Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How to repair the Equality Act

53 replies

IwantToRetire · Yesterday 19:36

I am not posting this because I support the aims of the article, but it has come up on a number of threads, that one of the reasons so many are continuing to challenge or ignore the Supreme Court ruling is because they want to create climate where is seems there is no other option than to change the status of Sex in the EA.

And that some MPs are actively working with them.

https://translucent.org.uk/how-to-repair-the-equality-act-2010-melanie-field-obe/

OP posts:
Pingponghavoc · Yesterday 23:35

Its a brave move to shed more light on the GRA process.

I think lots of people assume its more robust than it is. The hardest part is the wait for an appointment. The diagnosis itself is straightforward. And after that, a GRC is issued in weeks.

I think itll be difficult to square that with actually being treated as the opposite sex for all purposes.

Transperson · Yesterday 23:37

Pingponghavoc · Yesterday 23:35

Its a brave move to shed more light on the GRA process.

I think lots of people assume its more robust than it is. The hardest part is the wait for an appointment. The diagnosis itself is straightforward. And after that, a GRC is issued in weeks.

I think itll be difficult to square that with actually being treated as the opposite sex for all purposes.

You need to live 2 years in your affirmed gender before you can apply.

Pingponghavoc · Yesterday 23:41

People can do that before the diagnosis and while they wait for an appointment.

As I said, the hardest part is the time on the waiting list.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 23:44

It's not policing language to point out someone's politically driven decision to avoid the obvious and common language everyone else uses is neither natural nor effective nor accurate.

Nor is it policing language to highlight how this political reframing of women, the humans who have adult female biology, into a fractured set of supposedly unrelated identities, is worse for female people than simply recognising those identities alongside our common existence as female people.

alcovecupboards · Today 00:18

It's the most likely outcome frankly. We will be in a situation where there is no balance because there isn't any currently - and it will be reversed. And then we'll all be sorry. But hey, at least some people got a few years where they could be truly vile to trans people openly. Though no doubt they will pretend they never were when the time comes.

Transperson · Today 00:22

alcovecupboards · Today 00:18

It's the most likely outcome frankly. We will be in a situation where there is no balance because there isn't any currently - and it will be reversed. And then we'll all be sorry. But hey, at least some people got a few years where they could be truly vile to trans people openly. Though no doubt they will pretend they never were when the time comes.

The internet never forgets.

WallaceinAnderland · Today 00:23

There aren't going to be many MPs willing to stand up and explain why they think safeguarding should be dismantled for women and children.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 00:27

Women simply aren't the same as men who claim to be women. That is the be all and end all.

Any move to make women's spaces, rights, provisions or language "inclusive" of transwomen is implicitly accepting ss truth the belief these men have a genuine claim to be more like female people than other men.

And that belief turns every woman on the planet from simply a human female to some sort of assumes mental gender

It deprioritises all the physical and sex-influenced risks, experiences and challenges of women in favour of those things men who claim to be women experience.

It is a shocking, despicable thing to impose on women.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 00:29

"Balancing" transwomen's desire to be included as women with women's knowledge that they are not is like balancing slave-owners' desire to keep slaves with enslaved people's desire to be free.

Transperson · Today 00:30

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 00:27

Women simply aren't the same as men who claim to be women. That is the be all and end all.

Any move to make women's spaces, rights, provisions or language "inclusive" of transwomen is implicitly accepting ss truth the belief these men have a genuine claim to be more like female people than other men.

And that belief turns every woman on the planet from simply a human female to some sort of assumes mental gender

It deprioritises all the physical and sex-influenced risks, experiences and challenges of women in favour of those things men who claim to be women experience.

It is a shocking, despicable thing to impose on women.

"claim to be more like female people than other men." This is true though? Trans women are more female than cis males.

Like objectively it is, phenotypic sex isn't made up. Feed this to Google or something.

alcovecupboards · Today 00:34

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 00:29

"Balancing" transwomen's desire to be included as women with women's knowledge that they are not is like balancing slave-owners' desire to keep slaves with enslaved people's desire to be free.

