Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Miller v Chief Constable 18-19 November at Royal Courts of Justice.

82 replies

MalcolmTent · 16/11/2026 13:05

Just a heads up about this case.

"Miller v Chief Constable 18-19 November at Royal Courts of Justice.

@LincsPolice position is that ‘the victim must always be believed.’

This allows Person A to self identify as a victim, and to designate Person B as a suspect.

The police say that any requirement to consider objective evidence, to inform the named suspect of the allegation, or to conduct an investigation prior to recording the suspect in relation to the crime would be to disrespect the victim.

The ‘criminal’ record may appear on a DBS check.

In my case, it was a former officer who made the allegation - immediately after he was sacked for gross misconduct and deception. This, apparently, is irrelevant. In no way may this fact get in the way of believing him and criminalising me.

In 2019, it was the Fisher Price gangster Mrs B who played the system. In 2026, it’s disgraced cop Lynsay Watson.

Both found Chief Constables who willingly played along."

https://x.com/WeAreFairCop/status/2122239707962618259?a=IhFJEXdHGz4kRjnmdxU&s=19

WeAreFairCop (@WeAreFairCop) on X

Miller v Chief Constable 18-19 November at Royal Courts of Justice. @LincsPolice position is that ‘the victim must always be believed.’ This allows Person A to self identify as a victim, and to designate Person B as a suspect. The police say that...

https://x.com/WeAreFairCop/status/2122239707962618259?a=IhFJEXdHGz4kRjnmdxU&s=19

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Ereshkigalangcleg · Yesterday 20:46

MalcolmTent · Yesterday 17:11

Hmmm wonder if that's one of the well-known TRAs, perhaps even Watson himself.

Yes, he seems a bit overinvested!

Ereshkigalangcleg · Yesterday 20:50

If I’ve got time I’ll post all Sarah’s tweets from tomorrow’s hearing here.

WFTCHTJ · Yesterday 20:51

Having waded through Tribunal Tweets coverage of the Hayn es v Blackball Pool Federation case - specifically the claimants' brief wanging on at length about how not being able to play in the female category is a violation of various sections of the ECHR - I can't understand how this ever even made it to court. Surely it's a clear violation of his Article 6 right to a fair trial, and the only sensible course of action for the force was to remove it from his record, apologise and possibly make a token gesture of compensation for the inconvenience?

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 09:54

Fair Cop have just posted a summary of the first day. I haven’t got time to post all Sarah’s posts from yesterday but will post today’s.

Summary:

Day 2 High Court. The Home Secretary’s argument so far is as follows:

  1. Historically, crimes were under reported.
  2. Police forces demanded evidence before recording crimes.
  3. This was not good because reasons.
  4. The answer to this was to record every allegation as a crime.
  5. The burden of proof now rests with the ‘suspect’ to prove beyond reasonable doubt that a crime did not occur.

In effect, the answer to the alleged operational under reporting of crime has been to introduce systemic over reporting, which relegates evidence to a side show.

https://x.com/wearefaircop/status/2123347325430956249

WeAreFairCop (@WeAreFairCop) on X

Day 2 High Court. The Home Secretary’s argument so far is as follows: 1. Historically, crimes were under reported. 2. Police forces demanded evidence before recording crimes. 3. This was not good because reasons. 4. The answer to this was to record e...

https://x.com/WeAreFairCop/status/2123347325430956249?a=3PSMl0tZfRaSRZTsXGU&s=46

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 09:55

This is a really important case I think.

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 09:57

Ah she can’t go today. I’ll try to put up the posts from yesterday instead then. I expect there will be a summary at the end of the day today from FC or other interested parties.

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 10:00

Sarah’s posts this morning:

”Sadly can’t make it to the RCJ for day 2 of Harry Miller’s challenge to the Sec of State and Lincs police to record him as having committed a hate crime against Lynsay Watson - which he was never interviewed about and was not informed until a year later he made a data subject access request.

But I have heard enough from the Sec of State to be now very worried. Will write all this up later today.

For now, I note that in pursuit of a ‘vision’ to have the best crime recording in the world, our police are told to record reports as ‘crimes’ and the reporting person as a ‘victim’.

The ‘victim’ is simply believed, even when that ‘victim’ has been dismissed from the police for gross misconduct over online harassment.

Why on earth can’t the police record a ‘reported incident’ from a ‘complainant’? That’s still useful data, can track trends and escalation etc. why record a ‘crime’ on mere report and link it to the personal data of another so it risks onward disclosure?

The Sec of State and police case appears to be that 'crime' is a term of art and 'everyone' knows it doesn't really mean a 'crime' but an incident that will then go on to be investigated fairly and with an open mind.

well. I didn't know that. I suspect that if a 'crime' is recorded against my name and disclosed to a potential employer, they won't know that either.

