Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Why do some women fawn over these men?

677 replies

tetherabumfit · 19/11/2026 08:50

Just had to rant. I follow a nail polish group, and recently there was a post from a trans identified man asking for advice on how to have more “girly” hands, accompanied by a picture of a pair of absolute shovels.

It would have been hilarious if it weren’t for the dozens of replies fawning over this man, telling him how cute his nails were, how brave he is, and how his hands look completely feminine. My reply, stating he would never look “girly” as he was a man, got me banned. (I knew it would, just wanted to be a voice of reality).

But why do so many women pander to these men? Talk about turkeys voting for Christmas! I will never understand it.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
kitex · 19/11/2026 14:21

GreyskySexRealistsky · 19/11/2026 14:14

That's just gatekeeping womanhood kitex, tut tut, how transphobic

(as I was told once about "gatekeeping periods" 🙄)

I’ve heard about gatekeeping periods! 🤣 It’s so weird. Because we are female, it’s a biological reality for the majority of us. Do we gatekeep the menopause too?

MarieDeGournay · 19/11/2026 14:23

VividZebra · 19/11/2026 13:55

Why are people horrible about trans women? I really don't get it, and I hate it.

It depends on how you define 'horrible'.

Unfortunately, there's a small group of men who actually claim to be women - ridiculous, I know - and get upset/aggressive/violent if it's pointed out to them, however, nicely, that they are in fact men.

They and their supporters claim that's it's always 'horrible' to state that fact, even in polite and measured language.

It's an extreme position to say that it's always 'horrible' and even 'hateful' to say that transwomen always were and always will be are biological males, regardless of how politely it's expressed.

Transwomen are men. Not women, and not entitled to the few areas that are designated solely for the use of women, including words such as 'woman', 'she', 'and her'.
Adult male human beings, who are entitled to all the same human rights as everybody else, no more and no less.

Do you think that's 'horrible' VividZebra? Or as another poster implied, 'vitriolic'?

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 19/11/2026 14:25

WishIWasAPanda · 19/11/2026 14:20

Or perhaps it’s weaponised pretending it’s about fawning when it’s actually about laughing, being cruel and talking about someone behind their back.
or perhaps decency is something you all lack.

Is that what the OP did? Or just directly say he can never be girlie as he’s a man? Which is the truth.

paraphrasequeen · 19/11/2026 14:31

JLou08 · 19/11/2026 13:49

Because not everyone thinks trans people are evil predators with ill inteintentions. A lot of people think they are people who deserve the same respect and kindness as everyone else. You might feel like you're in the majority here but outside of MN most people aren't anti-trans. Even if they agree with sports and certain spaces being specific to sex they want to treat trans people like the humans they are instead of trying to put them down and make them feel ostracised.

Many women don't believe that these men genuinely suffer from gender dysphoria. Personally I take great exception to being used as a prop in some bloke's sexual fetish. It feels disrespectful. Therefore I'm disinclined to be 'kind'. I make no apologies for that.

Scout2016 · 19/11/2026 14:35

YouHaveAnArse · 19/11/2026 12:22

I've seen this, yes. Trans men post on r/bald (a supportive sub for people thinking about finally doing the shave) and things like that.

This is interesting- some of my gay male friends attend a social group for gay men and a TiF has been turning up... they are polite and chat to her but have said to me how awkward it is and that they and the other men are just hoping she'll stop attending. More likely is they will stop going and do separate meet ups. None of them consider her to be gay or a man.

Meanwhile she will be going home thinking she's passed and / or been accepted. It's not kind in the long run because with different men she could well be told in plain terms she's not welcome and why, or find herself in a dangerous situation.

Lhori · 19/11/2026 14:47

VividZebra · 19/11/2026 13:55

Why are people horrible about trans women? I really don't get it, and I hate it.

I think some women feel a bit insulted by it as they see it as the equivalent to someone making up in black face and joining a facebook group for afro hair tips. Also, some people think the trans women involved might be using the women to indulge a fetish.

I don't really care about that stuff because it is all part of the rough and tumble of the internet. However, I find women fawning over trans women rather irritating. Lets face it, women fawning over men always seems a bit demeaning.

dinodart · 19/11/2026 14:48

It's like telling little children their art is so good... even tho it's crap.

ArabellaScott · 19/11/2026 14:50

OP apparently he might need extra wide fake nails. Who knew?!

(Just a warning - that channel does include some videos that are NSFW or for younger viewers and it's all quite tacky imho if that's not too MEAN to say)

Ereshkigalangcleg · 19/11/2026 14:52

paraphrasequeen · 19/11/2026 14:31

Many women don't believe that these men genuinely suffer from gender dysphoria. Personally I take great exception to being used as a prop in some bloke's sexual fetish. It feels disrespectful. Therefore I'm disinclined to be 'kind'. I make no apologies for that.

Well said. Fully agree.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 19/11/2026 14:53

BettyBooper · 19/11/2026 14:11

The more I think about it, the more I think it's like these women treat TiMs like children.

