Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

When are universities going to stop teaching crap about gender identity?

96 replies

happydappy2 · 16/11/2026 14:58

My offspring is at a Russell Group Uni studying Criminology. Has just had a lecture about violence against women & on the slide titled Intersectional vulnerabilities it stated that Trans women experience 2-3 time higher risk of sexual assault than the general population of women.

My offspring approached the lecturer during a break and politely asked them to clarify how that statement could be true as most trans women have a penis between their legs.....the lecturer was not amused and accused my adult child of questioning their authority. My child politely asked for further explanation as trans women are men not a type of woman.....lecturer was having none of it.

We have since spoken-I've explained that that particular stat was probably taken from trans women who work as prostitutes and has long been debunked.

I am just so sad that this rubbish has not been cleared out of uni education yet-our kids are paying a fortune for a degree and some of what they are taught is just crap.

I'd be so grateful for any advice that others might be able to give me to help my offspring challenge this, in a way that won't have negative repercussions for them.

OP posts:
HoppityBun · 16/11/2026 20:59

I have no suggestions except to suggest that your offspring, to whom kudos must be given, might best perhaps approach this lecturer with an air of puzzled curiosity, rather than overt challenge. Open questions are always good.

Two obvious resources are Nick Wallis’s Gender Blog and the YouTube talks and podcast interviews of / by Dr Az Hakeem

Herewegoagain127 · 16/11/2026 21:15

happydappy2 · 16/11/2026 20:46

it was a seminar on sexual assaults against women......my offspring was questioning why trans women were being included in this discussion as they are not women.....

That’s a different question to the o/p.

you presented it as if they were questioning the stats around trans women being assaulted more often than women- they were “questioning how the statement could be true”.

now you say they were questioning why trans women were included in a lecture on violence against women, in which case it is more of a relevant question.

DrBlackbird · 16/11/2026 22:28

is it really “universities”. Are all students being taught this or is it a particular point on a criminology course?

@Herewegoagain127 the answer is broadly yes. For RG universities certainly. Many have explicit programmes of ‘Queering the university’ ie across the university as a whole albeit more actively or overtly in some departments over others. But definitely coming from central management. Mine does.

Manyanamanyana · 17/11/2026 01:04

Please thank your offspring for his or her bravery, every single question counts. And well done you for raising such a polite critical thinker 💚

AlonsoMosley · 17/11/2026 01:19

happydappy2 · 16/11/2026 14:58

My offspring is at a Russell Group Uni studying Criminology. Has just had a lecture about violence against women & on the slide titled Intersectional vulnerabilities it stated that Trans women experience 2-3 time higher risk of sexual assault than the general population of women.

My offspring approached the lecturer during a break and politely asked them to clarify how that statement could be true as most trans women have a penis between their legs.....the lecturer was not amused and accused my adult child of questioning their authority. My child politely asked for further explanation as trans women are men not a type of woman.....lecturer was having none of it.

We have since spoken-I've explained that that particular stat was probably taken from trans women who work as prostitutes and has long been debunked.

I am just so sad that this rubbish has not been cleared out of uni education yet-our kids are paying a fortune for a degree and some of what they are taught is just crap.

I'd be so grateful for any advice that others might be able to give me to help my offspring challenge this, in a way that won't have negative repercussions for them.

My offspring send me a recording of a class the other day. The mental gymnastics from the lecturer were mind-blowing.

They were told that certain characteristics could be observed. Using whales as examples the lecturer said that their size, the fact that they live in water, their color and so on were observable. But beyond that - you cannot observe. So - FOR FUCKS SAKE - apparently you cannot observe and group them into a sex binary. Whales! So, you cannot claim that one type of whale (eg - female) gives birth.

In university. How? Just how?

My offspring handed two papers in so far and got terrible marks - presumably because of questions raised about the science, or lack there of. For the end of term paper, it will be an "I accept the indoctrination" type paper. It will be interesting to compare the results.

It really upsets me actually. And all the more so because we are paying for it!

It is so tyrannical and farcical.

AlonsoMosley · 17/11/2026 01:23

asillysausage · 16/11/2026 19:19

I’m a mature student in my final year studying criminology and I regularly challenge my lecturer on this subject too!

I’ve pushed back against her own biases and told her she needs to stop making sweeping generalisations about such a contentious topic. We don’t always agree, and I’m certainly not afraid to question her arguments!

However, to her credit, she’s actually very supportive of my critical thinking and encourages me to challenge things. My dissertation focuses on gender-critical women within the criminal justice system and she’s been incredibly supportive of my research.

I’d encourage your daughter to keep questioning things, particularly the evidence behind statistics like this. Ask where the figures come from, what the research actually says and whether it’s being presented accurately.

University should be about developing independent thought, not simply agreeing with whatever a lecturer tells you. You can disagree with someone and still have a perfectly good academic relationship with them. That’s certainly been my experience!