If the police and politicians insist that its essential to record 'incidents' as crimes on the unchallenged say so of a 'victim' and then link that 'crime' to our personal data so that it can be disclosed to a third party... then we need to be very worried about this, particularly if the Conversion Practices Bill becomes law.

Therefore any report of an abusive conversion practice will be recorded as a crime against your name from the moment of reporting.

The dangers of creating an unchallenged ‘victim’ class should be obvious. Watson already owes GMP £42k from one of his vexatious actions. Looks like he will end up owing Lincs a similar amount!

The insanity of all this should be obvious. If the Conversion Practices Bill becomes law then I bet 100s of vexatious ‘crimes’ will be reported against Baroness Cass, and presented as valid statistics to inform Home Office policy! ‘Worrying upsurge of hate crimes among middle aged female professionals’!!!

I am sadly reminded I need to make yet another DSAR request of my local force just to check if they have recorded me as a terrorist on the say so of UK Lawyers for Israel. I must have had a very interesting impact on the crime stats for Wiltshire market towns

And now Harry has reported Watson to Lincs police under s179 of the On Line Safety Act who have replied to say that a crime 'may' have been committed. So under this frankly insane scheme, both Miller and Watson are simultaneously victims and criminals, all of this will be up for disclosure and crime statistics become meaningless gibberish.

Brave New World eh. Maybe time to review that Vision and Purpose statement.

Or just accept that 'crimes' around speech are nothing like physical assaults and damage to property and the police need to tread carefully here.”

https://x.com/svphillimore/status/2123349578183295277

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 10:12

It’s worth clicking through to the X posts to see the screenshots Sarah attached, one is from our friend and hers Sophie Molly, inciting people to report Baroness Cass for illegal conversion therapy practices (when it comes in)

oldtiredcyclist · Today 10:34

We are living in a truly mad World. How can the police possibly get away with this?

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 10:42

So I guess (and we’ve discussed this issue before here but not so starkly) every time the “hate crime statistics” are pointed to re trans, a significant number are likely made up “crimes” that have never gone through the justice system beyond a report.

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 10:44

They should be forced to clarify that crimes are different to reports of crimes. So if Miller has reported Watson it might be logged as a “crime” but there is no “hate” element so it won’t be included in “hate crime” statistics. Unlike the other way round.

MarieDeGournay · Today 10:58

oldtiredcyclist · Today 10:34

We are living in a truly mad World. How can the police possibly get away with this?

I know it's not the same, but I keep thinking about habeas corpus when I read about these 'crimes' the perpetrator knew nothing about.

Habeas corpus was, as I understand, developed to stop authorities banging people up for as long as they liked, for no reason except they wanted to - at some point the person, the body, had to be produced in court to be tried and convicted or acquitted of whatever they were supposed to have done.
[that's my IANAL understanding of it].

Google Translate and I [IANAL again - I am not a Latinist either] have come up with habeas scelus - at some point the person should be made aware that they are suspected of a crime, so they can defend themselves, and ' be produced in court to be tried and convicted or acquitted of whatever they were supposed to have done.'

I don't know if that makes any proper legal sense, but it seems to me that there's a similar mis-use of power by the authorities - a person is deprived of their good name rather than their liberty, but in both cases, there is an arbitrary denial of the right to know what you are accused of and the opportunity to defend yourself in court.

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 11:07

Tweets from yesterday from Sarah:

In court 69 waiting for @HarryTheOwl101 case against Lincs police to start. Looking at the 2011 Practice Guidance on live text based communication from court, I consider I am a legal commentator and don't need permission so will continue unless and until I am told to stop.

Court is small - room for about 15 members of public/journalists, no live stream and this is a matter of serious public interest.

HM's King's Counsel introduces the parties. Discussion about bundles. Judge would welcome a spare supplementary bundle. Agreement to see how we go. will identify Harry's KC as HM KC.

Judge has read everything she was meant to read which is an 'awful lot' but will need assistance from counsel to pick up on the nuances.

HM KC does not intend to read the skeleton argument but pick up 'big themes' where appropriate.

HM has gender critical views that has led him into conflict with transgender community. His views are set out in witness statement. HM was astonished to find out on 1 Sep 2025 by letter that complaints made about him 2 years before had been recorded as crimes against him. That astonishment has now reached this court.

Need to look at earlier proceedings for 2 very important reasons. The legal principles set out by the Court of Appeal in 2021 and the current chronology - events leading up to these proceedings follow from that CoA decision. Court will note first instance judgment in Feb 2020 and CoA decision Dec 2021.

In earlier proceedings HM challenged a similar defendant, the College of Policing and their guidance on non crime hate incidents, as well as the recording by Humberside Police of a NCHI against him. He succeeded in respect of both.

CoP guidance found to breach article 10 ECHR. Court will have seen from judgment of Knowles J that events prompting the NCHI were the promulgation of tweets by HM which were found 'profane' but legitimate expression of his views in political debate. He also found Mrs B the complainant was 'at the outer margins of rationality' para 280. Mrs B described HM as bigot and anti semitic.