It reminds me of when someone posts in a family group chat a picture a young child has drawn and everyone posts OTT comments, 'oh it's fabulous!', 'aren't you clever!' etc etc.

Yeah, it's cringe levels of patronising.

Yes, definitely.

GingerBeverage · 19/11/2026 14:56

But children have no power over adult women, whereas men do.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 19/11/2026 14:58

Bobbymoore123 · 19/11/2026 11:07

It sounds like you're bitter that not everyone shares your political opinions and doesn't harbour the same anger and resentment towards the group of people you hate.

So very very bored of the silly and lazy claim that women saying no to men appropriating our social, legal and political identity is "hate".

It's not "hate". It's just saying No.

No to being the backup actors to someone else's sexist fantasy.
No to being forced back into some stupd gender box about what "girlies" like to do
No to letting male people's idea of what it is to be a woman override the reality that female people exist, face consequences because we are female, and matter more than their need to perform an adopted identity based on stereotypes, fiction, fantasies and the most superficial and banal of observations.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 19/11/2026 15:01

GingerBeverage · 19/11/2026 14:56

But children have no power over adult women, whereas men do.

Exactly, it’s a bit naive I think, indulging these men in that way.

Scout2016 · 19/11/2026 15:22

VividZebra · 19/11/2026 13:55

Why are people horrible about trans women? I really don't get it, and I hate it.

Why do some men think it's acceptable to claim membership of an oppressed class?

Why do some men think everyone should twist their language and lie about reality so they don't have to face it?

Why do some men think it acceptable to take their fetishes out in public and force others to participate so they get the buzz of thier eactions?

Why do some men want to push the idea of trans children existing so they can justify their own middle aged "transitions" And why do so many wait until they have a wife, children and careers but think its OK for children to be left infertile life long medical patients?

Why are trans young people are told to estrange themselves from parents who don't affirm them and seek their "community", but detransitioners are then spurned by these "glitter families".

Why are people with medical conditions put in the same category as people who aren't happy with their sex and called an outdated term?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 19/11/2026 15:23

kitex · 19/11/2026 14:12

“I cannot accept a transwoman as a wonan because I don't accept that I am a woman in the ways he needs me to be to allow him to be a woman too.”

Same. Because my body is female, I have experienced things that no ‘trans woman’ will ever be able to do.

And the other way as well.

I don't especially experience the things or think of myself in the ways that the version of "woman" transwomen believe in requires.

It really is very simple. I think the only thing that all women have in common is our sex, and Genderists think... well I have no idea what the think all women do have in common, but I know damn well it isn't sex because they believe TWAW.

And we can't both be right.

And given that "woman" was until a hot minute ago the name for female people, and the name under which the rights given to female people were written, and the name under which our history, real and cultural, is recorded, and the name under which we as Feminists shared our expereinces and questioned the narratives and grew to understand what society had done to us...

Well, I reckon all of that means we as female people have the biggest claim to the name.

So while whatever it is that transwomen are calling "womanhood" may indeed be very real, and may indeed be somethig plenty of women do experience and find meaningful as well, whatever it is it is not beng female, so they can just go and find another name for it.

cherryicecreamisnice · 19/11/2026 15:30

StillgotmyiPod · 19/11/2026 09:18

As an old-fashioned cunty kind of woman who unfortunately was graced with "absolute shovels", next time please keep your comments about appearance to yourself.

If you can't say anything nice, it's best to just not say anything. It's a fun nail polish group, not speakers corner.

say that whilst imagining what he was doing with his shovels on getting replies to his honest request

tetherabumfit · 19/11/2026 15:34

@NewquaySurfGirlI don’t know where you get the idea that I don’t support women, as nothing could be further from the truth. @NewquaySurfGirl

OP posts:
HorseandHeron · 19/11/2026 15:37

VoltaireMittyDream · 19/11/2026 11:51

I have eventually left 2 different writing groups because each had attracted one man who never fucking shut up, and the women would fall over themselves to tell him how brilliant he was. In both cases the man was in his 80s, bellowing away ad nauseam while a bunch of women 40-55 gave up their precious Saturday afternoons to dote on him and never get a word in edgeways.

I'm so fucking sick of needy, self-centred, parasitic men - and the women willing to throw everyone else under a bus to appease them.

I see it so clearly now the fog of estrogen has lifted.

I agree. And to raise the issue, even among the fellow women would be unpalatable because causing a fuss, challenging others... these are not feminine qualities.

But I do it too. It infuriates me that it is so ingrained. If DH says something totally ordinary, like 'I made a cup of tea,' or, 'Do you fancy a walk?' I reply with, 'Thank you. That's great!' Or, 'Brilliant, good idea.'

