Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

TEMU breast removal "congrats" card

122 replies

EllasColeslaw · Yesterday 12:45

Disgusted to see this for sale on Temu. Why is there no equivalent card celebrating having ones penis amputated? What would be the options to tick on such a card?

TEMU breast removal "congrats" card
OP posts:
SirChenjins · Yesterday 19:26

ChequerToRed · Yesterday 19:25

I notice one of my posts is back, which is interesting.

That is interesting - did MN explain why?

mysticbob · Yesterday 20:41

HaveYouActuallyDoneAnyWashingThisWeekMum · Yesterday 15:23

Your final paragraph - actually breasts are a very precious parts of a woman’s body because first and foremost they enable her to feed her babies the best way possible. Secondly they can be an amazing source of sexual pleasure - but I think you’re a man and have no idea what I’m talking about.

Please don’t tell us that parts of our bodies aren’t sacred to us.

I don’t have children. Am I allowed to have my breasts removed if I don’t want them anymore, @HaveYouActuallyDoneAnyWashingThisWeekMum? Or are they still too sacred? Do I have bodily autonomy?

SirChenjins · Yesterday 20:43

mysticbob · Yesterday 20:41

I don’t have children. Am I allowed to have my breasts removed if I don’t want them anymore, @HaveYouActuallyDoneAnyWashingThisWeekMum? Or are they still too sacred? Do I have bodily autonomy?

Do you think you're a man?

mysticbob · Yesterday 20:48

Would it affect you if I did, @SirChenjins?

As it happens no, I don’t, but if I was having my breasts removed for any reason and someone got me that card, I’d be pleased.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 20:49

Sometimes I wonder - do Genderists ever take a step back, look at what they write and think "How the fuck did I end up arguing for that as a reasonable thing?"

I reckon there's a lot of boiled frogs out there.

HaveYouActuallyDoneAnyWashingThisWeekMum · Yesterday 21:12

mysticbob · Yesterday 20:41

I don’t have children. Am I allowed to have my breasts removed if I don’t want them anymore, @HaveYouActuallyDoneAnyWashingThisWeekMum? Or are they still too sacred? Do I have bodily autonomy?

Where do you draw the line with your “bodily autonomy”?

I’m certain the NHS wouldn’t allow you to have a healthy body part removed just because you “don’t want it any more” but your GP could guide you towards some psychological support in accepting the loathed body part.

SirChenjins · Yesterday 21:14

mysticbob · Yesterday 20:48

Would it affect you if I did, @SirChenjins?

As it happens no, I don’t, but if I was having my breasts removed for any reason and someone got me that card, I’d be pleased.

So the reason you would make that decision is not because you had body dysphoria, believed you had somehow been born in the wrong body and were in fact male.

Although quite why anyone would willingly put themselves through an unnecessary double mastectomy is doubtful - I would like to think you would also receive a lot of counselling and would have the funds to pay for it yourself. The NHS doesn't fund this.

You have no idea how you would really feel if you were ever to have your breasts removed because you've got cancer. How we say we'll feel and how we actually feel when faced with the real situation are completely different. You know that.

YourFunnyLion · Yesterday 21:25

this is disgusting

Transperson · Yesterday 21:31

YourFunnyLion · Yesterday 21:25

this is disgusting

Why?

Cheese55 · Yesterday 21:32

nutmeg7 · Yesterday 17:39

It’s emotionally immature and shallow. Trivialising mastectomy.

Exactly having a mastectomy can result in life long pain. It's not something to done unless absolutely necessary, like cancer treatment.

Manyanamanyana · Yesterday 21:46

Transperson · Yesterday 13:27

It's not for you. Why do you care what is being gifts to someone else.

Doesn't affect you in any way shape or form. Unless you have a trans friend that you disagree with their transition?