The decision of Humberside Police found by High Court to be infringement of article 10 and they did not appeal. Important for context, the guidance considered in Miller 1 - the Hate Crimes Operational Guidance, issued by CoP in 2014. The relevant parts are in the Court of Appeal judgment; see from para 18 Dame Victoria Sharpe. Section 6 HCOG - 6.3 recording NCHI, must be recorded regardless whether or not there is any evidence to identify the hate element. That primarily was provision under challenge in those proceedings. Mandatory requirement in CoP guidance to record an incident based on a report received.

CoA refers to perception based recording of hate crime in para 16 of judgment - the perception of the victim is the defining factor as to whether an incident is a hate incident.

Unfortunately we do not have the guidance in full in the judgment or the current bundle. Have a separate copy of the 2014 Guidance to hand to Judge.

Judge - I am a little bit lost at the moment. Familiar with Miller 1 but need to make decision on case before me. Would help me to understand where all this is going. I have read a lot of material and it is not helpful to be handed this. I am not being assisted.

HMKC - I will explain why I am taking you to this guidance.

Judge - it was not in my pre reading. I have two days to decide this case. that is the only time you have got. Not expecting to give a judgment within the 2 days, it will be reserved. But every minute of this time is valuable and I need to understand why I am being taken to this guidance and paragraphs in Miller 1.

HMKC - make the point in one sentence. This guidance in 2014 draws a distinction between way police were to treat NCHI and crimes. That is a crucial distinction which we will come to.

HM KC - Guidance can go in the back of the authorities bundle.
Other side say they don't have the guidance and Judge confirms if they don't have it, she should not be looking at it.
HM KC - guidance not primarily focused on the way that crimes are dealt with but CoA judgment para 113 confirmed that guidance does not deal with hate crimes. Will provide 2014 guidance to other side. But guidance on crimes do NOT require mandatory reporting based on self perception but require investigation.

HM KC - other side make some issue about that comment, so need to see guidance to understand it properly. Guidance had to be replaced after judgment in CoA and instructive to see the way it was replaced following Miller 1. We have the replacement guidance in supplementary bundle. It seeks to remedy errors identified by CoA.

see pg 1119, this guidance published 3 June 2023 by the Home Office. First para in intro is designed to assist police officers to make decisions about recording and retention of data. To decide if NCHI record needs to be made and processing of personal data. Common sense approach should applied and upholding fundamental rights of free expression.

Go on to page 1128, please read para 28-30. Reference to Annex 3, steps to be taken by recording authority before recording personal data. Read to end of Annex 4. Safeguards in place. pg 1136 - police officers' attention drawn to importance of freedom of expression. p 1138 freedom of speech and NCHI considerations in light of Miller 1 ruling. Risk of chilling effect on individual rights.

All very sensible guidance following CoA decision.

Then look in more detail at CoA judgment and see para 14 set out the complaint. The uncritical recording of NCHI without any investigation to support its veracity. CoA para 106 - question can be framed - does the Guidance sanction unlawful conduct that violates article 10. It does. So exactly that point arises in second ground of current case.

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 11:12

Tweets from Sarah Phillimore 18/11 continued:

The judgment in CoA was unanimous. CoA found Knowles J wrong to say guidance did not interfere with HM article 10 rights. At para 73 CoA said the recording of NCHI is plainly an interference with article 10 and likely to have a chilling effect on public debate. Para 76 referring to analogous Turkish case, MH belongs to a group of people easily stigmatised for his opinions and subject to complaints.

CoA expanded on the chilling effect, fear of record being made, but also at very least a non trivial risk that such a record would be disclosed on a criminal record check. Judge's decision that if this happened it would not be a result of the guidance is artificial.

First important point that this was interference with HM's rights to freedom of expression. at para 90 CoA said the uncertainty about what should or could be recorded diminished to unacceptable degree the possibility of a person foreseeing what might happen. In any event, the guidance was not proportionate as did not adopt the least intrusive means and insufficient safeguards to show that incursion to ECHR rights no more than strictly necessary.

Judge - if this is important, allow me a chance to read the paragraphs as we go.
HM KC - para 122 conclusion, please read as it is very important. In short, an interference with HM rights, lack of foreseeability and failure to use least intrusive means to achieve legitimate aim.
That is a matter of record. Move to events following judgment in December 2021. Shortly afterwards, LW began a tirade of tweets including accusations that MH committed perjury in those proceedings. Clearly disappointed with outcome in Miller 1.
See HM witness statement para 10, LW sent over 800 tweets between Feb 2022 and Dec 2022.