If I say or suggest something, I am rarely given a reply. Sometimes a grunt. But if I stop myself and try to match his lack of what psychologists call 'strokes' (signals of social approval) he notices and asks what is up with me. So he does actually need that steady supply of 'Darling aren't you marvellous for simply existing' while in no way feeling any responsibility to reciprocate it. He is a good man and supportive in other ways. I just annoy myself, when I catch myself doing it a hundred times a day. A hundred ego strokes a day versus none or one. Year in year out, that makes a difference to self esteem.

polypostlurker · 19/11/2026 15:39

YouHaveAnArse · 19/11/2026 12:46

Doesn't matter. As with any personal comments about someone's appearance, it will still make those with the same characteristics feel like shit to hear them.

Saw a thread on here once where someone said something like 'what if you went to a women's shelter and saw a pair of size nine shoes by the door' and it was lovely to know that if I was ever in that situation I wouldn't be judged sufficiently feminine to be appropriately helped.

This 100%.

I've never passed as a trans woman because at 5'4, with my size 5/5.5 feet and relatively small hands (amongst a lot of other stuff), I am an impossibility in Gender Cirtical lore. No one obsesses about scrutinising the average. The wrath of Gender Critical ideology is focused upon those who fall within the monster myths.

Those who mock women with shovel hands are the same people policing the toilet queues.

ArabellaScott · 19/11/2026 15:43

I suggest anyone who is of the opinion that cross dressing men are all harmless spend maybe half an hour googling that term. Not at work, and not when children can see the results.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 19/11/2026 15:43

tetherabumfit · 19/11/2026 08:50

Just had to rant. I follow a nail polish group, and recently there was a post from a trans identified man asking for advice on how to have more “girly” hands, accompanied by a picture of a pair of absolute shovels.

It would have been hilarious if it weren’t for the dozens of replies fawning over this man, telling him how cute his nails were, how brave he is, and how his hands look completely feminine. My reply, stating he would never look “girly” as he was a man, got me banned. (I knew it would, just wanted to be a voice of reality).

But why do so many women pander to these men? Talk about turkeys voting for Christmas! I will never understand it.

I think it's exactly because they know they are supposed to just see him as a woman, but they also know that they don't.

But intellectually they want to see him as a woman because they have bought into a set of values that say this if they are right and kind and openminded a woman is what they would see.

So they perform seeing him as a woman, because they want to even though they actually don't.

And of course a performance is for others. It's externalised. So they have to comment.

And they can't just comment something fairly neutral like they would to another woman - "oh, lovely shape! Are they gel?" - because you might say that to a man as well. So they have to over-compensate - "oh wow so pretty!! 💖" - just to make sure it is clear they see this person as a women like any other woman.

And they see others gushing as well, and it makes them feel even more like if they don't say anything someone might think they are a bit, well, terfy.

So - it's a performance by women frightened that their real feelings are bad.

ArabellaScott · 19/11/2026 15:44

polypostlurker · 19/11/2026 15:39

This 100%.

I've never passed as a trans woman because at 5'4, with my size 5/5.5 feet and relatively small hands (amongst a lot of other stuff), I am an impossibility in Gender Cirtical lore. No one obsesses about scrutinising the average. The wrath of Gender Critical ideology is focused upon those who fall within the monster myths.

Those who mock women with shovel hands are the same people policing the toilet queues.

Edited

As someone who was followed into the ladies as a teenage girl by a cross dressing man, who then masturbated at the sink, yes I would 'police' any men following girls into the ladies. And yes, even short men, or men with small hands.

Lexibletheflexible · 19/11/2026 15:44

EdithStourton · 19/11/2026 10:26

Nope. This bloke was pushing a boundary. Just a small one.

That's how it starts.

And in any case, the post was about the women fawning, not the bloke pushing a boundary.

No he wasnt. It was a person making an ad on the internet and someone who cannot understand boundaries harassing them

Lexibletheflexible · 19/11/2026 15:45

ArabellaScott · 19/11/2026 15:43

I suggest anyone who is of the opinion that cross dressing men are all harmless spend maybe half an hour googling that term. Not at work, and not when children can see the results.

If they aren't harmless, then harassing them online doesn't seem a good way to avoid these "dangerous" people. It seems like attention seeking

GreyskySexRealistsky · 19/11/2026 15:46

FlirtsWithRhinos · 19/11/2026 15:43

I think it's exactly because they know they are supposed to just see him as a woman, but they also know that they don't.

But intellectually they want to see him as a woman because they have bought into a set of values that say this if they are right and kind and openminded a woman is what they would see.

So they perform seeing him as a woman, because they want to even though they actually don't.

And of course a performance is for others. It's externalised. So they have to comment.

And they can't just comment something fairly neutral like they would to another woman - "oh, lovely shape! Are they gel?" - because you might say that to a man as well. So they have to over-compensate - "oh wow so pretty!! 💖" - just to make sure it is clear they see this person as a women like any other woman.

And they see others gushing as well, and it makes them feel even more like if they don't say anything someone might think they are a bit, well, terfy.

So - it's a performance by women frightened that their real feelings are bad.

🎯🎯🎯