Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Why do some women fawn over these men?

677 replies

tetherabumfit · 19/11/2026 08:50

Just had to rant. I follow a nail polish group, and recently there was a post from a trans identified man asking for advice on how to have more “girly” hands, accompanied by a picture of a pair of absolute shovels.

It would have been hilarious if it weren’t for the dozens of replies fawning over this man, telling him how cute his nails were, how brave he is, and how his hands look completely feminine. My reply, stating he would never look “girly” as he was a man, got me banned. (I knew it would, just wanted to be a voice of reality).

But why do so many women pander to these men? Talk about turkeys voting for Christmas! I will never understand it.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
tetherabumfit · 20/11/2026 20:42

Vontrapptrip · 20/11/2026 08:02

Couldn't you just have said something nice? I'm in a similar position with so eone I love and I use words like elegant and beautiful, but not girly, because they aren't. Being unkind is unnecessary, if it annoys you that much, maybe it's better not to comment.

Why would I lie? Being nice would be fawning and pandering to this man’s fetish. His hands were not beautiful, elegant or “girly”.

OP posts:
tetherabumfit · 20/11/2026 20:49

Vontrapptrip · 20/11/2026 08:28

I don't. However, that's a human reaching out for solidarity on their nails and if you disagree with what they're saying, it's better to take a broad brush approach, since we don't know the impact on that person.

Personally, I wouldn't comment on such a post if I felt negatively about it, but if I felt I had to say something, I would use complimentary terms. I wouldn't validate the girly part, but not would I I insult them.

Nail art isn't exclusively female.

It used to be, but the world has changed. I actually believe third spaces would be best, but the world is getting smaller and we need to connect. Many young transgender people are much more understanding of older women's issues because of mothers and grandmothers and if they can be respectful and understanding, we could do the same.

I’m an older woman in my sixties, and I’ve seen no evidence of young trans identifying men being understanding of older women. Why would they, they’re men with no idea of the lived experiences of women.

OP posts:
tetherabumfit · 20/11/2026 20:55

Vontrapptrip · 20/11/2026 08:39

So what motivates someone to be intentionally unkind? It's unnecessary. Just join a different group, but don't bring someone else down.

Telling the truth is not the same as being unkind.

OP posts:
tetherabumfit · 20/11/2026 21:09

NewquaySurfGirl · 20/11/2026 10:13

I would have thought that a feminist would be supportive of other women and their right to speak freely and support whoever they wish; do you not believe in freedom of speech for women, OP?

Nowhere have I said anything of the sort. Your faux-naive questions just make you seem ill informed and lacking in reading comprehension.

OP posts:
TransParentlyAnnoyed · Yesterday 01:19

tetherabumfit · 19/11/2026 08:50

Just had to rant. I follow a nail polish group, and recently there was a post from a trans identified man asking for advice on how to have more “girly” hands, accompanied by a picture of a pair of absolute shovels.

It would have been hilarious if it weren’t for the dozens of replies fawning over this man, telling him how cute his nails were, how brave he is, and how his hands look completely feminine. My reply, stating he would never look “girly” as he was a man, got me banned. (I knew it would, just wanted to be a voice of reality).

But why do so many women pander to these men? Talk about turkeys voting for Christmas! I will never understand it.

Why on earth does being malicious to her matter to you so much? Do you think you're being heroic?

That is such an unnecessary, spiteful thing to do. My god.

Wowthatwasabigstep · Yesterday 08:15

TransParentlyAnnoyed · Yesterday 01:19

Why on earth does being malicious to her matter to you so much? Do you think you're being heroic?

That is such an unnecessary, spiteful thing to do. My god.

The OP was absolutely not being malicious she called out a man and his cult followers on the lies and nonsense he was seeking to peddle.

He is a man, painting his nails or indeed applying makeup with all the lightness of a trowel and squeezing himself into a tawdry dress, will not magically turn him into a woman. He is a man who would better spend his time seeking counselling for his delusions rather than spending it grooming women on a nail polish group.