That had profound impact on MH and his family, set out in detail in his witness statement. paras 11-15. Consequence of that, Dec 2022 HM made complaint to police. LW was arrested and interviewed re a stalking charge.
CPS considered it but decided not to charge. Reasons for that in HM statement. paras 18 and 19. 12 Dec 2023 email, CPS assessment was that calling HM a Nazi etc are offensive and distasteful but do not meet criminal threshold for prosecution.
Brief flavour of the nature of the tweets made by LW

Next event is that HM then complained to Leics police, LW was at that time a serving police officer with Leics. 25 February 2022, so closely linked in time to judgment of CoA. As a consequence of that Leics police brought disciplinary proceedings against LW who was dismissed.
Record of that hearing in two places in the bundle.

What we have here is firstly pages 4-8 record of the outcome of the misconduct hearing and pages 10-20 the reasons given by the Chief Constable for the decision. See para 1.3 pg 4 the nature of the complaint. internal process April 2022 advising LW to desist posting messages as identifiable police officer. Para 1.7 LW continued to post derogatory and abusive comments while identifiable as a police officer.

Sets out way LW proceeded at that time. para 1.10 comments referred to Fair Cop as Nazis and fascists and making factual assertions that HM violent to women, Fair Cop as terrorists, HM as bigot and narcissist etc etc

These accusations were unwarranted. LW was also writing to the Home Officer making accusations of terrorism. Outcome is page 8, 27 October 2023. Dismissed LW without notice and gave summary reasons.

Chief Constable described this as 'high culpability' and 'high harm' case. Concluded that only proper outcome is dismissal without notice and PC Watson included on the barred list.

what happened next? on same day, 27 Oct 2023, HM tweeted 'we are pleased LW has been fired' 2 days later on 29 Oct 2023 LW made complaint against HM to Lincolnshire police and it is that complaint that ultimately becomes a record of a crime, which is the basis of these proceedings.

We have complaint in the core bundle. This is the occurrence recorded with 0693 at the end. The date is 29 Oct. Sets out the narrative of the complaint, presumably cut and pasted into occurrence log. The reference to a 'fabricated official statement' - will come back to this. that was the handle LW held onto in making this complaint.
LW also concerned that MH deadnamed and misgendered him gratuitously. This is GC belief that someone cannot name themselves a different gender, sex is immutable.

LW claimed he was receiving medical attention due to mental health difficulties, and asserted he had lost his job due to HM. But LW lost job due to LW's conduct. LW asserts 'I am not well mentally'.

There are 4 complaints by LW in all. 6 November 2023 LW makes further complaint - facing accelerated gross misconduct hearing due to HM vexatious complaint. Another on 23 November 2023 - HM deadnamed him, asserted that HM knocked on door of LW neighbour asserting he was a police officer.
October 2024 a further complaint of targeted harassment. HM accused him of identity fraud. 'I have been mentally unwell since I lost my job'.
That is the sum of the complaints, intimately related to the disciplinary hearing.

https://x.com/svphillimore/status/2123016057593991267

Sarah Phillimore profile picture

Sarah Phillimore (@SVPhillimore) on X

There are 4 complaints by LW in all. 6 November 2023 LW makes further complaint - facing accelerated gross misconduct hearing due to HM vexatious complaint. Another on 23 November 2023 - HM deadnamed him, asserted that HM knocked on door of LW neighbou...

https://x.com/SVPhillimore/status/2123016057593991267?a=vVjHb_UCG7laTw02Ovc&s=46

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 11:16

Tweets from Sarah Phillimore at the RCJ 18/11

See at pg 310. Heading declaration - this investigation shall be closed as outcome 15. Refers to all complaints made by LW. What is outcome 15? That is in supplementary bundle pg 780. But also in extracted bundle pg 90. Home Office crime recording rules. Judge reads.
Crime is confirmed and victim supports police action but evidential difficulties prevent further action.

Stepping back from sequence of events, we have LW falsely accusing HM of violence to women and terrorism. HM then recorded as harassing and stalking LW.
Police record originally recorded as harassment.
1 Dec 2023 - reclassified to stalking causing serious harm and distress.

Then move on for best part of a year. See from papers on 14 October 2024 HM contacted by DS Singh and 24 November 2024 HM was interviewed. Have transcript of interview in supp bundle pg 74.

At this interview HM was assisted by a solicitor EH. The note is taken from recording made by HM. No dispute about it. DS S says an allegation has been made. Debate/conflict about a particular tweet. We have the tweet being discussed at pg 59. DS Singh says this is was a fabricated official tweet from the police. Has handle of Fair Cop and says 'statement re dismissal of LW from Leics police'.

HM replies to DS Singh. Then again issue as to whether the tweet says it was from Leics police or not - that was DS Singh interpretation. HM asks DS Singh 'can I ask what offence you think I have committed'. This was reference to the On Line Safety Act - not yet in force.

Pg 41 HM says he reported LW to police. He considered private prosecution. <can't hear>
EH says can I check what section and what offence.
HM says I have already told you <can't hear>
'person who spent best part of 2 years threatening me... <can't hear>

DS Singh comes back to s179 Online Safety Act. HM is frustrated. '2 entire years he came for me again and again, accused me of being in an organised terrorist cell and involved in bombing in Colorado... commented on picture of wife'

<cannot hear HM counsel at all>

So that is the extent of the interview with HM in determining how to conclude the complaint. Shortly after the interview on 22 November 2024 DS Singh wrote to HM pg 323 Core bundle, to say no further action.