Sorry if we're a bit sensitive about mutilation of our secondary sex characteristics, what with female genital mutilation and stuff like that.
Mutilation of womens bodies for the aims of a regressive sexist ideology (parallels anyone) is not a joke.
Violence against women and girls is not a joke.
Our bodies are not a joke.

DangerousThingsILove · Yesterday 21:55

Missey85 · Yesterday 13:15

You know it's a joke right? It's for women that have had breast cancer and had a mastectomy? I've seen similar cards before 🙂 not everything is serious when did we stop humour are we not allowed to laugh anymore?

It’s trans activist language used to minimise the removal of healthy breasts.

Transperson · Yesterday 22:02

Manyanamanyana · Yesterday 21:46

Sorry if we're a bit sensitive about mutilation of our secondary sex characteristics, what with female genital mutilation and stuff like that.
Mutilation of womens bodies for the aims of a regressive sexist ideology (parallels anyone) is not a joke.
Violence against women and girls is not a joke.
Our bodies are not a joke.

Not your body, not your choice ✨

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 22:45

I guess the young fella upthread thinks he is being clever when he dismisses the long history of non-consensual or socially enforced multilation of women as not something worth getting bothered about. Those boys do like to pwn women by dismissing our historic suffering don't they?

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 22:49

TransParentlyAnnoyed · Yesterday 14:12

Breast removal isn't a tragedy. It's still a taboo that cis women can be happy without tits - I've seen so many men attack women for having reduction surgery.

Unwillingly losing your breasts because of cancer or future cancer risk is deeply traumatic because of the lack of choice involved and society's insistence that women aren't properly female without them.

Reducing the stigma of breast removal would really help those who have undergone traumatic mastectomy. Along with not policing toilets (a lot of those who have undergone mastectomy and the effects of chemo have encountered Toilet Vigilantism) and defining women in such narrow terms.

Trans guys and some nb people have top surgery, and it's a literal weight off their chests. So they celebrate it. So what?! Doesn't impact any of your lives.

People can do what they want with their own boobs. Most gender-affirming care is done on cis people after all - the removal of breast tissue in cis men, and boob jobs done to cis women. So long as that makes them happy, it's absolutely no one else's business.

Breasts aren't sacred objects, and everyone's body is their own - unique, beautiful and worth celebrating, whatever its shape.

Edited

God, you're so top to bottom offensive. The self righteousness is so jarring.

tobee · Yesterday 23:06

Cheese55 · Yesterday 21:32

Exactly having a mastectomy can result in life long pain. It's not something to done unless absolutely necessary, like cancer treatment.

Not forgetting the dangers of anaesthesia

Manyanamanyana · Yesterday 23:24

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 22:45

I guess the young fella upthread thinks he is being clever when he dismisses the long history of non-consensual or socially enforced multilation of women as not something worth getting bothered about. Those boys do like to pwn women by dismissing our historic suffering don't they?

Yep. It also highlights their inescapable disconnect with the long shared history we women actually experience as lived reality, it connects us in ways they will never understand. It's matriarchal lineage.
They will never be us. They must know that, it must really bug them. All they have is their purchased "bits", and some trinkets.
You're born female, or you are male.

Truinio · Yesterday 23:38

No human will have been involved in designing this card. Someone will have searched for something for someone undergoing ‘top surgery’, the card design will have been generated by an agent, and then the design cached and offered to others who search similar terms. It’s then printed on demand. The same method is also used for T-shirts.

Etsy is now full of this agent-generated crap.

Tears0fTheMushroom · Today 00:44

Transperson · Yesterday 16:49

I have a masters, thanks.

And I have 5 PhDs and my own elephant called Roxie.

Thank you very much!

(I might have lied about the elephant but you can't prove anything)

TransParentlyAnnoyed · Today 01:02

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 22:49

God, you're so top to bottom offensive. The self righteousness is so jarring.

Aww. Thank you!

VashtaNerada · Today 01:17

This is 100% not my type of humour but presumably some people find it hilarious. Each to their own. If you don’t like it, don’t buy it.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page