcare is your problem. One question does come up: When would you make up the missing hours? Realistically you need to look for a childcare setting that covers your working hours on Thursday & Friday. I read between the lines that your request was denied because there is some concern about meeting the contracted hours... correct me if I am wrong.

the thing is there has been no written letters this has all been in persons meetings either via teams or in person. I am not sure if i made it clear, but i offered to reduce my hours to 10-3, so i dont need to make up missing hours as my pay would be reduced

OP posts:
MyLifeInBooks · 17/11/2026 09:53

ThatFairPombear · 17/11/2026 09:45

the thing is there has been no written letters this has all been in persons meetings either via teams or in person. I am not sure if i made it clear, but i offered to reduce my hours to 10-3, so i dont need to make up missing hours as my pay would be reduced

So their counter offer was to go PT? As in dropping enough hours to make it viable to employ another person to make up the missing working hours in your team? Honestly, that's reasonable & legal. But you need to get it all in writing.

They did not deny flexible working as such, they denied the reduction in hours as a result of your flexible working request. Granted it was probably worded a bit wrong or you misunderstood, but that's why you need to have it all in writing.

MyLifeInBooks · 17/11/2026 09:54

Ask HR for a letter of confirmation... and go from there.

CDgirl · 17/11/2026 14:09

Hello. Can I check those hours as you've said childminder is 10-3.30 but you proposed working 10-3? That would be impossible as you couldn't start work and the time you need to drop off. Unfortunately more employers seem to be looking to standardise hours and WFH seems to be harder to get. Have you considered different child care arrangements that might work better?

Itsbeenalongtimeincoming · 17/11/2026 14:17

So your questions is - is this legal? From what you have said - yes.

You don't seem to have anything in your contract or in writing, so they aren't breaking your contract by denying you WFH two days a week.

You requested a charge of working environment (as is your right to do so). Verbally, your manager was amiable, but you acknowledge an application process so this would have been supportive but not where the decision is made.

Your employers evaluated the request and denied your request (which again they can do if they feel it is detrimental).

You effectively did ask for less hours on Thursday and Friday, so they tried to accommodate you by reducing your hours.

What other people are doing or have done isn't legally binding to you. Some may have it approved in writing, so their contracts may need to be changed if this is the new policy and frankly, they would have a case with their union.

Your role is predominately patient facing as a role and while you acknowledge there is a huge amount of paper work (I'm sure this is true), it may not warrant being at home to do it, nor warrant not being in the 'office' for patients should for example someone in your team be ill or already working from home based on written agreed changes to their contract.

I get it isn't what you want to hear, but I don't actually see the issue beside it just kinda sucks for you.

Sweethoneydew · 17/11/2026 14:23

ThatFairPombear · 17/11/2026 08:32

sorry this is a long one

hi all, i was hoping someone may be able to give any advice.

I work in the NHS in a mental health community team and it is a patient facing role however when i applied for the role it was advertised as hybrid however on my first day i was told they no longer offer hybrid in that particular team (even though most of the other teams across the trust continued to work from home) my manager just decided to scrap it in our team. so then all wfh had to be agreed with a flexible working application, the past 3 years i’ve been there there has been several parents wfh 2 days a week and so they proved it was possible, yes we are patient facing but we have a huge amount of admin that could be done remotely. So i returned to work September 14th and on the very first day i spoke to my manager and explained i wanted to make a flexible working application for thursday and friday at home due to childcare, i made it very clear that i would not be at home with my child but it was more so to balance the commute as thurs and friday our childminder only offered 10-3.30pm. So he verbally said should be fine, said hr ‘throw’ everything at mothers with children etc, but he told me to hold off with the application as we were undergoing a community transformation. So spoke to him several more times each time he was very positive about it and said it was fine with him etc, i submitted my application on the 21st of October, was told i had to meet with the director of HR who essentially said i was asking for to much: Now i would be annoyed but accepting of this is wfh wasn’t the norm in our trust and how i have friends all across the trust who continue to wfh in an informal and casual basis with no flexible working applications, no meeting the with the HR director etc and when i asked her why this was she explained that the new CEO wants to get rid of all flexible working in the trust (blanket rule?) my manager later told me that the trust have spoken to all the unions and explained they are going to end flexible working and don’t want grievances and the unions have supported this. so all they could offer me was going part time reducing my salary by half, when there are parents including fathers who continue to work from home. Im so disappointed and frankly very angry. Any advice would be helpful. is this legal?!

Sorry you’re going through this. I had a major issue with HR (not in the nhs!) when I went back to work to get my request formally agreed. This was to work an extra 3 hrs mon-thurs so I could finish at 1pm on a Friday. The only option HR wanted to give was reducing hours so you have a pay cut - absolute joke.

In the end, I got a “ local agreement” in writing because HR could not give me a legal answer as to why I couldn’t have my flexible working agreement signed off officially. My manager knew this, probably didn’t want me to take it further as I’m pretty sure I had a solid grievance.

You should speak to acas, it’s free! They were helpful when I spoke to them about my flexible working request.

Ultimately, HR need to give you a business reason as listed below. Ask them which one applies to denying you your request -

By law, an employer can only refuse a statutory request for one or more of eight business reasons:

  • The burden of additional costs
  • An inability to reorganise work among existing staff
  • An inability to recruit additional staff
  • A detrimental impact on quality
  • A detrimental impact on performance
  • A detrimental effect on the ability to meet customer demand
  • Insufficient work during the periods the employee proposes to work
  • Planned structural changes to the business

A refusal must be based on evidence and not assumptions. The employer should explain which reason applies and how it affects the business.