That letter is important as goes on to say that details of reported crime will be retained to make further inquiries if further evidence. but does not say what the police actually did, which was to record a crime of stalking.

(my bold)

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 11:19

My Twitter phone needs charging, will paste some more in a bit!

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 12:36

Tweets from Sarah Phillimore at RCJ 18/11

HM himself made a complaint Lincs police on 12 December which was dismissed on grounds that tweet did not meet threshold for prosecution, HM first statement.

Then in 2025 HM made a Subject Access request to Lincs to see what information they held, which prompted letter of 1 Sep 2025. This was the first that HM knew that occurrence log was recorded as a hate crime (stalking involving serious harm and distress).

Unsurprisingly, HM reacted to that as set out in first statement. Caused considerable shock to be recorded as a hate crime. He was entirely unaware such a record existed, never notified or given any opportunity to challenge. "My reaction was of disbelief, difficult to reconcile this with an interview about false communications, no questions about stalking, no opportunity to address this allegation..."

HM considered this profoundly unfair and that legal action was required to challenge it. Further absence of any meaningful attempt by Lincs police to assess the credibility of this complaint - LW had already been dismissed from the police force for gross misconduct and carried out a substantial campaign against others including HM. LW simply not credible.

HM refers to impact of crime recording on him personally, see para 53. Implications for reputation. Offence category for ordinary member of public carries obvious connotations of stigma.

Having been told of stalking, came as shock to HM due to lack of substantive justification. He had concluded that Lincs concluded allegations by LW were baseless and vexatious. Allegation of stalking was not allegation put to him in interview, has never been put to him. But hate crime recorded.

HM found it particularly distressing that marker against his name suggested serious escalation. Shame of being recorded. His step daughter is serving police officer, and her personal record may be impacted by association. This was malicious action by LW. Police bowed to LW relentless campaign.

This prompted the issue of proceedings. HM not aware of any allegation of stalking, not given opportunity to comment.

In light of that background must now consider the rules that apply.

Crime Recording Rules for Frontline Officers and Staff. about 70 pages. Importance of rules to provide accurate statistics and be trusted by public. Key section 'Whether to record a crime'. An incident WILL be recorded as a crime if on balance of probabilities circs described by victim amount to crime at law and no credible evidence to contrary. Belief of victim that crime was committed usually sufficient to justify the recording.

again my bold

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 12:37

Tweets from Sarah Phillimore at RCJ 18/11

We are in the area of perception based offending and recording which is in contradistinction to other offences which are more objectively verifiable such as damage to property. Anything concerned with hate and perception is inevitably more nebulous.
Important that any investigation that follows takes place with open mind to establish truth.
This guidance also covers when to record, p80 - as soon as information exists, no later than 24 hours after initial report.
Recording must NOT be delayed to carry out an investigation.
Guidance goes on to deal with outcomes and specific offences. p87

Information about outcome types. Reference to outcome 15 already made - evidential difficulties.
Then specific guidance for particular categories of crimes. Stalking is like harassment but more aggressive - obsession and persistence. Involves fear of violence and distress, two or more occasions to cause victim to fear.

Go on a few pages 114 to malicious communications. Should start with a belief in what victim says. Need common sense decision. Freedom of speech important, offensive is not necessarily unlawful.

Therefore a different approach to malicious communications than 'stalking'.

Must step back and consider exactly what is being recorded. Defendant's evidence says they are not recording a crime but an ALLEGED crime. Important for present purposes is the perception of what is recorded. HM or indeed any member of the public who isn't appraised of this guidance, will understand a recorded crime as being what it says - a crime.

my bold

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 12:41

Tweets from Sarah Phillimore at RCJ 18/11

Instructive to go back to what police told HM in Sep 2025 letter. No reference there to it being an 'alleged crime' that didn't proceed. It merely says the occurrence is recorded as hate crime of stalking. That is the consequence of these crime recording rules.

No suggestion of malicious communications and guidance is contradictory - says based on victim perception but then common sense assessment of whether its malicious - how can a police officer do those two things at the same time?

This was a lengthy introduction to a complex background. Now turn to issues in the case. The Crime Recording Rules are unlawful - unfair and fail to give adequate safeguards to article 10 ECHR rights.

Turn to consider common law charge that rules are unlawful. First issue not controversial, is test for court to apply to see if a policy is unlawful. A v Sec State SC judgment is key case.

This was SC decision concerning Home Sec policy of disclosure of info re child sex offenders. Key passage para 38. Derive particularly from Gillick case and Lord Scarman judgment. 'Does the policy in question authorise or approval unlawful conduct by those to whom it is directed'.