Edited

What a truly revolting thing to say. Do better.

Tears0fTheMushroom · Today 00:46

Transperson · Today 00:30

"claim to be more like female people than other men." This is true though? Trans women are more female than cis males.

Like objectively it is, phenotypic sex isn't made up. Feed this to Google or something.

Phenotype

Cary Elwes GIF
FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 01:03

alcovecupboards · Today 00:34

What a truly revolting thing to say. Do better.

I stand by it.

I get that you do not understand just how offensive and negating transwomen's claims of womanhood are to the separate reality of female people.

That is your problem, not mine.

Female people matter. The idea that we should be "balancing" recognition of our existence with the emotional demands of men who for whatever reason claim they are somehow also women is utterly abhorrent, just as negating of half of humanity as the sexism previous generations wrote into their laws.

You should do better.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 01:07

alcovecupboards · Today 00:34

What a truly revolting thing to say. Do better.

And your sexism revolts me. So I guess we are "balanced".

Which means by your values you should be ok with that.

Unless you only value "balance" when it's other people's rights and values you are giving away? Yours are sacrosanct, everyone else's are contingent?

alcovecupboards · Today 01:09

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 01:03

I stand by it.

I get that you do not understand just how offensive and negating transwomen's claims of womanhood are to the separate reality of female people.

That is your problem, not mine.

Female people matter. The idea that we should be "balancing" recognition of our existence with the emotional demands of men who for whatever reason claim they are somehow also women is utterly abhorrent, just as negating of half of humanity as the sexism previous generations wrote into their laws.

You should do better.

Are you black?

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 01:09

alcovecupboards · Today 01:09

Are you black?

Are you?

Tears0fTheMushroom · Today 01:17

alcovecupboards · Today 01:09

Are you black?

Are you assuming that in the history of humanity only black people have ever been enslaved and therefore only black people are allowed to mention slavery in any context?

There are women enslaved in the world right now who are not black (as well as some who are)
Believe it or not, slavery and people trafficking is not an historical event nor is it dependent on race.

IwantToRetire · Today 01:32

theilltemperedmonster · Yesterday 22:47

From the article:

I strongly defend people’s right to hold beliefs that I don’t share, but the law must draw the line where manifesting a belief has a disproportionate impact on the ability of others to enjoy their own rights and freedoms.

I agree with her.

What do you agree with. That over 50% of the population, ie biological females should have their rights undermined to give priority to the approximatley 10,000 people with GRCs?

I know it has now become common on this Feminism and Women's Rights forum to treat women who support women's rights as some sort of unimportant minority, but trying to say 10,000 people, and lets say 75% of them are TW that they should take precedence?

OP posts:
FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 01:32

Thank you. I spoke of "slave owners" and "enslaved people" to highlight the power and cost disparity. I deliberately did not narrow this to the Transatlanic slave trade because that carried horrors beyond the owner/slave power dynamic.

However, in the context of massice scale horrors, these are sobering numbers: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1353829222002039

5. Conclusions
There is consistent evidence of a survival disadvantage for girls and women in son-preference countries. There are over 126 million girls and women ‘missing’ from the world today. The survival disadvantage of girls increased significantly after the introduction of sex-selection technologies, which greatly compounded existing structural inequalities. Despite some improvements over time, male-skewed population sex ratios in many countries are still of concern. Time-series data and projections suggest the problem is getting worse in absolute terms as population levels increase in son-preference countries, which include the most populous nations of the world. New sex-selection technologies and economic downturns pose additional threats. This review highlights, above all, that the phenomenon of ‘missing women’ is still one of the great inequalities of our time. Profound gender discrimination in son-preference countries has severe and large-scale adverse impacts on the survival of girls and women at every stage of life.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 01:34

Tears0fTheMushroom · Today 01:17

Are you assuming that in the history of humanity only black people have ever been enslaved and therefore only black people are allowed to mention slavery in any context?

