Tweets from Sarah Phillimore at RCJ 18/11
So far as this claim concerns Sec of State it is a policy challenge, to non statutory guidance issued to police forces re recording rules. By way of overview the SoS response to claims of unlawfulness is that crime recording rules require recording of allegations not finding of guilt, primarily for statistical purposes.
Police would record and retain such allegations independent of rules. Rules are designed to further legitimate policy objectives including needs of victims. Also incorporate objective checks and wider safeguards so rules operate fairly and with due regard to article 10. possibility of individual unfair decisions capable of being made does not mean rules are unlawful.
It is essential that complaint is adjudicated upon with true understanding of the rules. Deal with standard of review and then the two grounds, applying that standard of review. Finally, some concluding remarks.
Starting point is s44 Police Act 1996. SoS may require police to provide information connected with policing. in particular information in form of statistics. Annual Data Requirement, referenced in witness statement. p219 core bundle. para 6. Explains that crime recording is mandatory function for police forces, to account to Home Office. annual data requirement is mechanism to collect data to formulate official statistics
Turning to guidance, Mr Williams' statement p242 core bundle - national counting rules in existence for many decades but in modern form since 1998, having undergone revision. Primary purpose is therefore to govern the recording of crime to provide statistical data required by home Office. but also serve purposes relating to identification and treatment of victims of crime. Non statutory guidance therefore test of lawfulness through prism of Gillick test.
Revised counting rules are the product of extensive empirical research which demonstrated problems with consistency in recording crimes and tendency to underrecording.
On the Record - thematic inspection report on Police crime reporting. 2000. p 274 contents page to give you sense of scope of this report. Crime recording at part 1. Executive summary. Look at some of the findings in the body of the report.
Found most police officers applied similar rigorous standard of evidence re crimes. What evidence required for NCHI? Most forces were prepared to no crime if dispute or doubt. conclusion in general with exception of serious crime, officers tended to seek evidence beyond reasonable doubt to record but used balance of probabilities to no crime.
under victim led crime reporting, police justified non crime if victim did not wish to pursue. Many officers said recording of such offences a waste of time. These findings are picked up in Executive summary. Way forward - merits and demerits in both form of recording, need nationally consistent and reliable methods.
Fast forward to 2014 HMIC inspection report - making the victim count. Lot longer than the other report. Crime recording process starts with call to incident handling. disengagement by victim and police which means crimes that should and could have been recorded at first call are going unreported. Details taken by call handlers often insufficient. That section of report recommended victim always be believed and this should be institutionalised and recording of crime should not be delayed.
What that shows is there was empirical research which underpinned development and still problems a decade on re consistency and under recording of crimes. but whole idea of NCRS was to remedy this.
Mr W statement - stress his credentials as a witness and research he has done - consistency in recording of crimes is necessary to ensure national crime decisions can inform public policy decisions. If dependent on judicial finding captures only small amount of crimes. Need data set that more accurately captures nature and scale of offending, to identify trends and assess impact.
information gathered is used internally re training. Management meetings to identify emerging crime trends. On a monthly basis meetings using crime recorded to determine risk to public and management.
If we needed to wait for outcome of prosecution we would not be able to identify trends as they emerge.
So with that body of evidence in mind and uses for which data is put, the threshold test in for reporting was devised. NCRS. National Crime Recording Standards.
It was a deliberate policy decision to enshrine a victim focused approach. To reduce extent to which recording decisions depended on differing approaches at initial stage. So police undertake objective assessment on assumption that information given is true, which is reinforced by direction on when to record.
General interpretation of principles - timeliness of recording. When information at first point of contact satisfies requirements. Must be recorded in 24 hours.
Investigation, whether by visiting for statement or seeking account would undermine the objectives of early recording and that was precisely what 2000 investigation revealed was happening.
All of this inevitably means that what is being recorded is not that a crime has been committed but someone has made an allegation that a crime has been committed.
It is well established that the application of NCSR, the data does not tell us how many crimes committed but how many reported to the police. Importantly, no one not even HM understands that the recording of a crime denotes the commission of a crime!
See HM skeleton argument. Para 10 p3 we see the very first and said to be crucial point of contact, word crime does not have the ordinary meaning of crime in everyday language. It is a term of art. An allegation is made. HM has understood this from the beginning. It is therefore difficult to understand the evidence relied on that HM himself understood as the import of such a record, particularly as he is a former police officer. He did ask re SAR for information in relation to this matter.
Lest there be any doubt about the policy objectives, one only has to look at the Vision Purpose statement in the supplementary bundle. Want to be the best crime crime reporting system with accurate statistics that puts needs of victims at its core... victims recieve the service they deserve, inform public of scope and risk of crime, allow intelligence on risk... inform development of policy to reduce crime.
conclude 16.25
my bold