If question of policy is unlawful must ask if it can be operated in lawful way but at the outset will lead to unlawful outcomes.
We say the flaws in the crime recording guidance is not a particular decision re HM but its application will apply to a number of other cases. There must be other people like HM out there.

We have an idea of the numbers effected by this recording. Pg 110 Core bundle para 2 - most recent statistics March 2025 show 15998 crimes recorded by police in England and Wales - 8009 re transgender hate crimes. This means a significant number of people every year must be impacted.

all bolding mine

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 12:44

Tweets from Sarah Phillimore at RCJ 18/11

Therefore this is properly characterised as a policy challenge, not individual challenge. This is approach of court in Miller 1.

CoA - we have to keep in mind this is a challenge about systemic illegality.

ssue of fairness in our statement of facts and grounds p21 Core bundle. Reference to 1911 case Rice - a dispute re LA requirement to pay same wages to teachers at maintained and non maintained schools. Went up to House of Lords. Need to ascertain the rule and the facts and in doing either must act in good faith with fairness to both sides, that is a duty on anyone who decides anything.

Must give fair opportunity to anyone involved in controversy. That was not new law in 1911! The common law is very clear and articulated in many ways in more recent case law.

Lord Diplock's two rules of natural justice. Any person adversely impacted by decision should not be left in the dark.
More recent case Lord Mustill six principles HoL 1994 in criminal justice. claim brought by prisoners serving life sentences for murder. Claimed system by which punitive element of sentence set was unfair as opaque. Reasons for setting tariff not known, could not make representations. Lord M summarised - did it fall below minimum standards of fairness and he nailed down the six principles for minimum standards - see pg 33 bundle.

These minimum standards are not only applicable to this case - of general application. Where Act of Parliament imposes administrative power, must be exercised fairly. Standards of fairness can change. Have been considered in different contexts but trend is for greater fairness for those adversely affected by decision making.

Principles of fairness can't be applied by rote, depend on context of decision, take into account in all its aspects. More important the decision, the greater the standards of fairness. Some cases where there are good public policy reasons where standards may be varied - national security cases for e.g..

Fairness will very often require a person who is adversely effected by decision, has the opportunity to make representations. They can't make worthwhile representations without knowing the gist of the case they have to answer. The prisoners had to know the gist of the reasons.

Person effected must know the process but also knows whether or not something has gone wrong, to raise an appeal or seek redress. These are the rules of natural justice.

Continuing momentum in Administrative Law to open decision making - recognised by Lord Mustill in 1994. Despite the unattractiveness of the murderous appellants, they were nevertheless entitled to know and understand why they got the sentence they did. We are now 30 years later. Openness in decision making is such that it is as plain as it can be, that standards set out by Lord Mustill should be applied. They are a norm that should be followed unless good reason not to do so.

Right that not expressed in absolute terms but with caveats that proved well founded. But also clear that the standards apply to administrative decision making generally. No reference to final determinations. No reference to restricting it to particular classes of case. It is a general proposition. Essentially that builds on 1911 case - it can't be good faith unless you listen to both sides, and that's a duty on anyone who decides anything. that might be too broad, but you know what he means.

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 12:46

Tweets from Sarah Phillimore at RCJ 18/11

Judge - you give national security as an example when its not appropriate to inform the subject of a recording, might that not also be true in many other cases, e.g. allegations of coercive and controlling behaviour. Are you suggesting that those individuals should be consulted... you are talking about lawfulness of recording and saying its unfair the way its been done. You emphasise the need for the subject to be informed, consulted, given details. Not this case, but other cases where there would seem to be ...

HM KC - domestic abuse good example as victims and perpetrators... that territory. Police have well thought through systems...

Judge - but I look at coercive control as those raise issues about harassment and stalking - how are the police going to be dealing with those

HM KC - take classic stalking case where that arises, police have duty towards any victim.

Judge they are just recording matter has been raised and take victim centred approach as otherwise these things don't get recorded and victims less likely to come forward.

HM KC - we are concerned with one form of recording

Judge - but you ask me to look at Lord Mustill re fairness. You pick national security but strikes me quite a few other areas where its problematic (to share info)

HM KC - abusive relationship example, no impediment and would be proper for the police to record an allegation, that is proper part of policing, to see if a pattern emerges. Not controversial, no impediment to fairness. Indeed even in this case police would have been perfectly entitled to make a recording of an allegation and may even have been required to. Having recorded such an allegation, its a matter for the officer to decide how to deal with it. Domestic abuse and sexual crimes are inevitably very sensitive and dealt with by specialist officers BUT at some juncture in all these cases, that person will right to defend themselves prior to conviction.

Judge - if complainant doesn't wish to give evidence and police want to keep a record of the allegation made, continuing domestic abuse allegation, obvious reasons. Are you saying at what point is the person it is recorded against given the chance to know about this?