I wonder if yours is in the closet so to speak? 😁

Not able to speak out but delighted that you are?

Apollo441 · 17/11/2026 02:44

Herewegoagain127 · 16/11/2026 21:15

That’s a different question to the o/p.

you presented it as if they were questioning the stats around trans women being assaulted more often than women- they were “questioning how the statement could be true”.

now you say they were questioning why trans women were included in a lecture on violence against women, in which case it is more of a relevant question.

Literally the first line of the OPs post

My offspring is at a Russell Group Uni studying Criminology. Has just had a lecture about violence against women

She didn't change context. You failed to read what she wrote. The question of why include males in a lecture about violence against women was always pertinant.

Those stats come from prostitutes in Brazilian favelas and have been thouroughly debunked. Sure, if you compare it to western hemisphere 'normal' violence against women it looks terrible.
But guess what? Comparing like to like (i.e. female prostitutes in favelas) the women's stats are even worse. Who would believe that activists would lie to make a point?

EveningSpread · 17/11/2026 03:03

I work in a University and one of the things I teach is the history of gender and sexuality.

Teaching the long history of the ideas & terms is very useful for helping students approach today’s popular and political discourses critically. The gender theorists of the 1990s and plenty of contemporary humanities/sciences scholars have interesting and sensible things to say about this topic. And of course they don’t all agree, so the topic shouldn’t be sold to students as set, it’s evolving.

Sadly though politicians, social media warriors, the media, and crappy knee jerk company policies don’t reflect the quality of academic discourse. Anxieties and trends can seep into academic subjects where they don’t have time for a really critical approach and want to give basic data, which sounds like it’s what’s happened here. Sad that the data isn’t appropriately framed or questioned.

As a society we’ve got lost in a few very limited populist discourses about trans rights and identities that police boundaries and shut down debate. It’s disheartening but the tide will turn, it always does! These things are never static.

But just to let you know that good teaching and quality academic discourse is actually alive and well! And I’m not even in a Russell Group!

asillysausage · 17/11/2026 06:10

AlonsoMosley · 17/11/2026 01:23

I wonder if yours is in the closet so to speak? 😁

Not able to speak out but delighted that you are?

I actually get that impression from her too! 😂 Especially during our dissertation supervision meetings. She’s told me how important my topic is and that there needs to be more research looking at these issues from a different perspective.

She’s also been really thorough with my work, making sure my arguments are properly supported and that there’s nothing the moderators can pick apart. So I do sometimes wonder whether she agrees with more than she can openly say!

OverpricedCupcake · 17/11/2026 06:13

alcovecupboards · 16/11/2026 19:59

Never. The old bigots will die off and with them their raging against progress.

You really think it's just older people who believe in biology?
Aw bless.

MaybeDoctor · 17/11/2026 07:03

Verisregina · 16/11/2026 19:08

I agree, our universities should be teaching students independence of thought, how to reason, how to argue and how to synthesis knowledge. It’s upsetting to think a student asking questions about lecture content should get a response like that.

I’m not in anyway defending your DC’s lecturer, but if you look at the cases of people like Prof Kathleen Stock at Sussex and Dr John Baird at Aberdeen, the lecturers themselves may be locked in the same Through the Looking Glass lunacy, where they can’t challenge the prevailing culture for any number of reasons, they want to progress in their careers or they have families and mortgages to pay.

Who knows what the answer is, but I think your fab DC’s bravery in questioning the lecture material is a good start.

In fairness, during the Dr Stock debacle (as it
became more widely known) there were many staff and students who sent messages of support to her and to the university management. The problem was that she had already been experiencing the harassment and intimidation for some time, so she was already at the end of her patience, and there was an even more vocal group who were campaigning against her. Another big factor was that UCU failed to support her. After she had left there was a petition signed by academics nationwide, in support of academic freedom.

Verisregina · 17/11/2026 08:03

MaybeDoctor · 17/11/2026 07:03

In fairness, during the Dr Stock debacle (as it
became more widely known) there were many staff and students who sent messages of support to her and to the university management. The problem was that she had already been experiencing the harassment and intimidation for some time, so she was already at the end of her patience, and there was an even more vocal group who were campaigning against her. Another big factor was that UCU failed to support her. After she had left there was a petition signed by academics nationwide, in support of academic freedom.

I don’t doubt there was private support, but whether she resigned or was forced out she still lost her job following as you say a horrifying campaign of harassment and intimidation that include death threats and continued beyond her employment at Sussex.

John Baird was also accused of being transphobic, homophobic and misogynistic and bigoted. He was attacked by both students and colleagues. His case may not be as familiar as that of Kathleen Stock’s but I believe it illustrates what can happen lower down the chain when lecturers express views in opposition to the current cultural climate.

