Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

When are universities going to stop teaching crap about gender identity?

96 replies

happydappy2 · 16/11/2026 14:58

My offspring is at a Russell Group Uni studying Criminology. Has just had a lecture about violence against women & on the slide titled Intersectional vulnerabilities it stated that Trans women experience 2-3 time higher risk of sexual assault than the general population of women.

My offspring approached the lecturer during a break and politely asked them to clarify how that statement could be true as most trans women have a penis between their legs.....the lecturer was not amused and accused my adult child of questioning their authority. My child politely asked for further explanation as trans women are men not a type of woman.....lecturer was having none of it.

We have since spoken-I've explained that that particular stat was probably taken from trans women who work as prostitutes and has long been debunked.

I am just so sad that this rubbish has not been cleared out of uni education yet-our kids are paying a fortune for a degree and some of what they are taught is just crap.

I'd be so grateful for any advice that others might be able to give me to help my offspring challenge this, in a way that won't have negative repercussions for them.

OP posts:
YerWot · 17/11/2026 20:20

no problemo @GreyskySexRealistsky ! I'm just glad the link works. I love the Wayback Machine.

I've done nearly ten university open days with my children in the last few years, and have been quite shocked by how brazen some of the universities have been in their anti-women stance. Bizarre that they seem to think we wouldn't notice. 🙄

@happydappy2 maybe Free Speech Union membership would be a good Christmas present for your offspring?

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 17/11/2026 21:22

Sure. Tell your kid to show respect to minorities and they're more likely to gain friends, have the respect of colleagues and not be regarded with suspicion.

It's entirely true that trans women suffer high rates of sexual violence. Your child displayed a total lack of sympathy with victims which utterly disgusted their lecturer. It probably also came across as victim-blaming.

Transphobia isn't heroism. Happy to help.

CreativeGreen · 17/11/2026 21:30

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 17/11/2026 21:22

Sure. Tell your kid to show respect to minorities and they're more likely to gain friends, have the respect of colleagues and not be regarded with suspicion.

It's entirely true that trans women suffer high rates of sexual violence. Your child displayed a total lack of sympathy with victims which utterly disgusted their lecturer. It probably also came across as victim-blaming.

Transphobia isn't heroism. Happy to help.

oh hello you

no, that isn’t true and even if it were, what would it have to do with stats about violence against women and girls?

GreyskySexRealistsky · 17/11/2026 21:33

Okay, so there's nothing in the OP's post to say that the student doesn't show respect to minorities, displayed a lack of sympathy, disgusted the lecturer, was victim blaming, or was transphobic.

Facts are so important.

Which is why the student was trying to clarify facts with the lecturer.

thesplendourfalls · 17/11/2026 21:55

@TransParentlyAnnoyed “Transphobia isn't heroism.

I don’t believe in transgender ideology so transphobia doesn’t exist.

Grammarnut · 17/11/2026 22:14

alcovecupboards · 16/11/2026 19:59

Never. The old bigots will die off and with them their raging against progress.

After the fair, alcove, the ship has sailed on trans ideology. It's going, going, gone...and I wish you would too - but I think you are here for the bier.

Grammarnut · 17/11/2026 22:18

AlonsoMosley · 17/11/2026 01:19

My offspring send me a recording of a class the other day. The mental gymnastics from the lecturer were mind-blowing.

They were told that certain characteristics could be observed. Using whales as examples the lecturer said that their size, the fact that they live in water, their color and so on were observable. But beyond that - you cannot observe. So - FOR FUCKS SAKE - apparently you cannot observe and group them into a sex binary. Whales! So, you cannot claim that one type of whale (eg - female) gives birth.

In university. How? Just how?

My offspring handed two papers in so far and got terrible marks - presumably because of questions raised about the science, or lack there of. For the end of term paper, it will be an "I accept the indoctrination" type paper. It will be interesting to compare the results.

It really upsets me actually. And all the more so because we are paying for it!

It is so tyrannical and farcical.

What course are they on? Please say it is not biology!

Grammarnut · 17/11/2026 22:22

Heggettypeg · 17/11/2026 08:05

If it is, no wonder the birthrate is dropping!

That needs the laugh emoji - you think gen Z really don't know it doesn't work with two people of different genders if they are the same sex? I fear you might be right.

Grammarnut · 17/11/2026 22:26

thesplendourfalls · 17/11/2026 13:55

Totally off topic but when did people start calling their son/ daughter ‘offspring’? It sounds so formal, just use son or daughter.

Centuries ago.

Grammarnut · 17/11/2026 22:33

Tzika · 17/11/2026 19:51

So rape only counts if it’s coitus? Worst take I’ve seen on this site.

This has what to do with anything? OP's offspring asked why transwomen (men) were included in a lecture on violence against women. Also, by implication, where the lecturer sourced the stats - which do not chime at all with UK stats on TiMs and violence. Rape in the UK is defined as penetration with a penis of the anus, vagina or mouth. Anything else is sexual assault.