Nobody can change sex, it is biologically impossible as we all know.

tetherabumfit · Yesterday 08:18

TransParentlyAnnoyed · Yesterday 01:19

Why on earth does being malicious to her matter to you so much? Do you think you're being heroic?

That is such an unnecessary, spiteful thing to do. My god.

Knock it off with the faux outrage, it’s performative and tedious.

OP posts:
SirChenjins · Yesterday 08:24

Isn't is funny that calling a man pretending to be a woman a woman is spiteful and malicious according to TPA - but a man calling for a woman to be raped, decapitated, burnt, attacked, lose her livelihood and so on is....well, he's never actually said ehat he thinks of any of that.

Hmm
NibliaBiblia · Yesterday 08:32

SirChenjins · Yesterday 08:24

Isn't is funny that calling a man pretending to be a woman a woman is spiteful and malicious according to TPA - but a man calling for a woman to be raped, decapitated, burnt, attacked, lose her livelihood and so on is....well, he's never actually said ehat he thinks of any of that.

Hmm

She is female. She disagrees with you - that doesn't make her a TW.

SirChenjins · Yesterday 08:54

But still never says...

MagpiePi · Yesterday 09:47

SirChenjins · Yesterday 08:24

Isn't is funny that calling a man pretending to be a woman a woman is spiteful and malicious according to TPA - but a man calling for a woman to be raped, decapitated, burnt, attacked, lose her livelihood and so on is....well, he's never actually said ehat he thinks of any of that.

Hmm

Those things don’t happen in TPA’s world and any references to them don’t happen either, so why would TPA respond to them?

It must be great to live in your own made up world.
🙈🙉🙊

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 10:29

I suppose the idea of it is nice. But as endlessly demonstrated: it involves non stop arguments and scolding of those who keep intruding reality into happyland. And as noticed in many court cases, happyland occupants seem to keep on persistently going looking for reality to have those conflicts with and be upset by. That's the part I'm still figuring out.

NebulousSadTimes · Yesterday 10:39

tetherabumfit · 20/11/2026 20:49

I’m an older woman in my sixties, and I’ve seen no evidence of young trans identifying men being understanding of older women. Why would they, they’re men with no idea of the lived experiences of women.

I doubt they'd even notice us, in real life. But for some reason they find themselves hunting us down on the internet to try and shut us up. Those are not the actions of someone with their own autonomy. Or strength.

MarieDeGournay · Yesterday 10:51

tetherabumfit · 20/11/2026 20:55

Telling the truth is not the same as being unkind.

True.
That said, the truth can be unkind
In my moral universe Smilethe answer to 'Do these shoes clash with this dress?'
should be

  • truthful if I've been dragged brought on a shopping expedition looking for the perfect shoes to go with that dress, because I know my friend wants to look her best.
  • not truthful if she is literally going out the door for her important event with no time to change either the dress or the shoes.

Some random man online asking how to make his hands less man-like through the medium of nail-polish?
I'd go with truthful, because even nail-polish can't make his hands look 'girlie' and it would be unkind to give him the idea that it could.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 10:58

I was thinking yesterday about the assumption that everyone is in good faith and that we must trust and refrain from judgment, and how that can be noble and well intentioned but could also be naive and very dangerous.

For me honesty is important. Lies put me on guard.

The person who lies, who transgress in this one thing, transcending concern for the world beyond: there's no evil he might not do.

theilltemperedmonster · Yesterday 11:24

You were unkind. Rather than try to do the impossible, think outside the box. Tell him to change how he uses his hands. Rest his chin on both hands like Holly Golightly. Pose winsomely with the back of one hand pressed to the forehead, or one forefinger pressed into a cheek. Wave them around like an Italian whilst speaking. Keep them always in view, so the nail 'do' and bling are a constant reminder of his womanhood.

Your attitude was unhelpful.

SirChenjins · Yesterday 11:33

MagpiePi · Yesterday 09:47

Those things don’t happen in TPA’s world and any references to them don’t happen either, so why would TPA respond to them?