This doesn’t mean some lecturers aren’t captured, or support trans-ideology but it is a pretty threatening culture in which to work for those who hold GC views.

www.pressandjournal.co.uk/fp/news/6896031/aberdeen-university-lecturer-cleared-harry-potter-transphobia-row/

Heggettypeg · 17/11/2026 08:05

OverpricedCupcake · 17/11/2026 06:13

You really think it's just older people who believe in biology?
Aw bless.

If it is, no wonder the birthrate is dropping!

Heggettypeg · 17/11/2026 08:11

MaybeDoctor · 17/11/2026 07:03

In fairness, during the Dr Stock debacle (as it
became more widely known) there were many staff and students who sent messages of support to her and to the university management. The problem was that she had already been experiencing the harassment and intimidation for some time, so she was already at the end of her patience, and there was an even more vocal group who were campaigning against her. Another big factor was that UCU failed to support her. After she had left there was a petition signed by academics nationwide, in support of academic freedom.

A few years ago, I came across a website where people in academia wrote anonymous testimonies about their own experiences with gender ideology. Staff, graduate students etc. I can't find the reference now, does anyone else know of it?

It was heartbreaking. Person after person saying they felt they had to hide their views to keep their job.

(Edited a typo)

Verisregina · 17/11/2026 08:22

As a PG student, I kept my head down and didn’t rock the boat. It’s not something I’m particularly comfortable with and I am certainly not proud of it, but at the time it felt risky to defend what’s now become a gender critical position.

CreativeGreen · 17/11/2026 08:22

Can’t see this going anywhere in a hurry, in RGs or post-92s either. It’s still a very intimidating atmosphere for anyone not captured

EveningSpread · 17/11/2026 08:50

CreativeGreen · 17/11/2026 08:22

Can’t see this going anywhere in a hurry, in RGs or post-92s either. It’s still a very intimidating atmosphere for anyone not captured

I don’t fully agree, having spent 8 years in a RG and 10 in a post-92.

What happened to Kathleen Stock was awful. She was targeted and hounded, abused. The institution should have done more to support her and again, its exemplary of the poverty of management & PR thought that they didn’t.

But there are many academics working on issues of gender & sexuality perfectly fine. That doesn’t mean their work isn’t discussing the same issues, but it isn’t centrally about publicly taking a side in this minute’s debate. It might be about how we’ve got here, or how these issues are examined in the media, literature, or how medical and legal discourses operate/change and why.

Equally at work, I’ve never done things like add “she/her” to my email signature and nobody has ever bothered me. I teach classes that cover terms and experiences of intersex, transgender, transsexual, transvestite, and the term LGBT (and its permutations!).

While there have been times I’ve been a bit worried about how classes will go because of how high profile these topics have become, I’ve not yet experienced any negativity from students. This might be because the classes are about teaching them this history of these concepts, why people care about them, the variety of views about them, how they are handled in different literature and what’s at stake - and not about telling the students what to think.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 17/11/2026 09:30

EveningSpread · 17/11/2026 08:50

I don’t fully agree, having spent 8 years in a RG and 10 in a post-92.

What happened to Kathleen Stock was awful. She was targeted and hounded, abused. The institution should have done more to support her and again, its exemplary of the poverty of management & PR thought that they didn’t.

But there are many academics working on issues of gender & sexuality perfectly fine. That doesn’t mean their work isn’t discussing the same issues, but it isn’t centrally about publicly taking a side in this minute’s debate. It might be about how we’ve got here, or how these issues are examined in the media, literature, or how medical and legal discourses operate/change and why.

Equally at work, I’ve never done things like add “she/her” to my email signature and nobody has ever bothered me. I teach classes that cover terms and experiences of intersex, transgender, transsexual, transvestite, and the term LGBT (and its permutations!).

While there have been times I’ve been a bit worried about how classes will go because of how high profile these topics have become, I’ve not yet experienced any negativity from students. This might be because the classes are about teaching them this history of these concepts, why people care about them, the variety of views about them, how they are handled in different literature and what’s at stake - and not about telling the students what to think.

It's fortunate that you have not experienced any negative responses. You might have, if students had felt able to say what they genuinely feel about the subjects. With the atmosphere in universities the past decade or so, none of us can say for certain if there has been a culture of fear or not, because no one has been able to risk bringing the topic into the open.

I see a few possibilities here:

  • You are saying and teaching what everyone around you wants to hear, therefore there has been no conflict.
  • Your students genuinely don't care enough about the subjects.
  • Your students really do care about the subjects, and they are all on the same page, either through indoctrination or because they just all think the same way.
  • Your students are afraid to voice their opinions.
  • You've been incredibly lucky and haven't encountered a transactivist yet who cares enough to kick up a fuss if you say the "wrong" thing.

When you finally meet one of those activists, you'll know it.