There are women enslaved in the world right now who are not black (as well as some who are)
Believe it or not, slavery and people trafficking is not an historical event nor is it dependent on race.

Apologies Tears - my post above was in reply to you

Pingponghavoc · Today 01:41

To get a GRC, a man only needs a diagnosis of gender dysphoria. Thats why its impossible to tell who has a GRC and who hasn't.

It would be very hard to make drugs or surgery a condition of obtaining a GRC, let alone make it based on appearance.

The law can only be based on the reality of a GRC, not imagined consequences. If surgery, drugs, passing, a dbs check are not part of the process, the law cannot assume thats the case.

Why would a man with a certificate need to be in female spaces, and how would a female space be fit for purpose if these men could use them?

It would never work in practice.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 01:45

Transperson · Today 00:30

"claim to be more like female people than other men." This is true though? Trans women are more female than cis males.

Like objectively it is, phenotypic sex isn't made up. Feed this to Google or something.

Not really, no. A so-called "cis" male who underwent the same medical interventions would have the same physical changes.

Transwomen who make physical changes (and as you know a large proporation do not) do so because they believe they feel something that makes them a woman. It is the feeling that comes first, and so it is the feeling, not the physical changes they may make because of it, that is the actual difference between trans-identifying males and so-called "cis" ones.

Outside their own heads, transwomen are no more fundamentally like female people than any other man is.

IwantToRetire · Today 01:49

Just to be clear, I like others dont think Gender Re-assignment should be a protected characteristic, but as a protected characteristic is has no relationship to what, (thanks to Stonewall constantly expanding it potential membership to keep its income up), being for instance gender fluid, non binary or any of the other "identities" (including furrys?). They are all the exact opposite of those with a GRC or "on the pathway". They are not fixed. They want the option to be what they identify with at the time.

There is no "medical" pathway. It is a pick and mix lifestyle.

It might be possible to categorise them an "non gendered" or something, but you couldn't write a law that would encompass the right to say today I am "..." and you must treat me as such, and a few days later claim something else.

Added to which if there was an attempt to try and expand GRA to self identity why shouldn't this right be extended to those like Rachel Dolezal and others who have some misconception that you can identify out of biological reality, ie not just sex, but race.

So whilst I am sure there are some Labour MPs etc., who are going along with this fantasy, it is in reality going to be really hard to create a law around.

Most stats have said that this group who just want to identify themselves into an altered reality are increasing.

The problem is that Stonewall and others wanting to have an ever increasing membership is not actually addressing the issue. But now they have done enough damage to the concept that women have sex based rights they are (in my opinion) immorally flogging the gross hatred of women to whip up support to get the definition of sex in the EA changed.

So much as I admire and benefit from the work of groups like Sex Matters because the female sex is under attack we also need or to get a voice that queries how the TRA current campaign is about misrepresenting what the issue really is.

Even the Judge in the Supreme Court said that in terms of the EA the only people to be in any way impacted by their ruling are those (around 10,000) people who were led to believe that their "legal sex" was the same as biological sex.

But had and has no impact on the non binaries etc., because in terms of the EA they dont exist.

edited for typos

OP posts:
IwantToRetire · Today 01:58

As a footnote I think it is quite clear why those like Rachel Dolezal who thought the could identify into a different race, were rightly condemned.

Because most people recognise that racism exists, and the damage of harm it does to those who are the victims of it, so it is morally wrong to think that a member of the oppressing group should be allowed to identify out of it.

But somehow, even though women have been the victim of sexism and the patriarchy for years, they dont seem to be thought important enough to warrant the support and understanding that it is morally wrong and of course impossible for a member of the ruling male sex class to identify into female sex class.

OP posts:
Manyanamanyana · Today 02:20

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 00:29

"Balancing" transwomen's desire to be included as women with women's knowledge that they are not is like balancing slave-owners' desire to keep slaves with enslaved people's desire to be free.

Edited

100%