Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

What sports don't distinguish men from women?

132 replies

Manxexile · 15/11/2026 15:35

I didn't want to derail the current thread about a transwoman suing one of the pool organisations for alleged discrimination on grounds of gender recognition, so thought I'd start this thread as I'm particularly interested in how different sporting bodies deal with this issue - and how they view the aspects of fair competition and physical safety.

So far as I can tell the only internationally recognised sport which doesn't appear to distinguish at all between men and women competitors and has them competing on an equal footing (ie open competition as opposed to having entirely separate mixed-sex events) is equestrianism: ie horse jumping and three-day eventing, plus I suppose flat racing and jump racing.

Are there any other open sports?

I had supposed that events like shooting, curling and archery might be open, but the Olympics has separate men's and women's plus mixed events for all three of those

NB1 - I'm a bit surprised that equestrian events are open at all, as I'd have thought that the greater strength of men would be an obvious competitive advantage - but I'm not a horsey event person so what do i know. Men might possibly aso have a strength advantage in archery, but shooting and curling?

NB2 - I see in the pool thread there seems to be some suggestion that if a sport is a "precision" sport, then men cannot have a competitive advantage over women. But i thought - perhaps mistakenly - that it was generally accepted that men had better visual spatial perception than women. Isn't this an inbuilt advantage in any sport involving positioning and 3d (or even 2d) space?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
SwirlyGates · Yesterday 12:35

@HarryPotterandtheClimateofFear I couldn't say, re strength.

I do sometimes wonder how much recklessness bravery plays a part. Showjumping, racing, eventing, are all dangerous sports, and it's well known than men are more risk-takers than women - just look at who does free climbing, who does tombstoning, who shins up buildings and climbs on rooves for laughs. As a rider I would be terrified going round one of those showjumping courses!

JustAnotherMinionForAMerchantOfDeath · Yesterday 16:37

ItalianoSl · 17/11/2026 16:16

Is that because the handlers are not being measured on anything that would differ between the sexes? It's a canine rather than human sport, isn't it?

It’s about how to handle the dog; working out the best lines, avoiding traps, ensuring clean contacts/jumps/weaves, not having the dog refuse an obstacle. Realistically at high level you won’t keep up with your dog anyway so you need to employ distanced handling, position yourself appropriately, etc. and it’s very female dominated.

ButlerianJihadNow · Yesterday 20:26

There are quidditch leagues that I believe field mixed teams (not a joke)

Wiki: Teams are required to be gender-balanced: each team may have a maximum of four non-seeker players who identify as the same gender on the field at one time, making quidditch one of the few sports that not only offers a gender-integrated environment, but an open community to those who identify as nonbinary.[6]

SerenaCat93 · Yesterday 21:02

HarryPotterandtheClimateofFear · Yesterday 12:21

@SwirlyGates that is really interesting (and a bit depressing!). A showjumper I follow on YouTube made the point recently that a horse she bought that had been produced by a man (and produced well and carefully) was used to responding to much stronger aids than how she likes to ride, so I wonder if strength does play a part in showjumping more than in other disciplines? And weight is much less of a problem within reason because the horses are so much bigger and more mature than flat racehorses.

That's a training issue. A well trained horse responds to the lightest touch. It shouldn't need a strong rider to yank it round a course. Elite horsemen like Ben Atkinson don't even need a bridle for the horse to perform excellently, he couldn't be further away from needing "strong aids" because he is a master horseman and the horse is listening to his every command.

The only time you would need stronger aids for a well performing horse to respond is when you're sitting on a ball of raw power that is bombing round the course and is not mentally regulated and tuned in to the rider. If the horse cannot regulate itself and stay calm enough to listen to light aids it's not well trained enough, but you can still win on it if you wrestle it round the course because raw power bombing round a course is fast and jumps high.

HarryPotterandtheClimateofFear · Yesterday 21:43

SerenaCat93 · Yesterday 21:02

That's a training issue. A well trained horse responds to the lightest touch. It shouldn't need a strong rider to yank it round a course. Elite horsemen like Ben Atkinson don't even need a bridle for the horse to perform excellently, he couldn't be further away from needing "strong aids" because he is a master horseman and the horse is listening to his every command.

The only time you would need stronger aids for a well performing horse to respond is when you're sitting on a ball of raw power that is bombing round the course and is not mentally regulated and tuned in to the rider. If the horse cannot regulate itself and stay calm enough to listen to light aids it's not well trained enough, but you can still win on it if you wrestle it round the course because raw power bombing round a course is fast and jumps high.

I don’t disagree. Her observation was just that the horse had been started by a heavier, stronger rider and took some time to adjust to her lighter style. But maybe this is a discussion to take over to the Tack Room board 😅

spannasaurus · Yesterday 21:44

ButlerianJihadNow · Yesterday 20:26

There are quidditch leagues that I believe field mixed teams (not a joke)

Wiki: Teams are required to be gender-balanced: each team may have a maximum of four non-seeker players who identify as the same gender on the field at one time, making quidditch one of the few sports that not only offers a gender-integrated environment, but an open community to those who identify as nonbinary.[6]

Edited

If it's a maximum of four players who identify as the same gender you could have 12 men playing on one team at the same time

4 men who identify as men
4 men that identify as women
4 men who identify as non binary

SerenaCat93 · Yesterday 22:01

HarryPotterandtheClimateofFear · Yesterday 21:43

I don’t disagree. Her observation was just that the horse had been started by a heavier, stronger rider and took some time to adjust to her lighter style. But maybe this is a discussion to take over to the Tack Room board 😅

I would argue that the rider was who started the horse made him that way not because he was stronger but because he was heavy handed. Many strong riders are light handed! But yes maybe a discussion for the tack room 😅

New posts on this thread. Refresh page