PhilosophicalBadger · 17/11/2026 22:43

I was completely dismayed to find that my wonderful Feminism and Gender Studies prof was one of the women who went after Kathleen Stock. She went from writing great feminist papers back in the day to writing essays about how saying 'biological female ' is a 'dog whistle ' against transwomen. 🙄

Yeah, it's rife and I'm very sad that Philosophy seems to be in the eye of the storm (along with sociology, psychology and criminology).

AlonsoMosley · Yesterday 12:45

Grammarnut · 17/11/2026 22:18

What course are they on? Please say it is not biology!

Small mercies @Grammarnut - not biology but humanities. On the back of being force fed forced thinking the offspring is thinking of switching over to Classics. We think it could be a very good thing.

AlonsoMosley · Yesterday 12:56

PhilosophicalBadger · 17/11/2026 22:43

I was completely dismayed to find that my wonderful Feminism and Gender Studies prof was one of the women who went after Kathleen Stock. She went from writing great feminist papers back in the day to writing essays about how saying 'biological female ' is a 'dog whistle ' against transwomen. 🙄

Yeah, it's rife and I'm very sad that Philosophy seems to be in the eye of the storm (along with sociology, psychology and criminology).

I took some fun classes recently in a university near us, specifically a course on Jane Austen and a few philosophy classes.

The Jane Austen prof invited speculation that Austen may have been a gender bender. The "idea" was pushed in almost every class. Various texts were presented as ambiguity leading to possible proof depending on interpretation etc. It was very poorly argued.

Philosophy was the most disappointing though - two out of three classes featured it. As it is a science based on argument, it truly fell at almost every turn.

I wondered if it was linked to professors getting reviewed by the students and perhaps getting hired on the back of those reviews.

AlonsoMosley · Yesterday 12:57

@PhilosophicalBadger

Have you any interest in a chat about Divine Comedy?

TheOldWhiteHorse · Yesterday 13:23

alcovecupboards · 16/11/2026 19:59

Never. The old bigots will die off and with them their raging against progress.

What people like this fail to understand is that the reason older women have been in the vanguard of the pushback against trans nonsense is exactly because we have more 'lived experience' of the patriarchy. Individuals will die off but there will be an unending train of older women taking our places.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 13:27

AlonsoMosley · Yesterday 12:45

Small mercies @Grammarnut - not biology but humanities. On the back of being force fed forced thinking the offspring is thinking of switching over to Classics. We think it could be a very good thing.

Ironically, the Classics will involve the study of gender 😀

EveningSpread · Yesterday 14:18

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 13:27

Ironically, the Classics will involve the study of gender 😀

Quite - there’s nothing wrong with the root of the term, it’s the political uses it’s been put to lately.

And also @Grammarnut and @AlonsoMosley theres also plenty of scholarship about biology & gender. Take Anne Fausto-Stirling for example. Rigorous, interesting biologist informed by humanities approaches. Her “Myths of Gender” does what gender studies once did: identifies and challenges claims about women’s supposed inferiority!

CreativeGreen · Yesterday 14:25

PhilosophicalBadger · 17/11/2026 22:43

I was completely dismayed to find that my wonderful Feminism and Gender Studies prof was one of the women who went after Kathleen Stock. She went from writing great feminist papers back in the day to writing essays about how saying 'biological female ' is a 'dog whistle ' against transwomen. 🙄

Yeah, it's rife and I'm very sad that Philosophy seems to be in the eye of the storm (along with sociology, psychology and criminology).

AP?

Peregrina · Yesterday 16:18

It's entirely true that trans women suffer high rates of sexual violence.

I assume that there would be nothing to stop this lecturer giving one about violence against transpeople.

They could then start with the bald statement above. Do they really? What do they mean by violence? Is refusing to call a man "she" violent?

I imagine if the lecturer bothered to research it properly they would find that there wasn't much evidence for this statement.

AlonsoMosley · Yesterday 17:15

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · Yesterday 13:27

Ironically, the Classics will involve the study of gender 😀

I think the classics will involve a lot of study of sex, sex based ownership, sex based violence, sexism, misogyny, homosexuality, pederasty and loads more besides.
They will of course study the theatrical use of men dressing as, and pretending to be, women, in ancient the plays to make points of ridicule and general observations of how the world will upend itself unless we get things under proper control.

But men becoming women? Those 3rd class specimens of grimness? Doubtful! 😁

Apollo441 · Yesterday 17:45

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 17/11/2026 21:22

Sure. Tell your kid to show respect to minorities and they're more likely to gain friends, have the respect of colleagues and not be regarded with suspicion.

It's entirely true that trans women suffer high rates of sexual violence. Your child displayed a total lack of sympathy with victims which utterly disgusted their lecturer. It probably also came across as victim-blaming.

Transphobia isn't heroism. Happy to help.

It's entirely true that trans women suffer high rates of sexual violence.

No it's entirely made up if you mean compared to women. Let's see your statistics and not from prostitutes in favelas.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page