HM KC - first stage is making allegation. Properly recorded as allegation. Then specialist teams to review allegation and decide appropriate type of investigation. Then decision has to be made as to whether to progress a criminal case.

Judge -if decision not to take further action, does fairness require the police to tell the person. Person adversely effected? Should be given explanation?

HMKC - not our case that national security is only area of exemption. But when its a recording of an allegation and no decision at that juncture.

Judge - it may be that... I am just interested in where it goes, can think of a few examples where you want police to keep record on file even if not taking action. Interested in knowing where that went in terms of fairness and what the police are supposed to do.

HM KC yes record as allegation

Judge - don't have to inform person?

Judge - e.g. of domestic violence. Where does it go? Keep the record, or only keep the record if being fair?

HM KC - I was handed this document at the door of the court. Intelligence report from Authorised Professional Practice from CoP

Judge - has anyone else got it?

HM KC - they can keep it on their records as intelligence

Judge - can keep a record but of intelligence but not recorded as a crime.

Judge - have I understood your point. Should not be recorded as a crime. Record it as some form of intelligence.

HM KC - we would have no difficulty if LW allegations recorded as allegations and kept on local police file

Judge - then HM doesn't need to be told or make representations, might be relevant later

HM KC - yes.

HM KC - crime recording rules require recording of a crime without telling person. Next point is the mandatory requirement to believe the victim. That is an important factor. Is the requirement to make a decision on the belief of a victim, accepting the victim is 'not the problem'. That is very different on making a decision based on victim's perception.

Recent years increasing tendency to 'believe victims'. that is for obvious reasons, as in past vulnerable victims not properly listened to. but believing victims is not final decision, on victim's say so. if that was the case, we would not have criminal trials.

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 12:49

Tweets from Sarah Phillimore at RCJ 18/11

Making a decision uncritically on assertion of victim assumes the victim is credible and makes no account of those motivated by malice or have mental health conditions that impair their judgment and credibility.

Needs fair consideration of both sides. Here decision made in 2023 and no investigation until 2024. Then decision made and a farcical interview with DS Singh. Even if that constrained to own facts, in policy terms an interview after a decision made was hopeless way to ensure a person was treated fairly.

The assessment by the decision maker was minimal. Guidance requires person making decision to determine if basic components of crime met.

look at this cumulatively. Deciding if basic components are met, decision is just made on review of complaint and to the civil not criminal standard.

Look at all factors in the round. Is the process as a whole unfair. We say taking all factors together, cumulatively this is an unfair process.

ADJOURN FOR LUNCH until 14.05.

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 12:53

Tweets from Sarah Phillimore at RCJ 18/11

Agreement that Defendant would start and have 30 minutes today and 2 more hours tomorrow. Want to check can sit to 4.30pm today. Judge will need to leave slightly earlier.

Resume 14.12. HM KC taking judge to authority. Challenge to a crime report by local police. p363 para 137 similar issues that arose in this case. There had been a reclassification of allegation re smacking. Question was - was it lawful without giving individual concerned opp to make representations? Judge said it was not.

Not an inflexible rule that allegations must always be put but what happened to claimant in this case was unfair. No need for a finding in more general terms.

An example of how the common law rules have been applied.

Returning to where we were before the adjournment. Our case is fairly simple and we have set it out. What are the contrary arguments? The defence raise a number of issues, including because there is an investigation, fairness is in play and sound policy reasons for recording a crime before an investigation. Even if there were sound policy reasons, that is no answer to fundamental human rights point.

It is repeated that crime log does not say a crime has been committed, its no more than an allegation. Communicates to reader it was no more than mere allegation. It does not communicate that to the reader, that was not what was said in Sep 2025 in letter to HM. No suggestion its an allegation, recorded as a crime of stalking. Language is important. Maybe that defendant understand its an allegation but it is not clear to the reader. If it was an allegation, why doesn't it just say so?

That language is crucial in this case. Continued reference in the log to victims, suspects and crimes. Not complainants, alleged perpetrator etc. Stated as a criminal conviction. Some cases where its inappropriate to inform alleged perpetrator but police have their own processes to deal with that - and the criminal process itself.

Defendant says rules for particular offences - we looked at those rules in respect for stalking and they aren't relevant. This isn't an offence of malicious communication.

Defendant says CRR are operationally simple rules, - hate crime guidance had become so large. CRR is the day to day guidance for front line officers. So that is the guidance we have focused on.

That is the common law challenge. Now turn to consider article 10 challenge - on all fours with Miller 1.

Present guidance interferes with ECHR rights in disproportionate way.
Judge - in your skeleton argument, to assess proportionality need to be clear about the legitimate aim, what are you conceding.

HM KC - Look at CRR p 157, objective and vision is to have best crime reporting system in the world, that puts needs of victims at its core, that is a legitimate aim

Judge - you accept that is the aim - we are squarely into proportionality but that is the context

Court troubled in Miller 1 by foreseeability. Person effected can't know what the impact of guidance will be. Doesn't know what the allegations are. Can't know the consequences of making a statement on social media when police actions are dependent on the perception of the person who makes the post.

