Tweets from Sarah Phillimore at RCJ 18/11
Judge - you give national security as an example when its not appropriate to inform the subject of a recording, might that not also be true in many other cases, e.g. allegations of coercive and controlling behaviour. Are you suggesting that those individuals should be consulted... you are talking about lawfulness of recording and saying its unfair the way its been done. You emphasise the need for the subject to be informed, consulted, given details. Not this case, but other cases where there would seem to be ...
HM KC - domestic abuse good example as victims and perpetrators... that territory. Police have well thought through systems...
Judge - but I look at coercive control as those raise issues about harassment and stalking - how are the police going to be dealing with those
HM KC - take classic stalking case where that arises, police have duty towards any victim.
Judge they are just recording matter has been raised and take victim centred approach as otherwise these things don't get recorded and victims less likely to come forward.
HM KC - we are concerned with one form of recording
Judge - but you ask me to look at Lord Mustill re fairness. You pick national security but strikes me quite a few other areas where its problematic (to share info)
HM KC - abusive relationship example, no impediment and would be proper for the police to record an allegation, that is proper part of policing, to see if a pattern emerges. Not controversial, no impediment to fairness. Indeed even in this case police would have been perfectly entitled to make a recording of an allegation and may even have been required to. Having recorded such an allegation, its a matter for the officer to decide how to deal with it. Domestic abuse and sexual crimes are inevitably very sensitive and dealt with by specialist officers BUT at some juncture in all these cases, that person will right to defend themselves prior to conviction.
Judge - if complainant doesn't wish to give evidence and police want to keep a record of the allegation made, continuing domestic abuse allegation, obvious reasons. Are you saying at what point is the person it is recorded against given the chance to know about this?
HM KC - first stage is making allegation. Properly recorded as allegation. Then specialist teams to review allegation and decide appropriate type of investigation. Then decision has to be made as to whether to progress a criminal case.
Judge -if decision not to take further action, does fairness require the police to tell the person. Person adversely effected? Should be given explanation?
HMKC - not our case that national security is only area of exemption. But when its a recording of an allegation and no decision at that juncture.
Judge - it may be that... I am just interested in where it goes, can think of a few examples where you want police to keep record on file even if not taking action. Interested in knowing where that went in terms of fairness and what the police are supposed to do.
HM KC yes record as allegation
Judge - don't have to inform person?
Judge - e.g. of domestic violence. Where does it go? Keep the record, or only keep the record if being fair?
HM KC - I was handed this document at the door of the court. Intelligence report from Authorised Professional Practice from CoP
Judge - has anyone else got it?
HM KC - they can keep it on their records as intelligence
Judge - can keep a record but of intelligence but not recorded as a crime.
Judge - have I understood your point. Should not be recorded as a crime. Record it as some form of intelligence.
HM KC - we would have no difficulty if LW allegations recorded as allegations and kept on local police file
Judge - then HM doesn't need to be told or make representations, might be relevant later
HM KC - yes.
HM KC - crime recording rules require recording of a crime without telling person. Next point is the mandatory requirement to believe the victim. That is an important factor. Is the requirement to make a decision on the belief of a victim, accepting the victim is 'not the problem'. That is very different on making a decision based on victim's perception.
Recent years increasing tendency to 'believe victims'. that is for obvious reasons, as in past vulnerable victims not properly listened to. but believing victims is not final decision, on victim's say so. if that was the case, we would not have criminal trials.