Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How to repair the Equality Act

54 replies

IwantToRetire · Yesterday 19:36

I am not posting this because I support the aims of the article, but it has come up on a number of threads, that one of the reasons so many are continuing to challenge or ignore the Supreme Court ruling is because they want to create climate where is seems there is no other option than to change the status of Sex in the EA.

And that some MPs are actively working with them.

https://translucent.org.uk/how-to-repair-the-equality-act-2010-melanie-field-obe/

OP posts:
Transperson · Yesterday 20:16

That is very good, that was the original purpose of the GRA.

Now we fix the SJC misleading, unworkable ruling by changing the law.

Very glad to know this is happening.
Maybe trans people will be ok afterwall

hatosh · Yesterday 20:36

Transperson · Yesterday 20:16

That is very good, that was the original purpose of the GRA.

Now we fix the SJC misleading, unworkable ruling by changing the law.

Very glad to know this is happening.
Maybe trans people will be ok afterwall

You'll be fine mate - just use the men's.

Transperson · Yesterday 20:37

hatosh · Yesterday 20:36

You'll be fine mate - just use the men's.

No.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 20:39

...aaand we're off! I predict 458 posts of nothingness. But only one from me, you'll be glad to hear. 😎

ErrolTheDragon · Yesterday 20:41

Hopefully there’s a sane majority who know that if it ain’t broke, you don’t fix it.

The law doesn’t need ‘repairing’, the Supreme Court judgement did that already.

HermioneWeasley · Yesterday 20:57

Wow, it really bothers some people that women have rights too.

If you include any men, regardless of their identity, their clothes, their surgeries, then a space or service stops being single sex for women. It’s as simple as that, as recognised by the Supreme Court.

MarieDeGournay · Yesterday 20:58

Thanks for the link OP.
Some familiar tropes e.g
'trans people being denied their human rights' - which ones?
and

a well-funded gender-critical and culture war campaign -
that elusive funding again!🙄

I'm not sure what definition of sex is proposed for the 'repaired' EA in place of biological sex, which was the original meaning when the Act was drafted, and which was re-confirmed by the Supreme Court.

So 'repairing' the EA is not accurate, it would be replacing sex-based rights with something fundamentally different. That's not a 'repair'.

References to the GRA2004 suggests that only transpeople with GRCs would be affected. That would mean that the majority of transpeople, who do not have a GRC, would not benefit from the 'repair'.

Maybe there is going to be an attempt to come up with a definition of the term 'gender' that's as clear, rational and consistent a definition as biological sex. So far, that hasn't happened. Basing legislation on amorphous, ill-defined concepts tends not to end well..

RareGoalsVerge · Yesterday 21:02

It would be an interesting chapter for project "Let them speak" to see what is actually proposed for a revised Equality Act.

Part 2 Chapter 1 of the Act gives detail of the meanings of each of the Protected Characteristics. Section 11 of which defines what is meant by Sex - and the SCJ was very clear in confirming that this means biological material reality of whether someone is male or female unaffected by any experience of Gender.

Any reform of the Act that tries to replace this with a fuzzy definition whereby men can be women and women can be men would have to come up with a legally coherent non-circular definition of What the Actual Fuck it Actually Means to experience a female or male Gender, without relying on abhorent sexist stereotypes or brushing it off with a handwavey fudge. Which we know is impossible because we've been asking for someone to explain it for decades now. Any such redrafting will totally fall apart long before it gets enacted into law but the process of them trying will shed so much sunlight onto the dark foundations of this ideology that millions more will be peaked and will have had enough.

Grammarnut · Yesterday 21:23

Transperson · Yesterday 20:16

That is very good, that was the original purpose of the GRA.

Now we fix the SJC misleading, unworkable ruling by changing the law.

Very glad to know this is happening.
Maybe trans people will be ok afterwall

Go away. The EA2010 is meant to be exclusionary, that's how rights to single sex provision for women is protected. Changing the law to say 'legal sex' will strip women of every right to privacy they have as well as ruining their sports, prizes etc. It will also mean TiFs will not be allowed maternity benefits or time off for maternity appointments, maternity leave etc but I daresay that's okay with you, since they are women.
I'm not going to respond to any other of your nutty, misogynistic posts.

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 21:23

To change this law would mean actively undoing legal protections for women and gay people specifically in order to provide men with supremacy over them, not equality.

If that's what floats your boat, be honest about it.

Grammarnut · Yesterday 21:25

RareGoalsVerge · Yesterday 21:02

It would be an interesting chapter for project "Let them speak" to see what is actually proposed for a revised Equality Act.

Part 2 Chapter 1 of the Act gives detail of the meanings of each of the Protected Characteristics. Section 11 of which defines what is meant by Sex - and the SCJ was very clear in confirming that this means biological material reality of whether someone is male or female unaffected by any experience of Gender.