It must be great to live in your own made up world.
🙈🙉🙊

Fair point.

I guess if you choose to believe men can be women, you can also choose to believe these things never happen - because you're a fantasist.

Cannotrun · Yesterday 11:48

The latest update from Janet Murray on the man wearing giant fetish tits at St Hilda's college, Oxford provides another example of women rushing to fawn over these men:

"...Equality, diversity and inclusion facilitator Hannah Ravenswood at St Hilda's called him a “wonderful human”.

Professor of medieval languages Helen Swift said she was looking forward to his teaching and learning posts..."

He's a bloke with a large beard who is choosing to go to work wearing a massive pair of rubber breasts, why on earth would any sane woman (or man) want to be seen publicly gushing over him? Crackers.

Screenshots attached for those who don't use X.

Why do some women fawn over these men?
Why do some women fawn over these men?
Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 14:17

I read that, and hear that mocking song from A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum, "I'm lovely.... what I am is lovely...."

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 14:21

MarieDeGournay · Yesterday 10:51

True.
That said, the truth can be unkind
In my moral universe Smilethe answer to 'Do these shoes clash with this dress?'
should be

  • truthful if I've been dragged brought on a shopping expedition looking for the perfect shoes to go with that dress, because I know my friend wants to look her best.
  • not truthful if she is literally going out the door for her important event with no time to change either the dress or the shoes.

Some random man online asking how to make his hands less man-like through the medium of nail-polish?
I'd go with truthful, because even nail-polish can't make his hands look 'girlie' and it would be unkind to give him the idea that it could.

I think if this kind of thing was sincere and not creepy, women would be fine with going along with it.

But inevitably the behaviour starts. It always does. It never is 'just another woman behaving like a woman'. That's when the difference between the 'ew' response and the 'gush' response gets interesting, because it's then conscious enablement.

As many pps have said, women don't talk like this to other women. For obvious reasons. And the man involved normally makes it clear quickly that they don't want to be treated as just another women.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · Yesterday 14:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ereshkigalangcleg · Yesterday 15:09

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 14:21

I think if this kind of thing was sincere and not creepy, women would be fine with going along with it.

But inevitably the behaviour starts. It always does. It never is 'just another woman behaving like a woman'. That's when the difference between the 'ew' response and the 'gush' response gets interesting, because it's then conscious enablement.

As many pps have said, women don't talk like this to other women. For obvious reasons. And the man involved normally makes it clear quickly that they don't want to be treated as just another women.

Edited

Exactly. It’s nauseating to witness.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 15:11

She wasn't doing anything to anyone by asking for manicure advice

That's an assertion.

Why do you think women might respond negatively to a man making a post like the one OP describes? What feelings might the women have had about it?

See if you can empathise with the women.

Wishesandhorses · Yesterday 17:04

It's beyond disingenuous to pretend that sexual excitement and gratification is not being gained by men in these situations, in the same way as many one handed posters come here for attention and gratification from women.

The constant demand that everyone engage in wilful and faux naivety while submitting to this use is much of what has gained the activist movement such a bad name.

BlueLegume · Yesterday 17:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ok @TransParentlyAnnoyed so I find the local man who wears Daisy Duke shorts with suspenders and lacy stockings and killer heels quite revolting. That does not make me unkind. It looks repulsive. Kids use the shop.

His penis/bulge is visible under the very tight shorts. He works in a shop. Not a fancy avant gard fashion shop - a simple shop. I live in a very tolerant multi cultural area. The local Muslims are very moderate and very friendly. He tries to engage the women about eyeliner - most wear a modest hijab but are wearing lovely make up. He is invading their space. He knows it. He is clearly a gay man, not a woman as he pretends to be.

I am not hateful. I hate the fact he tries to engage women into conversations by his over the top ‘OMG your lipstick is amazing’ nonsense. I now avoid the shop.

I used to spend a decent amount of money there.

Looking forward to hearing your opinion.