(other opinions are available, of course)

CreativeGreen · 17/11/2026 09:35

Well I wouldn’t want to give too many revealing details but where I work, the chilling effect is definitely real

Elbowpatch · 17/11/2026 09:50

is it really “universities”. Are all students being taught this or is it a particular point on a criminology course?

No, all students are not being taught this. I can’t believe that anybody would be so gullible as to believe otherwise.

MaybeDoctor · 17/11/2026 09:51

Completely agree @EveningSpread. What happened to Dr Stock was horrifying but it is inaccurate to suggest that all academics, students and institutions are entirely captured. Or that other people are complicit in persecution because they don’t do…what exactly?

A university campus is a big place with multiple buildings, staffing structures and subcultures. Or multiple campuses that are several miles apart. Not everyone is on Twitter, as it was then. They may not even be aware of something happening until it is almost over. As I said, people did speak up and express support for Dr Stock but the timing meant that it had already gone beyond the point at which it would be helpful.

The other factor is the person themselves. Someone can be the victim of a targeted campaign and also be a not very likeable person. We can all think of colleagues who rub others up the wrong way. Like it or not, this will affect how willing others are to come out and support them.

heathspeedwell · 17/11/2026 10:09

The good news is that most university students these days reject gender ideology, especially if they are studying medicine, engineering or STEM subjects. There was a very heartening HEPI Poll, which I'll dig out.

Verisregina · 17/11/2026 10:41

MaybeDoctor · 17/11/2026 09:51

Completely agree @EveningSpread. What happened to Dr Stock was horrifying but it is inaccurate to suggest that all academics, students and institutions are entirely captured. Or that other people are complicit in persecution because they don’t do…what exactly?

A university campus is a big place with multiple buildings, staffing structures and subcultures. Or multiple campuses that are several miles apart. Not everyone is on Twitter, as it was then. They may not even be aware of something happening until it is almost over. As I said, people did speak up and express support for Dr Stock but the timing meant that it had already gone beyond the point at which it would be helpful.

The other factor is the person themselves. Someone can be the victim of a targeted campaign and also be a not very likeable person. We can all think of colleagues who rub others up the wrong way. Like it or not, this will affect how willing others are to come out and support them.

I think @EveningSpread has highlighted an important point. University leadership has failed in ensuring freedom of thought and expression and academic rigour. I’m not sure where PR comes into it, perhaps in highlighting the numbers of students and colleagues who were prepared to support KS publicly and what the university was doing to ensure her safety and freedom to do her job as a professor of philosophy.

As to your point on whether an individual is likeable, I sort of understand it, but find it distasteful. I don’t know how I’d behave in that situation but I hope I’d at least recognize the injustice and act on that.

It is a really good example of why we need better leadership at our universities.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 17/11/2026 10:43

Heggettypeg · 17/11/2026 08:11

A few years ago, I came across a website where people in academia wrote anonymous testimonies about their own experiences with gender ideology. Staff, graduate students etc. I can't find the reference now, does anyone else know of it?

It was heartbreaking. Person after person saying they felt they had to hide their views to keep their job.

(Edited a typo)

Edited

I remember that. It was eye-opening. I'll hunt for it later (unless anyone can find it in the meantime)

EveningSpread · 17/11/2026 10:53

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 17/11/2026 09:30

It's fortunate that you have not experienced any negative responses. You might have, if students had felt able to say what they genuinely feel about the subjects. With the atmosphere in universities the past decade or so, none of us can say for certain if there has been a culture of fear or not, because no one has been able to risk bringing the topic into the open.

I see a few possibilities here:

  • You are saying and teaching what everyone around you wants to hear, therefore there has been no conflict.
  • Your students genuinely don't care enough about the subjects.
  • Your students really do care about the subjects, and they are all on the same page, either through indoctrination or because they just all think the same way.
  • Your students are afraid to voice their opinions.
  • You've been incredibly lucky and haven't encountered a transactivist yet who cares enough to kick up a fuss if you say the "wrong" thing.

When you finally meet one of those activists, you'll know it.

(other opinions are available, of course)

Respectfully, I don’t agree. I have had heated debates in class, handle difficult questions, and we discuss a range of competing views. But I’ve never had angry shutdowns or objections to my views. Partially because teaching them is not centrally about telling them my views.

The students also don’t necessarily arrive knowing what they want to hear, nor are they incapable of respectful debate. You do them, and a lot of university courses, a disservice.

They do however arrive with strong opinions on love, life, equality, relationships, and these are things they do care about. Gender and sexuality are, no matter our views, integral to our identities, and we acknowledge that.

I can understand all your speculative bullet points, and of course they’re all possible.

But equally, you ought to be open to the possibility that there is rigorous academic discourse going on in classrooms, and that academics and students are in certain places able to approach these topics critically.