Any reform of the Act that tries to replace this with a fuzzy definition whereby men can be women and women can be men would have to come up with a legally coherent non-circular definition of What the Actual Fuck it Actually Means to experience a female or male Gender, without relying on abhorent sexist stereotypes or brushing it off with a handwavey fudge. Which we know is impossible because we've been asking for someone to explain it for decades now. Any such redrafting will totally fall apart long before it gets enacted into law but the process of them trying will shed so much sunlight onto the dark foundations of this ideology that millions more will be peaked and will have had enough.

Australia has done just this. Replaced sex with gender identity. It's a disaster for women. And finally people in Australia seem to have noticed.

Grammarnut · Yesterday 21:26

It's what floats Transperson's boat Wishesandhorses. He hates women. Except the sort he pretends to be, naturally.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 21:45

It's absolutely disgusting that some people don't think the female half of humanity are important enough in our own right to have rights and protections as a separate thing to the identity of some sexist men who claim to be women.

Grammarnut · Yesterday 22:01

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

theilltemperedmonster · Yesterday 22:47

From the article:

I strongly defend people’s right to hold beliefs that I don’t share, but the law must draw the line where manifesting a belief has a disproportionate impact on the ability of others to enjoy their own rights and freedoms.

I agree with her.

NotBadConsidering · Yesterday 22:55

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 21:23

To change this law would mean actively undoing legal protections for women and gay people specifically in order to provide men with supremacy over them, not equality.

If that's what floats your boat, be honest about it.

And the idea that

a) a workable piece of legislation can be presented as a white paper
b) it can survive debate and voting in the HOC and
c) survive debate and voting in the HOL

is all fantasy land.

Datun · Yesterday 23:00

all fantasy land

The end.

JellySaurus · Yesterday 23:11

The way to repair the EA would be to remove Gender Reassignment from the list of PCs and to bundle it with the PC of belief. Because GR is the individual acting upon a personal belief.

Whether genderism and transgenderism are Beliefs Worthy of Respect in a Democratic Society is another thing that needs to be clarified. The way that living by these beliefs depends upon deceit, and upon removing rights from others, and upon validation by others without respect for their lack of consent, tells me that they are not BWORIADS.

Transperson · Yesterday 23:12

Grammarnut · Yesterday 21:23

Go away. The EA2010 is meant to be exclusionary, that's how rights to single sex provision for women is protected. Changing the law to say 'legal sex' will strip women of every right to privacy they have as well as ruining their sports, prizes etc. It will also mean TiFs will not be allowed maternity benefits or time off for maternity appointments, maternity leave etc but I daresay that's okay with you, since they are women.
I'm not going to respond to any other of your nutty, misogynistic posts.

Edited

I think parents of a child should have equal time off work, we shouldn't reduce anyone's time off.

Why are you telling me to go away, this a public forum and you don't have to interact with me.

EvelynBeatrice · Yesterday 23:19

Transperson · Yesterday 23:12

I think parents of a child should have equal time off work, we shouldn't reduce anyone's time off.

Why are you telling me to go away, this a public forum and you don't have to interact with me.

‘Equal time off work’ doesn’t do the job for natal females. It ignores the toll that biological reality has on women. Pregnancy, childbirth, breast feeding, long term childbirth injuries ( some becoming clear only in later life) - a period of recuperative leave plus legal recognistion of the impact is needed for true ‘equality’. That is why biology is important. But you know that.

Transperson · Yesterday 23:22

EvelynBeatrice · Yesterday 23:19

‘Equal time off work’ doesn’t do the job for natal females. It ignores the toll that biological reality has on women. Pregnancy, childbirth, breast feeding, long term childbirth injuries ( some becoming clear only in later life) - a period of recuperative leave plus legal recognistion of the impact is needed for true ‘equality’. That is why biology is important. But you know that.

It doesn't, I said not reduce, I.e. to give more time off to the other partner so they could be at home and help, the birthing person needs to recover and rest. And even afterwards they need to figure out how to be parents together.

EvelynBeatrice · Yesterday 23:23

A person who gives birth is a mother - in law and reality.

Transperson · Yesterday 23:24

EvelynBeatrice · Yesterday 23:23

A person who gives birth is a mother - in law and reality.

I'm not gonna missgender non binary, a gender, or trans men.

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 23:30

You can play with words all day. The obvious reality is right there in the picture at the top of the article linked in the OP.

Transperson · Yesterday 23:32

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 23:30

You can play with words all day. The obvious reality is right there in the picture at the top of the article linked in the OP.

Edited

Listen, I'm not policing your language, don't police mine. It's not that hard.

Swipe left for the next trending thread