Primary reason why CoA ruled was weren't sufficient safeguards in place to protect freedom of expression and we say exactly the same applies here.

<Defendant rises to say link is not operating?.

Non trivial risk of record being disclosed on criminal record check. Exactly the same here. Would not necessarily be disclosed but could be.

Judge - on that, Ms Wood's statement, I want to be able to understand everyone's position as to what this risk is. I have Ms Wood's evidence. What do you say the extent of the risk is and is it the same or different to assessment in Miller?

HM KC - exactly the same risk as in Miller 1. It's a non trivial risk, we rely on analysis of the CoA. but also the chilling effect is much wider than the mere disclosure. It is the impact on the individual exercising his or her freedom of expression. Saw reaction of HM to finding out he had a crime recorded. Someone who finds out they have a crime recorded will be inhibited in exercising their freedom of speech. Article 10 is obviously engaged.

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 12:56

Tweets from Sarah Phillimore at RCJ 18/11

Judge - I do want to make sure I have understood everyone's position. If article 10 is engaged I have to weigh up the seriousness of the risk so I need to know its extent. What do you say?

HM KC - court's task is to determine if its proportionate

Judge - I understand that. To assess proportionality I need to understand the extent of the risk.

HM KC - direct parallel with Miller 1. Risk of disclosure of enhanced criminal record check and risk of inhibition of speech. Exact risks of Miller 1 SAVE THAT we are here talking about recording a crime and impact on individual will therefore be greater.

When an individual is faced with that it will inevitably have a chilling effect on the expression of their views.

Judge - do you accept what Ms Woods has said in terms of what would be disclosed or is likely to be disclosed. Is there an issue about that or is it the agreed position

HM KC - can we turn to what exactly she says p239 core bundle para 29. would have to be considered for disclosure. would involve a review of the records

Judge - so have I understood correctly. If it wasn't for other matters, if this was the only incident, that wouldn't be disclosed on enhanced check, its because there are other things as well.

HM KC - she doesn't think it would be disclosed but our position remains its a non trivial risk of disclosure. Ms Woods doesn't say no risk of disclosure. And HM has no idea what records might or might not be held against him and neither would any other individual. Despite what Ms Woods thinks might happen in this case we are of the view its a non trivial risk of disclosure. That in any event is not relevant when compared to the significance of the chilling effect and insufficient safeguards for article 10. a mirror of Miller 1.

Main plank of case against HM is that Miller 1 distinguishes between 2014 guidance dealing with criminal and NCHI. But as we explain that was for good reason. The 2014 HCOG guidance sets out a legitimate and appropriate system for dealing with allegations of criminal conduct, as opposed to NCHI. Only get mandatory recording of allegations in that guidance re NCHI.

If position is its an alleged crime, why not say so? Is that because of collation of statistics? Collecting allegations as crimes distorts statistics in any event. So not a legitimate way to achieve aim of having world class criminal record recordings.

Recording of complaint as allegation not an actual crime, claimed it undermines utility of crime recording. That is simply not understood. Recording allegations as crimes does not further objectives.

my bold

Ereshkigalangcleg · Today 13:00

Tweets from Sarah Phillimore at RCJ 18/11

Now turn to challenge to Lincolnshire Police. First that decision made was pursuant to unlawful policy. that will depend on our challenge to the Secretary of State. But if the Secretary of State's policy is lawful, we say that Lincs police in any event acted unlawfully - four common law challenges and one DPA challenge. Learned junior will address court on DPA challenge.

Our case is really simple; recording of a crime of harassment on 6 Nov and a reclassification as harassment in Dec, without investigation was a breach of basic principles of fairness. and making the record without giving HM a chance to respond.

Not clear from Lincs case if they accept basic rules of fairness apply, if they don't accept it that would be extraordinary. Rules of natural justice plainly apply. Lincs case is directed to operation of policy itself. A lawful policy will assume it is underpinned by common law rights of individuals in any event.

Lincs relies on recommendations made by Inspectorate and that's all well and good but doesn't decide if the policy abides by natural justice.

Unevidenced assertion that if investigations took place before recording it would hamper not only recording but investigations themselves - that is a bold statement. Ask question - why would it hamper crime recording? Why record uninvestigated allegation as a crime? Record as allegation.

Wouldn't hamper investigations. Put on police record while investigations take place. Then reliance on national crime recording standards. Investigation then taken forward with open mind. but that doesn't tell us anything about the lawfulness of the decision to record.

No explanation of why HM wasn't told. Then Lincs police rely on procedure of cancelling records but that is not a means of curing common law unfairness. It's a hopeless submission and involves a reverse burden. To have a record cancelled, an individual must know about it and can prove to high standard he or she didn't do what is accused.

So we say no cogent or compelling answer.

my bold